EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Dan Siegel

Dan Siegel

Posted: October 6, 2009 12:47 PM

Michael Moore's Grapes of Wrath

What's Your Reaction?

?>

Michael Moore has made the most important and urgent political film of our time. In fact, he might have made the most American of films since the populist cinema of Frank Capra.

I hope that Capitalism: A Love Story gets the proper national hearing and deep respect it so well deserves at this time in our history.

Moore provides us a much needed alternative narrative to the new Gilded Age fantasies first launched on TV screens during the rule of Reagan, unchallenged or even seconded in the Clinton years, and taken to extremis by the Cheney/Bush crowd.

This film is a logical capstone to a twenty year documentary journey surveying the carcasses left behind by bootstrap capitalist ideology and cold-hearted greed, all greased by Washington's collusion. Moore's long march has taken us from the GM ghost town of Flint to the ultimate corporate crime scene pulled off by Wall Street during the Great Heist of the past year.

A film should be judged, in part, like an Olympics gymnastic performance based on degree of difficulty. A perfect 10 is earned here for deflating the decades-long cultural celebration of and blind worship to the victors of Casino Capitalism. Pulling this off in a documentary form by using subversive humor, great music, moving personal storytelling, impressive journalistic expose and grand analysis is truly no easy feat.

Admittedly, Mr. Moore can overshoot his target and gild the lily of documentary correctness. This film takes wholesale aim at the house of capitalism by displaying the most venal and outrageous practices of the ill-begotten bottom line. He does conflate heart-breaking home foreclosures and shocking local corruption (like a for-profit juvenile detention center in Pennsylvania that enriches its sleazy owners and a local judge) to condemn capitalism in toto.

But how refreshing it is to have a film that bravely forces us to think about why our economic and political system has gone so far off the tracks, and to confront the faces of those who are its severest victims. Working class and poor folks are invisible and verboten in the American media dream machine. However, Moore's cameras capture both the tragedy of stolen dignity and the possibility of hope in small victories enabled by, yes, good old fashioned community and labor organizing.

Capitalism captures the rising tide of anger across the political spectrum of citizens who increasingly understand that our children's future is being sold by purchased politicians and the wise guys who have made off with massive public loot.

But which populism shall we choose? The pitchfork crowd of teabaggers and birthers manipulated and misdirected by the Right and corporate lobbyists, and embodied by Joe the Plumber and Glenn Beck? Or shall we respond to Moore's progressive populist call for deep-seated democratic reform to take back our economy and politics?

Those choosing the latter are well-guided by the film's rare footage of Franklin Roosevelt calling for a Second Bill of Rights in 1944. Sixty-five years later we are waiting for this unfinished New Deal, and today witness the heavily-financed resistance to achieve even one of those basic rights, universal healthcare.

With the glimmering hope of the Obama campaign behind us, Moore's film is a wake-up call to renew and expand America's democratic promise. Will we create the America of the next Roosevelt, or revert to the country of Reagan? Can we win the cultural battle of the American soul by empowering citizens to care for the public good rather than buy into the dog eat dog dream of grabbing the big brass ring at any cost?

Viewers walking out of the movie theater might ask other basic civic questions: Where is the missing cop on the beat to arrest the golden parachute criminals of our day? Where are the regulators and media watchdogs that should have long-ago exposed the "dead peasants" insurance policies secretly taken out by the blue chip companies to cash in on their own low-level deceased workers? Why do we leave it to Michael Moore to ring Wall Street in yellow crime tape and back up a brinks truck to retrieve our stolen public treasure at the modern Temples of Mammon?

Watching the kaleidoscope of greed and swindle, one can understand Mr. Moore's parting words at the end of the film when he urges all of us sitting in the dark theaters to get off our bottoms and take a stand, and fast.

Recognizing how little has changed over the past year since the Great Heist (and reading about Wall Street's latest and dangerous money-making schemes), one can slump further back in the seat and watch a documentary Don Quixote fighting a seemingly lost cause. It is indeed dispiriting to see scenes of Obama's election night and realize that the Goldman Sachs boys are still in control of the really big dollars moving behind the scenes.

Nevertheless, it is heartening to see unsung and principled public heroes speaking out for the common good, like the fiery Ohio Congresswoman Marcy Kaptur, or Elizabeth Warren, the congressionally-appointed watchdog of the $700 billion government bailout, as well as religious leaders like Detroit Bishop Thomas Gumbleton. These are the prophetic voices people need to hear and guide us to action in these times.

In the end, we should all be grateful to have a bold civic filmmaker help us make meaning and hopefully take action in this age of high crimes and naked greed, something which our public servants and chattering media class has long failed to do.

So take your friends to see Michael Moore's film this week. Help send the message that the living and breathing peasants -- the real American majority -- are hungry for this kind of reality truth-telling.

Michael Moore has made the most important and urgent political film of our time. In fact, he might have made the most American of films since the populist cinema of Frank Capra. I hope that Capitali...
Michael Moore has made the most important and urgent political film of our time. In fact, he might have made the most American of films since the populist cinema of Frank Capra. I hope that Capitali...
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jorjan
11:57 PM on 10/08/2009
Great commentary on Michael Moore's exceptiona­l documentar­y. I saw it tonight and was moved to tears at the demise of the country I grew up in. I was married 19 years to an auto worker so it was especially sad to see how the unions were broken and jobs lost. Moore didn't go into how GM has built three plants in China but then I only knew about it a couple of weeks ago. Not much really reported on that I guess. This movie evoked so many emotions, laughter, sadness, anger and hope that maybe, just maybe we can all put aside our political difference­s and work together to take our country back from corporate America and Wall Street. The future of our children and grandchild­ren truly depend on it.
09:29 PM on 10/08/2009
Outside of the USA - America seems to have reached the ultimate pinnacle in corruption­, so greedy that it will take the whole world down with it - isn't this about when basic business ethics are completely lost - blame the hoards of lawyers and the teams of young bright wannabes who, at those secret bank meetings figured out how to screw every last penny out of their customers. Alas, yes it is true, I sat in on one of those meetings. And I have been threatened by the Chairman of the Board to sign, or be off... I guess my conscience go the best of me, and I had to quit the rat race. Ah, there are so few that do! Can something be done about it? People like Moore should be applauded from the highest peaks, as in them are the only true American heroes in my mind! I am not so courageous and so free to say the truth and that is so very rare!

Thank you for the wonderful article Dan!
02:56 AM on 10/09/2009
Thanks for your comment...­.you are so right about the loss of business ethics, and the challenges of truth-tell­ing in these times.
09:05 PM on 10/08/2009
Saw the film a few days ago. It should be required viewing for all in America. Was impressed by Bishop Tom Gumbleton of Detroit's remarks. Not suprising as he as always been very liberal in his views. Too bad he doesn't represent a majority of the Catholic hypocritic­al hierarchy.
08:30 PM on 10/11/2009
Agreed, Fateh! Dan's article great!!
Outside U.S. Moore's film is viewed like a Frank Capra populist movie and brings to mind the true art of film-makin­g to stir and inspire with ordinary heroes. The kind of American hero that is nonexisten­t Bush The Barbarian. Remember Mr. Smith Goes to Washington­? Now, " Michael Moore goes to Hollywood" and makes a documentar­y for the People!

In Canada, Capitalism is raising a stir and at the TIF it was attended to the point we had to wait outside for hours! Rep. Marcy Kaptur is a real hero and so's Elizabeth Warren, the overseer of the robber barrons who are now taking their jets to Europe while people are being evicted.

BROOKSLEY BORN, the woman who chaired the FCTC and warned Alan Greenspan about the fianancial "Fraud" that would ruin the nation, was mistreated by the sexist Greenspan and the boys in the green leather club and she resigned. Michael should have included that great prophet! Only mistake! The woman was a respected lawyer who wrote memos to everyone in l996-7. No one would listen. Greenspan and Rubin (who's been sued for fraud for millions!) couldn't wait to get rid of the lady....

Hillary Clinton said during the primary,sh­e had a plan for people dealing with foreclosur­es. It was sensible, specific--­unlike whatever Obama has (or NOT) done! Americans deserved a more mature, knowledgea­ble President with guts--not baritone rhetoric. Thank Zeus Mike Moore's around,eh?­!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jteamaz
06:02 PM on 10/08/2009
I just saw this film yesterday, I was extremely impressed. Every person in this Country should see this. Thank you Michael for your 20 years of perseveran­ce, I see why you're getting tired.....­.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dav ram58
04:37 PM on 10/08/2009
Whew! This Dan Siegel can turn a phrase! Excellent commentary and review of Michael Moore's film. Don and Michael are giving it to us straight.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skunky93
03:06 PM on 10/08/2009
It's a great film. I was impressed.
11:11 PM on 10/06/2009
I cringe when I hear people intimating that competitio­n is a bad thing, or that Americans need a crutch (protectio­nism) to succeed. I reject that view utterly and totally. I believe in Americans, and I believe we can successful­ly compete with anybody, as long as we remove the chains that hold us down. I also believe in freedom, and I want the freedom to choose for myself which products I buy. Japanese automakers didn't win huge market share by buying off politician­s. They built a superior product for an acceptable price. It took our automakers years to catch on that quality cars matter. American made cars are vastly improved since the 60s and 70s and 80s. Would that improvemen­t have happened without fierce competitio­n? Shield anyone from competitio­n and their inventiven­ess and productivi­ty start to disappear. Resources get misallocat­ed, and lifestyles deteriorat­e. I refuse to see myself as a victim.
10:37 AM on 10/07/2009
Since 1980, the Japanese automakers have been subsidized to the tune of 3.6 BILLION dollars by the American taxpayers!­!! ALL have received millions and I have the stats!
They are also subsidised by their government as well as have national healthcare and have a VAT tax (we don't) to build up capital.
Have you read that they are now being sued under RICO regarding Dimitoris Biller (a former attorney for them) for WITHHOLDIN­G evidence regarding which could turn out to mean HUNDREDS of REopened lawsuits regarding injury and deaths because they have a SUBSTANDAR­D roof?
Better yet, since you are in such awe of Japanese automakers­, check our the June 2008 National Labor Comitees' report about human rights violations at the Toyota Prius factory in Japan!
Read revered HISTORIAN Linda Goetz Holmes' book (she is coming out with a new one spring 2010) titled:

"Unjust Enrichment­-How Japan's Companies Built Postwar Fortunes Using American Pows"

They're all in their Mitsubish-­now part of Toyota, Kawasaki..­.
Have you forgotten about the Marshal plan stil in use by them 60 years later?
Hmmm....yo­u have the nerve to think our big three should compete against such odds with your precious so-called free enterprise­?
WAKE UP AMERICANS!
11:13 AM on 10/07/2009
I am weary of Amercians who spew untruths based on opinion, NOT facts. The Japanese LOBBYISTS lobbied our southern politician­s for $ AND just for example, the Toyota ASSEMBLY plant in Kentucky, got 1500 FREE acres of land and a special trade zone status to import THEIR parts from Japan!
Need I mention what happened to our electronic­s industry in this nation? What else do you want to subsidise then hand over? You must be either an elitist "Eloi" or a profiteer.
Go ahead, reject protection­ism, I assume you reject our protection­ist founding fathers and OUR Constitiut­ion also?
Only those SEEKING FACTS (NOT opinion) bother to read them before they THINK about knocking our nation's industries­!
By the way, planes leave everyday for more "superior" nations.
FYI-The Linda Goetz Holme's book mentioned has been out since 2001. Of course the many lobbyists that you insist don't exist made sure that it wasn't common knowledge. Only those SEEKING the truth bother to read facts before they THINK about knocking our nation's industries­! By the way, planes leave everyday for more "superior" nations.
04:39 PM on 10/08/2009
conservati­ve ideologica­l blah blah blah. Cooperatio­n will always, always, always be a better road that competitio­n.
07:15 PM on 10/06/2009
Hardly anyone knows that the Roosevelt film was lost and Michael found it, and the 2nd Bill of Rights that it contains. Michael doesn't talk about that in the film, just in interviews­. This is a profound event, this discovery, and needs more exposure.
12:32 AM on 10/07/2009
I agree, the FDR footage is a major find, in both historical and political terms. The concept of a Second Bill of Rights is perhaps the ideal vehicle to shape American politics over the coming decades.
03:17 PM on 10/06/2009
Serious question - what's the answer then? What's the next best thing? What provides the best for the most while providing incentives for individual­s to continue to work hard and achieve AND individual freedoms with a minimum of government control? I'm game to replace it - if only I could find something better...
03:42 PM on 10/06/2009
One small step would be to ban corporate donations for all political appointmen­ts - from judges to Congressme­n and Senators. If you take all of the corporate money out of the political process people motivated by greed would be much less inclined to run for office. Your elections would cost much less and those running for office would be more likely to be in it for the public good rather than greed and power.

It's just one step but it would make a huge differece. Only individual­s can send money to a politician - and those contributi­ons should be capped to prevent the wealthy from having undue influence.
09:41 PM on 10/06/2009
There is little question that all congressma­n and presidents (including this congress and this president) are bought by special interest, but it is not just the corporatio­ns. It is also the unions, and people.

I would love to see a ban on bundled or large contributi­ons, but congress is against and the constituti­on is against it. What we have is representa­tion by money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KarlaElisa
The atmosphere is Toxic
01:00 PM on 10/09/2009
The Supreme Court will be ruling as to whether for the purposes of donations, Corporatio­ns who are already treated as 'individua­ls' will be allowed to donate without restrictio­n to politician­s.
Frightenin­g stuff if you ask me.
http://www­.nytimes.c­om/2009/09­/11/opinio­n/11fri3.h­tml
03:47 PM on 10/06/2009
Let's start with retroactiv­ley ENFORCING our trade laws. Then subsidisin­g OUR industries as ALL of our competiter­s have done including a VAT tax like them.
We are almost to the point of where we were when we started this nation, relying on the rest of the world to supply us for our every need!
THEN we can rebuild and employ OUR citizens and they can afford to buy our manufactur­erd things. The other nations should pay their people enough to buy theirs instead of subsidizin­g key industries to come on to our soil and deplete the American owned ones then they could have a customer base as well. Henry Ford did it and it made him a rich man!
Our politician­s shrink with fear of a trade war that THEY started by opening up TOTAL access here to any nation for more profits for big business so they can claim it was only for "cheaper" goods while busting unions.
Thomas Jefferson WAS a free trader until he saw that we almost lost the war of 1812 because England blockaded our supplies.
So here we ago again, becoming DEPENDENT on other nations for thing we can do ourselves!
Only difference is our founders weren't invertabra­tes and cared more about our sovereignt­y instead of puppets of the rich and bragging about its citizens saving a few bucks at Chinamart.
We'd better grow a spine again or we'll all become ignorant elitist "Elios" just waiting to be devoured by the world's "Morlocks.­"
02:58 PM on 10/06/2009
EVERY American should be required to see this movie so they will at least see the presented facts and then they can judge for themselves­.
More Americans need to notice the timing of the 80's (Reagan era) and 2009 and how unbridled free trade was to be our silver bullet to the Ameriican dream.
It was all a ruse orchestrat­ed by the top wealthies 1% circumveti­ng labor unions to cut out the middle man (middle class) for profiting. VERY few middle class benefit as our sovereignt­y wanes.
Those who have yet to be hurt by free trade and cheap slave labor, will eventually be, and maybe then Michael will get his revolution­. The banks even screwed up and YOU bailed them out and paid them bonuses for it! Our banks AND foreign nation's banks are ALL screwing us by our HUGE trade deficit!
Until then, those that have been hurt, need to speak out, protection­ism is NOT Un-America­n nor isolationi­sm! We have Article 1 Section 8 in OUR Constituti­on to regulate foreign trade so as not to languish, now THAT'S being American! Tell those self-servi­ng rich bozos that!
Protection­ism is what our founders based this nation on, because they knew that was the FAIR and JUST way to grow our democracy and its citizens and deal with foreign nations who would take advantage of us, and they will, it's human nature to do so!
Instead, the 21rst century robber barons wrote new trade laws for their profit margins.
photo
Areyoukiddingg
We need a Reset
01:19 PM on 10/06/2009
The culminatio­n of the Reagan & W Bush (and to a lesser extent Clinton) administra­tions has resulted in an economic Katrina which has affected most families in the Middle Class and devastated those known as the "working poor". Michael Moore deserves much credit for exposing the lies, deceit and outright greed supported by the modern GOP. Go and see his film, then make a pledge that you will take action by calling your representa­tives, voting, and making clear your support of FDR's "2nd Bill of Rights". Mr. Moore is correct when he says we MUST remove money from politics, for as long as it remains, your representa­tives respond to the lobbyists instead of their constituen­ts.
04:05 PM on 10/06/2009
I like the idea that we should be urging our representa­tives to support the "2nd Bill of Rights"...­this is a great Big Tent for the healthcare battle, and a way to frame the wave of reform needed in the years ahead.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
erinker
05:54 PM on 10/06/2009
Agreed. The Dems are lousy at framing their agendas, and "The Second Bill of RIghts" is a wonderful way to frame many of the progressiv­e agendas.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:00 PM on 10/06/2009
Bravo, great review for a great movie. Michael doesn't demonize the Republican­s only, he demonizes the system that appeals to the worst in us, greed, avarice, gluttony..­.