More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Beth Broderick

GET UPDATES FROM Beth Broderick
 

It Happened One Christmas

Posted: 12/13/11 05:11 PM ET

It was five days before Christmas. I had recently relocated to Los Angeles from New York and was having trouble engaging the Holiday spirit. There was no Rockefeller Center with it's giant tree to marvel at. No fifth avenue crush of shoppers and revelers to knock up against. No bourbon on the rocks at the Oak Room watching the horse drawn carriages glide into Central Park. LA was trying. There were some lights on Wilshire Boulevard and Santa Claus had been dutifully installed in all of the shopping malls. There were Salvation Army elves ringing bells outside of Kmart and most folks had dutifully strung lights on their houses and inflated rubber reindeer for their lawns, but it just did not feel like Christmas. I had set about grumbling in the tradition of so many who had made the trek across the country before me armed with Woody Allen quotes and Big Apple big headedness.

In spite of this and in spite of temperatures that threatened to give old Saint Nick a heatstroke, I agreed to venture forth into the the shopping fray with my friend Lorraine and we headed to a nearby Music Plus store to pick up some Holiday tunes for her family. The store was located on a fairly crowded and decidedly unglamorous stretch of Fairfax Avenue. This was over 20 years ago, long before the glittering Grove with it's valet parking and concierge service, when there was still such a thing as a Music Plus store. We were out of the car and headed in to the store when something caught our eye. There was a van parked in the farthest space of the lot and something seemed off about it. It had an aura of abandonment and yet there was clearly movement inside. We watched for several minutes to see if the occupants would emerge.

It was one of those moments -- of which I have had far too many -- when instinct overcomes caution. Something was just not right in that van. We approached the old VW and tapped on the window. The woman in the driver's seat hesitated before slowly cranking the handle, her eyes haunted and wide with fear. There were three young children in the van as well, all bunched up together in the back seat. The woman had a large bruise on the left side of her face. She did not have to explain... it was clear that she had been abused and was on the run. This parking lot her only refuge. We asked if she had enough fuel to drive a few blocks to Lorraine's home and she nodded yes. We pulled out of the lot slowly hoping that she would have the courage to follow and breathed a sigh of relief when she pulled up behind us.

Once home Lorraine set about feeding the kids and I gathered laundry so that we could give them clean clothes to wear. The woman had a severe limp, but said it was nothing and set about bathing them. Lorraine and I pondered our next move. I began to make calls to City services and shelters. The news was not good. To this day there are almost no facilities in Los Angeles that can house a woman with her children. Many families in this situation are split up with the mother housed in one place and the children in another. This mother was willing to reside in a Music Plus parking lot in order to be with her kids. She would never agree to that.

After placing at least a dozen calls I was beginning to worry that the family would be consigned to the the van for the foreseeable future. I was running out of options when I placed a call to the Good Shepherd Center and Sister Joan Mary answered, her warm voice accented with an irish lilt. "Oh no," she said "we are over capacity and so is everyone else. There is just no place to put them... a terrible shame so many with no where to go." I begged, I cajoled, I pleaded with Sister Joan to help me place them. "I'm yours for life," I said. "I will volunteer raise money anything you need... just please do what you can!" "All right," she said with a heavy sigh. "I'll see what I can do."

The woman refused the medical attention she clearly needed, but accepted our offering of blankets and flashlights and the use of Lorraine's driveway. The family was invited to eat and bathe in the house, but there was just no place to bed them all. Two days passed. I was still making calls and working every angle to no avail. Tomorrow would be Christmas eve and I had to abandon the effort while my friends and I scrambled to find gifts for the kids. Around nine PM we settled the family in their van and poured a big glass of wine preparing to wrap gifts into the night, when the phone rang and Sister Joan's unmistakable Irish accent came over the line. "I've got them a place," she said. "They can come tomorrow to this address. We will give them a good Christmas." "God bless you, Sister," I said through tears, "I will not forget my promise." "Oh, I'll count on that," she said and that was good night.

The nuns at the Good Shepherd homes have rescued countless women and their children over the years. I kept my word and my friends and family provide Christmas gifts for their families every year. I used to give Sister Joan candy but she begged me to stop. "I 'll be fat as a house if you keep this up," she'd say with a ready smile. She retired a few years back, but the work goes on.

These have been tough times for the shelter and the nuns had to close one of their facilities due to lack of funds. Ever resourceful they doubled up their living quarters and turned their office space into housing, so that they would not have to turn desperate families away. These women have experienced abuses that most of us cannot contemplate. I am so grateful to Good Shepherd for answering their need and for taking my call on that dark night so long ago. Amidst the palm trees and under the blazing California sun, the spirit of Christmas shines brightly in their hearts all year round and has opened mine forever.

 
It was five days before Christmas. I had recently relocated to Los Angeles from New York and was having trouble engaging the Holiday spirit. There was no Rockefeller Center with it's giant tree to ma...
It was five days before Christmas. I had recently relocated to Los Angeles from New York and was having trouble engaging the Holiday spirit. There was no Rockefeller Center with it's giant tree to ma...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 96
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
11:44 PM on 12/25/2011
Charity only feels good to those doling it out.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Capn Scott
the 'moderated' me
09:56 PM on 12/25/2011
I was seeing a woman for a while recently who had supposedly left her previous relationship because of purported 'abuse'. She received help through connections from her workplace, who found her temporary housing and gave her other crucial support as she sought a new place to live.

Fast forward several years later and she still retains ties to this guy (he babysits her dogs while on vacation, and stores some of her stuff for her even though she has room in her new home for it all now, etc.) ..even to the point now where she has begun going out on dates with him again.

My conclusions are twofold:
1) The woman isn't as smart as I had thought or hoped.
and/or
2) The stories of 'abuse' by him were a load of crapola.

Anyways, the jackass in the entire situation was myself for getting involved with the woman in the first place while she continued to maintain ties to her 'ex'.
My parting advice to her was to not let her workplace and the people who had helped her out before find out she was now back seeing the guy again ...as they might tend to blame her this time around and not be so 'caring'....not to mention kicking themselves for wasting their time getting involved before. I know I'm kicking my self.
09:11 PM on 12/25/2011
Our society is sick at its roots. It needs to be watered, fed an cherished. Or Chopped down and have a now one panted.
YogiBear53
Atlas IS shrugging.
08:27 PM on 12/25/2011
This story underscores the need for Planned Parenthood and free abortion services as well. Too many people end up having children they cannot afford because they got pregnant. We have so many children in society today - our schools cannot educate them properly , no matter how much money we throw at the situation. And millions are lacking enough food. As a landlord I had plenty of unwed moms with as many as 8 children (by 5 fathers in one case). The drain on society is horrific. Luckily for some of these women there are section 8 and other programs, but school taxes are enormous.
Think "one child per parent!"
photo
Stalling
Holy Money
08:14 PM on 12/25/2011
And I read it thinking Beth was living in a van twenty years ago but alas she saw someone living in a van twenty years ago. What a shocker.
photo
SkreetGil1
The Power of Myth by Joseph Campbell
05:37 PM on 12/25/2011
The rich get richer and the poor get poorer and it becomes a mad, mad, dog eat dog world.

And the thing is...it doesn't have to be this way.

The income inequality is larger now in America than it was in the Roman Empire, ever!

We need to get rid of this horrible GOP and blue dog democrats.

Now!
photo
The Corporate Champion
Conservative, because someone's got to do the work
07:33 PM on 12/25/2011
Instead of regurgitating the empty rhetoric you read on HossPuff comments, why don't you do us a favor and donate some money?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Capn Scott
the 'moderated' me
10:14 PM on 12/25/2011
Why should the poor working man be the one to foot the bill while the wealthy and corporations pay little to none actual taxes after all of the loopholes, deductions and dodges available to them...and receive corporate welfare to boot.

Do yourself a favor and check out the recent list of the top several hundred corporations who paid next to no taxes in the past 3 years...some even had a net negative tax burden...meaning they got money back.
They're the same scum-sucking companies you read about in the paper ever day...i.e. Wells Fargo, B of A, Wall Street companies, oil companies, pharmaceutical companies, etc., etc., etc.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sheldon archer
Our facebook is Yuyun Archer
05:35 PM on 12/25/2011
If all Cristians were like that one could respect them. Sadly that is not the case.
photo
The Corporate Champion
Conservative, because someone's got to do the work
07:26 PM on 12/25/2011
Why do you mention Christians specifically? Why not any other group?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sheldon archer
Our facebook is Yuyun Archer
02:01 AM on 12/26/2011
Because the story was about a Christian
03:33 PM on 12/25/2011
Poverty, money-woes or joblessness never justifies abuse. Abuse is all about power over
another and nothing else. Employers are as likely to to abuse employees as an angry out of control man is to abuse a woman or vice-versa. Employers are more subtle which is why Americans fail to see the writing on the wall. This is a sign of the times, but we the people have power to change others lives for the better. The 99% need to form a strong coalition to change the direction of this country. We can do; Yes we can!!! Merry Holidays to all...
photo
Born to be riled
Undo in One and Two!
05:37 PM on 12/25/2011
Merry Holidays? Please, either be an atheist or don't be, but this half way stuff is hard to take. And moving a battered wife to the employee / boss arena, bit of a stretch,no?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
xenubarb
Nebulon V
06:56 PM on 12/25/2011
Merry Winter Solstice? Happy Festivus? Pasta Days, when the sun pasta halfway mark in Rastafarianism? Merry Saturnalia?

You know, you don't have to be a Christian or an atheist to celebrate this holiday season. The Winter Solstice signifies the lengthening of the days into a new year, surely worth celebrating no matter what you believe. Don't be so Christo-centric, it's part of why Christians are all whiney about a "War on Christmas." You don't own all the reasons for the season.
07:21 PM on 12/25/2011
Actually, I'm a Christian, but NOT the kind currently in favor of the GOP. You know, the loud obnoxious self-proclaimed Christians who thinks it's okay to force their beliefs on everyone else although they don't practice what they preach... I don't tell people my faith unless they ask. I don't preach and I don't discriminate against minorities, gay people, people of color, or the poor. I regularly donate to charity and I pray in private and I don't insult people with different religious beliefs.

Many employers inflict both economic and verbal abuse or threats on employees.
I know that from first hand experience. For recent examples of abuse against employees, you need look no further than Walmart, or Amazon warehouses where employees are asked to work in intolerable heat or stand out in the cold. If they complain or get ill, they are threatened with immediate replacement. To me, it sounds like another abuse of power which is something men usually inflict of women more often than women inflict on men. Research your own stats. I stand by what I said.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
El 84
Reason is my religion.
03:28 PM on 12/25/2011
Should I be proud to be an American when one of the biggest cities in the country doesn't have adequate shelter for homeless women and children. I quit believing all the propaganda fed me about what a wonderful, caring nation this is. It is not true. It is a crime-ridden, corrupt, selfish nation of two-faced hypocrisy.
On an unrelated note, that's a really cool picture of the 8.4 million dollar penthouse at Beaver Creek in the real estate ad that is supposed to look like a Huffington Post article.
03:16 PM on 12/25/2011
Heart wrenching story! No funding because the rich are hording so much of the wealth of our country. The economy is like a poker game folks, when one player out of ten has all the money the game is over.
12:51 PM on 12/25/2011
Prayers to Allah for all these women and children who have suffered domestic violence and to all homeless people. May I, in the upcoming year, do more to help people in need. Amin
photo
Born to be riled
Undo in One and Two!
01:29 PM on 12/25/2011
If only we could have 4 wives in America, the good men could take better care of the woman. No woman of mine would end up like this!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gavrielle
Empty... Empty... Empty...
03:22 PM on 12/25/2011
Women ought to be able to take care of themselves, not rely on others for safety and protection. The first time my now ex-husband laid a hand on me I got his shotgun and gave him ten minutes to pack his things and get out. I promised if he ever came near me again without an express invitation, I'd assume it was to do me harm and I'd get him before he got me. I haven't seen or heard from him in over 20 years.

That said, all things being equal, if you could have 4 wives in America, our women would demand the right to have 4 husbands. ;)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
akmomma
06:09 PM on 12/25/2011
"woman of mine"? Women are not property.
photo
splashy
Really?!?!!!
12:35 PM on 12/25/2011
It seems that there could be more non-religious places for people fleeing abuse. It's a shame that so much funding is being cut for them in favor of the wealthy keeping so much. What a sad commentary on the state of things here in the Us.

I'm happy that there are places to go for some, but there just isn't enough.
iridium53
Semper Fi
10:57 AM on 12/25/2011
a very nice story.

Happy Holidays
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
pattio66
I'm here!!!
09:40 AM on 12/25/2011
Thank you for sharing this happy ending, Ms. Broderick. I've housed many abused women and their children overnight or for a few days until they could make other arrangements, but the resources are few and far between. Thank goodness there are organizations like the Good Shepherd Center.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sonoflars
Growing old is mandatory, growing up is optional
06:54 AM on 12/25/2011
Unfortunately, this is our future. More poverty, more homelessness, more unemployment, more of everything that is bad. We've decided that we just can't afford to take care of people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spinotter11
Spinning through life and trying to understand it.
10:54 AM on 12/25/2011
But what is wrong with our society that so many people need taking care of? The woman and her children, the victim of domestic abuse? So many millions of people who have become marginalized and who suffer homelessness, violence, hunger? It seems to me that our nation is foundering. Is there any hope for a better future?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sonoflars
Growing old is mandatory, growing up is optional
11:14 AM on 12/25/2011
We have a perfect storm. 50 years of trickle down economics that has consolidated the nation's wealth into the top 10 percent (most into the top 1%), Free Trade deals that benefited corporations as they moved labor out of the U.S. to the 3rd world, suspension of Sherman Anti Trust enforcement that has permitted a handful of big box stores to destroy main street in every village, town and city in the country and finally the Supreme Court who have handed the political process to corporations, foreign and domestic. And.. and it's the biggest challenge we face, technology driven productivity that is replacing people faster than new jobs can be created. In other words, we deserve everything we're getting because we let them do it. And, it isn't going to get better until we stop them. Liberte, egalite, fraternite
photo
splashy
Really?!?!!!
12:38 PM on 12/25/2011
Much of that is the product of the patriarchal society and religions we have, along with the sociopathic addiction to money that says that if you don't have it you are to be considered lazy and good-for-nothing.

The ideology of Ayn Rand and others has infected too many, leading to too much selfishness and too little community.
photo
Born to be riled
Undo in One and Two!
12:47 PM on 12/25/2011
No, this was our past. It happened over 20 years ago. But keep hoping for Soylent Green if it makes you feel better.