iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Carl Gibson

GET UPDATES FROM Carl Gibson
 

McCain Should Release Romney's Tax Returns

Posted: 08/02/2012 2:30 pm

Mitt Romney almost won the GOP nomination in 2008, but John McCain ended up carrying the party nod as a well-known U.S. Senator and Vietnam POW. Romney was considered for the VP spot and submitted 23 years of tax returns during the vetting process. in the end, McCain picked Sarah Palin as his running mate, saying she was the "better candidate." Was there something in those 23 years of tax returns that made John McCain choose the dim-witted Alaskan governor instead?

Ever since George Romney, Mitt's dad, released years of tax returns in his run for president, the release of tax returns has been a tradition for presidential candidates. Mitt, however, won't do anything more than release partial returns from the most recent years, one of which showed a $77,000 tax break he got for his wife's dressage horse. What isn't yet known is that, in the 23 years of tax returns submitted to the McCain campaign, if Bain Capital fell into the category of major corporations that paid $0 in federal taxes, or even paid a negative federal effective tax rate and got a refund. If that's true, that should be information available to the voting public.

It isn't uncommon for a large corporation to pay a negative U.S. tax rate, given the numerous exemptions and deductions corporate lobbyists have succeeded in adding to the tax code through lobbying Ways and Means and Finance Committee chairmen and ranking members over the years. These same corporations, like General Electric, Bank of America, Citibank, Chevron and ExxonMobil got more back in federal tax refunds last year than any of us would make over several lifetimes. Some of these corporations, like Corning Inc., have the audacity to complain about high corporate taxation after paying $0 in U.S. taxes and getting a refund.

If Mitt Romney insists on running his campaign as a shrewd businessman who can bring economic prosperity back to America, Americans have a right to know if Romney ran his business ethically and paid his fair share of taxes. Just as it's inappropriate for a presidential candidate who opposed the auto industry bailout to criticize the guy who revived the American car manufacturing sector as anti-business, its equally inappropriate for a presidential candidate to complain of high taxes on the richest Americans and corporations while paying negative U.S. tax rates.

George Will had it right -- Romney not releasing his tax returns is a costly political move, meaning it must be more costly to his campaign for him to be transparent about his tax returns. But transparency about supporting the infrastructure of the country that enabled you to acquire your wealth should be required for anyone seeking the country's highest office. If Mitt Romney is so proud of success, he should release the tax returns that prove it. And if he won't, John McCain's campaign should.

 

Follow Carl Gibson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/usuncut

FOLLOW POLITICS
Mitt Romney almost won the GOP nomination in 2008, but John McCain ended up carrying the party nod as a well-known U.S. Senator and Vietnam POW. Romney was considered for the VP spot and submitted 23 ...
Mitt Romney almost won the GOP nomination in 2008, but John McCain ended up carrying the party nod as a well-known U.S. Senator and Vietnam POW. Romney was considered for the VP spot and submitted 23 ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:40 PM on 08/08/2012
Last president with tax return issues was Nixon and we all know how that turned out. GOP you need to get this guy to show or get him to step down. Unless they are going to buy the electoral college again.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
monstersfromtheid
micro-bio is empty - and staying that way
11:06 AM on 08/03/2012
Even a statement backing Romney, saying " We looked at his returns, he paid taxes" would end this in the news cycle.

McCain's silence is deafening.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:57 PM on 08/05/2012
Not a McCain fan, but I'm certain that it's understood that anything a candidate submits for "vetting" will be kept strictly confidential.

If not, I doubt any candidate---any party---would agree to "vetting" process.
12:31 PM on 08/08/2012
McCain already said he did not see anything disqualifying in the returns. That would be a political answer as I'm sure if they came to light and there were issues McCain would say "but I'm not an accountant".
10:32 AM on 08/03/2012
I don't see that happening... McCain is still smarting from the 2008 election - and defending his choice of his running mate, Sarah Palin. (I'd have more respect for him if he admitted he bungled that one.)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
jce1512
Not all who wander are lost
09:05 AM on 08/03/2012
I like this idea, how delicious.
photo
gothos
Kiss my ___, This is a Holy Site!
08:49 AM on 08/03/2012
I don't think McCain releasing Mitt's returns is a likely scenario.
photo
MayaAtlantis
We are all connected.
08:44 AM on 08/03/2012
McCain can clarify if Romney paid taxes for the years up to 2007. But who knows what happened in 2008 and 2009? And Romney or McCain saying that Romney complied with the tax laws isn't saying anything, because we all know the tax laws are skewed to the 1% and not paying anything could be legal.
11:51 PM on 08/06/2012
You're right about the tax code being "skewed" towards the 1%. The top 1% of income earners in 2009 paid over 36% of the TOTAL federal income taxes paid. And, it is legal to pay no taxes, as there are things such as municipal bonds and Roth IRAs. MANY wealthy people use municipal bonds to generate income, income tax free. However, they are paid a LOWER interest rate than a comparable corporate bond that is taxable. That helps the wealthy person not pay taxes, AND it helps the municipality build schools, roads, etc., at a lower borrowing cost than they could get elsewhere.
photo
MayaAtlantis
We are all connected.
09:03 AM on 08/07/2012
I hear you!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Callmecarol2
O Happy Day!
04:00 AM on 08/03/2012
Maybe he's already talked to Harry.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
monstersfromtheid
micro-bio is empty - and staying that way
11:03 AM on 08/03/2012
Is McCain the Reliable Source?

Does he hate Mitt that much?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mike1215
03:27 PM on 08/03/2012
Could well be.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jayaf1980
06:35 PM on 08/04/2012
He did in 2008
03:02 AM on 08/03/2012
McCain probably had to sign a confidentiality agreement to see them and cannot release them. Haven't heard McCain defending Tricky Mitts's refusal to release them.
Rowwdy
Truth Will Set You Free
09:05 PM on 08/02/2012
*Why should one millionaire throw another millionaire gaming the same system to the wolves??? They’re comparing notes, can you say two peas in the same pod…
Rowwdy
Truth Will Set You Free
09:52 PM on 08/03/2012
I just e-mailed Mr. McCain the following;
Mr. McCain, the following website has been removed from the internet, please e-mail the site I can go to which contains the same information
http://cdn2.dailycaller.com/2012/01/McCain-2008-Oppo-File-on-Romney.pdf

Thank You
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charmage
08:51 PM on 08/02/2012
If McCain can do that, he definitely should. How can you vote for someone you don't know about? Mortgage Companies ask for returns before granting a home loan. And you can't respond like Ann Romney and say, "You people" have seen enough. Romney seems to be hiding something.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jayaf1980
06:39 PM on 08/04/2012
The poor have to provide tax returns to qualify for food stamps. I had to provide 4 years of returns buy my house.

Simply put, WE PEOPLE have to provide our papers to banks and government agencies for a variety of reasons. Why is it so complicated to contemplate that we want the person who wants to run the government to release his to us so we can make a similar decision, Saying that they are hundreds of pages and complicated is the same as saying, you people are stupid and won't be able to comprehend them.
08:51 PM on 08/02/2012
Romney actually doesn't have a record; we can't see his taxes, can't see what he did at Bain, he destroyed records from the 2002 Olympic, and destroyed much of his record as governor. Frankly, we have only his word that he actually _did_ anything, save for sending jobs to China and establishing a fairly nifty healthcare system in Massachusetts. He doesn 't seem to want to brag about either one, either.

The only reason that he is the putative nominee (barring a fun food fight with the Ron Paul supporters) is that the alternatives were insane and/or didn't have enough money.

And the only reason anyone takes him seriously is because even rock-solid conservatives who know good and well that Romney doesn't care about them are willing to go ABO. For some reason, the guy who got rid of Osama Bin Laden, deports more aliens than Pres. Bush did, and helped put the Dow Jones stock average back over 12,000 (13,000 on a windy day) isn't respected by them.

Funny, that.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
OutToLunch
all hail the French & the Saunders...
06:44 PM on 08/02/2012
Steve Schmidt's on a campaign to redeem himself after the DKASP (the Disaster Known as Sarah Palin)....Nicole Wallace, too.

If McCain won't leak those tax returns, some patriot should....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
treadway123
treadway123
06:30 PM on 08/02/2012
He says Well McCain didn't have to release more then two years! He forgets McCain as a Senator is scrutinized already for MANY years! Vetted like no other for years! We know all there is to know about Senator McCain including he is NOT a Draft Dodger.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mike1215
03:29 PM on 08/03/2012
"Senator McCain ... is NOT a Draft Dodger". Indeed. Unlike Romney.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
treadway123
treadway123
04:28 PM on 08/03/2012
Romney couldn't get into Senate Race! The scrutiny on his Tax Returns wouldn't be exceptable an if he pulled what we think he did with his tax's he'd be facing a Ethic violations in both Senate an Congress!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Molly D
05:32 PM on 08/02/2012
Even if Mitt released his returns himself, would you believe them? He left out parts of the ones he did release. If he simply falsified previous years, how would anybody know? The Repubs and FOX lie wholesale about everything. They will do it here too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MikeInFla
05:27 PM on 08/02/2012
With patriots like Mitt Romney, who needs enemies?