iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Arianna Huffington

Arianna Huffington

Posted: May 3, 2010 06:54 PM

Life in the Age of "Much Worse Than We Thought It Would Be"

What's Your Reaction:

What was just a troubling oil spill a week ago is now, according to Interior Secretary Salazar, "a very grave scenario," and "potentially... very catastrophic."

In other words, it's much worse that we thought it would be. Has there been a crisis in the last decade that turned out to be better than we thought it was going to be? We are still fighting two wars that were going to be cakewalks, but have now lasted nine years and seven years -- much worse than we thought it would be.

Katrina looked like it could be bad but -- even though there were plenty of people warning about a Category 5 storm breaching the levees -- the devastation ultimately was much worse than we thought it would be.

Same with the housing bubble that was fueled by the Wall Street casino. Even though we now know that people in the Fed were warning of big trouble ahead as early as 2004, the warnings were ignored -- and when the bubble burst in 2008, it was much worse than we thought it would be.

The foreclosure crisis hit hard in 2009. But the government promised to protect homeowners... so when the first quarter of 2010 brought the highest number of foreclosures since they began keeping records, the scope of the calamity was much worse than we thought it would be.

In October 2009, the unemployment rate hit 10.2 percent, a 26-year high. But the $787 billion stimulus package was going to bring that down. It has, but not by much. Turns out, the unemployment crisis is also much worse than we thought it would be.

Perhaps we should start calling this the Age of "Much Worse Than We Thought It Would Be."

Our shortsighted thinking is still on full display in the Gulf of Mexico, even as the enormity of the crisis becomes undeniable. In a speech on Sunday in Louisiana, President Obama called it a "potentially unprecedented environmental disaster," and said the spill "is unique and unprecedented." And in downplaying BP's responsibility for the spill, a spokesman for the company also called it "unprecedented," saying "it's something that we have not experienced before."

That's the nature of unprecedented things -- they've never happened -- until they happen. But just because something is unprecedented doesn't mean it's unpredictable or that we're unable to plan for it. We can't see the future, but we can prepare for it.

In practically every sector of our society, the old order is exhausted. But we seem incapable of making fundamental changes without the loaded gun of a full-blown crisis pointed at our heads. For example, the financial crisis -- and what it has exposed about the behavior of Wall Street -- has caused us to rethink the relationship between Wall Street and rest of our economy. It's obvious the old way of doing things is no longer viable. But, absent the sense that everything is about to collapse, we are dragging our feet on deciding what will replace it.

And there are some other "unprecedented," "unique" -- and potentially catastrophic -- problems headed our way if we continue to accept the old order's lack of imagination about what is possible. I'm thinking, first and foremost, of our debt problem.

And no, I'm not joining the forces of those who use the debt explosion as a backdoor way of cutting or killing Social Security or Medicare. But ceding this issue to such retro-thinkers makes it that much harder to seriously tackle the problem.

America is like a patient in danger of suffering a massive heart attack. We may be able to postpone things with a bit of outpatient surgery, but we won't be able to avoid it without some serious lifestyle changes. The economic coronary isn't quite here yet, but it's on the way. And when it hits, it will, of course, be "unprecedented" and "unique." But not unforeseen -- let alone unforeseeable. Here are just a couple of the symptoms of big time trouble ahead:

  • By 2020, interest on the debt alone will reach $900 billion per year.
  • That same year, five segments of government spending -- Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, net interest and defense spending -- will account for an estimated 77 percent of all government expenditures. All other federal spending will have to come out of the remaining 23 percent.


And a recent report by the Bank of International Settlements makes it clear that this is a worldwide phenomenon. Financial advisor John Mauldin distills the report's bottom line: "Everyone and their brother intuitively knows that the current government fiscal deficits in the developed world are unsustainable."

The numbers in the Bank of International Settlements study make this clear. For instance, in Greece, the problem child of the moment everyone is looking at with horror, government debt could reach 130 percent of GDP next year. But Greece is far from alone. In the UK, it will hit 94 percent, and continue to go up 10 percent per year. And in the U.S., we could approach nearly 100 percent. As a Greek American, I'm all in favor of the two nations co-mingling, but sporting matching crippling debt is not what I had in mind.

"While fiscal problems need to be tackled soon," says the Bank of International Settlements report, "how to do that without seriously jeopardizing the incipient economic recovery is the current key challenge for fiscal authorities."

Exactly. And those fiscal authorities also need to remember that there is more to tackling the deficit crisis than just cutting spending. Rather, we need to think bigger -- we need to re-orient our economy so that it's once more an engine for production and productivity, not a vehicle for gambling and speculation. As Mauldin says of the old -- and still dominant -- order on Wall Street: "Let's be very clear. This was purely gambling. No money was invested in mortgages or any productive enterprise. This was one group betting against another, and a LOT of these deals were done all over New York and London."

Mauldin goes on to question why large institutional investors were even gambling on things like synthetic CDOs in the first place: "This is an investment that had no productive capital at work and no remotely socially redeeming value. It did not go to fund mortgages or buy capital equipment or build malls or office buildings."

So instead of limiting the deficit debate to talk of cutting entitlements, how about also having a discussion about moving to an economy that focuses on investing in small businesses and communities, and puts a premium on education and technology rather than on exotic financial instruments.

Last year, the Center for American Progress published its deficit reduction plan, entitled "A Path to Balance," by Michael Ettlinger, Michael Linden, and Lauren Bazel. "Large deficits can reduce national savings, push up interest rates, spark inflation, and adversely affect exchange rates," the authors wrote while warning that they "also provide fodder for those who wish to block new initiatives and scale back existing programs."

The plan calls for a "sloping path" to deficit reduction, as opposed to a "dive off a precipice," and has a goal of a fully balanced budget by 2020, with benchmarks all along the way.

A few months before its plan was released, CAP hosted an event called "Progressives and the National Debt: Consequences and Solutions." Princeton economist Alan Blinder noted that "in 1980 [policymakers] knew about the year 2010 but that was really far away." Well, it's not anymore, and given that much of our deficit problem is about huge numbers of workers born decades ago now hitting retirement age, Blinder quipped that: "the long run is now the short run and they're combining."

The needs of the past and the demands of the present exert a powerful pull on our attention while the future doesn't have many advocates -- it's always something we can get to later. And there was a time when we could get away with pushing our problems down the road, secure that our reserves would always bail us out. And there was a strong safety net to catch those who fell through the cracks. Well, those reserves are gone now and the safety net is frayed and full of holes.

So before the big deficit coronary hits, and is exploited by those who've been itching to slash entitlements ever since FDR and LBJ signed them into law, let's widen the discussion, and think bigger.

For a change, let's imagine a crisis that is worse than we think it will be, and take the necessary steps to avoid it. If we don't, we'll find ourselves facing another "unprecedented" disaster.

 
 
 

Follow Arianna Huffington on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ariannahuff

 
 
  • Comments
  • 854
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (22 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Armando Olmos
Political Advocate For Seniors And
07:14 PM on 05/11/2010
Things are always much worst than our elected officials are willing to tell us because the stakes are too high. Our elected officials are intimidated by corporations with deep pockets who could end their political careers because they can pump unlimited amount of funds into political campaign ads to defeat anyone they oppose. Our political officials live in morbid fear for their political lives. They feel threatened by their corporate masters as does the whole political structure. We live in a corporate dominate political structure that makes government dysfunction.
11:09 PM on 05/08/2010
The Sars epidemic and the H1N1 flue are both much smaller than we thought they might have been.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ancatdubh
10:42 PM on 05/08/2010
If you haven't already, watch "money as debt."

Our monetary system is inherently unsustainable and will inevitably crash. It doesn't matter what jokers we put in Washington, whether they're "red" or "blue" or tea-colored. The result is not a matter if if, but when.
photo
HamletsMill
All Myth is Astronomy
11:13 PM on 05/08/2010
Yep. We are facing a 500 year event. Everyone MUST educate themselves to the realities of this moment that has come. Send these links to every person you know! Our economy has now been totally gamed by sociopaths. Knowledge is power. We MUST stop them before it is too late!

CRASH COURSE IN ECONOMICS 101 - 21 VIDEOS (4 HOURS)
http://www.chrismartenson.com/crashcourse

ELLEN BROWN EXPLAINS THE LAST 350 YEARS - 5 VIDEOS
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QU0XiklHPMc
http://www.webofdebt.com/
http://webofdebt.wordpress.com/

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF EXPLAINS THE LAST 500 YEARS - 1 VIDEO
Life Incorporated: How The World Became A Corporation, And How To Take It Back.
by Douglas Rushkoff
http://lifeincorporated.net/

STUDY THE HISTORY OF THE 300 YEAR OLD FRACTIONAL RESERVE BRITISH BANKING SYSTEM MODEL THAT STILL RULES US TODAY - 5 VIDEOS
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVkFb26u9g8

CATHERINE AUSTIN FITTS: HER PERSONAL STORY
http://dunwalke.com/

Catherine Austin Fitts on Goldman Sachs (06/09)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PbjPHwBVCSU

Catherine Austin Fitts IRTA Barter Convention (09/08)
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5455605137215634518#””””
photo
suzc
Speak the Truth, even if your voice shakes
08:38 AM on 05/09/2010
What makes you think anything can stop them? (They have all the money and guns.)
What makes you think it's not already too late?
Just asking.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Kenright
I am my brother's keeper, not yours
09:56 PM on 05/08/2010
Amazing, Fish meal companies are having the best year they have had in years. Sometimes out of bad stuff, good things happen. But, somehow you'll never hear the good stuff on HP. Seems to be a very downer forum.
02:41 AM on 05/26/2010
That's pretty funny. Also I'm wondering why the price of gas hasn't jumped?
09:20 PM on 05/08/2010
Until Americans vote into office a real President who cares for America, things will keep on turning bad and most likely follow Greece's path of destruction.
Socialism has failed everywhere, where it has been tried. That is fact.

With the help of the Almighty God, this coming November we just might start bringing America back to what it once was.

MAY GOD BLESS AMERICA
photo
ReMarker
Facts and reason For The Win!
10:14 PM on 05/08/2010
Keep dreaming. Presidents don't cause miracles and God doesn't vote.

If you have problems with our current President, imagine how bad things would be if McCain had won.
11:56 AM on 05/11/2010
Amen brother!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ancatdubh
10:46 PM on 05/08/2010
What America once was? When exactly? When we had an agrarian, non-industrial economy? When Africans were owned as slaves and women had no rights? When Jefferson advocated the separation of church and state? (Sorry, he might have lost us "Almighty God's" help on that one).
01:29 PM on 05/10/2010
word. fanned!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deweaver
Scientist, businessman, semi-retired
08:50 PM on 05/08/2010
Leverage, whether public or private, always cuts two ways. We can't get the economy restarted without doing something about the ninby and bannana problem that gave veto power to every nut case in the country to block any innovation or something new.

In the 30's, we built the Empire State Building in one year, today it has been 9 years and 7 billion dollars in studies and dead trees, and we still have a hole in the ground at ground zero.

Our "can do" ability has passed to others like China and India and will never return.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steelsil
Warren/Grayson 2016! Yes We Can!
07:48 PM on 05/08/2010
Half of the population is below average in intelligence, and a number of those of above average intelligence vote their economic short term interest - the coalition of the two is called the Republican Party. If you do the math, it's a wonder that the country isn't in worse shape.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ancatdubh
10:52 PM on 05/08/2010
Good analysis. I came up with this formula: Greed+Fox+Church - Quality Public Education = GOP.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chrisfrenzy
I am that one guy who says those things.
08:05 AM on 05/11/2010
This is a work of staggering genius. Simple and profound.

[If you feel a slight breeze, it's because you're being fanned.]
07:47 PM on 05/08/2010
Its more a problem of media reporting styles than anything else. When things go better than people thought, it barely gets covered. The recovery of the ozone, the tsunami in hawaii, the cleanups in fargos floods, the recovery of ford, the paying back of GM's government loans, the quick recovery of the market... Honestly the entire economy has recovered incredibly quickly compared to talks of this bubble and crash being as bad as the one leading into great depression.

Let's see what else... anything involving y2k, GE's supposed capital problems, There are honestly probably a limitless number of things but they just don't make good media stories - catastrophes are really all you guys are interested in and they by definition are not going to be better than you expect.
11:36 PM on 05/08/2010
Thinky, I agree with your major point and with most of your examples. I do not, however, think the economy has recovered. There are even more empty houses in my neighborhood than two years ago, pretty much everyone I know has downsized their lifestyle dramatically, unemployment is high, interest rates so low they are not keeping up with inflation. Lots of things prevent me from saying the economy has recovered.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steelsil
Warren/Grayson 2016! Yes We Can!
07:17 PM on 05/08/2010
Dear Gulf Coast residents, I hope you are enjoying the 'benefits' of voting Republican, because it was Republican bought-and-paid-for Congressmen that gave you deregulation and very low caps on liability for the damages caused by off shore drilling. Lets see, which states gave us so many years of Republican misrule? Oh, yes, they couldn't have done it without the deep South. Enjoy your karma, red necks.
11:38 PM on 05/08/2010
What an insensitive and nonsensical thing to say. I can only wonder what you said to the "New York liberals" after 9/11.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:14 PM on 05/08/2010
The IMF is into privatizing everything, contributing to tremendous poverty. They are making "land grab" deals, where corporations buy huge tracts of land in developing countries, like Africa. They make terrible loans. Break up the IMF, set all their loans at zero, and then let's talk.
04:39 PM on 05/08/2010
Any country that has more people working for the government then the public companies is indeed in trouble. These people(civil servants) will never let go of that $35,000 to $800,000(postal workers) salary +lifetime benefits. No one will be able to help us like Greece. Some might even enjoy the day when are bills are due.

The ship will crash
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:29 PM on 05/08/2010
as Gandhi said.."we must become the change we want to see in the world"...to reclaim your freedom, change yourself first!!
04:28 PM on 05/08/2010
I think it is pretty obvious we need to eliminate money. Money is becoming obsolete.
The tragic irony is we invented it and we will go down at it's feet. This is the sign of truly stupid stupid species in terms of evolutionary characteristics. Award the human species the Darwin Award. The human species still operates off the primitive or reptilian brain. Therefore, the only thing what will save us is cultural evolution meaning understanding that this totally artificial construct called money has no basis in reality outside of the human brain. None. So because we are still primitive in terms of our biological evolution, we HAVE to rise above our own biology and abolish money. Once abolished, we redistribute the wealth and material items so all can have the basics of what they need, and we CAN do this, and this is the end of global destruction. It will be the creation of a totally new paradigm based on equal distribution of wealth, sharing, and cooperation. The elimination of money is the only way we are going to save the planet. The only way. If we do not get this, then we must go extinct like every other stupid species.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SeeDaddy
Ridicule is the Burden of Genius
05:49 PM on 05/08/2010
This "totally new paradigm" is itself an artificial construct that has no reality outside the human brain.
03:03 AM on 05/26/2010
Wasn't this already tried? Carl Marx, the other Marx brother, liked redistribution. Hasn't Visa and Master card replaced our currency....maybe you are right, let's all grab our clubs and get what "they" have like our ancesters did. " Civility " has left the house. "Money" works better than carrying around a 22# turkey in your back pocket. Some of the human species "still operate off the primitive...brain". We are definately all a "work in progress".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tobyzip
Where the heck did my micro-bio go?
03:49 PM on 05/08/2010
I used to wonder if there would be room for me under the bridge. Now, I wonder if there will even BE a bridge. Hi, Third World - got room for the Americans there???
10:00 PM on 05/08/2010
Fanned tobyzip
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thewho77
02:36 PM on 05/08/2010
cut military spending 80 percent. We would still have the biggest military IN THE WORLD
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chrisfrenzy
I am that one guy who says those things.
08:10 AM on 05/11/2010
Absolutely. We spend more on defense than the next fifteen countries combined.