More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dalia Mogahed

Dalia Mogahed

Posted: August 11, 2010 06:16 AM

Muslim Faith: Function Over Form


Editor's Note: Huffington Post Religion has launched a scripture commentary/reflection series, which will bring together leading voices from different religious traditions to offer their wisdom on selected religious texts. We are pleased to announce a series of reflections for the Holy Month of Ramadan featuring posts by HM Queen Noor, Dalia Mogahed, Eboo Patel, Kabir Helminski, and Rami Nashashibi. They will all be reflecting on a passage from the Qur'an, Sura 2:177, which appears below. Last month we featured Christian reflections on the Gospel by Rev. Jim Wallis, Dr. Serene Jones, Dr. Emilie Townes, Sister Joan Chittister, and Rev. James Martin, S.J. Coming in September we will feature Jewish commentaries for the High Holidays and in October Hindu commentary for Diwali. We hope all readers, Muslim and non-Muslim, will gain wisdom from the insights of our writers on the Holy Qur'an:

True piety does not consist in turning your faces towards the east or the west -- but truly pious is he who believes in God, and the Last Day; and the angels, and revelation, and the prophets; and spends his substance -- however much he himself may cherish -- it -- upon his near of kin, and the orphans, and the needy, and the wayfarer, and the beggars, and for the freeing of human beings from bondage; and is constant in prayer, and renders the purifying dues; and [truly pious are] they who keep their promises whenever they promise, and are patient in misfortune and hardship and in time of peril: it is they that have proved themselves true, and it is they, they who are conscious of God. (2:177 [Asad])

Many people, and not all of them from other faiths, would define Muslim piety as strictly adhering to Islam's exterior "rules," what in the modern West may seem like an endless list of dos and don'ts -- and mostly don'ts. While The Law is by no means irrelevant to Muslim piety, this ayah (the name for a verse in the Qur'an, which literally means "miracle" in Arabic) gives a more holistic picture. According to this passage, devotion to God is not merely about the motions -- facing towards the east or west -- but about the belief in certain ideals and the courage to act on them.

The scholars of Quranic revelation sequence explain that God revealed this verse shortly after He ordered the faithful to change the direction of prayer from Jerusalem to Mecca. This shift in the rules legislating worship made some people nervous. The ayah was responding by expanding their and our understanding of religiosity.

The verse begins with the foundation of piety -- belief in God. Islamic monotheism functionally means making God -- not money, ambition, or any other selfish interests -- lord of our lives. The implications are profound. It means ethics must rule over impulse, principles must supersede passions. It means that we must treat each other not according to the pull of society's power differentials, but according to the compassion prescribed by The All-Powerful.

The lifelong process of purifying the heart of its attachments to false deities, and therefore realizing true monotheism, is the very essence of our purpose.

The rest of the verse integrates the "how to" and the "outcome of" this cleansing process. To lead a God-centric life, we need to be grounded in faith, which means believing in that which we cannot see or measure in a laboratory -- an idea captured by the belief in angels. We also need guidance, what God's prophets and revelation provide.

However, beyond the theory, people need hands-on training to put God first. That is where Islam's devotional requirements or "five pillars" come in. The pillars of Islam, which include prayer, paying the purifying alms, fasting Ramadan, and pilgrimage to Mecca, like other "pillars," exists to support something, not just to exist. These tools, each in their own way, help free our hearts from the shackles of earthly addictions. Deep and regular connection with God through the five daily prayers gives us perspective and spiritual strength often worn away by the clamor of life's immediacy.

Sharing our wealth with those in need, though it is dear to us, gives us practice putting God before material gain. By giving some of our money to the orphan and the wayfarer in kinship, not patronage, we empower ourselves to be masters of our material processions, not their slaves, while at the same time building brotherhood in society.

The outcome of this dual-learning approach of principles and practice should be a heart and mind wired toward justice and compassion, and actions to prove it. The Prophet saw this as the core of his mission. He famously said, "I was only sent to perfect good character" -- good character demonstrated in trustworthiness, integrity and patience in times of great turmoil, as the ayah goes on to explain.

This is what it means to be truly pious, leading a life of principles, not just ritual prescriptions.

Dalia Mogahed is Executive Director of the Gallup Center for Muslim Studies. She writes here in her personal capacity.

 
 
 

Follow Dalia Mogahed on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dmogahed

Editor's Note: Huffington Post Religion has launched a scripture commentary/reflection series, which will bring together leading voices from different religious traditions to offer their wisdom on sel...
Editor's Note: Huffington Post Religion has launched a scripture commentary/reflection series, which will bring together leading voices from different religious traditions to offer their wisdom on sel...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 498
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
01:15 PM on 08/13/2010
Hi, Sorry but which Surah is Surah Asad?
01:34 PM on 08/29/2010
The quote is taken from Sura 2 (al-Baqarah). "Asad" refers to Muhammad Asad's translation.
07:44 AM on 08/13/2010
"Sharing our wealth with those in need, though it is dear to us, gives us practice putting God before"

She consistently avoid mentioning that sharing wealth and showing compassion is strictly restricted to the believers; for the non believers, different sets of rule apply.
01:40 PM on 08/29/2010
No, Muslims are supposed to help all needy people, regardless of religion. For example, see this: http://www.islamonline.net/servlet/Satellite?pagename=IslamOnline-English-Ask_Scholar/FatwaE/FatwaE&cid=1119503548680 or this: http://www.alrisala.org/Articles/mailing_list/charity.html
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:52 AM on 08/13/2010
another moderate Muslim voice looks to the scriptures to counter the wave of ignorant fundamentalism that has spread amongst modern Muslims- an act blindly called for by so many ignorant americans while it happens all around them.

and yet look in answer at at some of the denigrating and bigoted posts here.

plain barking mad
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:27 AM on 08/13/2010
"an act blindly called for by so many ignorant americans while it happens all around them."

Can you explain?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:07 PM on 08/14/2010
yes,

so many times you hear the question "where are the muslim voices of moderation?" "where are the muslim voices of condemnation for inter-muslim sectarian violence?" while all around the muslim voices of moderation and the voices of condemnation are everywhere around those asking the question.
the askers are blind to the actual manifestation of what they ask for
they are blind to this I believe because they are ignorant of Islam or have a misconception
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:39 PM on 08/12/2010
Sharing wealth, giving to the poor, caring for the unfortunate, is a plan designed and implemented by God. But it's not to be enforced by the government. Love is a personal thing and cannot be commanded. Nations don't love. Governments don't love. People love and give to others what they need---and without letting the left hand know what the right hand is doing. The best gift is always anonymous---leaving pride to wilt and die.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:46 PM on 08/12/2010
well the government is your tax money , so it'd better love you.
of course the role of the governement is to share the wealth , through taxes and make things that will be usefull for everybody like roads or bridge.
dont rich people use roads ? bridges ? clean streets ? well they need to give something back to the community
but god , please , stay out of my life , my property and my business ...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:48 AM on 08/12/2010
More proof that Osama Bin Laden is the infidel, the Pat Robertson of Islam, the Pope Ratzinger of Islam. Funny how right wingers torture their local religions to spread hatred, selfishness and hypocrisy. The only way any religions survives is by telling people to behave kindly and with tolerance to each other, yet the demagogues always find ways of contorting their religions to promote the very worst villainy mankind is capable of. If they don't have religion to use to justify their evil oppression, they will use any other vehicle, such as the Constitution, free market principles, marxist principles, what have you. Mankind needs to heed the warnings that every religion preaches about false prophets who use the Creator as a tool to increase personal power and wealth. Jesus said the same thing that was said in these passages, but unsurprisingly, those messages of charity and tolerance are utterly ignored.

What will happen when Ratzinger, Robertson, Bin Laden all realize they are preaching the same hatred and intolerance? What will happen if they all join forces to cram as much misery into the human condition as possible? Its a good thing that so far, their own bigotry gets in the way of them joining of forces, because they all have the same Orwellian dystopia in mind for humanity and the will to commit any atrocity to make that dystopia a reality. But there are signs that they will join forces, like when Pat Robertson said the US deserved 9-11.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:01 PM on 08/12/2010
Ratzinger, Robertson and bin Laden as equally bad? A bridge too far.
02:55 PM on 08/15/2010
Robertson was a large part of the power base of the Bush-Cheney mis-Administration. They invaded Iraq under a lie which resulted in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians and the destruction of a nation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
season555
Allaah knows best
10:29 AM on 08/12/2010
Will someone please tell me why do American Christians and Jews feel the need to smear Prophet Muhammed (pbh), does that make you feel better about your religion?

You will never hear a Muslim say anything about Prophet Jesus (pbh) and Prophet Mosses (pbh) not only do we believe that they are messangers of God, like all the others, and showing our respect for them is a tenet of Islam.
11:00 AM on 08/12/2010
The excuse these days, of course, is crazies killing innocent people in the name of Allah. They conveniently forget that Christians have killed innocent Muslims as well. Nothing new. It's all the same demonization of the other tribe in order to build solidarity within your own. We all do it. For instance: not all American Christians and Jews "feel the need to smear Prophet Muhammed". You yourself are demonizing Americans.

The task that all three scriptures and religious traditions give us is to fight the tribal impulse and realize that our true self-interest lies in building brotherly love globally.
11:55 AM on 08/12/2010
You must understand that most religions, especially those of commercial popularity, all have one credo in common.

"I'm right, and everyone else is wrong."
12:08 PM on 08/12/2010
That's what the believers in atheistism feel about theists as well. So that point is invalid. Everyne thinks their belief is correct.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
teknodum
06:53 PM on 08/15/2010
Magical thinking has been the "opiate of the people" that continues to intoxicate the masses
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:22 AM on 08/12/2010
My understanding of religion is directly tied to the nature of man. To be human is to be corruptable. Many seem able and willing to corrupt religions to suit their own purposes; God would never condone that.
04:14 PM on 08/17/2010
Well said
09:31 AM on 08/12/2010
Excellent idea HP!

This scripture commentary makes me think about what 17th century philosopher Spinoza calls 'true religion': he claims that if you 'scientifically' study the Bible to try to understand what this book is really saying, it's difficult to know anything about God himself, but there do is one single message that remains, once you leave out all the contradictions etc., and that is:

being a religious person means relating everything to God, and doing so will increase the presence of two fundamental virtues, i.e. those virtues which, when you try to put them in practice each and every day, are exactly what makes a person truely 'pious': charity and justice, in other words love.

According to Spinoza, this 'true religion' is universal (= accessible to every human being), and at the core of every particular religion.

It's interesting, because this article seems to confirm that idea.

Thanks for the article Dalia Mogahed!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:18 AM on 08/13/2010
remember that an underlying idea to the verses is that obsessing with a particular notion as being the start and end of every analysis of behavior and character is misleading.

Love alone is not the answer to true religion. Christianity which equates God with Love only deals with one aspect of God and there are many. The course correction was needed to counter the effects of human corruption on the last major course correction, the message of Moses. This course correction (Judaism) established laws of God and can be seen as a counter to human activity at the time when the Egyptian Pharaohs had begun establishing courts. Jewish obsession with Gods code forgot them love which Jesus came to remind them of.
The Koran (the final course correction to be made) has come with both Love and Law

That is an Islamic perspective
07:49 AM on 08/12/2010
Would Jesus not work with this Pres whom God also has placed in authority? Like Caesar?
would Jesus vote no against laws of justice for all, laws of true justice, fair, equal regulation laws protection for all Jesus middle class poor, on wall Street?
Would there be a wall street in God's Kingdom his house? Would one need a wall street in God's house?
Did Jesus ever rebuke Caesar, when he stood before him?
Did Jesus not know that whom God places in authority, power over his sheep, will also be judged? If a good shepherd or bad shepherd, that all placed in their seat of power by God will be tested and judge more harshly then others, also? Feed my sheep?
Has God not even laws of judges? Commanded to serve true justice for all?
Has God not commanded no one in power is to take bribes, but serve in true justice for all his people? Feed my sheep.
I ask there no rich or poor with God is there?
Nor in God's Kingdom. No one goes without.
did not God say, In heaven there is no Jew, Greek, man or woman, rich or poor etc?
But all are one, family? God's children who he is our Father.
Would Jesus vote no, not work for affordable health care for all citizens?
Or would Jesus be, fighting for, rising premiums, voting yes yes, to maintain Jesus, profit margins instead?
Just asking, you will know them by their fruits
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YankeeCanuck
dog
12:02 PM on 08/12/2010
I am not a believer, but I'd say you have a fine and truthful notion of Jesus the man. There are far worse things a person could do than live by his example.
Not only that, you have been respectful of the writer's intent in this interfaith series. What has made some folks so angry? That Christianity was not first in the series? That Islam was first? That's Islamophobia-- the far right cause du jour-- talking. You nailed it. Oops, I did not mean it literally. ;-)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:26 AM on 08/13/2010
this is why American democracy has some negative connotations in the Third World and especially in the Muslim World. Does democracy result in all the ills that plague America today? especially it's political system and representative government? If so, there must be a better way, there must be a democracy yet to be discovered in some nation's culture (not the west's which has failed to provide a wholesome solution or ideal) but in some tribe somnwhere's understanding of the world when wedded to universal principles of human rights to produce that elusive perfect and sought after form of collective government that results in freedom and liberty without resulting in American government today.

The World needs a better system to strive for, right now the most popular model is the American and Western European though the results of these models (as seen in America and Western Europe) though capable of providing some great benefits still amount to a zero sum game on true justice, true freedom, true liberty and true democracy

maybe democracy without trash is just not possible by humans and all we can do is minimise it
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:59 AM on 08/15/2010
Would you say that Islamic sharia would be an improvement?
07:33 AM on 08/12/2010
Would Jesus have voted no to unemployment? The poor middle class in need? Who lost their jobs, did not quit their jobs?
Would Jesus call the unemployed, drug addicts or lazy?
Did Jesus call the poor when he walked among them, they were poor, because they were, drug addicts or lazy?
Would Jesus give the wealthy more tax cuts and raise taxes on the middle class hard labors instead?
Or would Jesus give the middle class, a honest days work, for a honest days wage? True value of their hard labors?
Would Jesus only created jobs, if he was only given massive tax cuts? Or would Jesus serve all and share with all, all he had?
Would Jesus, himself, be happy with a living wage, or would Jesus also demand massive profits on top?
Would Jesus judge and hate others of different faiths? Or did Christ serve his enemies (his enemies, all of us) and died for enemies, those who hated him, instead?
Did Jesus ever spew, his hate, bitterness, kill anyone, or ever carried a sword, or force anyone to accept his word of God as truth?
06:48 AM on 08/12/2010
Jesus said a Dr does not go to the healthy, but to the sick right? To whom and where did Jesus go to? The sick? down trodden etc or the ones who were oppressing them?

Muslims believe in the say God we do, but practice their laws same Moses more strickly till this day. Muslims have never mocked Jesus, or used in cartoons or made jokes with his name, or have used Jesus name in cursing, either. Muslims honor, believe in Jesus, but not has their savior, but as a prophet of God only. To use Jesus name and mock him, to Muslims is blasphemy against God, for Jesus was a prophet of God, to the Muslims.

Muslims honor greatly Jesus Mother Mary, and the Blessed Virgin is written more about her in their holy book, then in the Bible.
06:42 AM on 08/12/2010
In Christ time, Christ to went once a year with all millions who believed in God to celebrate a feast day. A feast day commanded to be celebrated once a year. Remember when Jesus was 12, they all traveled there with his mother, Joseph, millions, when Jesus was lost, his mother did not know, was lost, till 3 days later.
06:39 AM on 08/12/2010
Greed? Feed my sheep. A command, I ask have not heard, this command given by Jesus which was the 1st commanded, told by Jesus, with worship God only, by those who say they believe in Christ, why?. Love your enemies has I have loved -you-.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PatrickforO
America needs a Labor Party
03:15 AM on 08/12/2010
That verse is a lot like what can be found in the book of James in the New Testament. Seems like lots of folks of all faiths would benefit by taking to heart this simple concept. I'm reading Under the Dome by Stephen King, and it has his usual take on evil - greed and lust for power. These two things undo us every time, I think.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Californian2020
03:11 AM on 08/12/2010
In the words of the great Homer J. Simpson, "Stupid Americans!" We don't know jack about the outside world!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JPalka
07:49 AM on 08/12/2010
It all starts with you! It is not the "Americans", you do not split knowledge like Wall Street wealth, it combines, so if you know something it is not in spite of somebody else.... and it does not make everybody else stupid. The epiphany is when you understand you don't know jack... or so I understand :)