iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Cathleen Falsani

Cathleen Falsani

GET UPDATES FROM Cathleen Falsani

God Is Green: Why 'Less Bad' Is Not Good

Posted: 10/ 2/10 06:52 AM ET

While I'm no militant environmentalist by any stretch of the imagination (I recycle; I don't compost), I do considered myself something of a tree-hugger.

There's even a sticker on my car that says, "God is Green." It's a statement of faith.

Still, when talk turns toward carbon footprints and global warming, lately a certain melancholy -- almost a vague acedia -- has begun to shadow my heart.

It all seems so ... Sisyphean.

We've abused Mother Earth and she's not happy about it and it may be too late to fix the fakakta mess we've made of our ecology.

Sure, in recent years a light bulb has gone on over the heads of religious leaders: "Aha! We should probably do something about this whole Earth-is-going-to-hell-in-a-handbasket-and-we-don't-mean-spiritually thing."

Such attention from people of faith -- Christians, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus, and a host of other religious traditions -- is a good thing. Nevertheless, none of the spiritually leaning environmental message I've listened to has grabbed my soul and given it a good shake.

That is, until a few weeks ago when I heard a humble prophet named Bill McDonough speak in Laguna Beach, Calif., my new hometown.

I didn't know much about McDonough other than the fact that he did something in the business world, and I expected little from the evening apart from supporting a friend's effort to bring world-class speakers to our sleepy surf town and sipping a glass of free Chardonnay.

I certainly didn't expect to have an epiphany.

McDonough is an internationally renowned architect and chief proponent of what some have christened the "Next Industrial Revolution." For 25-plus years he has led the development of cutting-edge sustainable (i.e., "green") architecture and, moreover, a philosophy of design that turns dominant design, business and environmental paradigms on their heads.

"Our goal is a delightfully diverse, safe, healthy and just world, with clean air, water, soil and power -- economically, equitably, ecologically and elegantly enjoyed," McDonough and his partner, chemist Michael Braungart, say of their "Cradle to Cradle" design philosophy. "How can we support and perpetuate the rights of all living things to share in a world of abundance? How can we love the children of all species -- not just our own -- for all time?"

Cradle to Cradle (or C2C) is McDonough and Braungart's answer to the "cradle to grave" model upon which so much of the world's design, consumption and commerce is based. We have designed products and industry that are made to be disposed.

In landfills. In the ocean. On the scrap heap of outmoded ideas and thinking.

Watch McDonough's explain his C2C philosophy at the 2005 TED convention below:


Here's where McDonough's message gave my soul a good jostling: The Earth is designed -- beautifully, elegantly -- to work and work well. It's meant to be self-renewing. It is intended for abundance, not scarcity.

As a believer, such ideas should have been self-evident to me, I suppose, but they were not or maybe they'd become obscured by years of hearing the message that we had to conserve before everything runs out (next year if not sooner.)

McDonough argues that the idea of, for instance, reducing our carbon footprint is essentially an effort to be "less bad." It's akin to beating your dog three days a week rather than five and praising it as progress.

"To be less bad is to accept things as they are, to believe that poorly designed, dishonorable, destructive systems are the best humans can do," McDonough and Braungart wrote in their book, Cradle to Cradle: Remaking the Way We Make Things. "This is the ultimate failure of the 'be less bad' approach: a failure of the imagination. From our perspective, this is a depressing vision of our species' role in the world."

Instead, McDonough asks, "What would it mean to be 100 percent good?"

Buildings can be designed to act like trees, McDonough explained to us. He has designed and constructed buildings that filter water, harness the sun's power, clean the air, are lit with natural light and with "green" (literally) roofs where native plants, grasses and birds flourish (even in the middle of downtown Chicago.)

In McDonough's buildings, waste becomes food. Materials are recycled and reused. Next to nothing winds up in a landfill. By choosing designs and materials that are not only non-toxic (or the closest to it available at this point) but also healthful we can change the world in tangible, lasting ways.

McDonough's latest effort is creating an organization that will certify products as C2C approved so that consumers will know that what they are buying and using is part of a regenerative system. The C2C certification is "a multi-attribute eco-label that assesses a product's safety to humans and the environment and design for future life cycles. The program provides guidelines to help businesses implement the Cradle to Cradle framework, which focuses on using safe materials that can be disassembled and recycled as technical nutrients or composted as biological nutrients."

If the C2C logo is on the packaging (or lack thereof -- natch!) you can be sure it has been designed with cradle-to-cradle and not cradle-to-grave in mind. By requesting and buying products that do the same, we can move the market to demand clean, healthful, restorative goods and services. By making conscious choices to invest our money in products, designs and commerce that are healthful and positive for our planet, we reward inventors, manufacturers and businesses that produce, transport and sell them.

Baby blankets that give our children nutrition rather than Alzheimers later in life. Doornobs that deposit positive doses of needed minerals on our hands rather than toxic discharges. Factories where the water that comes out is even cleaner than the water that goes in.

"Design is the first signal of human intentions, so what are our intentions?" McDonough says. "Modern culture appears to have adopted a strategy of tragedy. If we come here and say that we didn't intend to close global warming, it's not part of our plan ... well,  it's part of our de facto plan because it's the thing that's happening because we have no other plan. ...

"It took us 5,000 years to put wheels on our luggage. ... So there is no end game. There is an infinite game and we're playing in that game," he says. "The good news is the news of abundance and not the news of limits."

Recently McDonough has agreed to take those ideas and try to implement them at the WalMart corporation -- the nation's largest employer and a behemoth on the world market -- to try to transform it into a global leader in ecological improvement. He's a visionary, one with seemingly unending preserves of energy, ingenuity and chuzpah.

Using our imagination, intelligence and buying power, we can set the Earth on a path to healing and also ensure that future generations of all God's creatures (great and small) rest -- nourished and cared for -- in its loving, ample, natural embrace.

As a person of faith, how do you disagree with that?

Well, perhaps you could if you believe that the Earth is a cosmic rental car to which God has loaned us the keys to drive recklessly, strewn with fast-food wrappers, dent, ding, scratch and then leave by the side of the road when it runs out of gas.

McDonough's vision was refreshingly clear, intelligent and overwhelmingly hopeful. It spoke to our creativity, imagination and (divine) call to be caretakers, rather than dominators, of this garden of ours.

While he never spoke in explicitly religious terms, it was one of the most spiritually powerful messages I've heard in ages.

The Creator designed Earth to work seamlessly, a great cycle of life.

We just need to get out of our own way and start working with that design rather than against it.

 
 
 

Follow Cathleen Falsani on Twitter: www.twitter.com/godgrrl

While I'm no militant environmentalist by any stretch of the imagination (I recycle; I don't compost), I do considered myself something of a tree-hugger. There's even a sticker on my car that says, "...
While I'm no militant environmentalist by any stretch of the imagination (I recycle; I don't compost), I do considered myself something of a tree-hugger. There's even a sticker on my car that says, "...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:14 AM on 10/07/2010
We just need to get out of our own way and start working with that design rather than against it.

Exactly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Wood
A.T.C.G...(sigh)
11:51 AM on 10/04/2010
The Earth functions as the Earth is supposed to function...according to the laws of physics. There is a notable lack of evidence that there is a god. The vast probability is that there is no god, let alone a green one. It is incumbent upon humans to try their best to preserve the planet to our benefit. Earth won't care one way or another. It will just continue on it's journey according to the laws of physics...only without us...(sigh)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
AZreb
equal-opportunity Independent heathen
10:16 AM on 10/04/2010
"Nature is the only reality." We try to tame nature, we try to predict nature but it is impossible in so many ways. Instead of learning to live in harmony with nature, we seem to think we can overpower and control it.

And in so many ways we have destroyed nature and the natural balance. We poison prairie dogs, a food source for coyotes, and then wonder why coyotes are looking to domesticated animals as a food source. We overfish, overkill and then wonder why the supply is depleted.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbriani3842
400+ yrs of science & STILL no evidence for a god
01:49 PM on 10/03/2010
Sorry, but nature does not practice Capitalism -- which is the god this country truly worships. . .nature is a heretic and must be destroyed lest her teachings begin to poison the minds of your young'uns.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbriani3842
400+ yrs of science & STILL no evidence for a god
01:46 PM on 10/03/2010
Reading Carl Sagan's _Pale Blue Dot_ is enough to "shake your soul".

To truly motivate yourself to become the environmental change you want to see happening, all you have to do is look at the picture:

http://ropata.files.wordpress.com/2008/09/pale_blue_dot2.jpg

As Dr. Sagan said much better than I could, that's home. That's our place. Everyone who has ever lived and breathed was on that little pixel of color.

All of the blood spilled for a small piece of that small planet that orbits an ordinary star that orbits the center of one out of 200 billion galaxies has occured on that little blue dot.

That dot is all we've got. . .for all we know, it's all we're ever going to have.

What else do you need?

A god?

Really?

You don't need a god to take care of your home.

How about worshipping "good" instead of worshipping any god?

What else do you really need?
09:53 AM on 10/03/2010
WRONG!! God is white and clean shaven with blue eyes and a smallish straight nose. He looks really good on black velvet...right next to the king ...ELVIS!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:07 PM on 10/02/2010
Welcome, Ms Falsani, to true morality, even if you have chosen the path of superstition and myth rather than science to get to this point.

The following is a comment from a recently deceased dear friend who used to post on this blog:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

In so far as all morality is fundamentally based on preservation, betterment and continuation of life, there is no higher morality than environmentalism.

All religions pale in comparison.

Morality, when associated with religion, is limited and parochial. It is primarily focused on preservation, betterment and continuation of humans, but not all humans, only those following a particular belief system.

Even when it pretends to extend beyond that parochial realm – for example, “Love thy neighbor” and “Thou shalt not kill”, religious morality is limited to human life.

Environmentalism, on the other hand, encompasses preservation, betterment and continuation of all life, and, therefore, is the highest level of morality.

HumeSkeptic
_________________________________.
photo
emmanuel goldstein
Have you had your two minutes today?
10:55 PM on 10/02/2010
Jains (and most Hindus) and Buddhists have a deep reverence for all life. So do most Wiccans, Pagans. pantheists, and animists and shamanic religions usually do too. But, if it's not an Abrahamic religiion, why take it into account, right?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:47 PM on 10/02/2010
I could discuss each religion with its individual myths and dogma. But that is not what I set out to do. My objective was to convey an idea in a manner that most would understand it. Clearly, you didn't.

But, since you brought that up, Jainism (as an example) is extreme in not killing any living thing. That, of course, is based on the ancient thought that plants are not living things. The kill plants all the time.

In general, "preservation, betterment and continuation of life" shouldn't be taken to mean that no living thing should be killed, especially for food.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
AZreb
equal-opportunity Independent heathen
10:18 AM on 10/04/2010
Most Native American tribes have their practices based on respect and love of nature, too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barbara Graham
Comin at u from Area 5150
08:56 PM on 10/02/2010
God appointed man stewards of his garden. Man invented bulldozers and is currently in the process of making the garden into a tacky, ruined monument to man's greatness.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:21 PM on 10/02/2010
Let me remind you that we, you and I, are also humans, trying to do our best to reverse the damage. Sure, there have been technologists who used science to destroy much in nature, but there are also technologists who are trying to limit and even reverse the damage.

Don't give all the credit to God, whose existence cannot be proven, and put all the blame on all humans, for the folly of some humans.
photo
emmanuel goldstein
Have you had your two minutes today?
10:58 PM on 10/02/2010
Scientists require tools and the ability to travel in order to preform their experiments. Tools constructed often out of plastics and mined metals. You cannot separate science from technology, the two go together like religion and religious practice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbriani3842
400+ yrs of science & STILL no evidence for a god
01:48 PM on 10/03/2010
Don't you mean, "Through man, God invented bulldozers"?
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
02:56 PM on 10/03/2010
They don't know what they mean. It basically depends when you ask believers and how convenient (usually inconvenient) of a moment it is for them.
06:41 PM on 10/02/2010
This man gives me hope. Nature has given us the blueprint for life ever-renewing. Humanity must now look to the plant world for inspiration on how to continue and grow as a species. For far too long mankind has suppressed and devastated the natural world with no regard for the future, thinking themselves above or outside of nature. We must all wake up to the reality that we are one with the earth.
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
03:43 PM on 10/03/2010
No, we're doomed. The religious right, especially, is going to take us there.

It took Pope John Paul 400 years to pardon Galileo for their mistakes...We don't have that long and since the trend of the Religious Right is to follow a "God Will Save Us" solution to the Environment, this is NOT the rosed-colored view that is sold nightly on Faux or any of the other Corporate Entertainment News shows.

The center of power is NOT in human hands. It's in Corporate "hands" and since Corporations have no actual hands, they don't really care about people. One only has to think of Enron or general financial global meltdown to see the trend in action. Well, nothing has changed and nothing can change.

Generally speaking, humans are going to prove themselves too stupid to understand big shifts like this and it's simply too late to change any of this belligerent behavior.
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
08:35 PM on 10/03/2010
Go see "mememine69's" response below and it becomes QUICKLY apparent what the Religious Right has in store for us.
05:37 PM on 10/02/2010
William McDonough can " enforce " green collar jobs better than Van Jones can ; Obama must hire him
photo
LintLass
"When you can balance a tackhammer on your head...
03:32 PM on 10/02/2010
""Still, when talk turns toward carbon footprints and global warming, lately a certain melancholy -- almost a vague acedia -- has begun to shadow my heart. ""

It's a problem, that. Unfortunately, those of us who've been trying to wake you guys up for a lifetime weren't exactly listened to all along while things were made worse. Actively, even, while you scorned us and called it 'Moral.' (And us, 'evil libertine tree-huggers' )

Sure doesn't help that you guys seem trained to escalate any given thing till you can call it Apocalypse.

Don't despair, though. You gotta *get up.* My people can't do this *for* you. Don't go from bad guys to wusses on this. You have help.

""It all seems so ... Sisyphean.""

Sisyphus was too proud and greedy and thought he was above Death by main force. Funny how Christians teach the myth as an eternal sentence to never find balance, but like a lot of 'Hells,' there are options.

Some of them might involve asking for help.

Big ol' rock and pointy peak, you got there. Maybe you could use a friend with a well-used shovel. :)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicanada
Blogger, radio co-host, writer, editor, voice-over
12:59 PM on 10/02/2010
god IS green, and his symbol looks like . . . $
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
03:46 PM on 10/03/2010
That says it all.
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
03:48 PM on 10/03/2010
Besides, Christianity is "Green" ($).
photo
MikeDu
Both salubrious and lugubrious concurrently.
10:26 AM on 10/02/2010
I recall R. Reagan's hyper-fundamentalist interior secretary James Watt saying something along the lines of - We don't have to worry about the endangered species act because the rapture is coming. Its funny, though, how they never take that same attitude towards corporate profits. I suppose they must  figure corporate CEOs aren't going anywhere when the rapture comes so a big bank account would come in handy afterwards.

God is green in the same way God is anything else you want him to be. There's  a biblical passage or longstanding tradition for every occassion. Some passages are in vogue and some fall out of favor. Isaiah 33:1 "Woe to the that spoilest..." is not the most widely quoted biblical line among evangelicals these days.
photo
JohnFromCensornati
Wake up! It's 1984.
11:33 AM on 10/02/2010
"Trees cause more pollution than automobiles do." -- Ronnie Raygun
photo
LintLass
"When you can balance a tackhammer on your head...
03:40 PM on 10/02/2010
Just goes to show that whatever 'margin of error' deniers want us to live in, it's orders of magnitude smaller than the margin of *stupid* we should be allowing ourselves. :)