NYR More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Arielle Ford

Arielle Ford

Posted: February 9, 2010 05:46 PM

Are you Kindle Resistant? For the Love of Books... and Bookstores

What's Your Reaction:

"I have always imagined that Paradise will be a kind of library". -- Jorge Luis Borges

We are tactile creatures. We run our hands over furniture before we buy it. We feel the fabric of clothing before we ever consider trying it on. For many of us the same is true for the experience of buying a book. For me it starts with the smell when I first walk into a bookstore -- ahh, fresh crisp pages! Even if I can read the endorsements on a cover without taking it off the shelf, I still pick it up and I feel the texture of the cover and the pages inside. I LOVE BOOKS. I love the way they feel in my hands. I love the portability and share-ability of them.

Many of my friends are Kindle lovers but I find myself resisting getting any type of a digital reader. As a former book publicist I thought perhaps I was being a bit biased with my desire to always buy books from a bookstore. In order to get a better perspective, I recently solicited the opinions of others through social media outlets and I realized my adoration was shared among many. Can you feel the devotion in these responses?

I love having a collection of books at home that I can come back to anytime.

My bookshelf beckoned me to visit old friends again for inspiration, and to highlight what speaks to my heart.

The smell of a bookstore with a coffee shop is the most comforting smell ever!

Going to the library! The magic of being a kid and turning the pages on a colorful book, even if you're too small to read the words

I've met so many cool strangers who have walked by and said "I read that book, isn't it great?", and a great conversation started.

I love highlighting, folding back corners and reading the gems over again years later -- when they take on new meaning for me. I look at a computer screen all day and when I want to relax I want to turn pages, not scroll down.

I often buy extra copies of my favorite books when I see them at used bookstores -- this way I always have one on hand to give to someone. One of my favorite places is the library. I can't imagine a world without libraries either.

I cherish the smell and texture of the page. Even those that have been dropped in the tub!

I love to read a book then leave it on a train, or in an airport, or even in a hotel. I thank it for the journey it provided for me and then send it on its own journey to other readers.

I love books in my home -- there is something comforting about them -- old friends who made me laugh, cry, think, hope, grow. I mark pages in some and love to review my thoughts later! I love used books inscribed with love to someone or to congratulate on a milestone, it tinkers with my imagination!

I like my best friends in hardcover and they are my most valued possessions. I have a book of fairytales my Nana gave me when I was about 3. 42 years later, Nana is gone, and that book is like gold to me!

The other side of the page...

I do think a Kindle would be great on an extended trip because I'm a fast reader, and like to travel light.

There's nothing like losing yourself in a bookstore or library. That said, I received a Kindle for my birthday and it is a truly amazing device. I love it! What turned me around about the Kindle was that I found I was able to lose myself as easily in the text of a novel or non-fiction book as easily as the real thing. Borrow one and dive into a book and see if you find this is true for you. Plus, it is GREEN.

Here's hope for the best of both worlds

I remember going to movie theaters when I was very young and there were people with petitions trying to stop cable TV from coming to town because it would mean the end of movie theaters... guess what? Now we have the best of all of it... hoping the same is true for books and Kindle.

Let's all agree that when we are giving gifts this year that we BUY BOOKS at real BOOKSTORES. Every occasion is a great time for a new book or an old favorite. Birthdays, Mother's Day, baby showers -- could you imagine reading a bed-time story to a child on a digital reader?

Arielle Ford has launched the careers of many NY Times bestselling authors including Deepak Chopra, Jack Canfield, Mark Victor Hansen, Neale Donald Walsch & Debbie Ford. She is a former book publicist, literary agent and the author of seven books. To learn how to get started writing a book please visit: http://www.HowToWriteMyBook.com

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ESerafina42
Abandoned by wolves, raised by Republicans.
12:15 PM on 02/15/2010
Amen and hallelujah. (Actually, I just got a nook, but I see it as decidedly subordinate to my physical book collection. I just want it all.)

What drives me absolutely nuts is what I like to call Kindlevangelism. It seems like a lot of Kindle owners are not just happy to have it for themselves - they think that everyone else in the world should have one and anyone who doesn't want one is living in the Dark Ages. I'm on a couple of BOOK discussion boards (not in the Kindle forum) over on Amazon, and a lot of them act like people in love who have to work the name of the beloved into every conversation. "I bought X FOR MY KINDLE." I'm reading Y ON MY KINDLE." Why do they feel that everyone needs to know that? Reading is reading.
11:38 PM on 02/10/2010
I'm a school librarian and I completely disagree with the post concerning books totally going away. We've been told that for years! You should just see and hear the excitement of kids coming in, searching for a "just right book", enjoying the illustrations or photos, working to find the hidden pictures, or begging to be the next one to "get that book". Goodnight Moon's great green room still gives me warm fuzzies. The Kindle version would leave me cold.

I have the iphone Kindle and love it. And I teach and encourage technology use to my students. But I have no doubt that the library bookshelves will not feel lonely for visitors and fans. And, yes, I LOVE the scent of a library!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Schiavo
Poet
08:04 PM on 02/10/2010
Let's all agree we'll buy BOOKS from INDEPENDENT BOOKSTORES.
photo
Henry Hutton
Just call me PublishingGuy
06:34 PM on 02/10/2010
Printed books and bookstores will eventually go the way of the Dodo bird, and sooner rather than later. In 5 years they'll be as out of place as music stores and CD players would be at this time. And consumer demand--i.e. those who love a good book, and the convenience of wireless delivery and ebook device storage & presentation--will drive this change whether we like it or not.

Publishers and authors at the front end of this curve will benefit (or at least survive a while longer) while those resistant to this evolution (or revolution) will fall to the wayside. It's nothing new at all, it's just change...
06:07 PM on 02/10/2010
I would love to own a Kindle but I am presently unemployed and cannot afford one. I am living with family right now and am having trouble storing all my stuff....most of which is books! I like the idea of being able to read magazines and newspapers on the Kindle....that is more "green" because they get thrown away much quicker than a book. Also, if I need to tell someone about something I read, I could pull it up right then and there and quote it. I do love bookstores and I do have a library card, but I do want an Kindle!!!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Daws
Wants to go to there.
10:21 AM on 02/10/2010
I guess it's only a matter of time until I get an e-reader, but I like having books at home. I like collecting them and seeing them on my shelves.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:46 AM on 02/10/2010
The idea that the Kindle--or any other e-reader device--is "Green" is dubious at best. It is made out of nearly 100% non-biodegradable materials, some of which are toxic, and it must be plugged into a wall outlet. Just because it's not made out of trees doesn't make it environmentally friendly even by a long shot. Is a house made from plastic, exotic metals and composite materials more "Green" than a house made out of wood?

And here's where the case and other bits of your e-reader are likely to wind up after it's worn out (and it'll wear out a lot sooner than even the cheapest paperback):

http://www.mindfully.org/Plastic/Plastic-Plastic-Everywhere-Algalita.htm

http://www.environmentalgraffiti.com/featured/north-pacific-gyre-million-tons-garbage-growing/14477
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larkinvos
03:42 AM on 02/10/2010
The argument seems to be between buying books online
for your Kindle, or buying hard copies at the bookstore.

What about libraries? They're FREE!
GraceNotes
We live for books.
09:30 AM on 02/10/2010
I am a librarian and I love to borrow books. Our library now offers downloadble books as well as traditional hardbacks and paperbacks. But I also buy books, both for my own collection and as gifts, like the author of this piece emphasized. A famous librarian once said, "Buy the best, and borrow the rest, and use the library to help you decide which is which."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
osofar
America once was Exceptional
03:14 AM on 02/10/2010
One of the best jobs I ever had was working in bookstore. They did not pay alot, and I spent all my money on books. My daughter would wait there for her Mother to pick her up, so my daughter spent a couple of hours each day reading in the bookstore.

I too, need to see and hold the book in my hands to see if it is worthy. Ordering books on line is like sex on line. Both are best to be done with all the senses, and not on a computer screen!?!!
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
09:38 AM on 02/10/2010
I actually had nightmares from working in a bookstore. Granted, it was during the Christmas rush...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
osofar
America once was Exceptional
03:07 AM on 02/10/2010
One of the saddest things that ever happened to me was when I was moving my books to be stored in a basement (until I got my new place), the basement flooded and I lost around 1000 books. The sight of my books floating was like a mass death.

Now, I own a bookmobile for my books (they are easier to move this way). Alas, my books are in the Midwest, and I am teaching English in China.

Since the cost of getting books to China is so expensive, a Kindle would be a great substitute.

Heaven would be reading a good book, in a comfortable chair, on a cold and rainy day, next to a fireplace with my dog.

In the first Star Trek series, there was a lawyer defending James T. Kirk, and he preferred books to electronic reading. And, one of the great Twilight Zone episodes was when Burgess Merideth (Spelling) loved to read and was getting in trouble for it. Then, while he was in the basement reading, an atomic war happened. Coming out of the rubble, he could now read anything he wanted. But, alas he broke his glasses, and could not read anything!
07:47 PM on 02/09/2010
I'm with you in that I can't imagine reading a whole book on an electronic screen. But I prefer to buy my books online. It's much easier than visiting a bookstore.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:37 AM on 02/10/2010
And frequently cheaper. Up until recently I bought a huge amount of books from Amazon and other online sellers. However, I've come to miss the physical act of browsing through shelves, finding something strange and new and compelling almost completely and utterly by chance (instead of having it shoved at me as a "recommendation" by sales-software), even the smell of books new and old . . . . I won't stop buying books online, because one can find stuff through the internet that one can't otherwise, but I'm to the bookstores (and libraries).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abliss2379
09:13 AM on 02/11/2010
Browsing the Borders or Powell's Used Book Store, both walking distance from my office, is a definite lunch time treat I'd hate to lose entirely. A real oasis during a boring, desk jockey workday.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NajkaLion
07:31 PM on 02/09/2010
"Now we have the best of all of it...." This is the key phrase in your commentary. I, too, am an inveterate reader. I love books. I have bookcases overflowing with books. At the same time, I LOVE my Kindle. I can bookmark pages, highlight sections and write notes. I can carry hundreds of books with me when I travel. I absolutely want physical copies of my Harry Potter books, but I would love to have Harry with me at all times. Of course I want to read large colorful picture books to my granddaughter. At the same time, she loves being able to "read" her books on her computer screen. When no one else is available, she can listen to someone read the book to her. She loves both physical and electronic books. I find that I actually read more with my Kindle. The ability to download books in a minute encourages even more reading. Physical books are not going away, and we don't have to be electronic book Luddites. We can have it all.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:50 PM on 02/09/2010
I 100 percent agree with you. Long live physical books!