iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Craig Kanalley

Craig Kanalley

Posted: June 13, 2010 06:29 PM

Vuvuzela Ban? A Case for Vuvuzelas to Keep Blowing at World Cup 2010 (VIDEO, POLL)

What's Your Reaction:

The latest World Cup buzz has to do with something off the field, that ongoing buzzing reverberating the stadiums: the vuvuzelas.

They're all the rage these days, rage in the most literal sense for some, and Twitter can't stop talking about them, a Trending Topic as I write this.

Calls are mounting: Is it time to ban them?

Let's start with the cons. These South African horns drown out essentially all noise in the stadium, and they're impossible to miss on television broadcasts. Some rightly say they fail to reflect the ebbs and flows of the game.

FIFA considered banning the vuvuzelas leading up to the World Cup, worried they could be used as weapons or businesses could stamp ads on them, but ultimately didn't. However, countless players, broadcasters, and TV viewers have been complaining since the tournament began, and now word is they could be banned yet.

Besides the complaints, there are concerns they can result in hearing loss, and word is they can trumpet up to 127 decibels. So there are risks involved.

But hold on. The vuvuzela is all about South African pride. It has become a huge part of the country's identity and it has united a people. It's not time to silence the noisemaker.

Said one man, 26-year-old Hendrik Maharala of Johannesburg: "I feel like an African when I blow the vuvuzela."

Said a woman, 21-year-old Jessica Dyrand: "I love the noise."

Said another South African, 23-year-old Sazi Mhlwaitka: "It's our way to motivate players, to express happiness and how do you feel in the stadium."

It's hard to rip that passion out of these fans, especially since some 650,000 vuvuzelas have been sold for this World Cup. And they actually provide for one amazing and unique atmosphere, so it could all depend on your point of view.

Just look at these people and the great time they are having:

Are we seriously considering taking the vuvuzelas away from them?

Yahoo's Ryan Bailey may have said it best here:

A ban would rob the tournament of part of its cultural identity, leaving thousands of locals perplexed: could you imagine being told by an international body that you could no longer drink beer at American football games, or fall asleep during baseball? The South Africans wouldn't take too kindly to having a national institution removed.

Let the vuvuzelas resound. That's my take -- what's yours?

UPDATE (June 14, 2010): World Cup officials said today the vuvuzelas will NOT be banned.

 

Follow Craig Kanalley on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ckanal

The latest World Cup buzz has to do with something off the field, that ongoing buzzing reverberating the stadiums: the vuvuzelas. They're all the rage these days, rage in the most literal sense for...
The latest World Cup buzz has to do with something off the field, that ongoing buzzing reverberating the stadiums: the vuvuzelas. They're all the rage these days, rage in the most literal sense for...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 244
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
12:43 PM on 06/21/2010
Cultural Icon? They were invented by a toy company in 2001... awful shallow culture.. I guess the American baseball drinking helmets qualify as cultural icons..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chuck prebys
11:49 PM on 06/16/2010
Most irritating sound ever.
Ban them at the games.....let them blast away out in the streets.
I couldn't care less if it's an "African Tradition", dating way back to the early 1990's.
It's already a tradition that's lasted 20 years too long.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pecosdog
this sht writes itself
07:31 PM on 06/16/2010
So that is what that cicada sound is. Thanks for the info, I had been wondering. I hate cicadas. Ban it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:31 PM on 06/16/2010
It's strange, because I am quite noise intolerant, that the vuvuzelas do not bother me at all... I get really bothered by loud music from a passing car, or someone yelling into their cell phone, but this noise doesn't bother me at all. I'm just enjoying the spectacle, hearing new national anthems, and the vuvuzelas are just part of an immersive experience into a foreign land.

If you can will yourself to accept them, you will have changed your brain a little bit, and learned to be more tolerant and less angry - and you will be able to just enjoy the Cup. After all, you can't stop it, so that is the only real alternative.
Gasparilla
there is no clean coal
01:07 PM on 06/16/2010
These horns say everything that needs to be said about soccer. There is nothing going on so people spend the whole game blowing some annoying horn.
07:32 AM on 06/16/2010
Dull and dumb sounding horns only echo the game itself.
Who cares?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
GordonNYC
Not for Sale
10:54 PM on 06/15/2010
Using horns at a futbol game is not limited to South Africa, it is used througout the world including South America, it's here to stay. It adds a primal feeling and excitement to the game. It's a unifying expression.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:39 PM on 06/15/2010
Well Craig, another person African-born French captain Patrice Evra cited their negative effect on the most important thing of all...the play during the matches.

I know some people think they look oh so 'tolerant' by blindly supporting something because of its alleged cultural import, but being part of a world event like the football World Cup means been a good host, meaning polite and considerate of others. Mindlessly blowing a horn incessantly is neither.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tedwilliamshead
11:48 AM on 06/15/2010
The Vuvuzela Monologues with The Vuvuzela Game and User Manual for the Vuvuzela - http://tedwilliamshead.com/2010/06/15/vuvuzela-mania/
12:36 AM on 06/15/2010
I don't know what you guys are complaining about. If you don't like it then don't watch it. Use that finger and change that dial.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:41 PM on 06/15/2010
What an arrogant position. How dare we expect the voluntary hosts of a worldwide event to have some basic courtesy, the courtesy they showed when vuvuzelas were rightful banned from rugby matches in ZA a year ago?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spassmeister
to thine own self be true
07:56 PM on 06/14/2010
look - it's nothing personal or racial. please. it's a noise produced by a horn that became a fad sometime in the past 10 years and it's their decision to make. the fact that it sounds like a "test of the emergency broadcast system" being run during the world cup is, apparently, not an issue to the fans in the stadium, most of whom seem to enjoy it.

it is nearly impossible for many of us to keep the audio on during the game as a result, but I think we can live with that. It's sort of a shame for SA as this sort of adds a needless dimension to this globally viewed event.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:44 PM on 06/15/2010
"apparently, not an issue to the fans in the stadium, most of whom seem to enjoy it. "

Is that why thousands of complaints have been received? People may well be enjoying the matches, but that does not mean they like the bloody vuvzelas.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stereolabb
06:28 PM on 06/14/2010
These things are hideous, obnoxious and disgusting. Of course they should be banned.
06:02 PM on 06/14/2010
One thing we looked forward to in Africa’s first World Cup was the wonderful music of South Africa!

But where is it?

If the people sing in the stands, we do not hear it.

If the people are silenced by the vuvuzelas, that would be a crime borne out of a troubled past.

If the people lose their hearing because of the buzzing of the plastic bees, what is accomplished out of that?

It is not too late for the world to hear the beautiful music of South Africa. I hope that this tremendous, special opportunity will not continue to go wasted.
05:56 PM on 06/14/2010
The vuvuzelas are ruining the experience for the people visiting SA. If they don't ban them, SA (or anywhere in Africa) will never get the World Cup or Olympics again. SA has only had these cheap plastic trumpets for 10 years, so don't get fooled into thinking that it is part of their history or culture. All noise makers are usually banned from sporting events. What if they used fog horns or megaphones instead? Would you still defend their usage? The people blowing them just like making loud noises and enjoy annoying the people visiting their country. Ban the vuvuzela now and save some face.
04:00 PM on 06/14/2010
Since when has a kids toy horn made in China been considered a cultural identity or heritage? You have got to be kidding me. This stupid horn is one of the most annoying things I have ever heard at a sporting event. This should be a lesson to any other sports governing body that considers South Africa for an event. These idiots will annoy anybody and everybody they can.