More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bob Franken

Bob Franken

Posted: January 11, 2010 09:38 AM

Remnants of Old Racism

What's Your Reaction:


Experience is constantly given short shrift. All too often, the ones who don't have it belittle the value of life and work's hard lessons.

But sometimes those who have accumulated them haven't learned as much as they should. The comments by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid in 2008 that Barack Obama would succeed because he was "light-skinned" with "no Negro dialect" are a case in point.

His remarks were disclosed in an about-to-be-released new book "Game Change", by Mark Halperin and John Heilemann. Once they became public, Reid immediately apologized profusely, but he's not the only offender.

Then candidate Joe Biden's description of Obama as "An African-American who is articulate and bright and clean..." would certainly fit the bill. So would the barbs from former President Bill Clinton during the campaign that caused such an uproar for suggestions of bigotry.

All reflect the awkwardness with race that afflicts whites from the last generation who witnessed and supported the wrenching transition for blacks from oppression part way to mainstream inclusion.

By the way, the comparisons between the opinion expressed by Democratic Senate Leader Harry Reid and a line that resulted in the downfall of Republican Leader Trent Lott in 2002 are partisan nonsense.

Let's recall that Lott was bemoaning the fact that Strom Thurmond hadn't been elected President when Thurmond ran in 1948, as an arch-segregationist. Reid was complimenting the African-American who was running for President, in a remarkably clumsy fashion, to be sure. But he didn't seem to be pining for the good old days of American apartheid in the way Lott seemed to be.

Still he and all those who took part in the movement, or at least didn't stand in the way, continue to struggle with nuanced stereotypes and misunderstandings that were considered fact just a few decades ago.

Sometimes prejudice is subtle, and deeply ingrained, scattered through the mind during one's formative years. No matter what their history of goodwill, many still grapple with its remnants.

Today's adult-wannabees didn't witness these battles, they only see the fruits of the victories. They don't give a second thought to living in multicolored surroundings because they grew up in them, unaware of what it took to undo some of the country's sorry oppression.

On the one hand it's a crying shame they're so oblivious, on the other it's wonderful that diversity is such a given...there are not even memories of anything different.

Score one for those who are growing up unencumbered by the myths of ignorance that infected the last generation. They must hear the ramblings of the Reids, or Bidens, or Clintons, or their own parents, and wonder "What the hell are they talking about"?.

They are talking about those leftovers that still hide in the subconscious and escape every once in awhile when even someone of documented goodwill dredges up an old buried bias and blurts out something stupid.

Not all experience is beneficial. Usually, though, it's better than too little experience. You need a lot of it to know how to separate the good from the bad. But we must never forget there's always more to learn. And unlearn.

 

Follow Bob Franken on Twitter: www.twitter.com/frankenb

 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
SparkyDash
Save a pretzel for the gas jets.
06:39 PM on 01/11/2010
I do believe, that the more writers and bloggers who feel a need to write comments about Halperin and Heilemann's trash called a book, will only assure that such meaningless tawdry gossip, based on lightweight sources and friends of sources rather than actual interviews of principals, only assures that this heap of garbage sells.

But that is the only reason the *cough* book was written, and that is the only reason others are jumping on each tasty piece of filthy innuendo and writing about it.

Ramblings? I recommend periodically that all of us look up the word "irony" and take note.
03:42 PM on 01/11/2010
I wish the press would force Mr. Reid to explain why he made those comments. It shows some true character flaws. It really doesn't matter if his assessment was right, it just shows his backward thinking. Al Sharpton, E. Norton Holmes, Barbara Lee, or James Clyburn are not spokespeople for the Black Race. They are representatives, but when it comes to supporting H. Reid, they are only representing them selves. The same people that wanted T. Lott and Don Imus to step down should be asking Reid to step down. The precedent has already been set. This episode will be briefly cover in my next book Plain Talk Vol. 2--Digging a little Deeper. In the mean time checkout Vol. 1:

http://www.plaintalk2010.com

I hope this episode leads into a discussion on the race issue, because every week we have a new controversy about race. People like Obama and Tiger Woods have actually harmed race relations by giving people free passes. Like Tiger Woods gave Fuzzy Zoeller and Kelly Tilghman free passes for their racial gaffes. Now from the Vanity Fair story, we see why. Obama has done everything to avoid discussions on race, he should be leading discussions on race. This technique may buy people some wiggle room, but a new race controversy usually always rears its ugly head in short order.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
LizM
My micro-bio is too long for this space.
02:38 PM on 01/11/2010
Just for the record ... that's not what Biden said. If you're going to quote someone, you might at least try to get it right.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
memosyne
11:20 AM on 01/11/2010
Slavery was one of American's original sins. It was widely supported by whites before the Civil War. It was degrading to both slaves and owners. It was inhumane to slaves. Whites committed so many crimes against blacks that they were terrified of retribution. Today they are still afraid of blacks (see documentary "Bowling for Columbine" for Mr. Heston's admission that his support for gun rights was based on fear of blacks) but their fears now extend to fears of tax-supported reparations.
Fear is the most corrosive emotion we experience: it saps our moral conscience and is the root of all prejudice. Demagogues exploit it for political gain. President Obama's election has re-ignited racial fears in the U.S. We are always afraid of those we hurt and those we hate. I pray for forgiveness and for freedom from fear for all Americans.
02:54 PM on 01/11/2010
Fear is probably the most potent of all human emotions. And the current Republican generated 'fear' against the election and possibly re-election of Pres Obama has reached heights of hysteria never before seen against a first term president. According to the republicans, 'everything Pres Obama does or suggests is wrong.' They have decided that they will vote en-masse against every move the president makes; every trip abroad; every treaty he signs; every initiative he suggests.' And they know that there is enough public gullibility to keep an avaricious press dedicated to that sort of sensationalism so they keep piling it on. They know that no-one is more susceptible to this type of nuanced fear mongering than those who still easily digest and harbor racist beliefs against Pres Obama's election; and it is to those who they focus their appeal. It is easy for some of the more enlightened among us to see how others are being exploited by racial fear but those who refuse to remove the scales from their eyes are still blinded by it. And then there are those who have discarded their cheap hoods and sheets and have replaced then with designer 'sheets.'