More

Chris Durang

Chris Durang

Posted: November 22, 2007 07:08 PM

Trouble Feeling Grateful


I like Thanksgiving as a holiday; it's my favorite one after the storming of the Bastille. However, I've been having trouble feeling grateful recently.

I'm disturbed by the state of the world, and the state of the country.

As William Wordsworth wrote, "The world is too much with us." The "us" referring to all of us; or just to me, in which case it's the "royal we."

Grateful, let's see.

I am grateful that Scott McClellan said that Libby, Rove, Caird, Cheney and the president himself were "involved" in misleading him on the outing of Valerie Plame; and that they all participated in misleading the American public through telling him non-truths. Otherwise known as lies. I am grateful for that admission from him.

MSNBC though later reported that the publisher says McClellan did not mean to imply that Bush lied to him, only that Bush "participated" in encouraging McClellan to believe the others because Bush believed the others too. "Heck of a job, Libby. Thanks for the info, Dick! Doin' good, Andy!"

I don't know that I believe that cover for Bush, do you? I believe Cheney-Libby lied first, but Bush couldn't figure it out? Of course in the public arena, lies are very hard to prove as lies. Though Bush and his whole administration long ago turned into the Boys Who Cried Wolf. (Or Who Cried Wolfowitz, ha ha.) It's remarkable when they say anything true; I always begin by assuming it's a lie or manipulation.

The leaves turned color a full month late this year in PA. Climate change, fellas.

Grateful. I am grateful for the existence of old movies on DVD. I am grateful the trees are so pretty in the fall, though worried they turned so late this year.

I think Congress should subpoena McClellan and demand he make clear what he knows. I assume he'd obey a subpoena. Unlike Harriet Miers and Joshua Bolton.

How is Harriet Miers? Is she back in Texas? Has she found another incompetent but dangerous man to idolize? Or is she still sending Bush little greeting cards saying "you're the best" and signed with a smiley face over the two i's in her name?

Oh -- I am grateful that Harry Reid and the Democrats are keeping Congress technically in session so Bush can't once again use Congress' vacation to make his pigheaded, political "recess appointments." Good for them!

And good for Senator Jim Webb, who I saw on CNN after he both opened and closed a session, all by himself. He seemed in good spirits, and glad to block the President on this. Remember Webb? He's the one who refused to make small talk with the president when the president wanted to show faux concern about Webb's son over in Iraq. The president was real offended. Poor Bushie.

McClellan's story put Lewis "Scooter" Libby back in the limelight. I find his nickname idiotic, and it's annoying to see it over and over.

Scooter Libby, Scooter Libby. Told a lie, a great big fibby. Shove, push, shove, push -- you tell a lie if you work for Bush. That's what schoolchildren all over the country are chanting now, right before they rush inside to check their email on Myspace or Myface or Mypudenda.

Thanksgiving. I am grateful for this corn, otherwise known as maize.

I am grateful I am not one of the characters in the film Damage.

My dog woke me at 3:30 a.m. Normally he gets me up at 6, which is okay with me. Lately he seems to need to go out in the middle of the night. I blame Bush. And Scooter Hooter Booter Libby.

Anyway, I couldn't get back to sleep, so I turned on the TV; and I, my partner John and the dog saw the last 40 minutes of the Louis Malle film Damage on the Independent Film Channel.

The on-screen Dish Network description of Damage said this: Damage (1992), with Jeremy Irons, Juliette Binoche, Miranda Richardson. An English politician embarks on a catastrophic affair with his son's girl friend. (1 hr, 31 min.)

(Don't read the rest if you plan to see the movie someday.)

Catastrophic is right.

Jeremey Irons is in Parliament, and his son is engaged to Juliette Binoche. However, she's a bit of an enigmatic oddball (I missed the beginning, so I don't know what psychological nuttiness she's acting out of), and Irons and she have an affair, keeping it hidden from Jeremy's nice son and his nice wife.

Then Binoche's mother comes to tea and picks up what's going on immediately, and warns Jeremy to stop it. So he tells Binoche they have to call it off, it is his son she's supposed to marry after all.

Her response is to send him a key to a lovely pied-a-terre she's just rented for frequent sex with her father-in-law. Jeremy can't resist, and for reasons that made sense when you were watching, he by mistake leaves the key in the door.

The son shows up, hears orgasmic sounds, and walks in on his father and his fiancé having sex. The poor young man looks deeply upset, and backs out of the room, oblivious to the fact he's on the fifth floor, and he falls over a guard rail by the staircase, and splat he's dead. Naked Jeremy cradles his son's dead body, while Juliette goes off somewhere, without so much as an "oh my." Jeremy resigns from Parliament, and returns home to his distraught wife who appropriately asks him why he didn't kill himself.

This film made me grateful.

I'm grateful I didn't have an affair with my son's fiancée. I'm glad I didn't inadvertently cause my son's death or destroy my wife's life. And I enjoyed seeing Leslie Caron's brief appearance as Juliette's mother.

Ms. Caron seems charming, and I hope to have Thanksgiving dinner with her next year. Though would she come to Pennsylvania or would I have to go to France? Where is France exactly?

Oh, and I'm grateful for my partner and my dog and the maze and DVDs and fall even late. And I'm grateful that I use food for comfort, or rather I'm not grateful I use food for comfort. I need to contact Kirstie Alley and Valerie Bertinelli and go off to Jenny Craig meetings with them.

----------------------------------------------

P.S. I agree with the Wilsons' post today that it is outrageous that the New York Times did not run a single story on the McClelland comments in his upcoming book. What is the matter with the New York Times? Something sure is. And the Washington Post buried the story.

And why, in all the times I've heard the story of the outing of Valerie Prame as a covert agent, has no one ever said that aside from anything else, what kind of idiot rebuttal to Joe Wilson's report is it to say, well his wife recommended him???

It turns out, according to what I've read, she didn't recommend him, she wasn't the "cause" of his being chosen. But even if she had been, what kind of f-ing point is that?

Mythical Reporter: "Vice President Cheney, Joe Wilson went to Niger and he found NO evidence of Saddam having tried to buy uranium to make a nuclear bomb." Cheney: "Oh yeah? Well his wife recommended him for the job!"

And... so what?

Wilson's findings are meaningless because of who recommended him? WHAT ABOUT THE CONTENTS OF WILSON'S ARTICLE???

What about the fact that Cheney and Bush and Condi-Scooter-Rice went on tv and whipped the American public into a scared fury that Saddam was going to drop a nuclear bomb on us, and dragged us into a war that had nothing to do with 9/11, though Cheney said it did, and all the other Bushies either said it did or mussed the issue up... and now we're still there. What about the fact that the documents supposedly proving a Niger-Saddam connection were an obvious, obvious forgery? Who did the forgery? That helped send us to war. The Bush administration has no interest in that, they just want to keep saying "Oh yeah? Well his wife recommended him and so we win! Our point wins!"

I don't know if they CONSCIOUSLY chose to out Valerie Plame, but it's clear they knew she was in the CIA and they had no interest in checking on her status in their rush to say their "brilliant" rebuttal. It was a VERY SERIOUS omission. The CIA itself requested the Justice Department investigate it.

And yes, Bush talked all tough about punishing whoever outed a CIA agent... and then never brought it up again once it became clear it was people around him he did.

If Clinton's administration had leaked a CIA agent, either knowingly or sloppily, to sell a war, the outcry from the right would have been enormous. And it would have been correct to react with an outcry, no matter which party did something like that.

But the Republicans in this country are enormously hypocritical, and they have done nothing to face up to the disgrace and danger that is the Bush administration. Or to protect us from it. And the Dems are trying, but the Republican Senators are threatening filbuster on almost every single issue, demanding 60 votes that the Dems just don't have. Remember when Bill Frist was going to do away with the filibuster to punish the Democrats for threatening its use for judges? And now the Republicans use the threat CONSTANTLY, so that majority rule is now meaningless in the Senate. It has to be 60 votes.

The mainstream media acts like "the outing of an agent to send us to war" story is yesterday's news. It shouldn't be treated that way.

-----------

P.P.S. The New York Times finally ran a piece today (Friday, Nov. 23) on the Scott McClelland statement implicating Cheney-Rove-Libby-Caird-and-in-some-way-Bush in misleading both him and the American people on the Valerie Plame outing. The story broke on tv news and many newspapers on Nov. 20 and Nov. 21st. It was reported by the BBC, for instance, on Nov. 20.

The Times article today is actually an Associated Press piece, and does not focus on McClelland's accusation -- no, that's not news, is it? -- but is a mini-think-piece about how the tone of books press secretaries have written about their work with various administrations have changed over the years. The actual paragraphs written by McClelland and leaked by his publisher are not quoted in the article, as they are quoted in most other coverage of the story. Thus if you only read the Times you would not have that information. (Online it's buried in a Times "blog.") How the Times loves their think pieces. All the news that's fit print.

 
 
  • Comments
  • 49
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:23 AM on 11/26/2007
HOLIDAY RECIPE FOR LAME DUCK

Choose from the following foul:
Dead or sitting duck, big turkey, or chicken-hawk
(Guts will have already been removed from chicken-hawk, so stuffing may proceed immediately)
Remove backbone, but bind the bird with Duck Tape in hostage posture
to give structure and an impression of unity.
For an unexpected taste sensation, marinate the bird-brain in alcohol
forming it into a pretend head-shape,
placing where the head would ordinarily be.
Expect brain to shrink further in the heat.
Pluck bird, and feather the nests of the already wealthy and well-connected.
Create a stuffing of Rummy Rice and selected nuts.
Simmer in a cup of extra virgin 10-40 oil.
Then dredge in white phosphorus and bake (if unavailable, substitute napalm).
Line and press stuffing into every open pocket.
Turn heat setting to intolerable.
Place bird on rack and torture out of sight until skin falls off the bone
or until Constitutional lawyers stop you.
Skewer the wings together. Once bird is done,
remove the left wing completely and discard.
For flambe or blackened bird, toss in an I.E.D.
Cover duck, or duck and cover, as you wish.
Offer the bird to members of the press when they start to ask real questions.
Invite lobbyists to dinner first, and save them the most tender flesh.
Serve lying repeatedly on a bed of Saudi sand, and present with straight face
and talking points.
When all have gathered, prey over the community.
Follow the same recipe for Cooked Goose, but invite a few grunts on their third military tours for a last supper.
Send carcass and leftovers (if any) to New Orleans for a homeland gumbo or stew.

Copyright Dinah Kudatsky Nov. 2005
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
campaignman
07:01 PM on 11/25/2007
Great article. I've wondered the same thing about why the Bush team was able to sell the origin of Wilson's trip as important or relevant. Moreover, I am truly stunned by the lack of coverage by the NYT and minimal coverage by the WP. We must remember though that if it hadn't been for Woodward and Bernstein, Watergate wouldn't have come to light. NO ONE else was pursuing it. They didn't think it had legs.

Recess appointments, signing statements, laws and executive orders allowing martial law, abandonment of New Orleans, starting the Iraq war on lies, mismanaging the war because of ideology and crony capitalism, ignoring the war in Afghanistan and mishandling the one or two opportunities to catch Bin Laden, re-writing congressional testimony on scientific matters from agency officials to make them conform to WH policy (i.e. global warming), ousting federal prosecutors who failed to do GOP bidding (i.e. indicting Dems on unfounded charges before the '06 elections), saying "bring it on" to terrorists and watching them kill our troops for lack of proper protection since we had the military we had and not the military we actually needed, forcing a general into retirement for telling us all before the war in Iraq that we didn't have the military we needed to win, illegally spying on American citizens and demanding immunity for it, torturing captives and American citizens and redefining the word to avoid being held responsible, disappearing American citizens, not giving them access to an attorney, libeling their reputations, intimidating and prosecuting journalists, etc...

We have to be thankful we still live in a semblance of a democracy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:34 AM on 11/24/2007
As hard as it is to live this idea, giving in to despair is unacceptable. It's . . .forgive me, lazy. People in other times and in other places right now live through vile horrors, and keep the light of decency and honor alive in our species.
Turn your back on what makes you ill. Do whatever you can - use biodegradeable soaps, for shits sake, change your lightbulbs to CFs, recycle everything, give to Kucinich, make yourself a peace T-shirt, grow a tomato or a pot plant. Create, create, create. Spend time in non-human nature - it really fucking helps. Exercise - it keeps me from blowing my brains out. Take care of yourself and those around you. Blog. Holler. Write. Vote. Stop BUYING into it, in any ways you can. Do not give in to fear. En-courage one another. And never, never quit.
Peace, Y'all.
04:20 PM on 11/23/2007
I thought this was the year when we were going to stop having to come up with things to be thankful for on Thanksgiving. I am not thankful for this feeling that we are killing ourselves with silence on important issues. I keep wondering about the defense budget, we spend more than practically everyone else combined, we have most of the world's stockpiles of WMDs, and we seem to have a monopoly on 21st century weapons design. The question for our politicians is is this for offensive or defensive purposes, and the other question is if we cut our military budget in half, won't we still be totally safe from any other nation attacking us, and wouldn't that make us less tempted to start wars? I would be thankful if some of the politicians started discussing this.
02:27 PM on 11/23/2007
You are a successful playwright, your work is seen by people all over the world. How many writers, do you suppose, would kill for a tenth of your success? You may not be rich but you are well off, you have a home and plenty to eat and money in the bank. You are better off than millions and millions of people. You have a partner, how many people are there who never find love, who have no network of friends and family to care about them? You have the ability to write, there are people who will try all their lives and never be able to do what you can. On the other hand you live in George Bush's America. The bright side of this is that you have so much company. There are many Americans fighting to reclaim our beloved country, you do not have to look far to find someone who inspires you. So turn that frown upside down mister! In a year the loathsome toad will slither out of the White House and we will all wonder if it was just a bad dream.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
msfiskvletterman
01:20 PM on 11/23/2007
11/23/07
1:23pm
Burlington, VT

I am having trouble feeling grateful because I still can't get anybody to help me with my ID theft problems.
I am grateful for the shelter here in Burlington, though.
11:45 AM on 11/23/2007
Whatever happened to the "Nuclear Option" that the Republicans were going to use if the Democrats tried to filibuster? Why isn't there a nuclear option for Democrats? Why in the world are Democrats such wimps!!!!
11:27 AM on 11/23/2007
Regardless of how bad things get, I never have trouble being thankful for my eyesight, hearing, sense of smell & touch, friends, family, freedom to work where I want, freedom to eat at any of a hundred nearby restaurants, the beautiful sunrise and senset every day, etc...

If you take politics so seriously, like this writer does, that it affects your ability to be thankful...you need to visit a care facility for the disabled like I did yesterday.

The six people I visited (one quadropalegic (sp?)- hit by car while jogging, one a stroke victim who was sad that his family was not visiting for the holiday, one with a muscle disorder, and 3 people with no legs.

They all had a great sense of humor, and made my thanksgiving mean something special. Most of their thanksgiving was confined to a bed in a small room.

I'm a conservative that debates with liberals everyday... but we are all a part of the same family...and I still want the best for everyone.
11:20 AM on 11/23/2007
Here is one thing I'm definitely not grateful about: the fact that Paul G. Kirk and the rest of the site selection commission have rejected New Orleans as a site for any of the presidential debates that are slated to take place next year. Kirk lied by saying that New Orleans hadn't sufficiently recovered from Katrina to host a debate.

This is a politically-motivated sham and a slap in the face of New Orleans which is perfectly equipped to host such a debate. And BushCo's fingerprints are all over it.

WHAT THE PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE SITE SELECTION NEEDS TO DO FOR NEW ORLEANS AND LOUISIANA

1. Publicly apologize to New Orleans and Louisiana. Add that the decision to reject New Orleans had been made in error.

2. Tell the truth about New Orleans--that after Katrina she has hosted more than a few events and hosted them beautifully.

And this last demand is the most important, because it is the ONLY satisfactory way to resolve this matter. It is non-negotiable--nothing less will be acceptable.

3. Plan, schedule, and announce a FIFTH debate to be held in New Orleans.
11:15 AM on 11/23/2007
I was lauging so hard at this, I cried. You have a non-linear mind like mine! Are you scared? I think they started the "his wife sent him" to make him look henpecked, a girlyman. Not macho and self-directed like their pathetic little sweaty selves. Ooops--his wife could kick their ass. Well, lie out of it!
photo
llozano
Live and let live...
11:12 AM on 11/23/2007
It does seem difficult in times like these to find something to be grateful for. I do however find a lot to be grateful for not so much for the state of the country but for the opportunities they give us to continue to work for truth, justice and the American way. If this was a perfect world we would probably all die of boredom. In the case of Scott McClellan I too find it disconcerting that it has not gained too much traction with the media, tv or print. What I find more disturbing is that the Democrats and even to some degree the Republicans have not demonstrated any sense of outrage over the matter. It could be the timing of the story but you would think that if 9/11 had happened at the same time as the re-arrest of the boys from Arruba or Black Friday it would not have been delegated to the status of an old story or no story. We could be headed in that direction if we don't hold the press accountable for telling us the truth no matter how ugly or how uncomfortable it makes us feel. At work I have a few rules and one is that I want to hear the bad news first and from them first thing in the morning. I don't want to hear it after I have my coffee and settle in and I certainly don't want to hear about it from someone outside of our organization. My Thanksgiving will not be spoiled if I hear that Congress has grown a backbown and will begin impeachment hearings today.
10:49 AM on 11/23/2007
Thank goodness......I am on the down side of life. My grandparents and parent managed to escape the rightwing in Nazi germany. They had the insight to see things as they really were and decided to make good their escape, before Hitler had a crack at them.

Now I see the same beginnings of that fascism here in America and am wondering if I should spend my time somewhere else.....instead of waiting for that eventual knock on the door, at some very early morning hour.
10:43 AM on 11/23/2007
"If Clinton's administration had leaked a CIA agent, either knowingly or sloppily, to sell a war, the outcry from the right would have been enormous."

If the Whitehouse janitor had gotten a warning ticket for a "rolling stop" the outcry from the right would have been, and would until this day be, enormous. We need to know who we're dealing with so I listen to as much wingnut radio as I have time for (or as I can stomach, whichever comes first) and it is clear that the right is still ecstatic about the performance of the criminal conspiracy masquerading as an administration. Outcry hell, BUSHCO is viewed with all of the adoration of the savior.

And I'm actually grateful for that because if the right toned it down a couple of hundred notches millions of people would not be becoming as disgusted with everthing on that side of the political spectrum as is now happening.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gemstone1000
A Cut Above
10:37 AM on 11/23/2007
"It's remarkable when they say anything true; I always begin by assuming it's a lie or manipulation."

Question: How can you tell when Bush is lying? Answer: His lips are moving.
10:26 AM on 11/23/2007
RIP America.