Hillary Said the Word -- An Autism Mom Finally Feels Acknowledged

stumble digg reddit del.ico.us news trust

Posted April 25, 2008 | 11:23 AM (EST)



Show your support.
Buzz this article up.

The candidates are all talking about it, but when Hillary Clinton said it, I cried.

"We will tackle everything from autism to Alzheimer's, cancer to diabetes, and make a real difference," she said, in her Pennsylvania primary victory speech. Later, looking at that one sentence in the light of day, I understood why it stopped me in my tracks. Hillary Clinton put autism first on her list of dreaded diseases. First, even though it wasn't in alphabetical order.

It didn't used to be like this. When my now twenty year-old son was first diagnosed in 1991, you had to spell the word "autism" for most politicians.

The cynical voice inside of me says it means nothing, McCain mentioned it, Obama mentioned it and Clinton's speech writers probably put it in to keep up.

The mother in me ignores the cynic and says: Who cares why she mentioned it. All that matters is that she did. She did it with great clarity. And in the midst of what was, for her, a pivotal moment.

And she was right.

Autism is decimating a generation of children. One in 150 children, at the least, is now being diagnosed. It is an epidemic and in comparison it is making polio look like a sore throat. In the years to come our homes, schools, recreational facilities, restaurants, doctors' offices -- our entire world -- will be packed with young adults with all kinds of serious and deep communication and behavioral difficulties. To be a bit more graphic: people who can't say words but can't stop screaming -- people whose inability to communicate causes a frustration level that leads to violence.

These people were poisoned. One of the culprits is, no doubt, the mercury preservative that was put willy-nilly into so many vaccines. Probably it was also something else in the air or water, in preservatives or cleaning solvents or in the plastics that are turning baby bottles into killers. Whatever the substance that caused the mass poison, the epidemic is going to continue to grow until we get some answers about what causes autism.

Say what you like about Hillary Clinton, but when it comes to priorities, she got one right by putting autism up there with the other crucial concerns of our society: war, economics and dependence on oil.

For me it also explains why I can't seem to drop her as my candidate, even though I don't like all she has said or done. When it comes down to it, I can't extricate myself from her because ultimately she is the only candidate who puts intellect and sentiment together for me in a way that I can't resist.

Our son's name is Daniel Mulvaney and he has a long history with the Clintons. He was diagnosed as Bill was in the final lap of his presidential run. I remember sitting in the den on election night watching the returns with my child-insomniac. Dan could not speak but, indeed, seemed to be cheering at the results. He jumped up and down and was happier than I had seen him in months. Maybe, he was "thinking about tomorrow," like the campaign song went in those days. Maybe "tomorrow" one of those medical geniuses we kept consulting -- and paying -- would crunch all of those voluminous sheets of data they kept asking us to provide and figure out how a kid who spoke English and had words in Spanish, Cantonese and Tagalog at the age of three, now could not utter a word.

Time moves slowly in the world of autism. Bill Clinton made it through his first term and autism remained a deep, dark mystery. It was, and is, infuriating to recall that the world knew more -- and perhaps cared more -- about our president's dalliances than it did about damage to a child's brain. While "investigative reporters" chased blue dresses rather than scientists, Dan's teachers and the "experts" they consulted didn't really know what to do with him. This wasn't a movie: my son was not a savant, he couldn't count cards like Dustin Hoffman or play music or recite poetry. All he seemed to want out of life was to play with ropes, particularly the ones on Venetian blinds.

"Is there something else he likes besides ropes?" an exasperated teacher asked.

"Bill Clinton," I replied, quite exasperated myself.

I figured she'd think I was, at best, delusional. In those days the conventional wisdom was that Dan would never progress beyond the level of a nonverbal two year old.

"Okay," she said. "We'll make a re-elect Bill Clinton poster."

He seemed to like doing that too, even though to get him to paste the words on oak tag, the teacher had to use a technique called "hand-over-hand," which is just about as discouraging as it sounds.

Back then in the first Clinton term we were so alone as parents of kids with autism. Now, even worse, we aren't alone, we seem to be members of the fastest growing club in America. I never imagined in those early years that autism would be a topic of conversation of anyone even remotely close to winning a presidential election.

Dan still does not speak although he now gets out a few guttural utterances, all of which thrill us to no end. He does sleep better than he used to though and was not awake when the word autism was uttered on Tuesday night.

In the morning I told him what Hillary Clinton had said.

As is often the case, he did not reply or react.

I know though, the way mothers know things, that he is thinking about tomorrow. About a speech that could lead to action.

Hillary Clinton, I hope your mention of autism came from the heart. And from the heart of your very good brain. Because Dan and the other kids need more than just a mention, they need action.


 
 

Comments
24
Pending Comments
0

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:

Sorry that the campaign didn't respond to your "friend". They have responded to all the major organizations supporting children and adults with Autism. I live in New York State and I am proud to say that people move here from all over the world to get better care for their children with Autism. Senator Clinton has been a strong advocate for children with Autism since her days at the Children's Defense Fund...decades before Autism was "fashionable".
I am glad Senator Clinton is my Senator. My son deserves her. If as President she can somehow change health care in this country his future will be even brighter.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:33 PM on 04/27/2008

As a few commenters have noted, scientific evaluations have cast big-time doubt on mercury in vaccines as a cause for autism. What makes me sad about autism advocates relentlessly endorsing this theory is the time, money and emotion wasted on this dead-end when these same spirited, dedicated people could support the scientific community in a search for the real causes and treatments. I have found this blog, written by a neurologist, to have credible and skeptical discussions of medical science. He write frequently about autism and this post is an example: http://www.theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php?p=185

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:44 AM on 04/27/2008

The author may have 'no doubt' that the cause of Autism is the mercury in some vaccines, but medical science has nothing but doubt: there is no evidence in support of this assertion.

Autism incidence rates are identical in regions and nations which have never had thimerosol in its vaccines as in places that still do, or places which stopped years ago. If the presesnce or absense of mercury doesn't affect autism, then mercury isn't the cause.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:00 PM on 04/26/2008

It sounds like you are citing the CDC's study, the one everyone seems to hang their hat on. That study was not based on a representative sample and had TONS of problems with its methodology. Strange, considering how the scientists at the CDC should know better... Even stranger, they "lost" the original data so their findings cannot be replicated or scrutinized.

I do not believe there is one cause of Autism Spectrum Disorders. It is likely there are many causes. I do believe, however, that the fundamental problem is related to their metabolism. It is no coincidence that the majority of these kids, my son included, have chronic bowel problems. We will probably eventually find that some kids lack the ability to process and/or eliminate specific chemicals from their body.

It is imperative--and I cannot stress this enough--for the medical community to listen to parents and not discount our observations. Here's but one example: for years now there have been reports by parents who noticed that their child's symptoms abated when s/he had a fever. Some kids were said to gain the ability to speak and interact when they had a high fever, only to lose the ability once the fever subsided. The medical establishment dismissed this as rubbish. Finally, someone took the initiative to conduct a formal study and, lo and behold, they found this to be true for a statistically significant portion of their sample. Listen to the parents.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:22 PM on 04/27/2008

Medical evidence can be "doctored" or bought. We saw that with Vioxx.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:06 PM on 04/27/2008

I watched a Clinton town hall kind of meeting on CSpan. Someone asked her about Autism, she was on top of it, she knew what she was talking about. She said she wanted to start tracking environmental concerns, the way the CDC tracks infectious diesases, thereby hoping to get a better understanding of some of our health issues. And how our enviroment contributes to our health issues. I have not heard any other candidate talk about this. Environment tracking, as it relates to our health, should have been in place with a nice budget a long time ago. Hillary has the right idea.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:59 PM on 04/26/2008

Don't get your hopes up too high it's election season and that means "your wish is the candidates desire". AUTISM.................dear God help us all. We can't wait for the govt to help us out on this one. It's gonna to take a whole lot of blood, sweat and tears (and more tears) on the behalf of the parents. With God's help we'll come out victorious.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:06 AM on 04/26/2008

I, too, am a parent with an autistic child (Asperger's Syndrome). We are lucky in that my son has seemed to keep up with most of the developmental milestones, including speech, though he does have difficulty communicating with his peers and sometimes with us and has social difficulties. I know how frustrating it can be to have a child screaming at you because he doesn't have the words to express his frustration, though it sounds like you have had a more difficult road than me.

As a scientist and mother of an autistic child, I must take exception with your comments that vaccines are one of the culprits for autism or that "these people were poisoned". My son has had the same autistic quirks since birth and I don't believe that I somehow inadvertently poisoned him in the womb or that he was poisoned outside the womb.

My main focus is on acceptance of autistic persons, trying to understand their unique point of view, and harnessing their unique capabilities. Many adults with autism do not feel that they were poisoned, nor do they want to have their autism erased. Many would like to overcome their social difficulties, however, and that is one place where I feel that we as parents can help.

I do believe that autism warrants further research into its underlying cause and how best to help those with autism, but do not wish my son to be viewed as being "poisoned" or in need of a cure.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:21 AM on 04/26/2008

I should expand my comments, in that I'm not unsympathetic to parents that have kids that had a sudden change from social to non-social - I think that I would want answers, too. I think part of the problem is in lumping all autism spectrum disorders together. My son with Asperger's Syndrome is so mildly affected that I think it's more of a personality than an actual disorder. I've also observed that a number of men (and possibly women) in my family all carry the same traits as my son, leading to a belief (backed in science) that autism is, at least in some cases, genetic.

I think that part of the perceived increase in autism is an increase in diagnosis of much milder cases and recognition at younger ages. In some cases, I believe that these diagnoses are unwarranted, but I do think that for a vast majority of these kids, the diagnosis is a positive, leading to more help with social skills and teaching to their unique perspectives.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:05 AM on 04/26/2008

The doctors go back and forth between Asperger's and PDD-NOS with my son. I disagree that there is only a perceived increase in Autism. I am a therapist and the DSM is supposed to be my "bible", so I understand how some diagnoses can be en vogue (e.g., Bipolar disorder); however, I do not believe this to be the case with Autism Spectrum Disorders. If it's an issue of expanded diagnostic criteria, where are all the newly diagnosed ADULTS?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:31 PM on 04/27/2008

My guess would be that adults on the high functioning end of the spectrum have more or less learned to cope with the symptoms they have. Therefore, there is no reason for these individuals to seek out diagnosis, as it would likely not benefit them in any way. However, diagnosing children allows them access to a number of different services, resulting in a push to diagnose children, but not adults.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:10 AM on 04/28/2008

What is important to me is discussing autism and other disorders to help raise awareness and erase any stigmas attached. Neurological disorders/diseases are worldwide problems.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:51 PM on 04/25/2008

Barbara, it's a heartbreaking story you've told about your son. I feel your pain, every bit of it. You are right, we don't know what any candidate will do once they are in office and how much they mean what they say. But just hearing those concerns spoken by a candidate is cause for joy, for the moment. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this.
Maurine Meleck

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:23 PM on 04/25/2008

Of course Hillary was one who used her position to push for more vaccines at a younger age as part of her public health campaign back in the early 90's.

Thanks Hillary

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:55 PM on 04/25/2008

I am glad Senator Clinton spoke of autism and other medical disorders which are usually not discussed. Open discussion is needed for health issues which are largely ignored by the media. There are over 600 neurological disorders. Thank you Senator Clinton!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:31 PM on 04/25/2008

My friend, you are one of my heroes, but, I must tell you how disappointed I am in your support for Hillary Clinton. Obviously, we have shared the same experiences with the Clinton's as our president, but, we have reached far different conclusions.

You write: "Say what you like about Hillary Clinton, but when it comes to priorities, she got one right by putting autism up there with the other crucial concerns of our society: war, economics and dependence on oil.

I thought she "got one right by pure accident". Linking "Autism and Alzheimer's" was more "literationt" than "priority".

You write: Time moves slowly in the world of autism. Bill Clinton made it through his first term and autism remained a deep, dark mystery. It was, and is, infuriating to recall that the world knew more -- and perhaps cared more -- about our president's dalliances than it did about damage to a child's brain.

My friend, "The WORLD did not "know" or "care" more about "our president's dalliances". BILL CLINTON "knew and cared" more about his dalliances. Perhaps if Bill had concentrated his efforts asking why "autism was such a mystery"......"investigative journalists" could have spent their time investigating why "autism remained a deep, dark mystery" for his entire 8 years in office?

Please accept my apologies for disagreeing with you on this issue. As I said, you are one of my personal heroes!!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:34 PM on 04/25/2008

Dear rmoffi

. I hardly ever feel like a hero and I am very touched by your comments. Most days I just feel like a mother who is trying to make it through the day without messing up my children, my marriage, my writing and my teaching. I suspect I am far from alone.

No need to apologize at all, ever, for disagreeing. Many of my friends disagree with me when it comes to Hillary Clinton. I have tried many times during this campaign to listen to them, to listen to Barak Obama and ultimately I come away with the unshakeable conviction that Hillary Clinton is the smartest candidate and smarts are what we so desperately need.. As for the notion that Clinton mentioned autism as an accident: I don't think she does anything by accident. And I do know that Obama has a plan for people with disabilities but the issue here is not who has the plan but who can carry it out.

If you haven't read my "vintage" post from last Mother's Day about my late, great and brilliant mother-in-law Eileen Mulvaney I would be honored if you would take a look. Not mentioned is that she wore a "Vote for John Kerry" button on her hospital gown but her dying words included the wish that Hillary Clinton would some day be president. I am sure that from above she is agreeing with me when I say readers like you are valuable beyond expression.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:56 PM on 04/25/2008

Barack Obama has a plan for persons with disabilities, including a specific plan for Autism spectrum disorders. A friend of mine emailed the Clinton campaign over a month ago to clarify their position and has received no response to date. Hillary says we need more than "just words" and in this case she is right.

http://www.barackobama.com/issues/disabilities/

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:45 AM on 04/25/2008

Why can't you people see that killing Iraqi women and children is MUCH more important that health care for the children of this nation. Geeze, listen to the Corporate Sponsored Media, they'll straighten you out. If the Iraqi women and children are allowed to live, this country will cease to exist and all of us will be foreced to become muslims. So let's all get on board with the genocide in Iraq before we tackle the little issue of health care. Go USA!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:45 AM on 04/25/2008

Um, Hopeless277, Goodness you're comparing pples and oranges. Autism ain't a boob job or rotator cuff surgery. Its a HUGE burden on families financially and emotionally. Even under the best of circumstances, families struggle to hold it together and to date, have had NO inclusion in the basic insurance system. You might want to check out my HuffPo piece from yesterday (Barbara! Am I poaching a reader? Forgive me!) that explains just how much we autism families need to respect, attention and inclusion from our leaders.

And yes, we also need to protect the Iraqi women and children, having stormed their nation.

Best,

Kim Stagliano
HuffPo Blogger
Mom to 3 girls with autism

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:32 PM on 04/25/2008

Kim

Please do poach away! I'd love to be listed as a "similar blogger" with you. By the way, on top of autism my husband had rotator cuff surgery and it was no picnic when he couldn't use his arm to help with our son Dan. Dan needs a strong arm. Insurance of course paid for rotator cuff surgery but not Dan's speech therapy. What a world!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:03 PM on 04/25/2008

You need to find the post where the Iraqi people are priority. As an American, you should be more concerned about home first other issues second.
Oh, I just realized, your name is hopeless.
That explains a lot!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:04 PM on 04/25/2008

Killing Iragi women and children is a tragedy but it does not make children autism epidemic in USA less tragic. As a mother I completely understand Ms. Fischkin feelings. Mentioning autism in a speech may be a little thing but it shows that Hillary is aware of problems American families have to deal with every day. To me this represents real, not rhetoric, change in politics.
And, speaking of Iragi people, isn't ending the war priority #1 in democratic agenda anyway?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:11 PM on 04/25/2008
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in

 
 

 
 
Related Tags
 

 Site  Web ask.com