Huffpost New York
THE BLOG

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Dan Collins Headshot

New York Haunted by Curse of the True Blue

Posted: Updated:

President Obama visited upstate New York this week. While he was
there, we all speculated about whether being in New York, a state that
has legalized gay marriage, would prod the president to mention his
"evolving" position on the subject.

The next day, without any notable prodding from New Yorkers,
the president was back in the White House announcing his support for
gay marriage. This apparently had absolutely nothing to do with the
trip to New York, and also guaranteed that the visit here would be
completely wiped out of the national memory banks, overtaken by the
breaking news from D.C.

That's a shame because we deserve the chance to at least take
note of a presidential trip to our state for something other than
campaign fund-raising. It doesn't happen very often. We live with the
Curse of the True Blue. Everybody knows how New York is going to vote
in presidential elections, so nobody cares.

Obama's trip, by the way, was actually historic. He went to
the University at Albany's College of Nanoscale Science and
Engineering, praised it mightily, and said: "I want what's happening
in Albany to happen all across the country."

It's been a long time since anybody said they wanted "what's
happening in Albany" duplicated. Of course, Albany is usually a
synonym for a terrible state legislature. So let's take a bow.
Even the legislature isn't as bad as it used to be. Otherwise, we
wouldn't have gay marriage.

But let's also take this opportunity to complain about the way
the electoral college system disenfranchises us. We know it so well we
hardly ever bother to think about it. But if you live in New York,
your presidential preference counts for almost nothing -- maybe 1
percent as much as an Ohioan or Floridian, and I'm being generous.

New Yorkers talk about politics all the time, especially
during presidential election seasons. But nothing they say matters --
unless they're saying it over the phone to a relative in a swing state
like North Carolina or Virginia. If you want to help Barack Obama, you
can send money, or sign up to go door-to-door in New Hampshire. If
you're a Republican, your vote is precisely as meaningless because
nobody thinks you're going to have the power to turn your home state.
However, the sign-up sheet for New Hampshire still awaits.

Arizona has somehow turned into a swing state this year. The
Democrats say they're going to spend money to try to win its 11
electoral votes. New York has 29 electoral votes, and the only
presidential campaign ads we're going to see are the ones broadcast
nationally. If the parties thought they could save a few bucks by
blocking us out, they'd do it in a second.

You know the drill: Each state is allotted electoral votes,
based mainly on its number of congressional districts (i.e.,
population) and it's winner take all. Under that system, any Democrat
who has to worry about New York is already in such a hopeless
situation that he (or she) might as well just take to his (or her) bed
and give up the fight as hopeless. Any Republican who thinks he (or
she) has a chance to win it is so far ahead of the game he (or she)
could just devote available campaign hours to planning the victory
parties.

The obvious answer is to go to a popular election. Imagine.
Every single American's vote would count equally. The state you live
in wouldn't matter. Well over 60 percent of New Yorkers voted for
Obama over John McCain, but who cares? Getting New York up to 65
percent would be equally important as keeping Ohio at the same 51
percent as in 2008.

You may argue that this isn't going to happen. You would be
arguing from an extremely strong place. But that doesn't keep a guy
from dreaming.