More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Coleen Rowley

GET UPDATES FROM Coleen Rowley
 

Celebrating Spiritual Death On Black Friday

Posted: 11/25/11 02:12 PM ET

How many remember that this "Black Friday" marks the 10th anniversary of George Bush's famous presidential advisory just after 9/11 for citizens to do their patriotic duty by pushing their worries aside and going shopping? The idea of asking the American people to make sacrifices in the face of the coming "War on Terror" was too '70s, too Jimmy Carter.

The 2001 attacks were quickly seized upon by hard-core propagandists and "shock doctrine" advocates as the "new Pearl Harbor," sparking a decade of blatant social-psychological manipulation. The media onslaught has proved sadly effective in getting Americans to support the ongoing series of bloody and bankrupting wars and to overlook the root causes of this violence in today's world.

By incessantly pushing on the emotional hot-buttons of fear, hate, greed, false pride and blind loyalty (in that order), warmongers and flim-flam men have, since time immemorial, sought to bring out the worst in human beings. Up to now the propaganda has worked, persuading most Americans to accept with minimal visible coercion the enormous corruption and cruelty at the heart of the corporate-military-industrial-congressional-media complex.

I'm embarrassed to admit that I played a small role back in late October 2001 in stoking the national shopping addiction, which worked so well to distract the American citizenry from looking closely at 9/11. At that time, the officially endorsed shopping compulsion served to prevent people from asking questions about how and why the attacks had occurred, and from paying full attention to the horrendously wrongheaded initial responses. These included the mass roundup of innocents; the establishment of indefinite, due process-free, Kafkaesque detention zones at Guantanamo and elsewhere; and the initial conspiracy to go to the "dark side" and resort to systematic torture -- all of which served to morally bankrupt the United States.

At that time, Minnesota's Mall of America boasted of being the largest shopping complex in the world. Soon after 9/11, its stores, like others around the country, fell victim to the "Halloween terrorist threat hoax," which mall owners feared, would scare off would-be shoppers. And so, as our FBI office spokesperson, I dutifully participated in a hastily organized press conference instigated by the Mall. I merely spoke the truth at the press conference, assuring the gathered media that the warning that terrorists would target malls in the United States was just a hollow rumor that had gone viral, without any real evidence or intelligence behind it.

However, now that I see how American citizens are so routinely manipulated, I regret having contributed even in this small way to encouraging mindless consumption, which Bush, Rove and others pushed to keep people from questioning what they were doing. Stoking people's addiction to shopping is primarily a function of the "greed button," but the tactic also connects to the human frailties of indifference, complacency, false pride and blind loyalty.

If one Googles images of "Black Friday" and "shop until you drop," one finds numerous glossy ads and artistic renderings of pretty women carrying colorful packages and sacks.

Actual photos of hyped-up throngs of shoppers waiting to rush through store doors intermingle with these cute shopper images. It makes us all want to feel the high that comes with buying mostly worthless stuff and joining in this materialist orgy.

2011-11-25-blackfridaysafeshoppingweb.jpg
2011-11-25-blackfridayrushweb.jpg
The malls have become like churches, desperately preaching an empty prosperity theology, which holds that purchasing consumer goods made in foreign sweatshops somehow demonstrates God's blessing on American exceptionalism. Only a few dissidents, such as the Church of Stop Shopping Gospel Choir, are able to see that the shopping centers in their glitzy falsity mask true economic despair and spiritual poverty. American consumers largely fail to appreciate the immense irony in America's massive decline in power accompanying their conversion to consumerism. U.S. foreign policy in the post WWII period aimed at essentially enforcing a global system in which the Western powers under American leadership would maintain global dominance. What this essentially meant was being in control of the world's resources at the expense of non-Western nations. This fundamental objective of U.S. foreign policy in the post-war period was candidly admitted in a top-secret report written by then-head of the State Department policy planning staff George Kennan, who wrote in February 1948:

"We have about 50 per cent of the world's wealth, but only 6.3 per cent of its population... Our real task in the coming period is to maintain this position of disparity... To do so we will have to dispense with all sentimentality and day-dreaming... We need not deceive ourselves that we can afford the luxury of altruism... We should cease to talk about vague, unreal objectives such as human rights, the raising of living standards, and democratization. The day is not far off when we will have to deal in straight power concepts."


Reality, however, is going in the opposite direction of the 1948 plans. In 2000, the U.S. controlled 31 percent of the world economy; by 2008, that figure had fallen to 23 percent and, according to the International Monetary Fund, the projection for 2013 is 21 percent. In the past decade, the United States has lost one-third of its economic wealth or, put another way, since 2000, the U.S. has lost nearly a third of its relative power in international politics while China's has doubled and Russia's has tripled. According to economic experts, this decline represents the largest drop in the history books. Our international decline was well under way before the economic downturn of 2008, which further weakened US influence. Whether you believe in "reap what you sow" or what the CIA terms "blowback," the costly Iraq war, growing government debt and myriad unwise decisions resulting in economic weakness have cost the U.S. real power in today's world.

In fact, as we face individual and national bankruptcy, the malls have become for many Americans more a place to merely wander and lust than to actually buy. Large segments of the population have lost their jobs, health insurance and homes, and are so deeply in debt that when they surrender to the advertising-bred consumerist urge, they can only window shop, their credit cards rejected if they attempt to buy much of the stuff on display.

Martin Luther King Jr. warned that a country in continuous war approaches spiritual death. I wonder if he realized that this extinction would play out in the nation's shopping malls as, like the Romans, we distract ourselves with bread and circuses from the crimes and catastrophes that surround us, and the responsibilities we avoid.


(By Coleen Rowley with editing assistance from Hugh Iglarsh. Rowley is a retired FBI agent and former Minneapolis Division Legal Counsel, also a 9-11 whistleblower. She joined the Church of Stop Shopping before it even was formed. Hugh Iglarsh is a writer/editor/citizen based in Chicago.)

 
How many remember that this "Black Friday" marks the 10th anniversary of George Bush's famous presidential advisory just after 9/11 for citizens to do their patriotic duty by pushing their worries asi...
How many remember that this "Black Friday" marks the 10th anniversary of George Bush's famous presidential advisory just after 9/11 for citizens to do their patriotic duty by pushing their worries asi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 104
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:41 AM on 11/28/2011
People should be preparing for their lives after they leave this world, because this life is short and very temporary. It's preparation time for eternity and where do you want to spend it. When you see how people act with mob mentalities on days like black Friday, you can see that they only care about this world and not the next. They worship things and money and don't even know what this holiday is supposed to be about. Try living your life for Jesus and stop doing what satan tells you. Matthew 6:19-21 Lay not up for yourselves treasures upon earth, where moth and rust doth corrupt, and where thieves break through and steal:

20 But lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust doth corrupt, and where thieves do not break through nor steal:

21For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.
10:35 AM on 11/27/2011
Coleen: See how many people liked your article? More...more...more!
07:38 PM on 11/26/2011
It's a hard hitting blog, thanks Coleen. "Mindless consumption" seems the sum total of what our country's been involved in in the last 5-10 years or so, whether it's warfare, our elected officials, advertising, commercial culture, consumerism, etc.

I keep thinking the big question Americans need to ask ourselves going into the 21st century is what kind of country do we want to be, especially since we already know what has failed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrockskk
01:31 PM on 11/26/2011
No one's forcing anyone to shop.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aesops
10:19 PM on 11/26/2011
All the more depressing then isn't it?
photo
MimiK
living in dramatic times
02:19 PM on 11/27/2011
This is a questionable point; cognitive psychologists are paid many hundreds of thousands to explain to corporations how to manipulate the human mind in advertising, as first documented (to my knowledge) in a book by Susan Linn from Harvard.

So, while none of us are 'forced' to shop, it is not inflammatory, but hard, cold fact that our brains are expertly manipulated to make us want to.
photo
The Ben Bernanke
AMI (American Monetary Institute)
10:19 AM on 11/26/2011
Great article
09:43 AM on 11/26/2011
I'm reminded of the long queues in Moscow stores and dark sullen look of total surrender on their sad pathetic faces. That is precisely what we need.
03:50 PM on 11/26/2011
What we need, or where we're headed?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
Give peace a chance
09:43 AM on 11/26/2011
And they're beating the drum for Iran. Seems to be no end to military action.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
merrylander
Be Here Now
09:21 AM on 11/26/2011
Excellent article.
photo
WilliamBradford
Veritas vos Liberabit
09:07 AM on 11/26/2011
What complete drivel.

After the terrorist attacks of 9-11, and the uncertainty that followed, our economy could have fallen quickly into chaos. This would have been the worst result possible, and would have emboldened our enemies - giving them even more about which to celebrate. President Bush encouraged Americans to continue to drive the economy as they normally would to prove that we would not be defeated by these vicious attack. This was the right and necessary response.

We are indeed losing relative economic power in the world. But the key word is "relative". Clearly math skills are not a requirement for "special agents". Just because our percentage of the world's economic activity is shrinking does not mean we are losing ground. The world economy is growing and a number of countries that recently joined the modern age are growing faster than we are. That is a threat, but it is not because of our decline. The pie is getting bigger and our slice is growing somewhat more slowly.

It's a strange that the author can criticize economic activity and then bemoan our slow economic growth in the same article. This is very similar to the pointless confusion of the "occupiers".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tom Pumroy
practical dreamer-artist Man Ray
02:00 PM on 11/26/2011
They won’t print my reply to your comment so I had to flag you; I had no other means of letting you know what I thought about it.
09:00 PM on 11/26/2011
William the pie is the same size. That pie is this planet and there is a limited amount to go round. Money is the secondary resource. GWB probably did have good intentions sending everyone shopping after 9/11, but GWB was wrong about many other decisions, the Iraq war as the most obvious (deregulation, the next) But the biggest mistake of all leaders is neglect to act on climate science. By now we could have been independent of oil! We cannot return to our full-employment days unless we create a new industry and here it is right on our doorstep - green tech. American ought to capture this industry. We have the highest brain capital, a well-structured financial system and a willing workforce (still). Things tend to change quickly so let's not waste this glaring opportunity to lead the world in finding alternative, cheap, clean and abundant energy and all the industries that that would give birth to. America could be right on the cusp of becoming great again, a country that other nations respect. But this time, it will be by the attention and conviction of the masses, not only their shopping. With our collective and creative will we can change our trajectory tomorrow. But we need the 99% on board. If you want America to succeed you must know that these in power now are not the ones to do it. Carp diem!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hans Bickel
Visionary
11:34 PM on 11/26/2011
Hello Credence, worked at the Energy Department in Washington, D.C. in the policy and planning thinktank when there were few "green" voices around and watched helplessly as the green self-sufficiency initiatives ordered by Jimmy Carter (a very underrated President that was sabotaged by the "complex") were discarded by the new Reagan-Bush team in favor of the same old blood of the earth, oil based policies that appeased their oil buddies and still rule. We were able to stop the nuclear initiative though that saved us from the kind of disaster seen recently in Japan that didn't heed our advice. So if you're in favor of going green, that's excellent, but do you know that going vegetarian is the single most potent act each of us can take "to halt the destruction of our environment and preserve our natural resources." (John Robbins/Diet for a New America)

This conclusion is backed by the UN Food and Agriculture Organization, Audubon Society, Greenpeace, and Worldwatch Institute, to name a few. If half of Americans would back this initiative America would be the world leader again, guaranteed. Dr. Hans
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
My life is microbiodegradable.
08:43 AM on 11/26/2011
It is easy to see these crowds and feel that the whole country is out there acting like starving chickens pouncing on a pile of corn. It's the 24 hour coverage and the hype that convinces people that this is so. Even with full malls, it's a small percentage of the population. In my social group, I know of only one family that is braving the crowds. She says it's a fun way to get together with her sister. I truly don't see the big difference between this and the fondly looked back on crowded stores the third week in December of my childhood. The competition between stores and malls for a limited dollar has spread and fueled a competitive zeitgeist among the shoppers. However, I still maintain it's a small number in proportion to the entire population of the US. If stores priced things properly to start with, people wouldn't be looking for that bargain. The stores overprice the items in order to still make a profit when they offer "deep discounts". Some fall for it others do not. It is not the end of America. It's an evolution, perhaps a devolution to some, of one element in our society. Culture is and always has been in a constant state of flux. I don't fall for the happy images of the advertisements around the holidays. I also don't fall for the coverage that says this is what all Americans do. A lot of us don't fit the character.
08:25 AM on 11/26/2011
Ban "Black Friday." One nice fellow even brought his pistol to the event. This has gone far enough. ,
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aesops
10:30 PM on 11/26/2011
Black Friday is just a mirror held up to the American people's illusions about themselves. The vision is unpalatable, but pretty accurate.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Bellanova
I'm nobody. Who are you?
08:22 AM on 11/26/2011
What an excellent post. Coleen. Indeed, one of the best.

Looking forward to many more.
07:56 AM on 11/26/2011
I agree with Ms. Rowley that our insipid shopping economy is causing spiritual death but I don't read in her article or in any of the comments what we could do about it. Really, we couldn't just shut down the malls and quit shopping as many of the writers here suggest. Where would all of the store employees work? Wouldn't there be even more unemployment and poverty without these usually low-paying retail jobs? At least they are jobs! I really hate this economy, too, and believe me I've tried to buck it but have been forced to work at many horrible clerking jobs in my life. After all, we've got to be able to pay for somewhere to live, food, etc. What can we do?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tom Pumroy
practical dreamer-artist Man Ray
08:50 AM on 11/26/2011
Here is an answer from the comments:

blind melon scayf
. . . a revolution of consciousness? What a monumentally great idea.

spinotter11
I can't see anything else that can save us, do you?
photo
Passenger57
Keeping Calm And Carrying On...
07:39 AM on 11/26/2011
Awesome article...
GHarry
Kitty wrangler
07:05 AM on 11/26/2011
Someday the truth about the Iraq War will come out -- that it was the most sophisticated criminal conspiracy in history, and spectacularly successful. Literally hundreds of billions were dollars have been stolen or misdirected, new bureaucratic empires -- mostly unnecessary -- have risen and still flourish today, America's national security and economy have been severely damaged, and the people responsible for all that not only went unpunished but are still lionized in some Washington circles as very fine citizens indeed. America's national security situation today is nothing short of surrealistic.