More

Christine Escobar

Christine Escobar

Posted: April 14, 2008 02:08 PM

On citizen journalists and the validity of accounts


The fireball that has erupted over a comment made at a fund raiser has knocked me off my feet. Over the past few days, what amounts to a standard, though creatively written account of another political event/fund raiser by a citizen journalist has become the fuel for an insane amount of intolerance described here that is almost as hateful as the thinking Barack Obama is being labeled for with his remarks on economically disadvantaged small-town people.

Do I need to get into all the reasons why one might expect a man who has campaigned for last 15 months or so all over the U.S. to know better than to phrase his remarks as such? Well, that is not where I'm headed, and quite frankly, I say this with all honesty, it often falls on deaf ears. However, I do intend to speak out for my citizen journalist colleague, Mayhill Fowler, with whom I, and a number of other contributors, have written on The Huffington Post's Off the Bus since June of last year.

Mayhill, as far as I have known, is unabashedly supportive of Obama. She also has very keen eyes and ears as her writing attests. She is very artful at describing the scene and the atmosphere as well as the reaction she experiences at campaign events. Over the last several months, I have read her many posts, of which a vast majority are favorable to Obama's campaign efforts. And I have followed with a slight sort of envy her outright dedication to covering the campaigns, which isn't always possible when you have young children under foot as I do.

Therefore, I am appalled at the backlash she has received for having written her account of this expensive San Francisco fund raiser. I have attended numerous campaign events and, throughout my years training as a journalist, I've covered events, people, issues I did and did not care about, much as a citizen journalist or any journalist for that matter would cover. Some were favorable to an idea or candidate I supported, some were critical. But, all were written from the truth as I believe Mayhill's account was written.

What I don't understand is how ordinary Americans can attack the work of a citizen journalist, who is more a person like they are than is any big name paid reporter at any big news operation anywhere.

The value in the citizen journalist's account is that, unlike the paid reporter, they work for free. They are beholden to no one but themselves. And therefore, they are under no obligation to write, cover or opine about subjects but from their own unique perspective.

We must remember the amount of varying viewpoints, accounts, thoughts and questions citizen journalists may pose is the very cornerstone to the idea a free press, most crucial in this age of corporate controlled big media.

Let us not become so embedded in our support of a candidate at the expense of free thought and dissent that we forget the underlying foundation that allows our candidate his or her platform in the first place.


Follow Christine Escobar on Twitter: www.twitter.com/greenparentchgo

The fireball that has erupted over a comment made at a fund raiser has knocked me off my feet. Over the past few days, what amounts to a standard, though creatively written account of another politica...
The fireball that has erupted over a comment made at a fund raiser has knocked me off my feet. Over the past few days, what amounts to a standard, though creatively written account of another politica...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:38 PM on 04/16/2008
What Fowler (apt name) did was deceitful and unethical. She supposeably went to the fundraiser, which was off limits to the press, as an Obama supporter. But SHE IS PRESS, whether she works for free or not. Note her title "Citizen JOURNALIST." She had no ethical business being at the fundraiser as a journalist. I will no longer read her posts. As far as I am concerned, she is now a liar and a cheater.
09:51 PM on 04/14/2008
If you think that Mayhill Fowler is "unabashedly supportive' of Obama, then you like Jay Rosen and others on the HuffPo editorial staff have not bothered to vet Ms. Fowler. Ms. Fowler states in her own blog that she is likely to vote for Clinton. As well, I wonder if there has been a careful reading of Ms. Fowler's posts on HuffPo, it has been evident from these posts and the comments that they have elicited that Ms. Fowler was problematic as an objective commenter. Now be clear objectivity is not necessary; however, the problem with Fowler's post is the lack of transparency---pretending to be an Obama supporter while she has another agenda!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:34 PM on 04/14/2008
I disagree, fine let the lady write but to covertly tape Obama at a fund raiser when she knew the press was not allowed and then claim ignorance is unethical.
I would say the same thing, no matter who it was.
You all can try and stick up for her but this lady knew exactly what she was doing and to portray her as an Obama supporter is pathetic at best. She is no more an Obama supporter then I am a Bu$h fan.
I hope she gets kicked off the bus and the Obama campaign keeps her at arms length.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
slank
08:36 PM on 04/14/2008
Mayhill Fowler wrote a biased account without even approaching something like journalism in her blog. She certainly has the absolute right to do so but she also has put her opinions and judgments out there and she is being judged and hearing the opinion of others who also have that right. She is offering her opinion every chance she gets on MSM so please do not tell me she doesn't deserve some criticism, she is having a blast with this and all it was is a "gotcha" piece.