More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Christina Pirello

GET UPDATES FROM Christina Pirello
 

Stigmatizing Health: The War Against 'Health Nuts'

Posted: 07/07/10 01:00 PM ET

Healthy-eating disorder. Yes, you heard right, healthy-eating disorder. In its insatiable quest to create a mental problem or syndrome out of every human phenomenon and activity, the psychiatric industry has fabricated their most ridiculous disorder yet: 'orthorexia nervosa' which in Latin translates to "nervous about correct eating." Named by California doctor, Steven Bratman in 1997, this latest in a long line of left of center syndromes is no laughing matter. While not an entirely new syndrome, it has had new life breathed into it.

According to The Guardian newspaper, if you place your focus on eating healthy foods, you are mentally distressed and most likely in need of some treatment that involves pharmaceuticals, like psychotropic drugs. The theory is that fixation with healthy eating can be a sign of a serious psychological disorder. Huh?

Instead of calling this new syndrome "nervous about healthy eating disorder," which just sounds stupid (oh, wait, it is stupid), the geniuses that define mental health gave it a Latin name so it sounds authentically like a disease and not the made up delusional rantings of a pharmaceutical-driven industry that relies on us being weak, fat, sick and in fear of mental disease.

The Guardian goes on to say that "orthorexics" (official name for those of us afflicted with the idea that we would like to choose healthy foods so we can avoid illness) have rigid guidelines around eating. For instance, an orthorexic may eliminate sugar, salt, caffeine, alcohol, wheat, gluten, yeast, soy products, corn, meat and/or dairy products from their diets. And that's just the beginning, according to experts. These same "whackos" may also avoid foods that contain pesticides, herbicides, growth hormones, steroids or anything artificial. Wow, they sure sound crazy to me (she said, her voice dripping with sarcasm).

So according to this psycho-babble, attempting to avoid chemicals, saturated fat, sugar and anything artificial qualifies you as a mental patient. Taking care of your body by making healthy food choices and avoiding processed and other foods that steal your health tells society that there's something wrong with you. Really?

This goes along with that old cliché that calls these very same people "health nuts." You know the ones: the screwballs who exercise, eat right and live a natural life so they can avoid the lifestyle diseases that are killing Americans in record numbers.

What does that say about the rest of society? You know, the people who choose to be couch potatoes and shove junk food down their gullets. Are they "sickness nuts?" Funny how we've never turned that term into a cliché. Eating junk food, living on processed food-like substances is normal. The mental patients are the ones who choose organic, natural, whole foods. Am I the only one who sees how off the mark this is?

But okay, I won't go all Tom Cruise on you, saying that psychiatry is hooey and not needed. And certainly, there are real and life-threatening eating disorders that are yet another plague on our modern culture. Disorders like anorexia nervosa and bulimia require treatment and our serious attention.

This is not about those people. This is yet another assault on health-conscious consumers to set us apart from society and marginalize our efforts to maintain healthy, vital and productive lives. To declare healthy eaters as mentally unstable is part of the agenda to keep the status quo: the special interests will click along, buying labeling laws so manufacturers can continue to peddle the swill that robs us of our collective health.

According to The Guardian, mental health experts have even gone to the extremes of saying that the obsession about which foods are "good" and "bad" means that orthorexics can end up being malnourished. Again, in the case of other mental problems, like anorexia, this thinking can be just another excuse for not eating. But that's not who this article is talking about.

Let's try to follow the logic on this one, if you can call it that. Eating healthy foods that are beneficial to health can cause malnutrition. But the foods that every expert advises us to avoid: junk food, processed food, soda, etc. is assumed, by this line of thinking, to provide us with all the nutrients we need to build strong bodies and vital health.

This is, I must say, about as crazy a line of thought as I have ever heard. And I have heard some doozies. No wonder we have completely preventable diseases striking us down in record numbers. We are being told that eating healthy food is a sign of mental disease that can cause malnutrition.

What's really going on here? The truth shouldn't surprise you really. With all the discussion and focus on health and the role food plays in keeping or destroying our vitality, special interests, big pharma and conventional medicine have to figure out a way to marginalize healthy eating and living. How would they continue to thrive if everyone chose healthy food and did not need them as much?

They want us to stop questioning and rocking the boat. They want us to shut up and chow down on processed foods that make a lot of money for them and deliver nothing but disease and death to us. They prefer that we stop reading labels and asking what is in our food. They want to keep the dollars flowing from stuffed crust pizza, soda, candy, sugared cereals, burgers, fries and fried chicken in a bucket.

The best way to achieve that? Question the sanity of people looking at the health properties of the food they are eating. Tell society that people who think about what they put in their bodies are "obsessed" and "weird" -- maybe even sick. Broadcast that message loud and clear and things will stay just as they are. We'll stay sick, fat, weak, unable to compete on the world stage and reliant on pharmaceuticals to simulate health and wellness. We'll remain easy to manipulate because we lack the fortitude and clarity of thinking needed to create change. We won't question. We'll trudge along, compliant, numbed and docile, never questioning the actions of those in positions of authority who continue to lead them down the path of destruction with their food choices.

People that choose healthy food and exercise tend to think for themselves and question conventional wisdom as they see different results in their health. When you eat food with its nutrients intact, your mind and body are awakened to a different reality. You are excited by change and open to new ideas and possibilities. You are conscious of nutrition and work toward ensuring you get the nutrients you need.

This is very bad news for those who run our consumption-driven society. Blind over-consumption relies on ignorance and compliance combined with suggestibility. If we want people to keep buying stuff they don't need or even want, eating fast food and junk food and taking pills when they inevitably get sick, then they need to have their brains turned to mush. And there's nothing better for that job than processed food and television ads.

We live in a world where it's normal to be more like the walking dead than a fully functioning human, but that doesn't mean it's truly normal. We have had our health and our senses hijacked by food manufacturers who develop designer chemicals to keep us eating what they are selling. Dr. Dean Ornish said it best when he said that it's considered radical to ask people to dramatically change their diets and adopt a healthy, plant-based diet, but not considered radical to crack open their chests and perform heart surgery.

In the end, if you want to be alive, aware and in control of your health and destiny, eat more healthy foods that have been kissed by the sun, earth, air and water. Whole natural foods will give you most of the nutrients you need to function as a healthy, vital human. You will reduce your risk of lifestyle diseases; increase your energy; open your mind to reality without a chemical fog clouding your thinking and you will most likely be of normal weight.

In truth, healthy humans are the norm. It is our modern society and its obsession with profit that has compromised us to the point that illness is the new normal. And choosing health is crazy. Wow.

Health Nut

 
 
 

Follow Christina Pirello on Twitter: www.twitter.com/christinacooks

Healthy-eating disorder. Yes, you heard right, healthy-eating disorder. In its insatiable quest to create a mental problem or syndrome out of every human phenomenon and activity, the psychiatric indus...
Healthy-eating disorder. Yes, you heard right, healthy-eating disorder. In its insatiable quest to create a mental problem or syndrome out of every human phenomenon and activity, the psychiatric indus...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 70
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:36 AM on 07/12/2010
I found this article to be provocative in it's tone. The perspective reflects black or white thinking, much like what's found in someone who has an ED. As an ED specialist who has treated orthorexia, it is debilitating for someone to spend the entire day making their own soymilk from soybeans, grinding their own flour for bread and engaging in other rigid, isolating behaviors. It goes well beyond eating healthy. They can't go out with friends to a restaurant because they don't know what's in the food.
It can be tied to wanting to feel pure when the person is filled with self hatred and shame. It goes far beyond the food and is a symptom of a larger problem.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tsudopnem
I'm just this gal, y'know?
10:09 AM on 07/09/2010
Oh stop. The blogger is right. If I want to obsess and eat farmer's market local organic veggies and eliminate bad foods, I'm not a nut, even though I eat a lot of them!

I liked the term sickness nuts. Very cute.

And yes, I had real eating disorders when younger. Orthorexia is a cure, not a disorder.
11:04 AM on 07/09/2010
Eating healthy is a cure. Orthorexia is a disorder. The blogger has conflated the two. My niece went from being a healthy vegetarian to a healthy vegan to a person so obsessed with the food she put in her body that she would hardly eat anything for fear that it wasn't pure. It was undeniably obsessive, so it was way beyond "eating healthy," and it was not at all about body weight, so it was not anorexia. And it damaged her health. So yes, it is a disorder. I'm a health nut; I eat organic, assiduously avoid sugar and additives, and exercise religiously. But I'm not orthorexic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:47 PM on 07/09/2010
it is a sickness, my son drives me up the wall. I think i would rather chat with the jehovah's witness at door that listen to my son explain every thing I cook is toxic. This is annoying. every food container in the house is poisoning me. Please spare me from this kid.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrKND
04:24 PM on 07/08/2010
I think there's a distinction to be made, and it's not made here. Some people are obsessive about their diet, using words like 'cleansing' as if the answer to the question of what's ailing them is they are 'dirty' (what with the colon being filled with, well, refuse and system trash) whereas other people make healthy choices because they get the connection between what they eat and how they feel. Not every person that makes healthy choices has anxiety around those choices, and those who do may have a serious problem. I don't think taking a pill is the answer they need, either. Still, when you make this distinction, there's no need for healthy eaters to feel anxiety about a new psychiatric diagnosis.
12:49 PM on 07/08/2010
It's people like this blogger that make it difficult for people like me to not only find treatment in our society, but to not feel ashamed for the mental disorders I have suffered from since I was a child. I would love for this blogger to know what it feels like to deal with a serious anxiety disorder that takes constant work to overcome. And if it weren't for the drugs that the evil 'Big Pharma' developed over the years, I wouldn't be able to leave my house.

Part of my anxiety disorder involves issues with eating. I can totally understand how someone could fixate on certain 'healthy' foods to a point where they are obsessive and their eating habits are disordered. This ignorant blogger shouldn't be so dismissive to these kinds of behaviors. Maybe she should look at her own issues and insecurities (the ones that made her write this blog) and leave the rest of us alone.
12:20 PM on 07/08/2010
A small language correction, Ms. Pirello: "orthorexia nervosa" is actually a combination of Greek and Latin.

"Ortho" and "orexis" coming from Greek to mean "correct eating"; "Nervosa" coming from Latin to mean "nervous," as you have stated in your article.
photo
chaya
Another proud veteran
11:16 AM on 07/08/2010
Oh, please. Can we all just stop with the "war" rhetoric? Can we all just stop being victims for awhile? I thought the right-wingers were the only ones doing this. Now it's spreading to rich white people who eat "natural and whole foods"?

No, there is no "War against health nuts."
photo
farmilyman
everything is illusion
05:14 AM on 07/08/2010
There is a difference between being an informed eater and having fear and anxiety. The fear and anxiety alone will make you sick regardless of what you eat.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
organicconnect
01:20 AM on 07/08/2010
Psychiatry has gone out of its way to define "behaviors" that are "unhealthy" to an extreme that would be comical if it wasn't so sick in itself. This is from a profession that by its own admission cannot diagnose or cure mental illness. But they can sure prescribe drugs for them. The definitions of idiotic "illnesses" in the DSM are there ONLY so they can be billed for and prescribe addictive (profitable) drugs. They are made up by a committee, not based on any research or science at all. Don't take my word for it. A historian of psychiatry recently published a far more effective condemnation of the marriage between psychiatry and drugs in the Lancet: http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736%2810%2960532-6/fulltext
09:23 AM on 07/08/2010
The pharmaceutical industry has been creating "drugs" for no specific disease and than having conferences, to vote by committee, what battery of symptoms could be named a disease and which drug that has already been made can be said to alleviate the symptoms of the disease. Think about PMS & PMDD. We know PMS is real, now there is a PMDD that's worse than PMS? Really? Hmmm. Or is this just another hook into the wallets of consumers to pay for drugs that are sitting around in a lab. Really, what's the difference between the two?
08:27 AM on 07/10/2010
Be specific please. Links to academic articles about the conference, PMS or PMDD?
03:26 AM on 07/10/2010
I thought you had linked to an academic article. lol (to myself)
11:30 PM on 07/07/2010
I think the author is a little off in her comprehension of orthorexia nervosa. Orthorexia nervosa, indicates an unhealthy obsession with eating only pure healthy food. The operational word is unhealthy obsession. Read the story of Kate Finn in her own words at:Finding balance between the extremes of denial and indulgence. http://www.beyondveg.com/finn-k/bio/finn-k-bio-1a.shtml who subsequently died from Orthorexia nervosa. There is another article at this link with a picture of her shortly before she died. Orthorexia: Obsessing Over Health Food: http://abcnews.go.com/Health/Stossel/story?id=5735592&page=4. I've read several articles by Dr. Steven Bratman and he isn't talking about "health food junkies or people who have healthy eating habits and lifestyles. He's talking about a psychiatric disorder equivalent to anorexia and equally as dangerous. If you don't believe this, go to the link and take a look at Kate Finn. It's not a recognized mental disorder but what makes it real-people suffering from it and dying or a few paragraphs in a book.
09:39 AM on 07/08/2010
I wanted to thank you for your reply Danchi, I followed your links and while I agree that there's nothing inherently wrong with following a healthy lifestyle…as a matter of fact I'm currently "obsessing" about it. I do, worry about it…and I do think that many of us out here are concerned to the point of either inaction, or depression or obsession…sometimes we take our stances too far. I feel that on the whole something BIG must be done to fix our food industry/agribusiness…but, until it is shaken to the core we must find a balance, a workable means to live healthfully, do our part to live and eat responsibly. Did any of these posters catch Mark Bittman on On Point? One step at a time…do what you can. http://www.onpointradio.org/2010/07/mark-bittman-eating
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RedDogBear
10:28 AM on 07/08/2010
I always like to check out the site that something is hosted on. In the case of this article its hosted on the site Beyond Vegeterianism http://www.beyondveg.com/ This site is nothing but a bunch of anti-vegan propaganda. It makes me question the motives and authenticity of the article.

BTW, I'm not a vegan nor a vegetarian. I eat mostly vegetarian, some fish, and will eat meat a few times a year.
11:51 AM on 07/08/2010
Also a good point! Can't seem to do enough "due diligence"…always d@mned if you do, d@mned if you don't apparently. Thanks. Once-upon-a-time I was a vegetarian…and I miss those habits actually…getting back to them is verrrry hard once you've left 'em.
03:45 PM on 07/08/2010
There are two sites listed. Did you go to both sites? Or are you basing your objections to the one website? You can also go to a search engine, type in Kate Finn and get many hits on her story. This is not propganda for either side. It's an example of what how the author of this article has skewed perception as to what "orthorexia nervosa" is. On the Beyond Vegeterianism website you don't need to read the entire website, just the article in reference to Kate Finn. The other is a link from ABC News. Don't read more into the motivation for providing the two links.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
booki
06:48 PM on 07/07/2010
i have always been a "health nut, "
aware of everything that i put in my mouth.
what's wrong w/ that?
11:33 PM on 07/07/2010
NOTHING. It's called using your brain and common sense!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RedDogBear
10:33 AM on 07/08/2010
You are sick, you need to be medicated right away. Yes, I'm being sarcastic. The fact that such people are termed "health nuts" is itself a sign of how distorted our culture is.

BTW, I'm more of a health nut wanna be. I eat healthier than most Americans but that's not saying much, I still drink things like diet soda, etc.

One last thing, the more I learn about our food the more critical I think it is for people to be "health nuts" for their long term health, especially younger people. Most of our meat is shot full of hormones and anti-biotics, not to mention the way its prepared is so inhuman that no ethical person who knows can't be repulsed by it. But now even most fish is contaminated with chemicals such as mercury, especially things I used to eat a lot of like Tuna. And even veggies may be GMO with who knows what long term side effects not to mention all the chemicals used on non-organics.

You are one of the few smart ones, don't let anyone tell you otherwise.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ldillworth
05:37 PM on 07/07/2010
this article is annoying. "methinks the lady doth protest too much". being keenly interested and invested in your health is absolutely a good thing. but "orthorexia" refers to those with an unhealthy OBSESSION, not every person who is invested in a healthy lifestyle.
08:59 AM on 07/08/2010
Exactly. It appears this woman won't let rational thought get in the way of her agenda.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RedDogBear
10:35 AM on 07/08/2010
Well what you just said is not a rational rebuttal to anything she said its an ad hominem attack. If there is some bit of irrationality in the article please point it out. She made a lot of sense to me.
05:32 PM on 07/07/2010
"For instance, an orthorexic may eliminate sugar, salt, caffeine, alcohol, wheat, gluten, yeast, soy products, corn, meat and/or dairy products from their diets. And that's just the beginning, according to experts. These same "whackos" may also avoid foods that contain pesticides, herbicides, growth hormones, steroids or anything artificial."

Proud to be an orthorexic.
10:02 AM on 07/08/2010
Be aware of the fact that total elimination of salt from one's diet is life threatening. (elimination should not be confused with reduced intake).
photo
Nonyabizz
Facts are really just a liberal plot
12:47 PM on 07/08/2010
Incorrect. There is enough sodium inherent in whole foods. Added salt is never required.
12:48 PM on 07/08/2010
You're right. I actually haven't eliminated salt but use it in moderation and use a healthier Himalayan crystal salt which contains the full spectrum of 84 minerals and trace elements. Processed salt has 1 mineral in it. Iodine. So for me it's really about choosing the healthier foods and reducing or eliminating the bad foods.
04:58 PM on 07/07/2010
There a lots of things that are good in moderation but bad excess.

I don't know of any reason, in principle, that "healthy eating" couldn't be one them.

Then again, common sense makes for boring prose.
04:53 PM on 07/07/2010
This seems to misrepresent Orthorexia Nervosa. For one it is not recognized as a mental disorder in any of the medical manuals ( ICD-10 or the DSM-IV, neither is it part of the proposed revision of this manual, the DSM-5). Furthermore, the diagnosis of Orthorexia Nervosa is far more involved than just "nervous about correct eating". It was proposed to distinguish one with Anorexia Nervosa, from an individual who can be just as emaciated and calorie restrictive but has a different underlying motivation for their eating habits. While an anorexic wants to lose weight, an orthorexic does not desire to become thin but wants to feel pure, healthy and natural. While it is not inherently bad to desire this feeling, if combined with a Obsessive Compulsive tendencies and some extremely restrictive beliefs about what is "healthy", it can severely restrict caloric intake and intake of essential amino acids and vitamins to point of being life threatening. I consider myself a health nut but I am no where near this diagnosis.

P.S. Although I haven't found a treatment for it. I would suspect it has a wide range of treatment options like other eating disorders such as anorexia. This is not just limited to pharmaceuticals (like ones used to treat related conditions like OCD), but includes supplementation (vitamins and amino acids), psychotherapy and different types of cognitive behavioral therapy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sheldon101
sheldon101blog.blogspot.com Wakefield transcripts
06:31 PM on 07/07/2010
First fan. You might have some other interesting things to say, that I might be interested in.
03:34 PM on 07/07/2010
There they go, once again trying to sell a “normal life†via pharmaceutical drugs. Working on getting another group of long-term patients. Where is this ok & normal?

Psych drugs because I am too healthy in my choices? Yes, some may become obsessive, because they are one that obsesses. How about we treat the real issues in our country!?!

I'd rather be an educated & happy “health nut†than a poorly eating & depressed “couch potato†that has to eventually depend on prescriptions for the rest of their life because they are consuming foods; produced for the purpose of quantity ($$$) not quality which in turns contributes to a deteriorating lifestyle. Indulging in unhappiness induced by lack of exercise & artificial additives, spending lengthy times with family members in places of illness & sadness vs. places of life, such as the park, botanical gardens or the aquarium. Feeling as though they can not breathe, always tired and that there is never a silver lining.

Everything is connected!

We all have choices & I chose to make a conscious one:) The truth always comes to the light and the truth is being shown to the US that poor lifestyle choices are being made, we are seeing it in the rising death toll of food related diseases.

Thank you for bringing attention to the facts and displaying the conscious oblivion clearly! Those that are aware must continue with their love & joy of knowing they are living a life of their own.