More

Bryan Young

Bryan Young

Posted: December 27, 2007 10:13 AM

Would Our Presidential Candidates Risk Life or Limb like Bhutto?


I learned this morning, as everyone else did, that Benazir Bhutto was killed in a suicide bombers attack at a political rally in the lead ups to what were supposed to be free and fair elections in Pakistan next month. I was shocked, as everyone is, by the abrupt nature of her death. Obviously, she had the courage and conviction to run any sort of political campaign in a political climate as violent and hectic as Pakistan.

Realizing this, it made me wonder which of our current crop of Presidential candidates heading into next weeks primaries would have the courage and conviction to do the same were their lives at such risk for merely standing up as the opposition. Would Mitt Romney be running for president if his life were in danger at campaign rallies? Would Hillary Clinton? Would Mr. 9-11 himself, Rudy Giuliani, make a stop on the trail if security weren't tight as a drum? Would Barack Obama? Would John Edwards or Mike Huckabee even start running if they knew shots might be fired?

The answers I came to were troubling to me. I honestly don't know if any of the candidates would have the strength of will to run for the highest office in the land in the face of such lethal adversity.

Does anyone?

This is something we should consider in choosing our candidates. Is it in their character to stand for something greater than themselves, as Benazir Bhutto did, and pay the ultimate price for the beliefs they held so dear?

Maybe we should ask them. Sadly though, all we'd get is a perfectly manicured answer designed by a team of writers and political strategists to put our minds ease.

In the meantime, we should remember the sacrifice of actual leaders of moral conviction, strength and bravery and how they handled themselves in times of severe strife in the countries they were trying to make better with democracy. But on this day, particularly the sacrifice of Benazir Bhutto.

Bryan Young blogs daily at This Divided State.

Read more reactions from HuffPost bloggers on Benazir Bhutto's assassination

Follow Bryan Young on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BigShinyRobot

 
 
  • Comments
  • 64
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:27 AM on 12/28/2007
No, you have to believe what you're fighting for is right for all people and not just yourself.
Our politicians aren't selfless enough, just selfish.
05:35 PM on 12/27/2007
Much as I dislike Hillary, I must point out her husband was the target in at least three known assassination attempts (and possibly a fourth - a bullet from unknown sources was found embedded in the White House). Still, she campaigns.
03:19 PM on 12/27/2007
The reason Senator Obama has the Secret Service traveling with him (it was not his choice, it was required) is because of the many death threats and hate mail from this Christian nation.

So yes, he is willing to campaign knowing what is out there after him?
03:08 PM on 12/27/2007
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/joe-biden/a-new-approach-to-pakista_b_71733.html

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/joe-biden/we-need-a-pakistan-policy_b_71399.html

Joe Biden's comments on Huffington Post on November 6th and 8th on how to avoid a crisis like today.

Joe Biden was endorsed by Pakistan's President because 1) Joe Biden was the most knowledgeable about his country of Pakistan and 2) Joe Biden was the only American candidate who cared. Joe Biden has been in weekly contact with Pakistan's President and has repeatedly said this was the most dangerous country on the planet right now, not Iran.
02:59 PM on 12/27/2007
I think Mr. Young is conflating physical bravery and political bravery. Two very different things. And having one does not predict the other.

Personally, I will settle for political bravery in a candidate.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
lisakaz
02:13 PM on 12/27/2007
Simply put, hell no. Bu$h esp. would be cowering. They all need their handlers. Don't see much nobility among 'em.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
DRaymond
Network administrator, voiceovers
01:42 PM on 12/27/2007
I know it is considered cute nowdays to denigrate all politicians. But when you put yourself in the limelight, not just politically, you in some way make yourself a target. It is not as though we as a country have never had a political assasination. There were the two Kennedys and Martin Luther King Jr. Ronald Reagan barely survived an attack. Plus Lincoln and others. Yes you trust your security, but if your personal safety was your number one concern you would never get into the public spotlight.
01:42 PM on 12/27/2007
Who is to say the Democratic candidates aren't risking their lives? Are Pakistani rightwing nutjobs any worse than American rightwing nutjobs?
01:23 PM on 12/27/2007
Kucinich got death threats when he refused to privatize the power company.

To be fair, most presidential candidates are probably aware they may become targets.

Kucinich is the only with a consistent candidate of the American people. He has proven as mayor that he is not for sale.

Kucinich is so feared by the MSM that his impeachment of Cheney got zero headlines. Russert was tasked with "Moon beaming" Kucinich, and finally Kucinich was just excluded from the debates, since he was getting huge applause for impeaching Cheney.

Google Kucinich Wins

We can hope HRC will be different then the face she presents to win, but it rarely turns out that way.

Obama's eager choice for a "mentor" in the senate was Joe Lieberman, How can I possibly trust Obama, knowing that?

Strength Through Peace!

Kucinich!

Studs Terkel writes a great article about Kucinich:

http://www.thenation.com/doc/20020506/terkel
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
bascombe
Send the kids off to die, bleed their country dry.
01:06 PM on 12/27/2007
I ask:
On what basis is democracy supposed to be some de facto good form of government?

what we have is at least as corrupt and compromised as any other form of government in any other country today.
01:02 PM on 12/27/2007
It is a safe bet that the people who might assassinate any American Presidential Candidate would be the same people (at least idealogically) who assassinated Benazir Bhutto.
12:55 PM on 12/27/2007
I doubt that there is an issue for which any of the candidates would by willing to take a stand and lose, much less DIE for.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
bascombe
Send the kids off to die, bleed their country dry.
12:55 PM on 12/27/2007
NO, NOT ONE OF THEM!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:49 PM on 12/27/2007
Anyone who doesn't think that Obama has is now and will be at greater risk of assassination if he is nominated and elected president is kidding themselves. This event increases the risk.
12:47 PM on 12/27/2007
Ron Paul IS doing the very same thing.

While OUR political enemies here in America don't resort to suicide bombers, when someone becomes a dangerous enough threat to the power status quo, they usually wind up just as dead.

Paul speaks openly and candidly about the institutions that want to form a North American Union, that argue for the elimination of our Civil Rights, and defiantly spy upon us using the telecoms.

They killed 2 Kennedys and MLK because they were threats. And Paul today is the most dangerous man alive.

Welcome to The Revolution!