More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Charlotte Safavi

Charlotte Safavi

Posted: January 4, 2011 08:08 PM

Former Shah of Iran's Son Dead

What's Your Reaction:

Ali Reza Pahlavi, the second son of the former late Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, committed suicide at his home in Boston early on Tuesday morning.

According to the Boston Police Department, Pahlavi was found dead of a "self-inflicted gunshot wound." He is survived by his mother Farah Diba, brother Reza, sister Farahnaz and half-sister Shahnaz. His younger sister Leila died of a drug overdose in 2001.

Pahlavi, 44, was a mere child on the brink of adolescence at the time of the Islamic Revolution in 1979. He since devoted much of his life to studying the country -- and culture -- he was unable to remain physically connected to by virtue of his birth.

He had a Ph.D. from Harvard University where he studied at the Department of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations.

He could fill his head, but not his heart. Like many of his generation, including myself, he was left holding only a memory of home, with the added pain of never being able to return safely to his homeland.

According to Islam, suicide is considered a grievous sin, perhaps, in the end, he paid the steepest price... or was he a martyr, a sacrifice for a lost generation?

Below is the official statement posted on Reza Pahlavi's website:

With Immense Grief That We Would Like to Inform Our Compatriots of the Passing Away of Prince Alireza Pahlavi

RezaPahlavi.org | Jan 4

It is with immense grief that we would like to inform our compatriots of the passing away of Prince Alireza Pahlavi.

Like millions of young Iranians, he too was deeply disturbed by all the ills fallen upon his beloved homeland, as well as carrying the burden of losing a father and a sister in his young life.

Although he struggled for years to overcome his sorrow, he finally succumbed, and during the night of the 4th of January 2011, in his Boston residence, took his own life, plunging his family and friends into great sorrow.

Once again, we are joined with mothers, father and relatives of so many victims of these dark times for our country.

[Signed:] Reza Pahlavi, Farah Pahlavi, Farahnaz Pahlavi, Yasmine Pahlavi, Noor Pahlavi, Iman Pahlavi and Farah Pahlavi

 

Follow Charlotte Safavi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/CharlotteSafavi

 
 
  • Comments
  • 45
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:20 PM on 01/07/2011
A Democratic Iran is the future.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
07:45 AM on 01/08/2011
Thanks for your comment. This is the wish of most.
08:21 PM on 01/07/2011
Correction: Instead of 2006 please read 2001
Note: I was aware, in this time of mourning, the harsh words in my comment sound cruel and uncivil, yet I felt I am in front of the panel of historic judgment and I have to be as honest as a person can be. If anyone in the circle of Pahlavis is offended, he/she should know the harshness, brutality and humiliations Iranians felt under Pahlavis was inexplicably atrocious. Regardless, I feel bad and if any apology can remedy my supposed errors I reluctantly go for it. What I have to repeat again is, I wish patience, peace and all the BEST for Farah whom I have come to admire after watching the Queen and I.
07:50 PM on 01/07/2011
Part 1 of 3

Those who know me will show grave astonishment finding out I, a fervent anti Shah, anti ruthless dictators, tearlessly cried when I found out Shah’s brighter son has killed himself.

I am an atheist, believe capitalism, the way practiced in US and many other countries in the world is a primitive, appalling and barbarous system. I wonder why most people can’t see that capitalism is the source of all our miseries in our short ambiguous lifves. (As a practical workable semi-just system I’ll favor the Scandinavian approaches for running their countries).

In my view, Shah, was a deranged psychotic man. Until mid 70s he was an obedient, spineless servant of his masters who were viciously ruling Iran (Amnesty International in mid 70s identified Iran is the worst violator of Human Rights in the world). All the records of oil contracts, transaction of arms purchases, and countless dealing with foreign companies AND the creation and behavior of SAVAK etc etc all chillingly prove who Shah was.

Hypothetically if there was no Shah, no blatant intervention of foreigners in Iranian internal affairs then Iran had perfected its democracy and now all Iranians, because of their captivating culture (which was evolved during 1000s of years) could have hold their heads high ( not in shame and embarrassment of being members of a backward theocratic state).
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:18 AM on 01/08/2011
The relatively short-lived Pahlavi dynasty is one of many in the thousands of years of Iran's existence, including the Safavid dynasty from which I am a remnant. I think blaming this dynasty and that and this foreign government and that is counterproductive at this point in time, just another opportunity to vent and speculate. We are what we are. We need to examine our ancient and recent history, our overall context in the world at large, most importantly our national character, and look deep inside to see why we are what we are.
07:49 PM on 01/07/2011
Part 2

The above alone might articulate why Shah was such a horrible stooge. I have to rush to say that Shah’s father was also installed by British as well as Khomeini being forced down the throat of Iranians by foreigners in the same way they created Afghan Mojahedin, Pakistan and Afghan Islamic Republics or created Hamas in the occupied Palestine.

From the film ‘Queen and I’ I found out, Farah, by no means, is as deplorable as Ashraf (Shah’ sister) was. On the contrary Farah is, in my view, like a normal likeable housewife who, as usual, has brainwashed herself that ‘Her Man is the Greatest Sole in the world’. Such a deceptive self-indoctrination is amply explained by scientists of different fields. Farah’s blindness to see the transgressions of her husband is understandable and forgivable. Maybe her unforgivable offense is she didn’t attempt to stop her relatives indulge themselves in an orgy of plundering the country. However since I do not know all the facts I am sticking to the civil rule that Farah is innocent until she is proven guilty.
07:48 PM on 01/07/2011
Part 3

From media I knew Ali Reza, and her sister Leyla (who also committed suicide in 2006) were both bright. I imagine both possessed admirable sense of Integrity / honesty. I cant help contemplating the enormous pains Ali Reza felt when in the university he was studying the history of Iran. I know if I was in his place similarly couldn’t tolerate that heavy amount of anguish after finding out what had happened. The agonies must have been beyond the ordinary thresholds of human tolerance...... I feel his pains..... I identify him and her sister as part of my soul and psyche....in an uncanny way I salute to both of them.

I can’t explain my sympathetic emotions and how I feel about Farah now, one loss was too many, two is beyond pains, undescribable pains...

At one point I nearly felt all.....that is why I cried close to having tears...

Am I angry? Noway, ancient Iranian thinkers have taught me anger, revenge or violence are animalistic..I try to enter Rumi’s realm, be the entity which is “beyond any imagination”, the entity that its compassion fills all the infinite spaces.

My thoughts are with Farah, who for days has hidden herself in a room, not talking to anyone. I just want to tell her even some of those who were once in the camp of her husband’s harsh cirtics are trying to reach out to her and pass their deeply heart-felt condolences....
06:13 AM on 01/06/2011
Is it possible that instead of a voluntary suicide, Prince Ali Reza was forced to commit suicide? Is it possible that his murderer (s) gave him an opportunity to write a short suicide note? Is it possible that he was forced to say that he was depressed? Is it possible that his beloved brother, our Crown Prince is now forced to repeat the District Attorney's report and the suicide report? I feel sorry for Pahlavi's who have lost their beloved brother/son, for Iran and Iranians to lose their beloved young Prince, a beacon of light for young Iranians all over Iran. May God Bless the Benevolent, Kind, democratic, secular, humane, progressive, and beautiful Pahlavi Family - The Queen, The Crown Prince, and remaining Princess. Long Live Pahlavi. Long Live Iran.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:48 AM on 01/06/2011
Thanks for your comments. Iran has been wracked over thousands of years by violent change but lives on. The premature loss of a son and brother is a tragedy on the most elemental and human level, whatever the circumstances.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
koroush1336
An human rights activist and totally anti-mullahs,
01:23 AM on 01/06/2011
In such sad times, one should forget all his/her differences, in any given direction and simply express his/her condolences. This "end" is a general end (of course not this "form" of it) for ever one of us. Some people see it as "solution" to their problems in the life which is deeply sad. May he be in peace and his family have the power to cope with the lost of their loved one.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:49 AM on 01/06/2011
Thanks for your humane comment. I couldn't agree more. This isn't about politics or revenge, but about loss.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Doctoress
10:32 AM on 01/05/2011
Lots of fabricated and misleading information. He did not hold a Ph.D. in anything, He had tried to study for a Ph.D. but did not go on. "he was left holding only a memory of his country" like you? you don't have to hold the memory you can travel there, visit there, and even decide to stay there. It is your choice. Unless, of course, you have sold out your country to its enemies; the British and the Americans. He, unlike you, could not go back because of being the son of his father. What is your excuse?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
04:27 PM on 01/05/2011
Thanks for your response. I'm afraid the intricacies of the Ph.D. are unknown to me, though it's clear that he tried to study and learn something about Iran throughout his shortened life. When you are eleven or twelve, as he was when he left, you are left with impressions, yearnings and memories. I identify with this. It is true that I can go back to visit and likely will at some point, but as an educated, Westernized woman, who was born and mostly raised in England, I don't think I could live there. I don't feel comfortable with wearing a veil and not being able to freely speak my mind, small personal freedoms that I take for granted. With Islam or an Islamic Republic, I have absolutely no problem if that is what the people of a country want.
03:15 AM on 01/05/2011
Pinning it on the IR again??
02:25 AM on 01/05/2011
Now, this is the kind of article I would classify under the heading "pin it on the Islamic Republic even if it has nothing to do with it."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:25 AM on 01/05/2011
Thanks for your input, but nobody is pinning anything on the Islamic Revolution. Revolutions have side effects and people who are displaced, whether by necessity or by choice, have adjustment issues to deal with. I'm merely stating the facts.
10:09 AM on 01/05/2011
You are right. Revolutions has side effects, and so do Wars.Million of displaced Iraqis and over a million civilians dead.
RIP Alireza. I wonder if his depression had anything to do with the crimes his father committed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alimostofi
Astrologer, Commentator
09:05 PM on 01/04/2011
To a proud Iranian, who showed so much love for Iran, I say "Bedrood". And Charlotte, why bring Islam into it. Like many, he was secular.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
04:12 AM on 01/05/2011
Thanks for your comment. Like many he was secular; the country remains Islamic, so I wished to provide a context for my statement.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alimostofi
Astrologer, Commentator
05:26 AM on 01/05/2011
Islamic background is not the only background.
06:30 AM on 01/05/2011
You are an idiot.
photo
LogicalMathMan
Math, Finance, English, Business Instructor
08:48 PM on 01/04/2011
RIP...I wonder if the family will ever concede that they were mere pawns in the hands of the US. After the Shah was dethroned, our government spent $1 million a month maintaining his lifestyle and protection in Acapulco, Mexico, until they resolved his family's status to reside in the US.

Having a 22 karat gold commode was just sacrilegious.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:26 AM on 01/05/2011
I have no knowledge of this. A suicide is a tragedy either way. Thanks for your comment.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:39 AM on 01/06/2011
Someone wanted to share this information with the Logical Math Man but was having difficulty posting. I'm unable to verify these facts but thought to post them as they are the complete polar opposite of what the LMM believed.
My position remains that this young man died prematurely and it is a tragedy for his family either way. May he rest in peace.
Quote begins: "as I recall the U.S. govt. Froze all the personal assets of the royal family and wouldn't even allow them to come to the U.S for the shah's cancer treatment. If it wasn't for president Sadaat of Egypt giving the shah and his family asylum, they would've turned the shah and his family in to the blood thirsty Iranian revolutionaries, who would've eaten them for breakfast, lunch and dinner. That was a shameful way to treat your former allies. I wonder how witnessing this lack of humanity might have set the stage for the depression that those poor royal children suffered later in life."
08:45 PM on 01/04/2011
I find it truly shameful that this website is censoring negative comments about the Shah. What are we--in Iran?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:27 AM on 01/05/2011
Not sure I follow you. I'm just reporting the news. Thanks for writing in.
12:10 PM on 01/05/2011
I am not talking about you, Charlotte. Last night, HP was censoring any and all criticism of the Shah on another thread. I came to your thread hoping that perhaps my comment would make it through. My comment was in no way directed at you in any way.
10:42 AM on 01/05/2011
The so-called Islamic Revolution, much like the Mujahadeen/Al Qaeda or the short lived Pahlavi dynasty itself, was a cynical fabrication by the British and US anti-Soviet war machine that got out of control and developed a diseased life of its own.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
05:14 PM on 01/05/2011
Thanks for your comments. I just read Daughter of Persia, an interesting autobiography that touches upon some of the issues you discuss. Of course, as a memoir, it tells only the author's side of the story.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]