More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dave Johnson

GET UPDATES FROM Dave Johnson

Republican Budget So Loony Even the Republicans Think It's Nuts

Posted: 04/13/11 06:55 PM ET

The Republican budget is SO loony it's even scaring the right-wing nuts! How often does THAT happen?

The Republicans are voting on their budget plan this week. The plan eliminates Medicare and guts Medicaid, guts the rest of the government (except the things their oil company and military-contractor sponsors make money from), while dramatically cutting taxes on the wealthy and corporations. Reporters are asking Republicans to comment publicly on the plan and the responses are not what you'd expect. When reporters use "tread cautiously" to describe ANYthing Republicans do, you know something's up.

LA Times: "Boehner treads cautiously on Ryan plan":

House Speaker John Boehner offered qualified support for Rep. Paul Ryan's sweeping budget blueprint, which would convert Medicare into largely a private insurance system and transform Medicaid into a state-run block grant program... Boehner said he believed the Ryan plan will reduce the debt and will preserve Medicare -- but stopped short of singing its praises. (emphasis mine)


Washington Post: "Republican presidential candidates tread carefully GOP budget plan":

Mindful of the political risks, most Republican presidential hopefuls treaded gingerly after House Republicans unveiled a budget plan that would slash federal spending by about $5 trillion over 10 years while revamping health programs for the elderly and poor. (emphasis mine)


"Revamping" is reporter-speak for eliminating, privatizing, abolishing, doing away with.

Several, including former Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, praised the budget's sponsor, Wisconsin Rep. Paul Ryan, but stopped short of fully endorsing the blueprint and didn't indicate whether they backed the massive changes in Medicare and Medicaid. (emphasis mine)


"Massive changes" is more reporter-speak for wiping out, killing, destroying, sending to Heaven.

LA Times: "House GOP faces risky vote on Medicare, Medicaid":

Rep. Mary Bono Mack (R-Palm Springs) commended Ryan "for his willingness to begin a long-overdue and critically important debate." But she "continues to review this legislation," including its effect on Medicare,...

Even members of the freshman class, who ran on cutting deficits and upending political convention in Washington, are treading carefully. Rep. Lou Barletta, a Republican whose Pennsylvania district was held by a Democrat for nearly 30 years before his victory in November, declined to comment on how he would vote.

Rep. Sean Duffy, a Republican freshman from a working-class, erstwhile Democratic district in northwestern Wisconsin, also has praised Ryan but has not yet signed on publicly to the plan. (emphasis mine)


Politico: "Some in GOP squirm over Paul Ryan budget":

Rep. Tim Murphy ... is still undecided. Susan Mosychuk, Murphy's chief of staff, said it's a "high-profile vote" that they are "still taking a look at."

Rep. Gus Bilirakis... is "still looking it over and trying to decide." ...

Rep. Sean Duffy (R-Wis.) ... said he's undecided.

Rep. Steve Southerland ... is in the same place as Bilirakis.

So is Ohio freshman Rep. Jim Renacci. "He's still reviewing it"...


Even The Base

In "Plurality of Republicans want Medicare left alone," Ezra Klein cites a Gallup poll showing that even Republican voters don't like the Republican budget.

The most popular position in the GOP's coalition isn't that Medicare needs a complete overhaul, as Ryan thinks. It isn't that it needs major changes, or even that it needs minor changes. It's that we shouldn't try and control costs at all. That's not true for the Democrats' coalition, where both "minor changes" and "major changes" beat "no cost control," and it's not true for the independent coalition, where "minor changes" at least tie cost control.

And in more bad news for the GOP, elsewhere in the poll, raising taxes on the rich turns out to be very popular, while a plurality further cuts in programs.


Even Bachmann!

Saving the best for last, from the above-cited "House GOP faces risky vote on Medicare, Medicaid":

Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-Minn.), who is considering a presidential bid, said the plan "merits our full attention," but didn't go further. (emphasis mine)

Whoa, even Rep. Michelle Bachmann thinks it's nuts! When Michelle Bachman thinks something is nuts, you are waaaayyyy past nuts and into full-on, screaming, idiotic, crazy, frothing, hallucinating, straight-jacket-wrapped, padded-cell, chasing-with-a-net budget lunacy.

This post originally appeared at Campaign for America's Future (CAF) at their Blog for OurFuture. I am a Fellow with CAF.

Sign up here for the CAF daily summary.

 

Follow Dave Johnson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dcjohnson

 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:12 PM on 06/02/2011
Since we are all bashing Ryan's plan, let's all look at the democratic plan.......Oh wait.....there isn't one! Isn't it easy to try and destroy the only plan offered. At least they are trying to put something out there, just like last years budget that the DEMOCRATIC controlled government put out there and passed.....oh wait....they didn't pass a budget. See the pattern here folks? The democratic way...let's just keep kicking it down the road for someone else to handle.
11:09 AM on 06/06/2011
They do have plan, you call it Obamacare, it's comprehensive will lower health care costs and when the public option is added will introduce true competition to the health care industry.
So democrats do have a plan.When i was in school, producing idiotic solutions for problems, got you an F, I never was called brave when I produced something dumb, I was called "dumb".
Thats why I try to avoid doing things like that, i've got standards.
Paul Ryan produces a dumb plan, that guts medicare, and that lets insurance industry executives, the same people, of pre-existing conditions, decide on whether they will insure you.
Not! They wont.
These GOPers are the same people of the "death panels", etc.
They want to create, and have created in the case of Arizona, real "death panels", that really have killed people.
Man, the GOP really needs to develop a work ethic, professionalism and a sense of shame.
Instead of being stupid, all the time, they should trying saying and doing things that make sense.
Next thing you know, some prominent republican will be saying, evolution isn't real, and that humans and dinosaurs co-existed, or that Paul Revere rode to warn the British Army about armed American colonists,...oh wait.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjtaylor22
05:01 PM on 04/18/2011
the republican goal is to destroy the govt and allow full corporate take over of society......
12:17 PM on 04/18/2011
"treading lightly" does not equal "thinks its nuts," except in the world of liberal spin. They tread lightly because they know anyone who actually proposes a realistic solution to the debt will be demagogued (e.g. this piece) as trying to throw cherished entitlements under the bus. That's why Obama, being totally political as well as cowardly, simply proposed more of the same and myabe a few more taxes, which wil continue to kick the problem down the road until national bankruptcy.
06:52 AM on 04/16/2011
The wealthy are the wealthy by DEVINE RIGHT. Like King George, remember him?
Paul Ryan is an Ayn Rand apostle (in the religious meaning). The "extreme fitness" practice and blank, doe eyes are signs of the absence of critical thinking going on in that small head. The religion holds that spending is bad and tax rates and tax deductions ("tax spending" mentioned by Obama) have nothing to do with balancing the budget. When a family buys a home, the loan is for more that a years pay. When a family is short of food money, someone gets a second or third job. But the republican meme does not allow for this.
For the Ryan types, a deduction for a second home is allowed with no limit, and that cannot be discussed. Because it is an attack on republican religious certainty, it is banned from consciousness.
Ryan does not have a clue that Obama just eviscerated him. Unfairness does not compute for Ryan, the tea party, or republicans. The wealthy deserve the low taxes by Devine Right (the job creators?) while Medicare and Medicaid are for those non productive trash of non-wealthy. The old get ten years to prepare for death from preventable causes.
“…As you treat the least of these…”
10:35 AM on 04/16/2011
The nail's head has been hit.
04:54 PM on 04/15/2011
in all fairness, those not strongly supporting the plan haven't been able to read it.
04:53 PM on 04/15/2011
in all fairness those that didn't support the plan - couldn't find anyone to read it to them yet.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rastadaddio
none but ourselves can free our minds
12:12 PM on 04/15/2011
they want to destroy every social program that benefits working americans so they can give huge tax breaks to the richest corporations and people.
photo
CommodoreP
Darn the torpedos, full speed ahead!
01:23 AM on 04/15/2011
Your article highlights one of the problems with the media today. JUST EFFING SAY IT already!!! Don't say 'massive changes'. elimination within the next ten years.

People need true information. The media's rush to be fair and not labeled as lefties means only that they are repeating GOP talking points (Obamacare) or are kind of, sort of, dancing around the truth.

People shouldn't need a freakin' interpreter for their news. Not everyone is that smart. We elected Bush twice and Trump is running a strong second in GOP polls. Please just explain the truth. I'm not saying you need to write "GOP hates hard working, poor, minorities and loves to have gay sex with corporate overlords" but, you know, actually...
gparks
Fan of truth, justice, prosperity for all!
05:26 AM on 04/15/2011
Good point!

Fanned-125
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carolyn LeBeauf
12:07 AM on 04/15/2011
This is why I never questioned anything THE PRESIDENT has ever done since being elected. I knew he from the day he began campaigning for the presidency, he would be the smartest man to ever be president of these UNITED STATES. He took the republicans and their pundits lies, name calling and disrespect of his presidency. and just kept trucking along. Doing the business he was elected to do. Lots of times I wonder how he could take it but I guess that's what brilliant people do.They have no time for liars, and hate spewing, because he knew all along he was too smart for these ignorant people.
gparks
Fan of truth, justice, prosperity for all!
05:27 AM on 04/15/2011
True THAT!

Faved-1-

A Fan
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carolyn LeBeauf
12:01 AM on 04/15/2011
The praise Ryan for his bold and courageous move, but they won't go along with it because they don't understand that fuzzy math. Ryan is walking around the capitol like he is the big man. I am afraid what will him happen to him when his big ego deflates. The republican Party has taken 2 years , to make themselves the biggest joke, the congress of the UNITED STATES has ever seen. Mitch McConnell is the granddaddy of the jokers. I am so excited to have someone like SEN HARRY REID as leader of the senate and a member of the democratic Party. Thank you GOD.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Angie Tyne 1
I want my disagree button!!
06:28 PM on 04/14/2011
This is a test for Ryan. He is yet another 'rising star' in the GOP. Each one is tested to see if they can do well enough as salesmen. So far they have all washed out. Whoever can convince the majority of the base that his ideas are good wins the 2012 bid.
05:52 PM on 04/14/2011
They won't commit to anything longer than a bumper sticker.
photo
MED1025
Here to save the day
05:06 PM on 04/14/2011
To paraphrase Paul Krugman. This isn't a class war, its a war on arithmetic. The numbers don't add up.
gparks
Fan of truth, justice, prosperity for all!
05:30 AM on 04/15/2011
Ha Ha ... I hadn't heard that one!

It is certainly true! And President Obama CLEARLY said that in his speech and on the interveiw for ABC!

Fanned -154-
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dgjewel
09:47 PM on 04/16/2011
I'm so glad we have all of the brains and common sense on our side ! The GOP has zip ! None of them can compare.
photo
MED1025
Here to save the day
09:59 AM on 04/18/2011
Unfortunately, they have an excellent disinformation outlet (Faux) that dazzles those from the shallow end of the gene pool who gladly give them their votes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerry Vasquez
A Unapologetic liberal
04:10 PM on 04/14/2011
Very Telling, isn't it? When asked, on the record, one usually responses with no comment not this
kind of blather. That party has for so long just dealt with sound bites and sloganeering that the mere
mention of something concrete has them completely flabbergasted.
12:57 PM on 04/14/2011
They have no idea how to govern, how to make things better for anyone but the top 2%, and they only know how to do that because they are told.