Katrina Pain Index 2011: Race, Gender, Poverty

Six years ago, Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf coast. The impact of Katrina and government bungling continue to inflict major pain on the people left behind. It is impossible to understand what happened and what still remains without considering race, gender and poverty. The following offer some hints of what remains.

$62 million: The amount of money that the State of Louisiana and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development agreed to pay thousands of homeowners because of racial discrimination in Louisiana's program to disburse federal rebuilding funds following Katrina and Rita. African-American homeowners were more likely than whites to have their rebuilding grants based on much lower pre-storm value of their homes rather than the higher estimated cost to rebuild them.

343,829: The current population of the city of New Orleans, about 110,000 less than when Katrina hit. New Orleans is now whiter, more male and more prosperous.

154,000: FEMA is now reviewing the grants it gave to 154,000 people following hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Wilma. It is now demanding that some return the long ago spent funds! FEMA admits that many of the cases under review stem from mistakes made by its own agency employees. FEMA's error rate following Katrina was 14.5 percent.

65,423: In the New Orleans metropolitan area, there are now 65,423 fewer African-American women and girls than when Katrina hit. Overall, the number of women and girls decreased since Katrina by 108,116.

47,738: Number of vacant houses in New Orleans as of 2010.

3,000: Over 3,000 public housing apartments occupied before Katrina plus another 1,000 under renovation were bulldozed after Katrina. Less than 10 percent (238 families) have made it back into the apartments built on the renovated sites. Only half of the 3,000-plus families have even made it back to New Orleans at all. All were African-American.

75: Nearly 75 percent of the public schools in New Orleans have become charters since Katrina. Over 50 percent of public school students in New Orleans attend public charter schools. There are now more than 30 different charter school operators in New Orleans alone. According to the Institute on Race & Poverty of University of Minnesota Law School, "The reorganization of the city's schools has created a separate but unequal tiered system of schools that steers a minority of students, including virtually all of the city's white students, into a set of selective, higher-performing schools and another group, including most of the city's students of color, into a group of lower-performing schools."

70: Seventy percent more people are homeless in New Orleans since Hurricane Katrina. People living with HIV are estimated to be homeless at 10 times the rate of the general population, a condition amplified after Hurricane Katrina.

59: Less than 60 percent of Louisiana's public school students graduate from high school with their class. Among public school children with disabilities in New Orleans, the high school graduation rate is 6.8 percent.

34: Thirty-four percent of the children in New Orleans live in poverty; the national average is 20 percent.

11: Eleven New Orleans police officers were convicted of or plead guilty to federal crimes involving shootings of civilians during Hurricane Katrina aftermath.

10: At least 10 people were killed by police under questionable circumstances during days after Katrina.

3: A three-fold increase in heart attacks was documented in the two years after Katrina.

Number unknown: The true impact of the BP oil spill in terms of adverse health effects is vast but unknown. Delays by the federal government in studying the spill's physical and mental health effects hinder any ability to understand these issues with accuracy. A year after the spill, more people are reporting medical and mental health problems.

This article was co-authored with Davida Finger, also a professor at Loyola University New Orleans College of Law.

 

Comments

[kirok2002]

03:15 PM on 08/23/2011

So Mr Quigley, so what your stats show is that New Orleans is a better place that the Black polulation has decreased and the White polulation has increased? Seems right to me. Bottom line is you take an element out of the equation, and the solution seems to be easier to obtain. The one thing I learned about New Orleans is that a majority which were African American, were very dependent on the government. Not all mind you, but most. Remove that element and "boom" life seems to be better. If you look at any of the more recent tornado devestated areas, you see no uproar of how the government is not doing enough to help the victims. Dependency on the government is so wrong in cases like what happened in Katrina. Sad as it was, it proved that people need to depend on themselves to make ends meet.

[glaikery]

08:30 PM on 08/24/2011

Have you ever wondered why so many people were dependent on the government? It's quite easy to say that people need to depend on themselves to make ends meet when there are jobs available and equal opportunities between whites and blacks, but this was not the case before the storm and we as a society are still not any closer to achieving a level playing field . Years (centuries even) of institutional racism make it quite difficult for this "element...of the equation" to be independent of government assistance when you take into account the inequalities in education and a lack of regional opportunity. Please, do not claim that New Orleans is a better place since the black diaspora because this is not the case.

[dibert]

02:16 PM on 08/23/2011

i am a 62 yr. old african-american woman, who left new orleans "avoid" the storm....and ran into the worst storm of my life...i was stupid enough to think that if i evacuated for only 2 weeks...i could return and hit the ground running....well, lo and behold after moving many times, prices for housing doubling and sometimes tripling, nonprofits who gave more assistants to outsiders than people who were devastated by the storm....and still, i am not "back"....ask mr. james carville who was given the voter rolls of people who were registed voters (democrats) in new orleans..it was his "job" to locate people and help in their transistion back....why didn't he make any attempts to help me "get back"....he and his family are now living there....

[PatriotPaul]

11:10 AM on 08/23/2011

These facts are so important to be reported. I only wish the major news outlets would concentrate more on facts than emotions and hearsay. It's ironic but NOLA residents probably had more to fear from their Police and Blackwater guards than their fellow residents.

Paul Harris
Author, "Diary From the Dome, Reflections on Fear and Privilege During Katrina"

[fluzaoash]

01:59 PM on 08/23/2011

exactly.

We stayed during the storm, granted we were on Audubon park right near Children's Hospital...no flooding. Little did we know that the real trouble was lurking out there, the police, Blackwater, also word of some former Israeli guards who landed their helicopter IN the park after being brought in by some residents in the area(but we found out about that later, of course).

So yeah- the water, not nearly as scary as what could have happened if we ran into those paid to "serve and protect." The best thing we got out of it was the National Guard being there for months and months after, THEY were our police, the ones to trust.

[LMPE]

05:23 PM on 08/22/2011

I was living with a host family in St. Petersburg, Russia, when the storm hit. We watched on TV how New Orleans now looked. Here I was a representative of the US and I had to explain that my government let this happen.