On Monday, April 6, The New York Times Business/Media section ran a story by Brooks Barnes titled "Pixar's Art Leaves Profit Watchers Edgy." Barnes referred to Pali Research's Richard Greenfield, who downgraded the stock of the Walt Disney Company because of a poor outlook for Pixar's new animated film to be released in May.
The film, titled "UP," is about a 78-year-old man who ties thousands of balloons to his house. The Times story quoted Greenfield as saying, "We doubt younger boys will be that excited by the main character;" he also complained about the lack of a female lead.
When a friend called my attention to the story and asked what I thought about the affect on Pixar's creativity of a Wall Street stock downgrade, it got me to thinking...
SCENE: New York Fifth Avenue apartment, about 9:30 p.m. A boy, Atticus, is in the study doing his 5th grade homework. His father, Richard ("Dick") enters. The father is tired from a long day's work writing reports about entertainment companies. His coat is off showing his red suspenders, and he's smoking a cigar.
Dick: "Hi, son. How's the homework going?"
Atticus: "Good, Dad. What did you do today?"
Dick: "Same ole, same ole. Wrote a couple of reports - one on Pixar's new movie, "Up."
Atticus: "I hear it's supposed to be good. I hope it'll be as good as 'Wall-E.'"
Dick: "'Wall-E' was propaganda and it didn't do that well in the box office - only $224 million."
Atticus: "But it won an Academy Award for best animated movie and it gave a great message about the environment."
Dick: "That was the problem. As Jack Warner of Warner Bros. once said, 'If you want to give a message, send a telegram?'"
Atticus:"What's a telegram?"
Dick: "That's what they used to call text messages before there were cell phones. All that matters are box office receipts - how much a movie makes."
Atticus: "Come on, Dad. My English teacher at Browning says that myths and stories tell us how to live our lives. It's not about the money; it's about making good movies."
Dick: "You're too young to understand, Atticus. You have to make money."
Dick: "Because that's what it's all about - making money."
Atticus: "You mean like Mr. Madoff?"
Dick: "Don't get smart with me. He's a crook. I'm a stock analyst."
Atticus: "Oh. Are stocks and derivatives the same thing? And weren't you writing about how great they were last year?"
Dick: "Look, I get paid - and paid well so you can go to Browning - to write and recommend stocks for our clients to buy or sell. And I'm not the only one to downgrade Disney; other analysts did, too."
Atticus: "Did they also say to buy Citi Bank like you did?"
Dick: "Listen, Atticus, don't get smart with me. I'm just trying to make a living, not save the world. I have no responsibility to the public, just to the people who pay me and who buy stocks and derivatives from us. I can't help it if there are crooks on Wall Street. They're responsible for the crash and the depression, not me. I'm just following orders."
Atticus: "OK, Dad, don't get upset. I know you're trying. But do you have to knock Pixar? Their movies make people feel better and maybe to live better lives."
Dick: "That's not my job."
Atticus: "What is your job then? And are you proud of it?"
How will Donald Trump’s first 100 days impact YOU? Subscribe, choose the community that you most identify with or want to learn more about and we’ll send you the news that matters most once a week throughout Trump’s first 100 days in office. Learn more