More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Carole Bennett, MA

GET UPDATES FROM Carole Bennett, MA
 

Do You Have a Drinking Problem? 12 Questions to Ask Yourself

Posted: 07/15/10 09:00 AM ET

As a family substance abuse counselor, my clients frequently poise a concern about their loved one's alcoholic intake and whether or not they are really an alcoholic. I hear statements such as "I think my girlfriend is an alcoholic because she drinks almost a bottle of wine while making dinner," or "My husband frequently comes home inebriated, but he swears he can handle it and hasn't been in trouble because of his drinking" or "I really don't think I have a drinking problem just because I've had a DUI."

Specifics and actual questions to determine whether one is or is not in trouble with their drinking can help with the answer.

Though I am not personally in recovery from alcohol or other mind-altering drugs, my own family and friends struggle with the disease. Professionally, I have worked with hundreds of clients with addiction issues and without, and the best litmus test for determining if one is an alcoholic comes from the strong and respectful program of Alcoholics Anonymous and it's 12 simple questions.

The following list is taken word for word from their pamphlet "Is AA for You?" If honestly answered, you can determine your own disposition. If you answer "yes" to four or more of these questions, you may be in trouble with your drinking.

How Long Can You Last?
1 of 13
Have you ever decided to stop drinking for a week or so, but only lasted for a couple of days?
Total comments: 28 | Post a Comment
1 of 13
Rate This Slide
No Way.
Yes

  • 1

  • 2

  • 3

  • 4

  • 5

  • 6

  • 7

  • 8

  • 9

  • 10
Current Top 5 Slides
Users who voted on this slide
loading...

So, what's your score? Remember, four or more and you may wish to strongly consider changing your lifestyle.

I have presented this questionnaire to my clients that are the family members or friends of the prospective alcoholic. It has proven very interesting (and different) as to see how they see their loved ones in connection with alcohol. Often the prospective alcoholic is in denial about their possible addiction issue and may dismiss theses questions as bunk, defend and justify their position with flimsy reasoning or take a combative stance. They can't or don't want to visualize themselves in this position, even though their mate, spouse, parent, sibling or whomever can see these dispositions as clear as day.

One last thought. Just because someone may not meet this criteria does not mean they don't or might not have an issue with alcohol. For some, two glasses of wine can find them blotto, irresponsible and no longer a social drinker. As the family member or friend, don't let the prospective alcoholic say "See, I'm not an alcoholic, I haven't answered "yes" to four of these questions." They may have a different gauge or actions that might make them just as vulnerable to alcoholism as the person whom these concerns fit like a glove.

For the prospective alcoholic that is reading this, be your own honest judge. You know yourself better than anyone. Even if you are not ready to encompass a clean and sober lifestyle, be true to yourself and take the first step in admitting the possibility that you may indeed have the disease of alcoholism. It is nothing to be ashamed of; it can actually be empowering to start taking control of your life. You and your family and friends will be very grateful that one day (hopefully sooner than later) you will seek a healthy, loving relationship with not only yourself, but them as well.

Please do leave a comment below or drop me an email with your thoughts, suggestions or requests for future areas of focus.

If I can be of service to you or your family, please e-mail me at Carole@familyrecoverysolutions.com or visit my website.

 
 
 
As a family substance abuse counselor, my clients frequently poise a concern about their loved one's alcoholic intake and whether or not they are really an alcoholic. I hear statements such as "I thin...
As a family substance abuse counselor, my clients frequently poise a concern about their loved one's alcoholic intake and whether or not they are really an alcoholic. I hear statements such as "I thin...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Harvo
Corporations are not people, they don't pay taxes.
11:39 PM on 07/21/2010
Beer is my best friend. :)
Beer never treats me like a doormat when it's feeling 'less than fresh'.
Beer never does it's very best to create an argument simply because it wants one.
Beer never acts like I should jump through flaming hoops because it has an attractive bottle & label.
Beer never acts like life should be handed to it on a silver platter because it was born with an attractive bottle & label.
Beer never makes demands of me because it has something I need, it only gives of itself and asks nothing in return.
Beer is never insulting.
Beer is never condescending.
Beer never displays out of control anger.
Beer never flirts with other guys when I'm in the room.
Beer is never constantly concerned only with what it wants.
Beer is never self centered.
Beer is never in a constantly bad humor.
Beer never makes totally idiotic decisions with money.
Beer never complains.
Beer is never disrespectful.
Beer never chews with it's mouth open.
Beer never talks with it's mouth full.
Beer never purposely wakes me up when I need sleep.
Beer never talks constantly about nothing when I'm listening to music.
Beer never purposely tries to be irritating.
In short, beer is never a beech.
11:47 PM on 07/19/2010
Alcohol is so pernicious that, if it came onto the market today, it would be an illegal controlled substance in 6 months.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:27 PM on 07/18/2010
Any real addict/ alcoholic will answer the test look at the results and then go back and change their answers, so?
Two alcoholics were drinking bottles of bud and driving when they saw the blue lights and heard the siren. The driver says ' quick tear off the label and put it on your forehead!" which both drunks then did. As the officer looked into the car he saw the two drunks with bud labels stuck to their foreheads and asked " have you two been drinking?" , the response " No sir, we're on the patch!".
Rehab, a $10000 Big Book.
photo
clearwaterclearmind
couldn't stand bush. can't stand obama for the sam
09:21 PM on 07/18/2010
why not just ask if i'v ever had a drink ever and try to have me committed to a 20,000$ rehab clinic you get kickbacks from?
photo
jmpurser
See My micro-bio
11:30 AM on 07/17/2010
Have you ever come to in your own urine or feces?

While operating your automobile have you engaged in navel maneuvers or sunk marine craft?

Do you not remember where you parked your car until you find it in your living room?

Do you find cable TV to be entertaining?
07:03 AM on 07/17/2010
As an active alcoholic, I was delusional and very impaired. There was also no one that could convince me to change what I was doing. When I was drinking, I could honestly answer every question NO.

A. I never decided to stop drinking for any period.

A. I lived by myself and interacted with very few people. The few people who tried to tell me what to do were just being rude and nosy.

A. I also drank to get drunk so this question did not apply to me.

A. I had prescription medications to wake me up in the morning.

A. I was confused by people who could drink without getting into trouble.

A. Although I had 5 arrests, I always attributed that to my problem with police, not alcohol.

A. I never had to try to get extra drinks at a party. I always brought enough for myself in case the liquor ran out.

A. I always wanted to get drunk. I also couldn't imagine not drinking.

A. I always managed to post bail in time to make it to work. That's one advantage to working the evening or graveyard shift.

A. I couldn't imagine life without alcohol, so the answer is no.

Although there was no single one event that made me consider getting sober, I believe that when people stopped trying to help me by bailing me out of bad situations. It finally came down to either trying to get sober or going to prison.
11:55 PM on 07/16/2010
There are actually 3 simple questions
1) Do you drink when you don't want to
2) do you get drunk when you didn't intend to
3) Why are you reading this? Normal people don't waste their tme reading polls about alcoholisim

Good luck!
08:20 PM on 07/16/2010
Interesting that Ms. Bennett, a clinician, chose to post AA's questionnaire "Is AA For You?" instead of one of the clinically validated alcoholism questionnaires such as the AUDIT (which has been shown to be about 94% accurate in detecting alcohol dependence).

In any case, it is important to note that while the AA questionnaire may indeed lead one to conclude that a change in drinking behavior is appropriate, this does not necessary mean that AA will provide an appropriate or effective approach to changing that behavior.

http://www.mrw.interscience.wiley.com/cochrane/clsysrev/articles/CD005032/frame.html
http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:46 PM on 07/16/2010
Ok, So I'm glad I don't have a drinking problem, but apparently I'm a sexaholic.
03:19 PM on 07/16/2010
I thought I had a problem with drinking, but as it turned out it was a hypoglcemic problem with sugars. Now I know booze is a super sugar but what happened to me was the sugar and candy I ate made my insulin levels rise and I would crave alcohol, the booze actually wiped out the high levels of insulin, It became this seesaw effect. When I stopped drinking major health problems developed. My body couldn't get rid of the insulin that my body was making. Only when I stopped eating sugar did my cravings for alcohol go away.
05:03 PM on 07/19/2010
Interesting! How did you figure this out, or is there somewhere I can read more on this phenomenon?
photo
TheSojourner
My blog is up and running.
06:50 AM on 07/16/2010
If all the booze companies went out of business, I couldn't care less. I never developed a fondness for alcohol, so I never had a problem with it, I actually seemed to have a built in switch that told me when to stop when I did have a drink or two. Later on, I discovered that I actually liked the non alcoholic versions better than the alcohol laced ones. A "virgin Mary", tonic & lime, etc., those are usually my type of drinks now.

Why am I writing this? Because one of my dearest friends for years had an alcohol problem, They tried AA, too religious. Cold turkey, too hard. What made them stop? They made the decision and stuck to it, finally the light dawned. It wasn't easy, but they've been booze free for over twenty years now. I don't say this will work for everyone, my friend had strong motivation,support and determination.

As you can see, there are different ways to a solution. But there is hope for some people. The rate of recidivism of AA'ers by the way is not small, either. If you chose your poison, perhaps it's possible to choose the antidote for your own needs; I don't know. Just throwing this out, maybe it will help someone. Of course, first you have to really want sobriety.
12:27 AM on 07/16/2010
I read Ms. Bennett's bio, and it certainly sounds like she's been through the wringer with her family's substance-abuse problems. I have nothing but empathy for her. Unfortunately, she strikes me as a prime example of the old adage "If the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem is going to look like a nail."

Not everyone who drinks has a problem. And, conversely, not everyone who has a problem drinks. There are numerous reasons why people drink alcohol - some like the taste, some enjoy the feeling and, yes, some want to get drunk. But in today's society, we seem so quick to label everything a possible addiction: alcohol, medication, shopping, sex, gambling, exercise, etc ... Where is the line drawn between people with individual quirks and mindless, conforming automatons?

Since the dawn of recorded human history, people have used various methods (drugs, religion, rituals, intoxicants, sexuality) to transcend the bounds of everyday life. Instead of condemning something that seems to be hardwired into the human psyche, perhaps we should spend more time investigating the "why" instead of constantly harping on the "why not."
RTIII
Poster of over 0.0135% of all HufPost comments
06:55 PM on 07/16/2010
Good post, thanks.

Fan #3.
photo
HeevenSteven
20 Minutes into the future.
04:19 PM on 07/15/2010
The only one I answered yes to was #2; so I'm going to drink to the fact that It's not my problem; it's theirs.
02:30 AM on 07/16/2010
Well, when I was in a relationship with a 12-stepper who had massive control issues, I would have answered yes to #2. I don't think trying to control everything and everyone in your life is the key to sobriety.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zombie fairy
12:22 AM on 07/17/2010
However, for some 12-steppers, it is. I've been on the receiving end of a 12-stepper who, when confronted with not being able to control me, threatened to start drinking again if I didn't do what he wanted. My solution was leaving him - I have no idea what happened to him after that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
raysny
57, married, mental health care
03:57 PM on 07/15/2010
These questions help determine if a person has a drinking problem.

I don't see how having a drinking problem means that one needs a religious program that preaches powerlessness and spiritual healing as the remedy.
06:40 PM on 07/15/2010
I agree. You don't see because if you did you wouldn't reduce a complicated set of human behaviors to a distorting one liner . Alcoholism kills under the guise of heart disease, liver disease, diabetes, "accidents," brain damage, etc. Alcoholism kills family life. And I can say from years of experience that no serious person in recovery dictates to anyone how to get and stay sober. There are many paths to sobriety. The only test is if it keeps you sober and turns your life and relationships with others around. Alcoholism is not just about alcohol. It's about mentality. Lots of people white knuckle it for decades, but their lives, work, and relationships are still unmanageable. They are miserable folks who sabotage themselves from the minute they wake up until they go to sleep. And anyone, alcoholic or not, who cannot recognize their own powerlessness is full of hubris and denial on multiple levels. Many alcoholics have turned their lives around through numerous paths, including AA. People who bash AA are irresponsible deterrents to addicts who might actually save their lives with that program. Who are you to judge? And people wonder where the posters are.
08:54 PM on 07/15/2010
Irresponsible? Right... It's incredibly irresponsible to overreact to -- in an attempt to shut down -- criticism of misguided conventional wisdom -- wisdom that has proven itself to be not just ineffective but dangerous, that hasn't evolved in the slightest (and refuses to) in the past 75 years. Accusing people who question "powerlessness" of having a defective character (hubris, for crying out loud), is exactly why AA is irresponsible. People like you are lording this weird moralistic garbage over vulnerable and broken people.

If you have a problem with alcohol, please investigate all your options -- they are many responsible, science-based, empowering, free programs out there.
11:48 AM on 07/18/2010
I don't know why you were pounced on here, raysny, by claims you are down on "AA". What I got from your comment is something I totally agree with...the question of why does everything always have to come down to religion? In my opinion, organized religion OFTEN takes advantage of people in desperate, weak and vulnerable situations! For example, the way they go into prisons and "brain wash" those we are weak minded and those feeling hopeless and desperate at an extremely low period in their life. Or the way many "missionary" groups go to areas where medical care for children is desperately needed and use that as a tool to convert the locals away from Catholicism. (just to site a couple of examples that come to mind) Seems like "AA" is yet another case where the "religious" take advantage of someone's vulnerable state as a way to promote their beliefs. That's not to say "AA" hasn't greatly helped many people...just as medical aid in primitive countries probably HAS saved the lives of many children who would have otherwise died...but the bottom line is, why can't the same "help" be given in the name of the "greater good", and not to promote religion or a certain religious agenda.

Am I wrong???...this seemed to be more to your point to me?
03:29 PM on 07/15/2010
I answered yes to 3 out of the list.

I need a drink
I need more
You think about another life (yes I think about Eva Greens and how damn good looking she is)
Holypat777
Got no time 4 closed minds-WA/3D
03:38 PM on 07/15/2010
I'll drink to that.