More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bob Franken

Bob Franken

Posted: January 14, 2010 10:04 AM

Haiti Vis-a-Vis Health Care Reform and the Bankers

What's Your Reaction:

The President's image purveyors were quick to remind us yesterday that he spent a very long day bouncing between endless White House meetings. His Chief Executive concentration was constantly switched back and forth from the huge obstacles still confronting a final push for health care legislation and, of course, the unimaginable disaster in Haiti.

Surely, as he shuffled from one room to the other, he could not ignore the context, the relative magnitude of each. Maybe we should all take a moment to think about that.

It's worth comparing the miseries of health care and the other economic inequities in the United States to a catastrophe in a nearby country where thousands upon thousands have died, where maybe millions walk around desperately missing the miseries that are part of their everyday existence. At least their struggles were part of a routine that has literally been crushed and swallowed up by uncontrollable forces.

Decent health care? Few Haitians had it in normal circumstances. They died from diarrhea and other scourges we don't even think about here. Now, what little treatment and sanitation infrastructure there was, is obliterated. The injured, the weakened, can only be left to die in the streets by dazed passersby who are helpless.

As terrible as the lives of so many medically deprived are left by the unequally distributed system is here and as truly important as it is to make the first paltry improvements, none of that compares to the unspeakable desperation and deprivation in Port-Au-Prince.

Perhaps it occurred to others that Washington provided another context on Tuesday. How lucky the major bankers were. The first hearings, where they had the audacity to defend their gross compensation and minimize their colossal business mistakes, got little of the scornful attention they deserved.

The debate about their calculated greed and the millions of victims it caused in this country was almost completely overshadowed by those uncontrollable forces of nature that have laid waste to the impoverished victims in Haiti. Those who did notice could be forgiven for fantasizing about taking away the massive riches of the undeserving, and immediately transferring them to the relief efforts.

Still more context: it is entirely appropriate that the U.S. leads a worldwide rescue. We need go back less than a century to remember the brutal occupation of the country by American Marines, leaving a ravaged country that never recovered.

Actually many nations, most notably the French, have shared in the exploitation, beginning as far back as 1492. Even without that sad history, all nations owe our fellow human beings whatever resources it will take to help Haitians start to recover the tatters left after such a calamity.

Health care reform here? Absolutely. Better protection from economic grand larceny? You bet. But let us not forget, not how lucky we are, but how unlucky millions in Haiti and the immediate imperative to do whatever it takes there, where what there was of meager health care and the fundamental necessities and the hope for a better life have all been obliterated.

 

Follow Bob Franken on Twitter: www.twitter.com/frankenb

 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:30 AM on 01/15/2010
Interesting essay. Especially taken within the context of the bankers. It's amazing the disparities in this world.
jhNY
Mercy.
02:11 PM on 01/14/2010
On the island of Santo Domingo, which is what Haiti and the Domican Republic were called in the bad old days when the sugar industry dominated the lives of all who lived there, it was (but I can't for the life of me remember where I read it) estimated that 500,000 enslaved (by the French and the Spanish colonials) people died over a single 50-year period so that Western Europeans might enjoy the taste of cane sugar. And yep, the Marines were in Haiti for about 35 years in the 20th Century, and did little good, and much not good defending American business interests against the Haitian people. But then, more recently, there are Papa Doc and Baby Doc Duvalier, homegrown devils, who looted the nation and ruled by means of a terror state dominated by paramilitaries and secret police, for whom the US can only be blamed for propping up. But we are most recently responsible, under GWB, of instigating a coup in Haiti, which removed the democratically elected President Aristede, and we helpfully whisked him out of the country under threat of arms. Our hands are hardly clean, and most American firms there have taken advantage of the weak and corrupted government there to set up industries that operate without oversight or enforced labor or environmental statutes. Let's hope we as a nation roll up our sleeves now and get our hands dirty helping these bewildered and impoverished people however we can!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:12 AM on 01/14/2010
Are you trying to say "vis-a-vis"? I can't figure out what "vise-vi" means. Just asking.
jhNY
Mercy.
01:54 PM on 01/14/2010
Bet you're right about that nonsense combo word in the headline, but heck, it was probably submitted with the assumption an editor would fix it. Unless this is a headline editor's work...
06:29 AM on 01/15/2010
It seems to have been fixed. I only saw "vis-a-vis".