More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

A Kenyan Brothel's Lasting Impression

Posted: 03/ 8/11 12:00 AM ET

This year's International Women's Day comes at a difficult time. The brutal sexual assaults and harrassments described by women at Cairo's Tahrir Square last month were a visceral reminder of the ongoing subjugation suffered by so many women and girls around the world. Abuse and humiliation of women is an outlet for rage, addiction, dominance and control and, at times, a tactic of war. As my friend and writer Nicholas Kristof recently wrote in his forward to my memoirs: "The central moral challenge of the 19th century was slavery, and in the 20th century it was totalitarianism. In this century, the equivalent moral challenge is to address the oppression that is the lot of so many women and girls around the world."

We are all guilty of discounting difficult realities. At home in the United States, we often ignore the unacceptable daily facts facing women worldwide -- the thousand women who die each day in pregnancy or childbirth, the tens of millions of girls who are kept out of school, and the millions more who are regular victims of violence and abuse. A few years ago, in my role as Global Ambassador for the health organization PSI (Population Services International), I visited a Kenyan brothel -- it was a scuzzy flea-bag flophouse on a teeming street in a broken-up, tough part of town. Rooms were rented in 15-minute intervals to exploit prostituted women who often fought over clients, so desperate were they to survive.

I met a woman there name Shola, who was not as hardened as many of the other women I've met in brothels in 13 countries. Shola was a teenager -- six-feet tall, rail thin and heartbreakingly gorgeous. She was one of seven children. Her mother died in an accident when she was 12; when she was 15 her father died of tuberculosis. Her father's relatives took their land and she was left alone, in charge of her siblings. She dropped out of school and tried to make do. At 15, she found out she was pregnant. At 18, she was pregnant again. This time, her boyfriend left her.

Two months pregnant, hungry, with no education, no skills and her health collapsing, Shola made a poor and disempowered woman's classic "choiceless choice." Every day at 9 a.m. she would take the bus to the crowded street where Imet her, and she would sell herself to strange men for sex while a neighbor watched her child. She earned a dollar on her back, two dollars on her hands and knees. Struggling to feed her growing toddler for whom her breast milk was not enough, she worked until her eighth month of pregnancy, and was having exploited sex again a month after delivering. She was innocent and fragile. And she was so ashamed of what she was doing.

2011-03-08-ashley.jpg

It's easy to distance ourselves from Shola's agonizing lot in life and to ignore her story on a day like today. But we must remember that her life is not so different from our own. She is a woman with incredible potential, dreams and hopes. My own mother was a high school senior when she found out she was pregnant. She took money out of her piggy bank to secretly hire a cab to visit our family doctor and confirm the pregnancy. When the doctor found out she was pregnant he wept; when my grandmother found out, she screamed. Like Shola, my mother had to drop out of school and was forced to move out of her family's home.

Fortunately for my mother, she was born here in the United States, And unlike Shola, my mother had grandparents who, despite the dramas, pitched in to help, and a boyfriend -- my father -- who adored and helped care for his girls.

Thanks to these important blessings, in spite of her own considerable hardships, my mother was able to raise a healthy, productive family. Shola doesn't have those same opportunities, and her situation puts her life and her family's at risk. Every day, she's exposed to lethal sexually transmitted diseases like HIV and further unintended pregnancies. And when she is not healthy and strong, her children can't be either. Children who lose their mothers at a young age are 10 times more likely to die prematurely than those who have not. For Shola and millions like her, the onus lies on us to help as much as we can to create opportunities for her and her family to live healthy and happy lives. If we want peace, we must.

As a start, I encourage all of you to honor and remember Shola today by educating yourselves and those around you. I read a perplexing poll that said that the majority of Americans believe that 25 percent of our federal budget goes to foreign aid. Actually, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) receives only one half of 1 percent of the federal budget for foreign aid. I hope you'll take some time to learn where that money goes and how USAID and all Americans are improving the health of millions of people in the developing world in HIV/AIDS, malaria, child, maternal, reproductive health, and tuberculosis. I also hope you'll focus on what more still needs to be done to help women like Shola. Even if all you can do is spread the word, it's something. Eli Weisel said to fail to transmit an experience is to betray it. In a world of difficult problems, that is a challenge that you can meet. The time is now, and our sisters across the world are waiting.

Ashley Judd is an actor and philanthropist currently serving on the board of directors for the global health organization PSI (Population Services International, as well as other NGOs). Read more about Shola and Ashley Judd's other travels in her upcoming memoir All That is Bitter and Sweet.

 
This year's International Women's Day comes at a difficult time. The brutal sexual assaults and harrassments described by women at Cairo's Tahrir Square last month were a visceral reminder of the ongo...
This year's International Women's Day comes at a difficult time. The brutal sexual assaults and harrassments described by women at Cairo's Tahrir Square last month were a visceral reminder of the ongo...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 76
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
Heather Whaling
Communicating ... Connecting
10:07 PM on 03/13/2011
Thank you for sharing this story. I recently traveled to Haiti, where I visited a rape crisis center. It was heartbreaking to see their nightmare (earthquake, rape, extreme poverty, etc.). As we were getting ready to leave, the girls did a song and dance for us. At their core, they're still teenagers who wanted to appreciate "girly" things. The hope and resiliency I saw, and what is described in Ashley's post, is incredible. It's a powerful reminder that here in the US, we're so blessed and we have an opportunity to help those in need -- even if it's something as simple as giving a voice to those who don't have a voice of their own.

Heather
@prTini
Syed Ashraf Meer
believes in justice
04:56 PM on 03/13/2011
Thank you for this blog entry, it was incredibly touching and I hope it opens the eyes and hearts of more people in this country.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alise 28
04:02 PM on 03/13/2011
Thank you for your blog. It is beyond comprehension that in our part of the world there are also these terrible brothels that employ young women to satisfy men who use and abuse.
These estblishemnts seem to have an air of respectability about them believe me they are no different to any other part of the world.
photo
robadeaux
Your labels have expired....
07:01 PM on 03/13/2011
Why is it beyond comprehension? Do you not realze it is the way of that small portion...
that 10 or 20% of the population who screws things up for everybody?
Be they mercenaries, war mongers, pimps, con-men, religious zealots, politicians and others of the criminal sort, by far most humans really do just want to get along.
We can't seem to do anything about them and they keep screwing things up...
and they are the same the world over.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alise 28
03:54 PM on 03/20/2011
thank you for your reply ...yep in some respects I agree with you ................
03:55 PM on 03/13/2011
This is a very affecting article, but I have two observations: First, Shola made the choice to have two babies in the face of economic insecurity and with a man to whom she was not married, before she was forced to her choiceless choice. Woudn't you say that choice determined her later lack of choice?

Second, aside from feeling awful for Shola, what are we to do? Most HP readers want the U.S. out of anything that smacks of colonialism and want us to stop being the world's policeman, but isn't that what USAID is? Doesn't our aid always come with strings attached? For example, doesn't food aid require that food come from the U.S.? Don't such programs frequently destroy local food production?

Again, I'm sympathetic to Shola's plight, as is anyone who hears such a sad story, but thinking that the U.S. can change the education, land ownership, and family structure of Kenya without interfering in their politics is just silly. And thinking that we can send a few bucks and end choiceless prostitution is woefully naive.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:26 PM on 03/13/2011
I doubt very much if Shola's pregnancies were a matter of "choice."
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SirenForSanity
Hi De Hi Hi De Ho Times
10:59 PM on 03/13/2011
From the article:
" Even if all you can do is spread the word, it's something. Eli Weisel said to fail to transmit an experience is to betray it. In a world of difficult problems, that is a challenge that you can meet. The time is now, and our sisters across the world are waiting."
It is a small thing being asked of you, simply speaking up against atrocities.
02:53 PM on 03/13/2011
Ashley- Really an amazing blog entry. Without taking away at all from this we in the US don't have to travel so far to this is level of abuse. Just go to places like the South Bronx in New York where dedicated hospitals are caring for huge HIV populations and battered men, women, and children in the face of neglect by the government budget that is ever decreasing for the poor.The institutional heroism of the medical people in these indigent communities keep the fiscal, psychological, and social poverty above the the line.

You are doing amazing stuff with your time. Thank you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CPAwADD
My super power is sarcasm!
12:05 PM on 03/13/2011
Ashley, your beauty is more than skin deep and as such is the kind which endures.
10:30 AM on 03/13/2011
these girls need to make better choices in life. if you go into brothel work, you just may end up pregnant...
12:26 PM on 03/13/2011
You apparently didn't read the article.
12:35 PM on 03/13/2011
I'm sorry, Did you not read the article? First of all, she was pregnant before the brothel, and secondly did you not understand what a "choiceless choice" is? This article is NOT set in a rich secure neighborhood or even a secure country.
HenryT2
Wake me for the revolution
08:47 AM on 03/13/2011
First, I really feel for Shola and countless other women in the world who are forced to make "choiceless choices" It's heartbreaking and unacceptable that women (or men) would be forced to put themselves in humiliating and unhealthy situation. But I'm not sure how much less of a tragedy this would if Shola was forced to work in an unsafe factory for 14 hours a day, 7 days a week for an even less money.

Prostitution, is usually a last resort. It's not something women like Shola enter into lightly. If you were to solve all the economic problems of all the people, you probably wouldn't have any prostitution. However, this is almost impossibly unlikely.

Consequently, I think prostitution needs to be legalized, and regulated. Take away the moral implications, and the only major issue remaining is the health and safety issue. And when you're dealing with foreign cultures, you HAVE TO ignore the moral implications as they may be entirely different. The health issues could be reduced with mandated condom use and health checks. And the safety issues would probably be greatly reduced when these women are working within the system with protections in place rather than when they themselves are classified as criminals.

Like Ashley Judd, I am glad I was born an American. But Shola was not. As counterintuitive as it seems, taking away Shola's horrible, choice is not the answer. Making the horrible choice she was forced to make healthier and safer is the regrettable answer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bert Dodson
libral gramma
09:43 AM on 03/13/2011
Is it now. You are discussing a future in the sex trade with your children, what a career path. Why the Wharton School will offer post grad degrees in Brothel managment, and how to recruit and keep staff. Perhaps we can franchise brothels to maintain quality, what a family oppurtunity, jobs for mom,dad and the kids.
It is very telling that no matter how poor, uneducated, unskilled, and unemployeed a nation is it can still manage to support prostitution. Women having to sell themselves isn't the problem it is a culture that thinks it is okay to buy an other person. Prostitution is the last form of slavery that is still practiced and defended by the developed world.
When the buyers are held up to the same shame and leagal penalties as the sellers then we will see its decline not before
HenryT2
Wake me for the revolution
10:24 AM on 03/13/2011
Sex in itself is not immoral or "slavery". Paying for physical gratification is also not immoral. We've made paying for sexual gratification immoral. But, if it's legitimate and both parties receive some sort of benefit, it's not necessarily evil. Paying for a massage in which a person rubs your body for your physical pleasure is acceptable as long as it doesn't result in sexual gratification. But would it be acceptable if the masseur was underpaid, abused, at risk, and had no legal recourse? In that case, would the solution be to make massages illegal?

And I'm not saying that it's not something that is good or healthy for society in general. I myself don't drink, smoke, or partake in most of the legal "sins". But I wouldn't outlaw them either.

And I agree that the idea of it becoming mainstream with degrees in brothel management and franchises is extremely distasteful. But have you looked around you at the modern world? Much of the world today is made of up horrible abuses created by the capitalist system. But I don't think the answer is to ignore the basic desire of humans to barter for mutual benefit but to reduce or eliminate abuses.

I find it difficult to pity top earning strippers who make thousands of dollars per day. Or to pity the legal prostitutes in Nevada who earn $300K+ per year. I don't admire them, but it's not the same. And the difference isn't the morality, it's the legitimacy and money.
11:42 AM on 03/13/2011
It's illegal in pretty much all of the developed world. What are you talking about? And held up to the same shame? Where are prostitutes held up to their shame? If they're ashamed to be having sex for money don't you think the man who needs to pay for sex has more reason for shame? I don't understand what you're saying, I think you're mad and talking irrationally, that doesn't foster good debate.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SirenForSanity
Hi De Hi Hi De Ho Times
12:58 PM on 03/13/2011
Where Shola lives, legalized and regulated WOULD mean 14 hour days, 7 days a week for even less money. To argue to legalize prostitution and justify that with 'there has always been prostitution' will insure that there will always be prostitution.
03:02 PM on 03/13/2011
And there WILL ***always*** be prostitution. That is not the argument anyone needs to have, just as there will always be people who need to eat and therefore people will need to cook, sell food, etc there will always be prostitution. It's how it's handled that matters.
HenryT2
Wake me for the revolution
02:48 AM on 03/15/2011
Exactly my point. She either made the choice not to get the job where she worked 7/14 paid badly, or couldn't even get that job. Ideally, the solution would be to fix the economy where the job she got or could get would give her good pay and conditions. Until/unless that happens, you should protect the women who have to make the tough choices.

I do agree with your, and the other person's point about possibly eventually seeing "corporate prositution". Perhaps the solution to that would be something like the British system where prostitution itself is not illegal but solicitation is (and I believe "pimping" as well).

And as far as "there has always been prostitution", that's not my argument. My argument is more in line with, "there has always been and there will always be a demand for sex, and as long as there is an unfilled demand for sex, there will always be prostitution."

Unfortunate, yes. But the refusal to accept this as a basic human desire that people are willing to pay for is unproductive. We need to protect the unfortunate women who make these choices.

@Bert mentioned the possibility of one's children making this choice. Legal or not, some peoples' children have made this choice. Do you think these people would prefer that efforts were made to protect their child, or arrest their child?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hajji
08:14 AM on 03/13/2011
You continue to write and say the toughts I feel.

Thank you, Ashley, once again for proving that intelligence, talent and compassion for the planet and its people can amplify the voice of the plight of women from Kenya to Kentucky and around the world.

Keep making me proud, Homegirl.

-T
photo
cornelison
College grad. Life-long liberal.
05:14 AM on 03/13/2011
Give liberal women a chance to run this world for 100 years and humanity will have a chance to heal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LeftRight
TANSTAAFL
03:57 PM on 03/13/2011
Sounds good to me!! Speaking as a liberal man, my wife is the smartest person I know, excepting only her daughters!!
Gracey28
Lady Sunshine
03:29 AM on 03/13/2011
Excellent post. Heartbreaking. Now is the time to raise our voices and raise awareness.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mansterEZ
searching for secular humanist fact-based truth
01:24 AM on 03/13/2011
Ashley, you're my shero.
photo
MikeDu
Both salubrious and lugubrious concurrently.
12:13 AM on 03/13/2011
The 'choiceless choice' is coming to a neighborhood near you. The collapse of the middle class, the export of decent working class jobs, the breaking of unions, accompanied by the simultaneous dismantling of vital public assistance is going to leave a lot of citizens in desperate straits. Only a finite number can support themselves in a town picking up discarded bottles by the side of the road for the redemption nickel. And we all know what jobs are left after there's nothing left. That's where the Charlie Sheens of this word enter the picture.
08:43 PM on 03/08/2011
Excellent post...unfortunately, this poor young woman's experience mirror millions around the world...thanks for your post...keep working on this as we all do...these are our sisters and it is horrible and we can all contribute to change....Happy Women's Day!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JanusDaniels
07:03 PM on 03/08/2011
Still another "... perplexing poll that said that the majority of Americans believe that 25 percent of our federal budget goes to foreign aid. Actually, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) receives only one half of 1 percent of the federal budget for foreign aid."
I'd like to give "only one half of 1 percent of the federal budget for" our military, and a trillion dollars for foreign aid. Retrain our soldiers into jobs in the peace corps. They'd have more skills they could use in civilian life.
We'd have a better economy world wide, and we wouldn't need to fight wars.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mozartssister
07:43 AM on 03/13/2011
F&F, a thousand times.