More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bill Davenhall

GET UPDATES FROM Bill Davenhall
 

Geomedicine: The Missing Link In Our Personal Health History

Posted: 02/05/10 03:45 PM ET

In 2001 I was hit by a train. Okay, not a real train but it might as well have been! My train was a heart attack. When it happened I thought to myself, "why me", "why now", "why here?" I thought I was in good health. I had followed the advice of many doctors, but still the train hit me. As I worked through my crisis, I started thinking about the many factors that could have contributed to my heart attack and wondered why I had not had better warning?

Having worked in and around healthcare for many years I had learned a great deal about how to avoid a heart attack. You know, the usual things: avoid risks, live a healthy lifestyle, control my weight, choose better food and drink, don't smoke, reduce stress ... all excellent advice to a reasonable person.

Like many of you, however, I had provided a lot of personal information to all my healthcare providers over many years, such as family history, medication history, surgical history, disease history, allergy history, social history and of course my lifestyle inventory. I now wondered why none of that information had actually helped avoid the roaring train bearing down on me.

I soon began to discover that there were many different reasons why I may have been hit by that train. In addition to all the usual suspects, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, stress, genetics, I discovered that many environmental conditions and exposures could greatly increase my risk for a heart attack. Things like air quality and exposures to pollutants -- some that I did not even know existed in the communities where I lived. As I began to research the places (aka geographies) where I had lived -- both as a child and an adult -- I began to discover disturbing information on what I (and my doctors) could have already known about the quality of my various environments and what the impact might be on my future health.

My search was not easy, even on the Internet. Large volumes of health information spread across many governmental and health related websites of varying quality. While I cannot prove that any one of my specific environments caused my health attack, there was plenty of evidence that some of the contaminants I had been exposed to in places where I had lived, were well known precursors to circulatory and respiratory disease -- and yes heart attacks. It was at this moment that I realized that a physician looking at my health history, in the absence of any specific information about my unique environmental exposures (geographically), would be less likely to warn me, let alone guide me away from the oncoming train wreck. The problem, as I have come to see it, is that none of my physicians had a useful or easy way of translating all that rich environmental health research into something that would benefit me directly. Why was it so difficult for me and my doctors to connect the dots?

Every place I have ever lived and will live is part of my medical history. The impact of breathing bad air in many of the places I have lived will surely follow me where ever I go, and therefore, my medical record should be automatically informed about new research findings of relevant health risks.

Unfortunately today, my medical record and probably yours as well, is already a vast collection of clinical facts, observations, test results and diagnostic conclusions but remains silent about the accumulation of environmental health impacts and risks. As a patient as well as a good health-seeking consumer, I need to be better served by the great wealth of environmental health research that is available. I also need to do what I can to increase the capacities of physicians to consume and use this information in smarter ways.

I invite you to think about the places you've lived, or where you live today, and learn more about the impacts of your environments on your own health. I've worked with my colleagues to share a new online app (free and anonymous) that can help give you some ideas on how you might approach your own health discovery process as I have done. There is much to learn about geomedicine and understanding how it can become a valuable tool in clinical practice. I hope that I can begin to help readers of this blog to learn more about the subject of personal geomedicine and discover ways to stay healthier longer. If you're new to this discussion perhaps watching my TedMed talk and reading Alana Kornfeld's blog on that event will help.

 

Follow Bill Davenhall on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BillDavenhall

In 2001 I was hit by a train. Okay, not a real train but it might as well have been! My train was a heart attack. When it happened I thought to myself, "why me", "why now", "why here?" I thought I was...
In 2001 I was hit by a train. Okay, not a real train but it might as well have been! My train was a heart attack. When it happened I thought to myself, "why me", "why now", "why here?" I thought I was...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:02 AM on 02/10/2010
Very interesting post and ideas. I agree, we can try to take full control of our personal health and still miss something important such as our previous and current exposure to environmental factors. I think about the teenagers with their cellphones (electrical stimulation) ,or our overuse of computers (me included !) (more electrial stimulation), plus so much more out there that we don't know about.
It is good to research your past exposure and see if any of it could be "detrimental" to your future health. As an example, I think of a doctor in France who grew up fishing from the Rhone river( a hugh river in the SE of France) . NOW the Rhone river is considered one of the most polluted in France, but back then noone mentioned that the big electrical units that were dropped in the river because they had nowhere to go could cause the fish to spread mercury and other toxins to those who ate them. This doctor, after eating fish all summer in his youth, has had numerous cancers and continues to fight to show the link between his past environment and current health. And, by the way, it is now forbidden to eat the fish in the Rhone. Mary Brighton, MS, RD
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bill Davenhall
01:18 PM on 02/23/2010
Thanks you for your thoughtful comments. There are many stories similar to the one of the French physician - I have heared or read at least one every day since I began to blog on the topic of geomedicine! It should not be a surprise to me since making public data accesible has always been my chief concern. If we all wait until medical science has the "smoking gun" about what causes our "idiopathic" enviornmentally related diseases we would be not be well served by our unique ability to "connect some dots" - just like the French doctor has done. I suspect that has a medical professional you have more stories about this subject?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Alison Rose Levy
Connect the Dots www.healthjournalist.com
01:13 PM on 02/09/2010
Dear Bill:

Thanks for sharing this. Having reported on a wide scope of health practices and interventions for over twenty-five years, I always consider it so helpful when something new helps us to look at health from a new perspective.

I'd heard about this app from both Alana's coverage and my colleagues at Urban Zen where I also blog. What's exciting to me about it is that it helps us understand our connection to our environment. Bravo!

And as Ray points out in his comment below-- what then can we do about that? As the point certainly is not to fret about things we can't change, but to learn how to change the things that are impacting so many of us. Things like contaminants in our food, air, and water-- as per the comment on fracking below.

It's natural for people to feel disempowered or overwhelmed when this topic comes up because the concern is that this may be hard to address. But the more of us who are aware of it, the more possible becomes a community of support.

And it's also vital to connect with the many health interventions that can help relieve toxic burden to prevent the kinds of illnesses that result.

This is the kind of connecting the dots that we need to do in health care. Thank you for your great work.

For health insight, science, and action, get the free ezine at www.healthjournalist.com
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bill Davenhall
01:11 PM on 02/23/2010
Alison - thanks for your comments on the subject. You put it into the "right" perspective as well - getting to some of this information is just too hard and so by making it more accessible we create opportunties for self discovery. Thanks.
08:52 AM on 02/09/2010
Oh it dosen't do it for UK citizens. Interesting perspective... health is an oxymoron... there's certainly much that you can do to look after your health, but doing too much worrying/research over it could be called unhealthy.

From Vicky Allison
Writer of http://www.AntiCelebrity.net
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bill Davenhall
01:27 PM on 02/23/2010
Vickey - thanks for your UK insights on the subject. Having too much information is frequently a problem for society but what we need is greater understanding of this information. Our greatest need in this space still appears to be knowing what to do with what we know - understanding what it could mean to our health. Smoking is a great example - in spite of all the information available today about the harmful effects of smoking - millions of people still do it - proving your point in a way - that just having more informaion is simply not enough! I often remark 'when people don't have any information they make it up"! Geomedicince to me is a partnership between you and your doctor - using all the information you can get your hands on to make intelligent choices that benefit you. That is my message as well as my hope - in creating more energy around the notion that our medical "partnerships" need to exploit information that appears relevant to us and what we think makes us sick.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RMankovitz
Researcher, inventor, entrepreneur, author
10:53 PM on 02/08/2010
The comments below are based on research in the books "Nature's Detox Plan", and "The Wellness Project."

I certainly agree it is important to be aware of your environment and its toxin load. On the other hand, what are you or your caregiver going to do about it?

My approach, based on two decades of research in the field, and author of books on the subject, is as follows. We do not fully understand the effect of many toxins on the human body, we do not have test methods to determine the levels of many toxins in the environment or in the body, we have yet to identify what many of these toxins are, and the medical establishment is mostly clueless as to how to remove toxins from the body.

In today's world, I cannot think of any location that could be considered toxin free. Accordingly, regardless of where you live, the proactive approach is to take all reasonable steps to insulate yourself from a whole bevy of toxins, and to put in place a detox regimen.

By way of a simple example, everyone in the U.S. should have a drinking water filter in place in their home; a shower filter to remove chlorine; home air filtration with a microfine HEPA filter in conjunction with UV; minimal artificial flooring; and a regimen of detox protocols based on those provided for us by nature.

Roy Mankovitz, Director
http://www.MontecitoWellness.com
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bill Davenhall
01:06 PM on 02/23/2010
Well said!
photo
brooklyncitizen
Quaerite primum regnum dei
08:07 PM on 02/08/2010
Interesting perspective on illness. I think it's all mysterious, random and not personal, like just about everything that happens in life.
06:14 PM on 02/08/2010
I've lived very clean except for the last five years, Chicago loop, 27 chemicals hanging around. No wonder I felt like crap!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:28 PM on 02/08/2010
anyone living near Natural Gas fracking beware : http://www.gaslandthemovie.com/

natural gas: one of many industries that are killing land, water, animals, and people.

and thanks for this post: environment - both the obvious chemical exposure and safety of water - as well as the general vibe/energy of the people/culture and the balance of nature around us, have a lot to do with our physical as well as mental health. the 'wherever you go, there you are' mantra i have found to be true in terms of inner demons BUT even that can be influenced by where we live and what we are "taking in" in our environment. I feel grateful I even have a choice in the matter.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bill Davenhall
01:04 PM on 02/23/2010
it's all about having choice - and the information behind it that seems to matter to how we all engage with our enviornments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ralph Noyes
I rant therefore I am.
02:04 PM on 02/08/2010
Like childhood exposure to above-ground nuclear tests?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:53 AM on 02/08/2010
How close does a person need to be to the various chemicals and for how long?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bill Davenhall
12:57 PM on 02/23/2010
It depends...not a precise answer but according to the scientists in the field of enviornmental health it depends on the exact chemical in question, how long (days, weeks, years) you were exposed to it and then there is the issue of your own body's unique ability to absord certain chemicals. If you visit www.toxmap.gov you can learn more about each chemical tested..in places you have lived. You will also discover that many more chemicals have not been tested!. (out of 80,000 known chemicals, the US EPA only tracks about 600 and far fewer have been received significant "testing". The more you discover the more curious you will become in learning more!