iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Daniel Cubias

Daniel Cubias

GET UPDATES FROM Daniel Cubias
 

Are White People Disenfranchised?

Posted: 05/14/11 04:50 PM ET

Recently, I received some hate mail from a white supremacist. It's a rare, but not unprecedented occurrence.

Her sentiments were ignorant and bizarre, of course. And clearly, they in no way reflect the opinion of most Americans. I wondered, however, how many individuals would agree with one of her statements, which was that white people are being oppressed.

In fact, CNN recently investigated this phenomenon... no, I'm serious; they really did. According to sociologist Charles Gallagher, whites "went from being a privileged group to all of a sudden becoming ... the new victims."

I must admit that this news caught me off-guard. I somehow assumed, based on all statistical and most anecdotal evidence, that white people still held the bulk of the power in America. Clearly, I was wrong.

Yes, white people still account for about two-thirds of the American population.

And yes, in terms of who runs the country, the discrepancy is even greater. About three-quarters of Congress is white. Seven of the nine Supreme Court justices are white (although some would argue that the Jewish members are not really "white"; let's leave that argument alone). And of course, it is only in the last two years that the president has been of another color.

And OK, it is fair to presume that most corporate boardrooms feature an overabundance of white people. And one could point out that rates of poverty and unemployment are substantially greater for ethnic minorities. And we can add that, culturally, most films and television shows focus on white characters.

Still, it is clear who is being crushed under the steel boot of diversity: white people.

Just ask members of the Tea Party, whose members are overwhelming white. A recent poll found that 61% of Tea Partiers identified "discrimination against whites as being just as big as bigotry aimed at blacks and other minorities."

Apparently many white people "are acting like a racially oppressed majority. They are adopting the language and protest tactics of an embattled minority group."

How did this turnabout happen? Well, many sociologists, such as Gallagher, believe that bigotry aimed at white people actually hasn't increased. Rather, factors such as the election of Obama, the effects of the Great Recession, and that old hobgoblin -- illegal immigration -- have combined to scare white Americans into thinking that they are strangers in their own country.

"The very definition of being an American is going through a profound change," writer Tim Wise says. "We can no longer take it for granted that we (whites) are the dictionary definition of an American."

Indeed, I never defined "American" that way, But then again, as a Latino, I am part of the problem.

So what can we do to help disenfranchised white people? Should we restructure affirmative action so it pinpoints at-risk youth in Pasadena rather than Compton? Should we practice tough love and advise white people to pull themselves up by their bootstraps? Should we offer free Spanish classes en masse, as English is clearly on the way out?

Well, at the very least, we will have to change our terms. White flight will now be black flight. And white privilege will now be Asian privilege.

But there I go -- telling people what to do again. I guess I just suffer from liberal Latino guilt.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 60
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
adcan49
Lone Star Liberal
08:36 AM on 06/28/2011
Another great post...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:55 PM on 06/06/2011
Lol, we will be a minority in a short period of time. I promise you will see a lot more of this mentality. And what is white?? Well, what is Latino?
12:12 AM on 05/18/2011
It's very simple, really. The republicans have successfully used scare tactics to get whites to vote for them. They always make up a boogey man around every corner. The whites have been paralized with fear and will believe anything.

Home of the brave?
photo
Soule23
Anti-micro-biol
07:51 PM on 05/15/2011
Of course white people have been systematically disenfranchised. Look at the facts:

1) They can't buy, sell, and own slaves anymore
2) They can't legally force members of other demographics to occupy the lower positions on the socioeconomic ladder anymore
3) They can't run internment camps anymore
4) They can't run Native Americans off of desirable real estate anymore
5) They can't give legislation names like "The Chinese Exclusion Act" anymore.

If this is not oppression, you tell me just what is.

*sarcasm off*
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:07 PM on 05/15/2011
Don't look now but "diversity" has this country by the nose, and it's always been so.

The two largest Euro-American groups are the descendants of German and Irish immigrants. The Irish immigrants of the 19th Century were highly persecuted. Some German-Americans were confined in internment camps during WWII.

Most of those Irish immigrants spoke Gaelic as their native language.

Of course, French-Americans and Italian-Americans are major segments of European migrations who were not English speakers.

These cohorts are hardly homogeneous as a group. When Polish, Scandinavian, and eastern European descendants are included, diversity is glaringly evident.

Never mind that all of these groups are mixed and descend from populations that were mixed and continually at war with each other. What's not diverse about such demographics?

According to the Pew Hispanic Center, nearly 70% of US "hispanic" citizens classify themselves as "white".

Somehow, the glaringly silent question, the question that goes raucously begging for an answer, is "what is white?" Who decides and why?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Daniel Cubias
09:46 PM on 05/15/2011
"What is white?" (or "Who is white?") is an excellent question. Perhaps another post is in order to address that one.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gguy
05:01 PM on 05/15/2011
I've noticed the predictable attacks on the author from those that accuse him of identity politics. What he is referring to is the ludicrous notion that anglos in this country are somehow vanishing or losing power, when in fact, as he points out, most postions of power in this country are still held by "white" men. This false notion has been building more feverishly since Obama was elected president. This fact is not a coincidence, as is blatantly in evidence by people saying they want to "take this country back". From what exactly? It doesn't take a brilliant mind to figure it out.
12:08 AM on 05/16/2011
Nobody's disputing that some anglo-americans are leveling ludicrous charges of being discriminated against. But, sorry, the author IS engaging in identity politics.
thebigbike
ran away to be a cowboy
04:59 PM on 05/15/2011
a great deal of the "white" "victimhood" has to do with the fact that pretty much everyone who isn't in the right track to being rich or already rich is getting the shaft from wall street and the multinationals that dominate both the economy, and the government, and run the for the benfit of their owners and executives.

used to be. if you were white, there was always somebody lower on the slide but, a lot of whites are getting a taste of what people of color had to put up with.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cleo Creech
Atlanta writer, poet, activist.
01:40 PM on 05/15/2011
As a white guy I think it just depends on your perspective.

If you see yourself as part of a diverse and dynamic America, then absolutely not, you're just part of the big tapestry that makes up this country with as much voice and opportunity as anyone else.

However if you see yourself as somehow the guardian of a white euro-centric status-quo way-of-life, then you're just setting yourself up for disappointment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vietveter
To the FAR LEFT
07:22 AM on 05/15/2011
Are White People Disenfranchised?


As to separate them from other races? NO!

As to the greater scheme of things and along with all other races? YES

Humans in general have been steadily more disenfranchised by big international business
Every day – every week – every year – and at all times. We are headed back to darker ages.
02:35 AM on 05/15/2011
sibyl9 Commented 5 hours ago
"The white supremists are as ridiculous as the La Raza
activists. They both have about the same number of teeth and,
most certainly, the same low IQ."
------------------------------
What's wrong with this post?
01:19 PM on 05/15/2011
Nothing, as far as I can tell. This article--as are the other articles written by this author--is racist. He consistently dismisses all "white" people, and is probably anti-semitic. I don't think he would have a problem if the racial majority of the country were "hispanic," but is clearly disturbed by the majority being "white," and I am pretty sure he'd have a problem if the racial majority were "black." This article is a perfect example of what's wrong with identity politics: it tends to reproduce the same blindnesses and hatefulness as the politics it purports to be fighting againt.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gguy
04:54 PM on 05/15/2011
There's a lot of assumptions in this response. From what does one glean anti-semitism from the post - a reference to how white supremacists view Jews? Where is there any indication the author is disturbed by an anglo majority, or even a black majority?
02:33 AM on 05/15/2011
"(although some would argue that the Jewish members are not really "white"; let's leave that argument alone)"

What do you mean by that?
IMOPINIONH8D
because I want it empty...
11:30 AM on 05/15/2011
Ask a klansman what it means. The History Channel has a show they show about the klan from time to time. They openly hate Jewish people as much as they hate African Americans.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dan Crabtree
01:15 AM on 05/15/2011
Yes sir re..the white anglo american is in reality slowly vanishing.With them goes the brillant minds that brought the human race from mud huts and teepees to homes..who built the cities that all now walk in or invented the automobile that all drive..the cures for hundreds of diseases..time for another race or mixed races to take the wheel and i have no problem with that fact..hope they posess the same drive and determination all the anglo immigrants brought to this nation some 150 years ago..if they indeed do.. this nation will be fine...Feel free to start the personal attacks..Its a lib thing..i understand.. no problem..
IMOPINIONH8D
because I want it empty...
11:37 AM on 05/15/2011
So the white anglo American (which I'm one) built all the cities of the world. Expalin China then, what about Japan, South Korea or the MiddleEast. White anglo Americans can share the responsibility of helping America develop. We are a melting pot nation, remember 5th grade history class?
photo
papapj
..light as a feather..
11:55 AM on 05/15/2011
What's this, another acolyte of the Pat Buchanan school of historical revisionism?
01:07 AM on 05/15/2011
Note that a "tongue-in-cheek" article about the various whinings of minority "activists" would be considered per se racist. Indeed, anything that interrupts the constant bleats of "White racism/minority victim" is verboten.

But hey, this article denigrating the legitimate concerns of founding stock Americans ia a-ok.
01:16 AM on 05/15/2011
Lots of comments from non-minorities didn't make it through the filters.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Daniel Cubias
02:15 AM on 05/15/2011
When referring to "founding stock Americans," I presume that you are including the black slaves whose forced labor made it possible for European colonists to prosper.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Slater Torret
03:49 AM on 05/15/2011
Nice article, Daniel.

I'm white and I think those folks are a wee bit hysterical. Economically, everyone is suffering, except the wealthiest 25% (appx), and what this majority group are doing is classic scapegoating, IMO. Textbook fearmongering from the conservative establishment permeates our media. And now, they're going after (drumroll please) SENIORS! Those selfish old people who are stealing from your children's college fund!

http://www.alternet.org/economy/150930/america%27s_largest_newspaper_launches_a_nasty_attack_on_grandma_and_grandpa/?page=3
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Slater Torret
03:50 AM on 05/15/2011
I'm not sure if that links is going to work, but you can search "Alternet, America's Largest Newspaper Launches a Nasty Attack on Grandma and Grandpa."
iridium53
Semper Fi
12:43 AM on 05/15/2011
Are white people disenfranchised?

ROFLMAO
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:33 AM on 05/15/2011
Very good article.