iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Avery Stone

GET UPDATES FROM Avery Stone
 

The Death of Innocence at Amherst College

Posted: 10/22/2012 10:18 am

On Thursday night this past week, 300 Amherst College students, faculty and other members of the community congregated at the top of the campus' iconic Memorial Hill -- the "selling point" spot for prospective student tours, with an expansive view of pristine foliage and open sky -- in complete silence. A fire burned in the middle of the space, the flames lighting up faces like half-moons in the night. I thought back to earlier that day. I'd been in my music class. My professor had stopped mid-lecture to ask us our thoughts about the landslide of accounts of sexual assault at Amherst that were surfacing. A boy had raised his hand and mentioned that night's firelight healing vigil, meant to honor survivors at Amherst -- he said he didn't understand why it was happening: Don't vigils occur in response to death? That night, I looked around at the hundreds of silhouettes in the dark. A boy standing in front of me put his arm around a girl's shoulder as she leaned into him. A woman next to me wept quietly, her hand over her heart. I found myself asking -- hasn't there been a type of death here, too?

I wish I could say I'm a stranger to hearing about sexual assault at Amherst, but that wouldn't be true. I am not a survivor of rape on this campus, but have found myself close to many who are -- largely women, but a few men, too. My freshman and sophomore year roommate was raped during our first spring semester. Twice. The perpetrator was a socially prominent boy on campus. For two years, I observed my roommate as she navigated her trauma -- in her own mind, within her group of friends, and then eventually, with a counselor. As with many of the stories that are now surfacing, my roommate experienced a shaming response from many of the students she told -- that she asked for it. But you went home with him. What did you think he wanted? Why did you go back again? She often told me she wished she could take back what he took from her. That night at the vigil, I thought about the first day I met my roommate -- putting away her pink and green bedding, an innocent charm about her, bright and lovely. Today, she is the same woman, but there is visible grit in her now. There is immense strength. There is darkness. And most importantly, there is the truest form of loss.

My former roommate is one of the many survivors on this campus who have suffered largely in silence. This silence has come at a price. Currently, Amherst College is a place where women like Angie Epifano -- a survivor who bravely shared her story with The Amherst Student, the College's newspaper -- have dropped out because of how both students and the administration have treated them. Amherst College is a place where men who've raped have been allowed to stay in roles of power and prestige on campus. This sickens me. But I believe it. For the past two years, I have been an active part of the culture that allows this to happen. I have witnessed many instances of sexual disrespect -- at parties, in dorms, even in places as mundane as our dining hall -- and have not spoken up until now. But the images I've seen are engrained on my brain: a female student telling another to hide her sexual assault because it would harm the perpetrator's athletic team's season, the blurriness of sex tainted by binge drinking, men rating women's appearances as they walk around the corner of our dining hall, women confessing to wanting to take enough pills to make their pain subside. The list goes on. I realize that not everyone is a perpetrator. I also realize that sexism and sexual misconduct are rampant on college campuses around the country. But that does not invalidate what has already happened at Amherst. Even though this cracking of the College's perfect façade will catalyze change, there are many survivors like Angie and my former roommate who have lost something vital under the care of Amherst College -- and no amount of change in policy, discussion, or apology can return it to them.

The following day, I walked back to the spot where the vigil had been and looked out at the mountains. For the first time in a long time, I felt grief. That boy in my music class had, whether he knew it or not, been right. Among all of this iconic New England beauty, these intelligent students, these "lives of consequence" -- the College's motto -- I realize there has been death: the death of not only survivors' innocence, but also the death of sense of self for so many of us here. Although I cannot know what it's like to have been raped, I often feel that being here causes me to lose sight of who I am. But now, people have begun speaking up -- and I will be next. I cannot change the past, and I do not know how to heal. But I know this feels like a start.

 

Follow Avery Stone on Twitter: www.twitter.com/averywstone

FOLLOW COLLEGE
On Thursday night this past week, 300 Amherst College students, faculty and other members of the community congregated at the top of the campus' iconic Memorial Hill -- the "selling point" spot for pr...
On Thursday night this past week, 300 Amherst College students, faculty and other members of the community congregated at the top of the campus' iconic Memorial Hill -- the "selling point" spot for pr...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tom Matlack
Man, Husband, Dad, Writer, Venture Capitalist
03:56 PM on 11/05/2012
As a tragic follow up to this piece please read the suicide note of an Amherst College student who was sexually abused and didn't make it: http://goodmenproject.com/ethics-values/lead-a-good-life-everyone-trey-malones-suicide-note/
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
SaraKay Smullens
10:16 PM on 10/25/2012
To read a post detailing years of working with those who have been sexually abused and raped, and the necessity of breaking a code of silence, please go to the Broad Street Review, and type
Male sex abuse and the silence of women
BY: SaraKay Smullens May 30, 2011
The alleged sexual predations of Arnold Schwarzenegger and Dominique Strauss-Kahn make the headlines but are only the tip of the iceberg. As a family therapist, I can testify firsthand that sexual abuse is prevalent in all cultures, the privileged as well as the poor...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
SaraKay Smullens
10:06 PM on 10/25/2012
This horrific reality is everywhere. We must keep talking and talking and talking about it, breaking a code of silence. I would like to share the following.
Broad Street Review: Male sex abuse and the silence of women
As a family therapist, I can testify firsthand that sexual abuse is prevalent ... Time for women to speak up SARAKAY SMULLENS. My first client of the day was in her mid-30s ...
www.broadstreetreview.com/...abuse_and_the_silence_of_women - Cached
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drew2248
02:44 AM on 10/25/2012
James Nolan's slanderous comment about members of fraternities as "primitive cadres of adolescents narcissists" perhaps says more about his emotional inadequacies that it does about college fraternity members. Why not make an equally fatuous statement about sororities? Perhaps you could then insult all young people as inadequate in some way? Or perhaps just claim that all young men who are sexists? Why stop there? Let's make sweeping statement after sweeping statement like "people who work in college counseling centers develop a particularly hostile view of students."
05:42 PM on 10/23/2012
I went to a small new england college in the 70's and early 80's. One saturday night, a young woman had too much to drink and was "gang banged" by fraternity brothers. Rumors circulated about what had happened that night. The next weekend, at a screening of The Turning Point ( a movie about a ballerina and her mother), men and women in the audience called out "choo choo" when the young woman and her friends tried to sit down. "Choo choo" was a saying that referred to "pulling a train"-sexual intercourse with one man after the other. I'm 53 now and I am haunted by the remembrance of that evening and feel sad that I wasn't strong enough to stand up for that young woman and what she went through. As far as I knew, the fraternity brothers got away with that assault-and who knows how many more. They are fathers now and perhaps reading about the Amherst article-their daughters would probably be college age. Wonder how much remorse they have? Could they possibly know how much pain she went through?
02:06 PM on 10/23/2012
Excellent and thoughtful posting. And timely given what happened at UMass just one week ago. You'll notice the article on NUMEROUS occasions uses the term "forcible rape." Why are we using this term now which is ridiculously redundant?
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/23/umass-amherst-gang-rape_n_2005316.html?ref=topbar
03:40 PM on 10/23/2012
Because statutory rape isn't forced.
04:04 PM on 10/23/2012
Good point. Thanks for the clarification.
photo
James Michael Nolan
Jim is President of Southwestern College
11:13 PM on 10/22/2012
During my years (many years) in University Counseling Center work, I found myself wondering why universities tolerated so-called "Greek" life. I cannot begin to tell you what percentages of campus problems could be located in those primitive cadres of adolescents narcissists posing as "service organizations." Of course there are the good ones, we all know that, and of course virtually EVERY "chapter" will fight to the end to uphold the honor of THEIR group, but anybody in university mental health knows that they are, as a collective, a huge problem. Not sure if that is the case at Amherst, but I wanted to bring this up for discussion as a related issue...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:19 AM on 10/23/2012
I went to a small Catholic college in MA and we didn't have Greek life. I agree with what your saying- despite our lack of fraterinities and sororities our students in service organizations or clubs of prestige had this "aura" around them that meant they could do no wrong and had administrators fighting to uphold their image and make sure nothing could taint that as it would bring shame opon the group. Students would use their club as an excuse to behave as they wished, as if "I volunteer on weekends makes me a good person so I my conduct no longer matters."
12:02 PM on 10/23/2012
I have noticed that Men who need to run in packs,IE fraternities ,clubs etc., are by far the most immature, and I think the evidence is abundant that fraternity kids have zero respect for others
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lilrockdiva
Run Tell That!
07:37 PM on 10/22/2012
America no longer needs to go abroad in search of monsters to destroy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cobraxus
Defend The Innocent_Protect The Weak
01:19 PM on 10/22/2012
here in this country we have fiefdoms.colleges and universities.the catholic church.the boy scouts of america.even the US military.the facade is all.their images protected at all costs.the guilty are never punished and the victims shamed into silence,just to preserve an illusion.bullies are coddled while those who stand up to them get thrown to the wolves.abuse victims suffer their whole lives but what of their abusers?having been given license to do whatever they want without consequence at such a young age are they allowed to just go on making more victims over the course of their lives?do we just keep quiet so as not to spoil the decorum?at what point do we say enough.this ends now.
photo
Wrench Turner
Fuhgeddaboutit...
01:23 PM on 10/24/2012
The situations with the RCC and BSA are completely different from the issues facing colleges and the military. On the one hand you have authority figures taking advantage of children, on the other, you have students assaulting students. Unfortunately, with young people, as long as there is alcohol and cohabitation, these issues will come up, the best we can do is prosecute the offenders.
06:19 PM on 10/24/2012
I, respectfully, disagree. At a college with as much prestige as Amherst, the students must have proven enough maturation and development to be considered ready for a small New England college lifestyle. Alcohol often does facilitate these situations and cohabitation certainly adds a level of ease often unavailable in other lifestyles, but young people are not to blame. Students assaulting students is no different than authority figures taking advantage of other students. When you are involved in this situation, it is all the same. One individual is exerting his or her power over another. As the survivor, you feel powerless. You do not think of your attacker as your peer, you think of this person as someone who wants to hurt you, to make you suffer. You have no control. We should not settle for simply prosecuting the offenders. We CANNOT settle for prosecuting the offenders. We must change the entire culture that promotes this behavior. Alcohol and cohabitation are not justifiable means for rape and sexual violence and people assault people, regardless of their age.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Velvetrabbit23
12:29 PM on 10/22/2012
It begins some time in the early grades when boys stop having girl friends over to their house to play or for birthday parties. Then, around the age of puberty the testosterone kicks in and the physical attraction of the young females becomes intense. The culture creates all kinds of gender behaviors for young males to show their manhood. A pattern of "differences" becomes imbedded in the male psyche and the mating games begin. In the female quest for equality, power and control really lies with them. However, most males want to control. This is an evolutionary instinct to be dominant. Hetero males have a hard time sharing power with their female counterparts. So, the battle of the sexes begins at an early age. Fortunately, the years soften these traditional gender roles. After falling in love, trying to maintain marriages, watching children being born, having parents die, growing older and seeing loved ones growing into successful adults, males do sometimes change. Young people need good role models. Men who have accepted females as equal partners in life whether in the workplace or home, need to nurture, advise and teach younger men to respect, love and have women as allies in their life. At the same time women need to assert their power, say no and mean it and stand up for their rights as equal, free and strong human beings.
05:10 PM on 10/23/2012
Women who have accepted men as equal partners in life whether in the workplace or home, need to nurture, advise and teach younger women to respect, love and have men as allies in their life. At the same time men need to assert their power, say no and mean it and stand up for their rights as equal, free and strong human beings.

I regendered your last two sentences.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Velvetrabbit23
11:09 PM on 10/23/2012
Cool
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Arion
11:27 AM on 10/22/2012
Being male, I think it took me far too long to wake up to the horror of rape. only in the last decade has it really sunk in(I'm 77 now). For me rape, murder and treason are the three great unforgivable horrors.
03:39 PM on 10/23/2012
How about when a woman rapes a man? Is that still an "unforgivable horror"? Because feminists like Stone do not even think it should be a crime at all.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Arion
09:37 AM on 10/24/2012
I'm not sure. if the woman was as much stronger and heavier than her victim as the man is usually, I guess it would be just as horrible.
02:55 PM on 10/24/2012
Of course it's still an unforgivable horror. Rape is unforgivable regardless of the gender of the perpetrator, and in saying otherwise Stone gives feminism a bad name.