More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Beth Weissenberger
 

Why Divorces Get Ugly and How to Have a Good One

Posted: 02/16/11 01:06 AM ET

If you are married and socialize with a group of friends on a regular basis, at some point at least one couple if not several couples in that group will go through a divorce. It's inevitable. The divorce statistics are too high. Almost one in every two marriages ends in divorce these days and most of those divorces turn ugly. You know, you see it all the time. The "once" loving couple is now slinging mud at each other from across an expensive conference table in a high-powered attorney's office. But, it doesn't have to be that way.

  • First Marriages: 45 percent to 50 percent end in divorce
  • Second Marriage: 60 percent to 67 percent end in divorce
  • Third Marriage 70 percent to 73 percent end in divorce [1]
Right now, my husband and I are in the process of getting divorced and we are the best we've been in a year and half. As a coach, I know this is not common, but how my husband and I have handled the end of our marriage was a contributing factor to having our divorce go smoothly. We've been married for 12 years and have a nine-year-old daughter. After almost 10 years together, I had become unhappy in our marriage. Instead of keeping it a secret and hating my husband in my head, I told him exactly how I was feeling. We had a real conversation about our marriage and he told me what he wanted me to work on as well. For a while, we worked privately on ourselves but things didn't change. We decided to get outside help. We went to marriage counseling, did a course on relationships and got coached. We spent a year and half working on our marriage. Finally, after Thanksgiving 2010, it really wasn't working and I asked my husband for a divorce. Now, we're getting divorced. And are we sad? Sure. Am I blaming my husband for the divorce? Absolutely not. Is he blaming me? No. We tried to fix it but it didn't work. We loved each other and spent 12 years together but we shouldn't be married anymore. The best part is that we are taking responsibility for our part in the breakup of the marriage. There isn't any anger or hatred because we're not blaming each other. And by owning our own crap, our nine-year-old daughter is completely fine about us getting divorced. Yes, she's sad -- like we are -- but she's ok. She's actually doing great. Why Divorces Get Ugly
  1. One spouse has a dirty little secret. The reason most divorces turn ugly is because someone in the relationship has a dirty little secret. They've been lying to their spouse about how they feel and have been privately entertaining the idea of getting a divorce. They stop liking their husband or wife and begin living in the zone of "it's over" without ever telling their spouse. The spouse has no idea what's going on and believes the marriage is fine. This dirty little secret slowly destroys the relationship.
  2. That spouse builds a case against their partner.
    So, the spouse with the dirty secret begins to build a case in their head about the big, bad, evil person they're married to. They're mean. They ruined my life. I hate them. The spouse with the secret feels completely justified as the innocent one because they're talking to themselves about the awful person they are going to dump. They don't realize they are a withholding liar. They are causing all the tension. They don't have the balls to have a conversation with their spouse and tell them they are unhappy and considering divorce. Instead they lie and explain away their happiness in their head, creating an even more toxic environment.
  3. No one owns their own crap in the marriage.
    Now, the one spouse is not only building a case to dump their partner, they're also pointing the finger and blaming the downfall of the marriage on their spouse without acknowledging their part. They believe they are the innocent victim and their husband or wife is the "bad" one. It never even occurs to them that they may have also contributed to the downfall of the relationship. All they do is blame and play innocent. This leads to complete breakdown of communication between the spouses.
  4. All real communication is gone.
    The Handel Method is about looking at yourself and how you got where you are in your life. We get clients to really understand why they did what they did in a particular situation and to own it fully. When you look at your part in the breakdown of your marriage it ultimately releases all the blame you had on the other person. You have to own your own issues and own that you got yourself into this mess. You picked your spouse and forgot that you did. There's a natural way to fix it. But if there's no truthful communication between the spouses, nothing will get resolved. Often partners walk away from a relationship without knowing the truth of what really happened in their marriage. Which is often why second and third marriages fail as well. The person never learned what they needed to learn about themselves in a relationship, which would keep them from having another bad marriage.

You can say goodbye with love

The night before we went to the mediator to help us start legally dissolve our marriage, I got a bouquet of flowers and a thank you card from my soon-to-be ex-husband. In the card he thanked me for who I had become over the years and how I had helped him become the man he was today. He was excited for our futures and thrilled how well our divorce was going. When I showed the mediator the card, he was shocked. Most of his clients are barely speaking when they walk into his office.

If you own what you did in the marriage and how you got there, then the divorce is simply just dividing up the money and dealing beautifully with the children. You walked into the marriage with love and you can walk away with love. It doesn't have to be ugly.

Some advice if you are considering divorce:

  • If you're unhappy, go to your spouse and tell them what's wrong. Be completely honest.

  • Communicate to your spouse and figure out if the two of you want to make an effort to save the marriage or not. No pretending to be innocent and harboring bad feeling.

  • Look at your role in why the marriage is breaking up and own your crap. Don't just blame the other person.

  • Communicate the truth about the marriage. Walk away knowing it was both of you who contributed to the downfall of your marriage. It's a powerful feeling.

[1] Statistics source is Jennifer Baker, Forest Institute of Professional Psychology, Springfield, Missouri


 

Follow Beth Weissenberger on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Hglifecoaching

 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:13 PM on 03/18/2011
You left out a huge reason why some divorces get ugly: abusive relationships in which one partner who is angry and controlling and is not willing to compromise, to discuss, or to accept that any way is possible beyond his/her way. There is absolutely no negotiation, no fairness, no tolerance, no logic, no discussion, nothing beyond what that angry, controlling partner wants, period.

Trying to suggest possible strategies for individuals in this type of marriage is beyond counter-productive, it's just plain wrong, especially when one's safety is involved.

All those strategies are great for those who are in partnership relationships with individuals who are at least somewhat stable, but they're no use to those of us with the one simple, reasonable goal of leaving without any interference.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:35 PM on 03/04/2011
Divorces get "dirty" if you're married to someone with borderline personality disorder.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Beth Weissenberger
03:22 PM on 03/03/2011
I'd like to thank everyone for reading my blog and commenting on it. In response to the question about why second and third marriages have a higher divorce rate, one theory is that the person never handled the issue of why their marriage didn't work in the first marriage. Instead of fixing what's wrong, the person gets married again and the issue repeats itself into the second and third marriage. It's important to take a hard look at yourself and YOUR issues (not your partners) before getting into another relationship. The issue needs to be addressed and resolved, otherwise history will repeat itself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Venicelady
Ignorance is NOT bliss.
11:16 PM on 02/27/2011
In looking at the percentages of divorce that you posted, I noticed that the rates increased for divorce in second and third marriages.

Any insight into why that may be?

Thanks for your response on this question, Ms. Weissenberger.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
littlefairy
One little fairy against the world
05:10 PM on 03/01/2011
Personally, I think there should be statistics that include how long a person waited after leaving the first marriage before marrying again; whether or not the new spouse was someone with whom s/he'd been having an affair while married; whether or not the person got any significant counseling after the divorce; whether the person jumped right into dating while going through the divorce. All of these play an important role in the choice a person makes the next time around, and to lump all failed marriages into a "70% of second marriages end in divorce" can be vastly misleading.
09:01 PM on 02/25/2011
In my experience, the process of HOW one gets divorced has a huge impact on the ugliness. The early selection of a divorce process is crucial. If possible, avoid litigation and choose a form of alternate dispute resolution like collaborative divorce or mediation.
02:25 AM on 02/25/2011
I am presently six months into the process of a divorce. No fault divorce filed by my wife. So far i have been removed from my home, had all of my personal belongings taken from me, large portion of my take home pay taken (january was around 78%) and my time with my children is limited to a 3 and 1 schedule when i am home. Am i having a good divorce so far?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
littlefairy
One little fairy against the world
05:13 PM on 03/01/2011
Gee, chebaudoin, you mean you had an experience--are having one--that is far more like what MOST divorces are like? No offense to the author of the article, but get real. First of all, very few people will be in a situation as they were, and very few couples will come together with such amicability. Good for them, but it can be very hard to feel like you are doing anything right if you compare yourself to her/them. Just do the best you can to be a person of integrity and work through the pain--and your contribution to the demise of the relationship. And then, let her own her part, too. Divorce is a major life event.
07:53 AM on 02/21/2011
What a wonderful job you did in articulating the importance of spouses moving away from the
blame game and getting interested in what their contribution was to the failure of the marriage. Might I add that the process of discovering "your crap" is not necessarily a solitary one. Working with a psychotherapist, a lifecoach, or in a divorce group are effective choices for studying oneself to learn where you went wrong, what to avoid, and how to do it better next time. Betsy Ross,LICSW
12:57 PM on 02/20/2011
Very good advice but unfortunately it only works when both parties are able to move forward without impeding the others future.

Having lived divorce my whole life, through childhood and my own divorce after 6 years of marriage and 2 children, I have one piece of advice to people contemplating marriage. Marry someone who will make a good ex wife as you can live with a bad wife but you cant live with a bad ex wife.

This leads to the question of what makes a good ex wife? A good ex wife is someone who will always be able to support herself and be financially independent. A good ex wife realizes the value of both parents being equally involved in the raising of children, kids don't "visit" their fathers. A good ex wife realizes the benefit in maintaining respect to the father of her children and how this will help her move ahead in her own life.

Of course these qualifications are not gender specific and must be adhered to by both parties but they should always be discussed before marriage not during divorce. Marriage is a high risk investment and realizing how to mitigate these risks before the contract is signed will go a long way to ensuring everyone has a positive future no matter what the outcome.

Sadly the only emotion that is more intense and uncontrollable than new love is when love turns to hate.
09:34 AM on 02/20/2011
If your strong enough to go away with love, wasn't it strong enough to stay married? I guess I'm just old school: divorce is for serial cheating or abuse. Other reasons are just frivolous.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
littlefairy
One little fairy against the world
05:15 PM on 03/01/2011
I would not say they are frivolous (although some certainly are), but perhaps we have such a culture of making ourselves "happy" that I think you have a point. For some reason, people think marriage should be easy. It should be rewarding and healing, but most things of real value are not gained or kept easily. Still, I am not anyone else's judge. We all have to bear the results of our choices.
photo
jf12
Occupying myself
12:42 PM on 03/02/2011
100% of divorces are about sex and money, including the one in the article. Almost all divorcing women have secret bank accounts "which doesn't count as lying because, well, you never know".
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Belinda Rachman
Fly in the ointment lawyer
09:08 AM on 02/20/2011
You have EXACTLY the right idea about what divorce can be and a perfect attitude about your role as well as the perfect solution. By hiring a mediator, you avoided the inevitable war that would have happened had you each "lawyered up." As a family law attorney since 1996 and one of the leaders of the Peaceful Divorce movement, I know too well the dangers of letting someone with a financial interest in keeping the fight going, drive a case towards a long battle because they get paid more the more the clients fight. Nice, honest people who just want to protect the children and save money should avoid hiring their own divorce lawyer and seek the best mediator in their area! Look for an experienced family law attorney who focuses their practice on mediation and NOT litigation. There are a lot of wolves in sheep's clothing who want business, any business but they are not experts in crafting win/win deals. Ask what percentage of their practice consists of mediation. Ask what their success rate is and how long and how much an average case takes. Your children will thank you. I wish my parents would have worked together instead of demonizing each other!
12:23 AM on 02/17/2011
You must have been married to one in a million.
You ASKED your husband for a divorce?
Your husband sent you flowers and a card saying thankyou for who you now were and helping him become the person he now was the day before filing for divorce?
No blaming each other or anger at each other for the divorce?
Truthfully, I have never heard of a couple being so polite and understanding to each other when going through a divorce. Even those who say there are no problems usually are just hiding the anger or resentment.You both are obviously mature, caring, confident, intelligent, healthy, secure people and I am in awe.
Like I said, one in a million.
Good luck to both of you.
07:09 PM on 02/16/2011
I was stunned by the 1-2-3-4 progression of your article, because it so closely resembles what I've been through. My wife (not yet my ex) followed this to a tee. As another comments below, I suddenly did not know this person. And despite the horrifying speed with which she dismantled the marriage, she expected that the kids wouldn't really be hurt, that I wouldn't be hurt, that I would be okay with what she had decided and that even the legal business would be easy. I couldn't even think about the legal business for months, and now that we are at that point, it looks like it will be very hard indeed. While I've been months in counselling working out what happened and how I contributed to what happened, even going so far as sending her a letter about what I wish I'd done differently, she has yet to take ownership for anything. I don't think collaborative law will work in this case, as we are so far apart.
10:11 PM on 02/16/2011
Paste- My ex put me in jail, attempted to have me arrested for sexual assault on my 15 year old step daughter. Luckily, she wouldn't cooperate with her mom and admitted to the police what her mother said. My ex spent the 18 months we were apart not working, to better build a case for child support. Her boyfriend is a drug dealer, fresh out of jail. My ex is incapable of self reflection and I highly doubt she assumes any of the blame. With all this, when we went to mediation we were able to settle. It was unbelievable. Good luck to you. Remember you will be linked with your ex for the rest of your life. Let go of the resentment, don't ask her to accept responsibility and you will be the better for it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
littlefairy
One little fairy against the world
05:18 PM on 03/01/2011
The pain was sort of overlooked in the article, huh? I hear ya! While it MAY be true that the couple (in the article) truly have accomplished this sort of feat, it also may be true that they are merely congratulating themselves for nothing real. Time will tell whether their choices in life are wise ones or selfish ones.

Still, we all have the freedom to be ourselves, even if that means harming another person. Pity--at best--when it is someone you made a vow to.

I hope you can find healing.
11:39 PM on 03/01/2011
Thanks for the kind words, and I am stumbling toward some version, however imperfect, of healing. Funny how exercising that freedom can cause so much damage. I guess she did what she thought she had to do, but a lot of hearts were broken, a lot of dreams dashed. And I wonder if she's truly happy in the new life that she's made, given the bitter price the rest of us have paid. As you say, time will tell.
02:48 PM on 02/16/2011
I am glad that you are in the process of a successful divorce. This is the very best thing for your daughter. You and your ex deserve praise. My divorce turned nasty almost immediately. My ex stated that she needed to aid my eldest step daughter and move 1200 miles away. She would also be changing my son's name. There is so much more to this story.
Anyway, she is mentally ill and a narcissist. Our divorce got worked out by the mediator. She is behaving well now. I accept my role in the divorce, and this is very important. I have also forgiven her and I want her to have success. He success will have a positive impact on my son. One aspect people forget is the child is a part of you, the child is also a part of your ex. Therefore, if you strike out in anger at your ex, you hurt your child and yourself. I know what you are thinking, very deep. Thanks for sharing your story.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:34 AM on 02/16/2011
You are right, there is no way to have a good divorce when one party goes ahead and does items 1, 2, 3, and 4 on your list. The other party is left to contemplate those burned bridges and watch their spouse disappearing over the horizon while thinking, "Who did I marry? I do not recognize this person."

I hope readers who are thinking about going down that road will take heed and reconsider.
07:42 AM on 02/16/2011
You make many good and eloquent points. Thank you for your perspective; it's very thoughtful.