More

David Goodman

David Goodman

Posted: September 25, 2009 12:37 PM

Death Panels are Real

What's Your Reaction?

In August, as the health care debate heated up, former Alaska governor Sarah Palin took to her Facebook page and declared that President Obama's health care plan would include so-called "death panels."

Many on the left were outraged. But, the truth is, death panels are real. They already exist.

Every day in this country, life and death decisions are made by for-profit insurance companies.

A recent report by the California Nurses Association found that the state's health insurers reject 1 in 5 medical claims. One insurance company, PacifiCare, rejected nearly 40% of all claims.

When Sarah Palin warns of government bureaucrats rationing your health care, she neglects to realize that health care is already rationed by private insurance companies.

Palin should look no further than the case of Nataline Sarkisyan. Back in 2007, the then 17-year old Sarkisyan was in desperate need of a liver transplant. But, her insurance company, CIGNA, refused to pay for it. Her family fought the insurance company tooth and nail to get her liver transplant covered. Nataline's case soon got attention in the national media. Facing criticism, CIGNA finally agreed to pay for the transplant. But, it was too late. Just hours after CIGNA approved the liver transplant, Nataline died.

This isn't to say that President Obama's health care plan will be perfect. No program ever is. But, without health care reform, insurance companies, whose only motivation is profit, will continue to decide who lives and who dies.

 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:14 PM on 09/26/2009
Every day in this country, life and death decisions are made by for-profit insurance companies.

Absolutely true and one has to determine who he or she would prefer to make these decisions: a for profit corporate bean counter or a not for profit government run health care program employee.
06:13 PM on 09/25/2009
Not just death panels, debt panels too.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Decipherer
Objects may be closer than they appear
01:50 PM on 09/26/2009
When it comes to health care, debt = death.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EbonBear
opinionated hairy man
03:19 PM on 09/25/2009
Many of us already knew this. The same people who complain about "government beurocrats getting between you and your doctor" (which wouldn't happen anyway) have zero problem with insurance company beurocrats doing the same. Given the choice, I'll go with the civil servants every time, they don't have a profit motive to deny you care.
02:54 PM on 09/25/2009
I've long found it ironic (but not surprising) that those who are against putting a cap on CEO's salaries are against not just health care reform, but have long favored abolishing the minimum wage. Executives in many industries who earn tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars still thirst for more money and absolutely could care less about tens of thousands of people dying every year due to no health insurance or the millions who have lost their jobs and their homes.

No country and no set of laws can regulate greed, but we do need laws that regulate the pernicious effects of unchecked greed. We won't even have a country left if things don't start to change for the better.
01:45 PM on 09/25/2009
Wow