iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Brian D. McLaren

GET UPDATES FROM Brian D. McLaren
 

Interfaith Misunderstanding in America

Posted: 09/10/2012 12:30 pm

It's been a great year for interfaith misunderstanding in America.

There was a U.S. senator's wild allegation about Islamic extremists infiltrating the American government.

There are the ridiculous -- and ongoing -- claims about a conspiracy to "impose sharia law in America," starting in Kansas and North Carolina, of all places!

And then there's the persistent myth -- like many other myths, strangely popular among Fox News viewers -- that Barack Obama is a Muslim, accompanied by the belief that being so, if it were true, would be a scandalous thing.

Then there were debunked claims -- purveyed by the website of a Christian organization ostensibly pursuing justice -- that the Muslim Brotherhood was crucifying their Christian opponents. The post is still up, with the words "Stop Christian Genocide in Egypt" prominently displayed.

And then there's the perpetual news about the latest hijinks of this or that crazed pastor, imam, rabbi or priest who -- despite their different traditions -- manage to mirror one another's stellar misunderstanding of "the other."

Muslims, of course, feel the heat of these misunderstandings. The Sikh community feels it as never before.

Whatever our faith tradition, we all should take the dangers of interfaith misunderstanding seriously because all of us -- Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, Jews, agnostics, everyone -- are affected.

Interfaith misunderstanding is a contagious disease. Misunderstanding among "us" begets hostility against "them," and hostility against "them" begets more hostility, which eventually circles back against "us." As the global fever of interfaith hostility rises, everybody potentially finds himself in somebody's crosshairs.

But beyond practical reasons for countering interfaith hostility with interfaith benevolence, there are powerful moral reasons for doing so.

For me, as a Christian, at the core of my faith is the call to love my neighbor as myself. Jesus makes clear that my neighbor is not merely my sister or brother -- someone like me who likes me. From his Sermon on the Mount to his parable of the Good Samaritan, Jesus makes the audacious claim that my neighbor includes the stranger, alien, outsider, outcast and even enemy.

But I notice among many of my fellow Christians a strange and deep-seated resistance against this clear teaching of Jesus. It's as if we think he was a little overly idealistic on this one -- so we'd be better to stick with something more realistic: "Love your neighbor and hate your enemy."

I've been researching and writing on this subject for a long time now, and I have a new book this month that grapples with it in depth and detail: "Why Did Jesus, Moses, the Buddha, and Mohammed Cross the Road? (Christian Identity in a Multi-Faith World)." My conclusion is -- among my fellow Christians, and I imagine in other faith communities as well -- that interfaith misunderstanding flows from misunderstandings within our own faith. When we fail to understand the dark sides of our own history, the heart of our own doctrines, the purpose of our own liturgies and the thrust of our own mission, we will project our misunderstandings on our neighbors of other faiths.

In other words, hostility doesn't begin when we encounter the other. It begins when we're gathered together among us. It's an identity thing. The path to greater interfaith understanding begins in a fresh reformulation and deeper understanding of our own faiths. Those of us who have a voice in each of our faith communities can become agents, activists and examples of that better understanding.

 
FOLLOW RELIGION
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
05:54 AM on 09/12/2012
The only misunderstanding about `interfaithiness' is that should be in any way concerned about any old myth.

Just sweep all the superstitious BS into the trash, and get on with your life.
10:55 PM on 09/11/2012
Mr. McLaren:

We are to love our neighbor as ourself and do so by preaching the Truth. Where did Jesus promote 'interfaith understanding'?

Mark 16:15:
"And He said unto them, Go ye into all the world, and preach the Gospel to every creature. 16 He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved; but he that believeth not shall be damned."

The elders, chief priests and scribes (His own) rejected Jesus and His teaching.

Mark 8:31
"And He (Jesus) began to teach them, that the Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders, and of the chief priests, and scribes, and be killed, and after three days rise again."

If people in Christianity aren't in order, i.e. disobey His Word and teach false doctrine, what is your hope for 'interfaith understanding'? Do you use this as an opportunity to preach the Gospel?

And, if Christianity divides households, why should 'interfaith dialogue' be any different?

Micah 7:6
"For the son dishonoureth the father, the daughter riseth up against her mother, the daughter in law against her mother in law; a man's enemies are the men of his own house."

The Lord repeated this in Matthew 10:35-36:

"For I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother, and the daughter in law against her mother in law. 36 And a man's foes shall be they of his own household."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JDH1950
11:06 AM on 09/11/2012
I do not believe there is an interfaith "misunderstanding" at all. We suffer from the "I don't want to understand your faith" attitude coming from the right-wing so-called "Christians."
photo
ILoveTheUSofA
BREAKING NEWS: There is no God.
08:33 AM on 09/11/2012
After Dahshur, the infernal scenario of attacks, plunder and expulsion is now taking place in a number of other villages in Egypt. The inhabitants of Talbiya, a village in the governorate of Alexandria are now victims of the unjustifiable absence of security forces that give the chance to thugs and criminals to threaten these citizens to extort money from them, mass-evict them from their houses, and rob their properties. The authorities are still turning a deaf ear to their cries for help.

These families have found no solution other than to rent a room or erect a tent to shelter themselves during their forced exile.

Numbers of reports of kidnap, robbery, extortion and murder have been submitted to the police and no action was ever taken. In fact the gangs went as far as to steal the precinct computers to make sure any information about them disappear forever.

http://www.copticsolidarity.org/cs-releases/803-armed-terrorization-and-expulsion-of-copts
photo
ILoveTheUSofA
BREAKING NEWS: There is no God.
08:00 AM on 09/11/2012
Christian Copts in Upper Egypt are under attack, hours after a call for their eradication appeared in the form of leaflets calling on Muslims to kill Copts, specifically naming regions of Upper Egypt.

A report by Fady Talaat, for Al Akhbar News, published August 14, has the details. In Al Gallaweya Village, Sohag, Upper Egypt, Christians are being beaten, their stores destroyed, and their properties plundered. The attackers are declaring that “any Christian who dares to leave his house will be killed”; and the Copts are complaining that the police only arrive after the damage has been completely done.

http://www.copticsolidarity.org/cs-releases/784-copts-in-upper-egypt-attacked-beat-plundered
photo
ILoveTheUSofA
BREAKING NEWS: There is no God.
07:38 AM on 09/11/2012
Among the many stipulations Christians had to agree to when they capitulated to the invading armies of Islam in the 7th century, and as captured in the Pact of Omar, was never to raise their hands against a Muslim—even if the latter was the aggressor—and never to have relations with Muslim women. If they failed to follow these rules as well as many others, their lives—and the lives of their surrounding coreligionists—became forfeit.

As Mark Durie points out in his book on dhimmitude, The Third Choice: "Even a breach by a single individual dhimmi could result in jihad being enacted against the whole community. Muslim jurists have made this principle explicit, for example, the Yemeni jurist al-Murtada wrote that 'The agreement will be canceled if all or some of them break it' and the Moroccan al-Maghili taught 'The fact that one individual (or one group) among them has broken the statute is enough to invalidate it for all of them.'"

http://www.raymondibrahim.com/12236/the-collective-punishment-of-egypt-christian-copts
05:05 PM on 09/10/2012
Thanks for this great essay. I've been reading your new book and have found many of the sentiments and conclusions echoing my years of research and praxis in this area. I am looking forward to adding a Salt Lake City venue to your upcoming book tour, and sharing briefly the work of the Evangelical Chapter of the Foundation for Religious Diplomacy that works to shape new evangelical identities on interreligious encounters through advocacy, education, and conversations. Interested evangelicals can learn more, as can those from other religious traditions where FRD has chapters helping their religious communities, by visiting the website at www.fidweb.org.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:44 PM on 09/10/2012
No really learned/wise person can have interfaith misunderstandings. Because all faiths belong to a single tree of humanity, indeed single tree of all life anywhere in the entire universe.

One faith directs its main branches from trunk onward, second sub-branches, third twigs, leaves and flowers, fourth the fruit and so on. If one will know truly one will respect all faiths equally.
photo
Chikkipop
Emergency Cancellation Archimedes
08:07 AM on 09/11/2012
"If one will know truly one will respect all faiths equally."

I respect all faiths equally, which is not at all.

There is no need for faith.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:13 AM on 09/11/2012
I myself am beyond all isms, but at the same time know that all isms have a place in Universe's One Scheme of Things. Yours too must.
04:41 PM on 09/10/2012
This essay takes the interfaith movement another important step forward. Being self-reflective, self-critical is essential to all healthy relationships and the future of humankind. Interfaith activists have been saying this for decades. Hearing the case put so beautifully in HuffPo Religion is like coming up for air. The resistance will be huge, as some of the judgmental comments demonstrate. But persevering opens us up to healthy friendly relationships where once there was ignorance and enmity. Thank you Brian McLaren, for being a beacon for love and goodness.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
notanaxkiller
Athiests are Godless
04:07 PM on 09/10/2012
Why is it so hard? Follow the teachings in the new testament. Done.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
notanaxkiller
Athiests are Godless
04:05 PM on 09/10/2012
There was a U.S. senator's wild allegation about Islamic extremists infiltrating the American government....Yeah...That's REALLY wild.
aa260022
The times they are a changin'
02:41 PM on 09/10/2012
I don't even begin to doubt we'll soon see Sharia law in North Carolina and much of the southern states. I just don't think it'll be Islam's sharia, but another faith's
02:01 PM on 09/10/2012
I must have misunderstood the blasphemy charges against the fourteen year old Christian girl.
Silly me, I'll have to be more careful or I might become susceptible to the dreaded Islamophobia.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CMB1969
raging moderate
02:24 PM on 09/10/2012
I don't think anyone would pretend that religious tolerance is as endangered in the United States as it is in Pakistan, but that doesn't mean that the struggle has been totally achieved once & for all in our country. That would be like saying that concerns about poverty in the US are irrelevant since our poor are not as desperately poor as the masses in Haiti.
12:01 AM on 09/11/2012
"I don't think anyone would pretend that religious tolerance is as endangered in the United States as it is in Pakistan..."

If the OIC have their way, soon EVERYWHERE will be Pakistan!
01:48 PM on 09/10/2012
"Interfaith Misunderstanding" is built into religion.

Every religion exists by claiming a monopoly on "spiritual truth," a monopoly on God. If it didn't it would no longer have a reason to exist. If all religions were true, it wouldn't matter what religion you believed in, and that would be the end of doctrinal religion.

The correllary is that every religion that claims a monopoly on truth must also claim that all other religions are wrong. If A is true, then B is false.

What we have is not a true "misunderstanding." we have countless religions all over the place each claiming a monopoly on "the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth," and each claiming that all other religions are wrong.

Can you imagine the Pope speaking, saying, "We believe the teachings of the Catholic church are true, and so are the teachings of the Buddhists, the Jews, the Protestants, the Muslims, the Hindus, the Sikhs and Zoroastrians, the Voodoons, the Mormons . . .?"

No. I am right. God is on my side. You are wrong. You'll go to hell.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CMB1969
raging moderate
02:21 PM on 09/10/2012
there is one mountain top, but many paths that lead up to it. Which path is "true"? that is simple--the path that you have chosen to take.
photo
Chikkipop
Emergency Cancellation Archimedes
08:13 AM on 09/11/2012
Mumbo-jumbo alert: There are no metaphorical mountain tops.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
libwingoflibwing
Leftist, Christian, Non-Violent Revolutionary
03:21 PM on 09/10/2012
You are making the same mistake as the Fundamentalists, except from the other side of the issue of acceptance/rejection of the religion.

The mistake is conflating two kinds of truth. The first kind is the truth of spiritual experience where one experiences meaning, purpose, inner peace, love, connection, a sense of transcendence and/or a sense of profound immanence of the ultimate in all things. The second kind is the truth of EXPLAINING all this. It is totally possible to believe one's explanatory truth is the correct way to understand the existential truth and yet still affirm that others with less accurate attempts at explanatory truth to still have the existential truth.

This way of doing religion has been around for a long time, but the modern version, called Liberalism, was best defined by Frederich Schliermacher in the early 19th Century. This way of thinking about faith, combined with a realization that one's own Tradition's explanatory truth is not absolute, is the well spring of "Deep Ecumenicism." Even the Vatican has embraced Deep Ecumenicism in the modern age.

Religion does NOT have to be done the way Fundamentalists of all Traditions do it, and a lot of religion is not done that way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kittie King
10:34 PM on 09/10/2012
Well, not out loud anyway... but I bet they still think it.
recless
Evidence first. Believe later. Maybe.
01:46 AM on 09/11/2012
Uh-huh. In science this is called subjective data vs empirical/objective data. There is no "truth" in spirituality beyond the individual's delusions of what they are experiencing as these experiences are unverifiable beyond their own skull (and let us be clear here, cognitive neuroscience has shown that our concept of "self" and "self-conscious" are physically delusional).