In the ongoing fight to keep tarsands oil in the ground, no group has been more vocal, more consistent, and more effective than native and indigenous groups on both sides of the border.
When I think back on the year's campaign -- which has at least temporarily halted construction of the pipeline -- many of the faces I see in my mind's eye come from native communities: Melina Laboucan-Massimo in tears describing the death of family and friends from the strange cancers now common across the tarsands territory, or Gitz Crazyboy showing pictures of the wrecked landscape where he grew up. The Indigenous Environmental Network, small and underfunded, was just as key in this fight as the biggest of the Washington green groups.
This Friday, tribal leaders from across the continent will meet for their third summit with the president in Washington, and one of the prime items on the agenda will be the fight against the Keystone Pipeline. They'll talk about the way both the pipeline and the process of approving it have violated treaties, and they'll present the president with a copy of the Mother Earth Accord adopted in a special meeting at the Rosebud reservation a few weeks ago. It's a strong document, full of details about the impacts of tar sands mining and pipeline leaks and carbon emissions -- but it also speaks with the real power of the people who've lived longest and best on this continent. Indeed, it begins by affirming that "the earth is our true mother, our grandmother who gives birth to us and maintains all life."
In many ways, that's the most real language anyone's used in the entire debate. It sums up all the scientific testimony about parts per million and degrees of temperature rise--and it trumps all the empty nonsense about "energy security" and "pipeline jobs" that turned out, on closer examination, to be so much nonsense. Nonsense that was backed by millions upon millions in lobbying dollars, repeated in endless TV commercials, bandied about by pundits of every stripe. That nonsense may still carry the day -- the investment of the oil industry in the tarsands is so large that they will keep at it relentlessly. But at least for the moment, the Indians have carried the day.
And they may be able to keep doing so. The next round of tarsands pipelines are slated to go west from the Alberta deposits to the Pacific coast of British Columbia, there to be shipped via tanker to China. I was just in Vancouver and met all sorts of people organizing to block those pipelines too -- and many of their leaders were from the native communities too. Along the Canadian coast many tribes never even signed treaties, and Canadian courts have granted them great power over their land -- enough power that they seem confident of victory.
No win lasts forever, not in environmental battles. There's always someone there who wants the money badly enough that they'll find a way; no one has longer and more painful experience with that reality than native peoples across this continent. But on Friday native leaders will be representing their sovereign nations with full pride in the fact that they helped face down the oil industry, at least for a while. It's a last-ditch battle; but maybe, just maybe, it's the kind of fight that can help turn the tide.
Follow Bill McKibben on Twitter: www.twitter.com/billmckibben
Mike Casey: Can Obama Go Back to Political Base(ics)?
If Bill McKibben and the native American communities are REALLY serious about saving Mother Earth, they need to deliver the votes.
McKibben needs to translate Green into Jobs. Much of the public, fooled by all the commericals on CNN, think that environmentalists want to take away their jobs. He needs to find ways to prove that going green will improve the economy. If you heard President Obama's remaks last week on retro-fitting buildings, you will see that is precisely what Obama was doing. The same applies to the EPA's drive to eliminate mercury emissions.
So instead of protesting outside the White House, take your demonstrations to CNN, or to K Street or to the headquarters of oil and coal companies.
Second DO NOT throw away your votes for some Green Knight or Green Knight party like Ralph Nader, the Greens or anything that Occupy Wall Street comes up with. Bear in mind that even a pure green candidate like Ralph Nader would face the same problems in the Senate with the filibuster.
Bill McKibben's political strategy must include the following. First, elect the most or more progressive candidate for Congress. Second, re-elect President Obama.
Failure to follow this advice will ensure a victory for the Koch Brothers and the oil companies. 2012 may well be the environmentalists' last chance to stop Keystone.
Here it is, shovel ready, thousands and thousands of jobs. And the left wants those people to remain unemployed.
Water is our most precious resource, we can't live without it. We can't live with oil and coal, they are killing our earth.
After one study found that moose meat in the region could contain 453 times acceptable levels of arsenic, the Alberta government produced its own study showing arsenic to be "only" 17 to 33 times the acceptable levels. So tainted are fish in the area that some First Nations have reported that "fish frying in a pan smell like burning plastic."
The study, Canada's Toxic Tar Sands: The Most Destructive Project on Earth, goes on to discuss the massive tailing ponds containing a poisonous mixture of water and oil that result from the oil extraction process. It says they constitute "a megadisaster waiting to happen to the region's water supplies." Already covering more than 50 square kilometres, these lakes of toxic soup are held back only by earthen dikes, one of which rivals China's Three Gorges as the largest dam on the planet. Quoting David Schindler, one of the world's top water scientists, the study warns: "If any of those tailing ponds were ever to breach and discharge into the river, the world would forever forget about the Exxon Valdez."
http://peakenergy.blogspot.com/2008/02/tar-sands-emissions-higher-thean-145.html
http://www.gcrio.org/doctorgc/index.php/drweblog/C53/