More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ari Solomon

GET UPDATES FROM Ari Solomon
 

Does Eating Meat Make You a Bully?

Posted: 01/30/2012 4:45 pm

Here is the definition of the word bully: "A person who uses strength or power to harm or intimidate those who are weaker." Many of us know firsthand what it's like to be bullied. We know what it's like to be vulnerable and scared, and to have that be taken advantage of. I never considered animals to be a part of that equation.

Then, a few years ago, a random discussion on a talk show led me to research factory farming, a practice that produces 99 percent of the animals we consume in the U.S. I not only read about the horrors of these places, but, thanks to countless undercover investigation videos posted online, I saw them. I saw baby calves being screamed at and punched in the face by desensitized farm workers. I saw turkeys being kicked and thrown against walls until their wings broke. A saw a baby pig having its head bashed in with a brick. These poor animals were being abused, tormented, and killed by merciless beings many times their size. They were being bullied.

Even though I was never in situations this extreme growing up gay, many LGBT people are. They are regularly verbally abused, physically assaulted, and even killed. And while there undoubtedly is a difference between people and animals, the question must be asked: when it comes to things such as fear, pain, and suffering, aren't animals much more like us than they are not like us?

I know we all love a good burger or turkey sandwich, but isn't our consumption of these foods perpetuating the power-hungry and cruel attitudes we so strongly oppose? Is it really such a stretch to ask that all those who feel be liberated from the suffering caused by bullying? Because whether you want to admit it or not, that's precisely what it is. This realization, subconscious at the time, led me to become a vegan. By choosing to avoid animal foods, I feel I'm sending a strong message that I won't be a party to bullying in any form.

I know it's difficult to imagine giving up some of your favorite foods (you'll discover new ones, trust me) but I invite you to learn the truth about where those foods come from. Really think about it. Sit with it. Be honest with yourself. Does knowing that you pay other people to treat animals this way feel good in your soul?

A brilliant writer, Laura Moretti, once said this about animals:

Animals are the most victimized living creatures on earth; more than children, more than women, more than people of color. Our prejudice enables us to exploit and use them, as scientific tools and expendable commodities, and to eat them. We do to them any atrocity our creative minds can summon. We justify our cruelties; we have to or we can't commit them.

Chew on that.

 
 
 

Follow Ari Solomon on Twitter: www.twitter.com/VeganAri

 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:14 AM on 01/31/2012
Ari,
I just wish so many more people would get this. It breaks my heart all over again each day knowing that billions of animals all around the world are subjected to the most indescribable forms of cruetly at the hands of humans. It is hard to live a peaceful life, when you know that so many of your fellow sentient beings have to live the horrendous lives and die the most dreadful of deaths. Animal Liberationists are making gains, but they seem so small and so slow. At times it feels so hopeless. But we can never give up. We have to keep being a voice for our gentle voiceless fellow creatures, as hopeless as it does feel sometimes.
10:38 PM on 01/30/2012
Good concept Ari, but did you really just say this?:

"And while there undoubtedly is a difference between people and animals"

Humans are animals, and we all have the same right to live free from exploitation, on our own terms, with or families, experiencing everything that is natural to us. That is what veganism is all about. Its not just about the suffering and factory farming, those are merely symptoms of the way we human animals view other animals.

And the quote from Laura Moretti makes it sound like all animals are one group, while each gender, race, and sex of humans are another group with equal weight. Perhaps not the best way to end an article that is supposed to be about veganism.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ari Solomon
02:25 AM on 01/31/2012
1. This piece is written not just for vegans but for everyone. You can define your veganism any way you choose, but veganism for me is about making choices that, in so much as I can, reduce the suffering of animals. We can wax poetic about philosophy or we can talk about making choices, real actual choices, that make a difference.

2. As far as there being no difference at all between people and animals, I'd have to disagree. Animals don't factory farm other animals. Animals don't build bombs. Animals don't believe in religions that allow them to torture and slaughter other animals. There is a difference, of that there is no doubt.

3. I stand by the Laura Moretti quote. I think it's brilliant and drives the point home that discrimination and devaluing of life, any and all life, allows for the basest of human character.
09:08 PM on 01/31/2012
I think the problem with your answer for number two is you didn't state it like that in your post and therefore was the reason for vegandave to question this. I too, thought the same thing but as you explain it here, yes, that makes sense now. However, great post, keep writing and thanks.
12:13 PM on 02/10/2012
Hi Ari, think you will find this of interest, it explains our bullying nature and adds a sick twist re our current relationship with animals and plants.
What everybody and their dog missed re primate origins, the unique symbiotic association with hormonally and bio-chemically rich developmental environments/sex organs. Such an association effectively re-writes the primitive mammalian genetic code resulting in a symbiotic organism with very unique physiology and highly advanced neural architecture.
End the association after millions of years and the mammalian DNA in isolation does what it always did, builds an effective but 'primitive' survival neural system. The mammal slowly reverts to type, aggressive, competitive and without much self awareness or empathy.
The unique and rare traits ie high cognitive function, enhanced perception and empathy etc erode to the point that there is no subjective awareness of the problem.

Humans are the most obvious example, progressively more aggressive/stupid and increasingly deluded. The condition results in a peculiar neurology/psychology whereby those most afflicted are most frightened and aspire/are driven to take control. The result, the most dysfunctional members of our society take control, just look around.
Despite staggering implications already attracting broad spectrum support.

Rough outline here, other links on page

http://beyond-belief.org.uk/node/8
09:37 PM on 01/30/2012
Thanks for your article. It's so true that we tend to "personify" our pets so that cruelty to them would be wrong, but to "commodify" whatever animals we are already in the habit of consuming, so that we can overlook cruelty to them (though we prefer to have someone else do the dirty work).

For meat-eaters (including myself, who prefers eating vegan but will take what I'm served in social situations), ignorance is bliss. But the more a person learns the back story on animal products, the more painful it becomes to see that turkey on the table. I appreciate people speaking out, like you have done. I'm just a little more inspired in my own convictions now. Thanks.
07:14 PM on 01/30/2012
Brilliant article, I had never thought of it this way. Most people would never subject dogs and cats to these kinds of abuses (or even raise and kill them "humanely"), so why pay others to do it to cows, pigs and chickens? We don't need to eat animals to survive, and not eating them reduces much suffering in the world. Thank you, Ari.
07:07 PM on 01/30/2012
Great piece Ari. While people will undoubtedly find fault with your comparing the treatment of animals to the bullying of humans, it is an apt comparison that needed to be made. Keep on fighting!
07:01 PM on 01/30/2012
Thank you, Ari, for continuing to speak out for the voiceless. And bravo for reaching out to the LGBT community with this message of peace.
06:44 PM on 01/30/2012
Well put. I grew up fat, and know what it is to be bullied. Once I found out how animals are treated on factory farms and in slaughterhouses, I knew I couldn't perpetuate that cruelty.
06:43 PM on 01/30/2012
Wonderful article. Just as the bullying is bad for the bullied, it's equally harmful for society to allow and accept such abuse. Our culture is so inconsistent in labeling some forms of cruelty as egregious and other forms as accepted or even deemed as necessary - despite "cruelty" being so incredibly obvious and definable. And a hypocritical society is a dangerous one.
06:12 PM on 01/30/2012
What a great way to connect LGBTQ issues to animal exploitation. Thank you so much!

I do wish, however, that activist writers who write about animal farming would not distinguish between factory farms and family farms. While no one can argue that the immediate lives of the animals raised on these local/smaller scale farms are generally treated better during their lifetimes than those in factory farms, animals on smaller farms also suffer. They suffer the intense loss of friends and family.
They may develop a bond with the people who tend them, causing them enormous betrayal when those same people ship them off to be murdered. The relationships that animals have to one another and even to humans shouldn't be dis-counted as we think about the issue of animal farming.

Also, all kinds of animal farming reinforce the commodification of non-human animals and continue to entrench in our public psyches that torturing someone based on her species is not only okay, but it is absolutely normal and expected.

And indeed, I write this as a lesbian who was bullied in middle school. So I am always grateful for articles connecting animal and LGBTQ issues.