iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Cenk Uygur

Cenk Uygur

Posted: September 2, 2008 02:21 AM

What If Bristol Palin Were Black?


Christian-right leaders and conservative stalwarts have praised the decision of Bristol Palin, the daughter of Governor Sarah Palin, to carry her child to term. She is 17 and conceived this child out of wedlock. Now imagine she wasn't the daughter of a prominent Republican politician but an average person. Now imagine she was black.

What do you think conservatives would have to say about her? "Typical, urban youth with no sense of responsibility raised with loose morals who plans to depend on the state to take care of her child." You know it. It's not within dispute. That's exactly what they would say.

Barack Obama has told everyone to lay off this because it is a personal, family matter. Yes, but it also has public policy ramifications. Governor Palin is for abstinence only education. Well, that obviously didn't work.

Has she learned her lesson? Will she now amend her policy position on this matter given her personal record of failure in implementing this ridiculous stance?

Notice I am not blaming Bristol. Quite the opposite. People like me are the ones that defend the Bristols of the world. It is conservatives like James Dobson, Rush Limbaugh and yes, Governor Palin who usually attack people who find themselves in Bristol's situation. They demand a dogmatic adherence to moral strictures and chastise and belittle women who have children out of wedlock. Especially if they are women of color.

Which brings us back to Obama. Do you think the Republicans would lay off of Obama if his 17 year-old daughter had gotten pregnant out of wedlock? You know the answer to that question. Everyone does.

"This is what the permissive liberal attitude gets you. If you allow your children to think everything is acceptable, they have no boundaries. They wind up getting themselves in trouble like this. It's a predictable result of the liberal lifestyle."

And that's before the subtle and not so subtle racial implications are brought into this. There is a constant double-standard of how black and white people and politicians are covered in this country. When a young black girl gets pregnant, she's looking to get money from welfare. When a young white woman gets pregnant, she made an unfortunate mistake and her family is being supportive in trying to help the make the best of it.

Cindy McCain was addicted to drugs and stole from her own charity to feed her addiction. Now what do you think the Republicans would have done if Michelle Obama had done that? How do you think the press would have covered it? You think they would have called it a simple mistake and moved on?

When presented with these examples, no matter who you are, you know in your heart that this double standard exists. All of this is not said to condemn Bristol Palin or Cindy McCain. This is to get you to think twice about your own assumptions about the next time you hear a story of a young African-American woman who got pregnant in the inner city or a minority who got addicted to drugs and committed a crime to feed that addiction.

There but for the grace of God go Bristol Palin and Cindy McCain.

Watch The Young Turks Here

Follow Cenk Uygur on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TheYoungTurks

Christian-right leaders and conservative stalwarts have praised the decision of Bristol Palin, the daughter of Governor Sarah Palin, to carry her child to term. She is 17 and conceived this child out ...
Christian-right leaders and conservative stalwarts have praised the decision of Bristol Palin, the daughter of Governor Sarah Palin, to carry her child to term. She is 17 and conceived this child out ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 120
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
01:58 PM on 09/10/2008
i think you all missed the point - where have you people been. read the kidscount report published by the annie casey foundation. the statistics are staggering and this is in the face of millions of dollars of teen prevention funding programs.

all of this foolishness is obscuring real issues. the two parties are in a fight over the ability to control how the country moves forward with constitutional laws. if the right (republicans) gain control our country will move more towards the "disciplinary" and letter of the law type of society and if the left (democrats) gains control our country will move more toward "discretionary" and flexibility in the type of laws issued and passed in our country.

so the move the public involves itself in the trash talk, the public loses the ability to really discern which candidate will do the most good for the country.

besides we are all human. if you were born you got here through a sexual encounter. get over it.
02:26 PM on 09/04/2008
So let me get this straight. The Democrats are stereotyping the Republicans for their thinking they would be stereotypical in a hypothetical situation? Sorry, but that is a stretch. Race is not the issue here, but they are trying to make it the issue. I should also point out that it is not as if they are leaving them alone about this.
photo
tuttlemsm
Frustrating, isn't it?
01:27 PM on 09/04/2008
Once again, Cenk Uygur shows why he's my favorite blogger on Huffington Post.

Ever since Reagan's mastery of patriotic imagery, the double-standard has been in place.

Republicans are the standard, normal, ordinary, patriotic Americans until proven otherwise.

Democrats must first *prove* that they are standard, normal, ordinary and patriotic.

That's why the Republicans always get the benefit of the doubt. And the Democrats never do. That's why "liberal" is a dirty word and "conservative" is nothing more than the polite, affectionate term for bat-excrement crazy.
12:40 AM on 09/04/2008
The reason this is an issue is because the Republicans have spent years defining and then reacting to a perceived moral and social problem that they blame in no small way on undereducated and too young, single mothers having their babies on medicaid and living off welfare. For decades they have blamed much of the nation's economic woes on this population that is almost always described as being urban, poor, uneducated and non-white. Lately the vitriol has been directed against hispanics, particularly those "illegals" having children in in the US.

The irony is that Bristol Palin and her unborn baby are catagorically eligible for medicaid and all the services and benefits that come with that eligibility. Of course they won't use it because they will not need it. But that simple fact of economic status is all that separates the Palin family from the millions of young women and babies against whom the compassionate conservatives have been railing for a generation.

Would it be different if they were black or brown and/or poor? You bet.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Einstein44
10:19 PM on 09/03/2008
If you are not in the RIGHT WAY of thinking (Republican Party rhetorics),you are non-existent in their mind...They do not seem to even acknowledge their major flaws as others..So,so sad.Yet,they have become the biggest hypocrites when they disregard their faults..Oh no! not the conservative Republicans...They are perfect on personal attacks and smearing negative targets to those that disagree with their so-called principles...What a joke !!

Bravo for Cenk for pointing out the truth !!!!!
03:32 PM on 09/03/2008
"When a young black girl gets pregnant, she's looking to get money from welfare. When a young white woman gets pregnant, she made an unfortunate mistake..."
Who thinks this? Not me.
I'm a white, conservative male, who is virtually blind to race, and I feel I'm one of the majority among conservatives.
It seems that liberals constantly hit us conservatives over the head with the racist card. You're all wrong. You are the people who continue to racially divide the country, through stories like this one.
Shame on you liberals.

Example: Saying that "I want all illegals out of the country," would get me classified as a racist. When infact, I think racists are scumbags.

Stop the racial divide!
01:31 AM on 09/04/2008
Well spoken. Stop the prejudice liberals. Your making yourselves look terribly ignorant.
photo
tuttlemsm
Frustrating, isn't it?
01:28 PM on 09/04/2008
Methinks savagenation916 doth protest too much.
12:11 PM on 09/03/2008
I have been searching the internet high and low just waiting for someone to have the guts to say just that!!!! It's unbelieveable how everything that happens to white folks is "excusable" and every so quickly. If this had been on Obama's dime his house would have been bombed, his life threatened and all of the other double standard crap that goes with it. This is the absolute best article I've read since we learned of this embarrassing nonsense. Unbelieveable. And by the why I a white 50 year old woman. This praising acceptance of this teenager's limiting life changing experience is absurd!
10:41 PM on 09/05/2008
I'm glad someone else had enough to say this, especially your last sentence. I'm getting tired of the praise for teenage pregnancy, too. It's keeping these poor girls back at younger and younger ages. Sad.
09:19 AM on 09/03/2008
Yet another one of many hypocrisies in this race. I've listed at least 6 others (http://www.ireport.com/docs/DOC-74408), but think of others hourly as I read well written articles like this one. What troubles me, is that without a true mass media outlet, there is no way to aggregate the message from the people to those in power...except to Vote on Nov 2nd.
09:01 AM on 09/03/2008
Right on. But take it a step further..what if *Sarah* Palin were black? With her five kids? One of whom is unmarried and pregnant?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DFutureIsNow
08:54 AM on 09/03/2008
The republicans never chastise the rich, it's the middle class and the poor who are always on the right wing extremists sights
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:33 AM on 09/03/2008
A-Freaking men
12:35 AM on 09/03/2008
Sad but true
11:25 PM on 09/02/2008
Thank you so much for this post. If anything illustrates the hypocrisy of the "religious right," it is this Bristol Palin Baby Mama Drama. If she were black, we'd be hearing all over the place how "inner city" (read: blacks) don't take any personal responsibility and how their culture is broken and dysfunctional. We'd also be hearing from the right wing blogosphere that this pregnancy was the very reason they became conservatives because they don't think they should have to support (read: welfare for blacks) these out of wedlock births. This would all be to imply that "those people," are hopeless so why should you have to pay for them? I like how these conservatives are all now saying this is a private matter when it's one of their own and it's politically inconvenient to be consistently opposed to teen pregnancy and out of wedlock births. Now they are all screaming that this is liberal media bias and that liberals are being hypocritical for launching criticisms. However, they're missing the point that we aren't criticizing the girl, rather criticizing their hypocritical moralizing. You can't present yourself as the party of morals and live up to none of them. Sorry
09:29 PM on 09/02/2008
Great points. When Lacy ancd Conor Peterson disappeared, (and I do have deep sympathy for Lacy, Conor, and her family and friends) a female reporter admitted if the missing people were not-white, there would not be as much air time and attention devoted to them. God created us equal. When will we realize this?
09:06 PM on 09/02/2008
NO,NO,NO; That is not the plan from the Republicans. If she doesn´t withdraw we will be set back some 40 years. Where she will be place in the as the mouth piece for McCain, an the Black man(Obama) is not allowed tell the white woman she is wrong.