iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bruce Friedrich

GET UPDATES FROM Bruce Friedrich
 

Someone, Not Something: The Truth of Cats and Chickens

Posted: 07/05/2012 4:45 pm

Most Americans understand that dogs and cats are individuals with personalities -- that they are someone, not something. At Farm Sanctuary, we provide lifelong care for more than 1,000 chickens, pig, cows, and other farm animals who were abused or neglected. We get to see firsthand how these animals also have personalities, interests, and individuality -- that they are also someone, not something.

But it's not just individuality that defines farm animals. Science has shown in recent years that pigs and chickens outperform dogs and cats on cognition tests. In her introduction to the groundbreaking book The Inner World of Farm Animals, Dr. Jane Goodall sums up the science on farm animal behavior, cognition, and emotion: "Farm animals feel pleasure and sadness, excitement and resentment, depression, fear, and pain. They are far more aware and intelligent than we ever imagined...they are individuals in their own right." And as Richard Dawkins rightly notes, evolution worked in other species just like it worked in us, so of course other species have emotion, cognition, and self-awareness, just like we do.

Dr. Temple Grandin, in Animals in Translation, writes that "when it comes to the basics of life... [other] animals feel the same way we do." She goes on to explain that both humans and other animals share the same core emotions ("rage, prey, chase, drive, fear, and curiosity/interest/anticipation") and "four basic social emotions: sexual attraction and lust, separation distress, social attachment, and the happy emotions of play and roughhousing."

We could have told you from our farms that chickens, turkeys, pigs, and all farm animals love to play and roughhouse, that they enjoy the company of one another and will become distressed when a good friend is taken away for a day at the vet, and that they mourn the loss of loved ones, just like elephants do -- as captured so poignantly in When Elephants Weepby Jeff Masson and Susan McCarthy.

One Farm Sanctuary resident who has taught us that farm animals have personalities is Nikki, a mother pig who was found on a levee during the Iowa floods a few years ago, exhausted and emaciated, protectively nursing her newborn babies and letting out cries of alarm when approached by rescuers. Nikki and her babies were kept together at Farm Sanctuary, and every night she continued to build a nest for them to sleep in. Now, Nikki and her babies continue to have a relationship that any human mother or daughter would recognize: There is both authority and friendship. She remains a gregarious and happy pig who enjoys socializing -- and who welcomes all guests to the barn with her loud voice. One thing that Farm Sanctuary guests learn right away is that Nikki remains extremely protective of her children, as you might expect from someone who had such a traumatic early experience with them.

Another example is June, who came to us from New York City after a cockfighting bust. When we got June, she had known only cruelty, and she had been accustomed to the fruitless task of attempting to save her babies and the babies of other hens from the cockfighting ring. For months after coming to Farm Sanctuary, whenever a caregiver entered the barn where she spent her nights, June's chicks were not in sight. But when their heads would pop out from under her wings or tail, she would scurry and tuck them beneath her -- even when they were too big to hide -- and then puff up her neck feathers and peck at anyone who tried to pick them up. She never forgot the abuse of human beings and the pain of separation. Until she died, after years at Farm Sanctuary, she continued to keep her children close.

This is June:

2012-06-06-June4.jpg

One interesting thing about farm animal science is that until the past few years, the hypothesis was often that animals would not be able to do what was being tested. Yet time and again, the animals proved the opposite. We now understand that farm animals can anticipate the future, delay gratification, dream, play, communicate with one another in complex ways, and so much more. As Dr. Grandin rightly notes, "[w]e don't know what animals can and can't do. The fact that we're constantly being dumbfounded by brand-new abilities no one had a clue animals possessed ought to be a lesson to us about how much we don't know."

So if you consider yourself someone who cares about animals, please don't eat them. If you wouldn't eat at cat, please don't eat a chicken. If you wouldn't eat a dog, please don't eat a pig. Farm animals are at least as intelligent as other animals, and they are interesting individuals in their own right. Each is someone, not something.

Find out more about pigs' ability to play video games and use mirrors, chickens' capacity to delay gratification and navigate obstacle courses, cows' "eureka" experience upon solving problems and deep social bonds, and much more at www.FarmSanctuary.org/Someone.

 
 
 

Follow Bruce Friedrich on Twitter: www.twitter.com/brucegfriedrich

FOLLOW GREEN
 
 
  • Comments
  • 13
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
morphine507
clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right...
09:41 PM on 07/08/2012
Great article! Now we are truly beginning to see the damaging effects of meat diets on our planet. Not only are meat eaters killing animals, they are killing humans as well. It's time to move towards peace and limit suffering. We are civil beings right?? Lets act like it.
03:24 PM on 07/06/2012
Oh vegans. You’re so cute. Keep pretending that you are noble and compassionate for not eating animals. It feels good to put yourself and your lifestyle on a pedestal and assert your superiority on the rest of us. Doesn’t it?

Hold onto that feeling. Cherish it. You’re doing the right thing. Know in your heart that those little creatures appreciate your abstinence. They’d thank you if they could. You aren’t like the rest of those mean humans, you are making a difference. Don’t just live the lifestyle or talk the talk. Believe it!

It makes the rest of us laugh harder.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bruce Friedrich
Sr. Dir. for Strategic Initiatives, Farm Sanctuary
03:22 PM on 07/09/2012
This is my favorite sort of reply; only people who are extremely challenged take the time to reply in terms like this.

And you even had to go through the registration process in order to reply--I'm flattered and pleased; thank you.

Cheers,

Bruce
04:27 PM on 07/09/2012
Thanks Bruce. I’m flattered you took the time to respond and that you consider me to be among your favorite commenters. I’ll admit I took some time to get the prose just right. I’m glad you appreciated it.
08:02 AM on 07/06/2012
Just like it's wrong to conclude that farm animals are not sentient beings with emotions and feelings, it's also wrong to conclude that they are all equal on their abilities to experience said emotions and intelligence levels. This statement, "If you wouldn't eat at cat, please don't eat a chicken." really irks me. I have pet cats that I don't eat. I have pet chickens that I don't eat. I still eat chicken and I have no qualms with it. Acknowledging that something has feelings doesn't give it the privilege of being removed from the food chain. A bear would eat my cats and my chickens with no remorse and I'm sure he's aware that they are "more alive" than a tuft of grass.
09:04 AM on 07/06/2012
Very true Gabrielle! I get a little tired of these vegan platitudes concerning animals as well. Yes, animals do fear death and can show what WE might refer to as emotions but it's silly to equate animal behaviors and emotions, which are instinctively based, to human ones which are primarily linked our culture and society. It's not the same thing no matter how much we attempt to interpret it as such. We do have a relationship to animals and our environment that we must consider and a responsibility (due to our cultural ability to destroy and control) to ensure the sustainability of animals and the environment we affect..but that does not require removing animals from our diets completely to accomplish.

Being vegan and fighting for animal "rights" does not remove you from the overall negative impact humans have on animals and the environment. "Protecting" animals does not make them equal to you, it places them in dependence of you. A global conversion to veganism will not significantly "improve" the success of animal species (which is more important than any single animal saved from slaughter), it will only alter how our population pressures others. No matter what we do we have a negative impact on other animals and that's not going to change...sustainability of our actions is key, not the complete removal of one of our best sources of nutrition
12:37 PM on 07/06/2012
You are compartmentalizing as you must do in order to continue your eating habits and not change. Animals most certainly DO have cultures! Killer whales and other ceteceans live in family units their entire lives - like us. Crows have language and pass information down through the generations, like us. If we stopped industrial farming we could positively affect global climate change, and feed a lot of hungry people using those resources. We can get all the nutrition we need from plants. I've been doing it for over ten years and I'm very healthy and not obese. Of course we all will ALWAYS have a footprint on the earth, but shouldn't we try to reduce it? We are rapidly headed for the tragedy of the commons, if we continue as we are. Even if you choose to negate animal suffering, do you not care about the health of the planet and its people?
11:24 AM on 07/06/2012
This is typically the kind of specious reasoning that people like you use to justify the horrors that most farm animals are subjected to on factory farms where they are treated like nothing more than an inanimate unit of production, so that you don't have to give up that slab of dead, tortured flesh on your plate. You are not a bear...and social evolution is all about our species evolving in our thinking so that we no longer find it acceptable to force another living, sentient being to endure physical/emotional pain and suffering, ending with premature hideous slaughter so that we can continue to indulge our most base and egotistical instincts. Grow up!
01:42 AM on 07/06/2012
Cool that you are writing about this Bruce, and thank you. But it seems inconsistent to keep referring to then as "farm animals" when in fact they are farmED animals. We don't say "rape women," that would imply they exist for the purpose of rape. When we say "farm animals" it implies they exist to live on a farm. They are FARMED, just like women are raped. Not "dairy cow" but "cow used for dairy," not "lab animals" but "animals in a lab," and so on.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bruce Friedrich
Sr. Dir. for Strategic Initiatives, Farm Sanctuary
03:19 PM on 07/09/2012
That's an interesting discussion at Farm Sanctuary, where we don't farm (verb) our animals, but they are farm animals (they live on our farm). So while I went 15 years agreeing with what you say here, once I started talking to others at Farm Sanctuary, I came to see it as more nuanced. I assume it's obvious that your comparisons don't hold once you grant that Farm Sanctuary is, in fact, a farm... BTW, I think that "cow exploited for her milk" and "animals exploited/abused in a lab" (active verbs) improve on your examples even more. Thanks Dave, Bruce
11:49 PM on 07/05/2012
Thank you for this important article. Going vegan is the best decision I have made. It is a win-win lifestyle as it saves the lives of other sentient beings and has amazing benefits for one's personal health and the environment.
05:17 PM on 07/05/2012
Indeed. My four adopted hens are unique individuals with whom I have developed deep bonds of companionship. I was never an "animal person" until these chickens came into my life. They have taught me so very much about myself and other species in general. When left to their own devices, chickens will seek our companionship, plain and simple.