David Heilbroner

David Heilbroner

Posted: December 14, 2009 01:37 PM

Evangelicals, Israel, and the End of the World

What's Your Reaction:
It's been just nine years since dooms-dayers expected the new millennium to bring the end of the world, yet the cry of "Armageddon" still rings out. Last month alone, NASA had to allay fears of a 2012 end-of-the-world scenario.

And why not? We all know humans are doomed. Either our sun will explode in a few billion years or God's wrath will consume the planet tomorrow. But few Americans have embraced the coming of the End Times as intensely as the Evangelicals profiled in Waiting for Armageddon, a documentary I co-directed with Kate Davis and Franco Sacchi, to be released theatrically in New York City, Providence and Boston in January. In the film, we join Christian Evangelicals on an explosive tour of the future as they see it, from anguish to the sublime perfection of a new world.

There are some 50 million Evangelicals in the US who believe in the literal truth of Bible prophecy. You can argue theological accuracy all you want. This massive block of citizens possesses unshakable belief that the end of the world will be heralded by a series of prophetic events some of which have occurred (e.g. 9/11 and Hurricane Katrina) some of which are ongoing (the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan).

I am not talking about Bible-thumping, street-corner ravers, though one or two do appear in our film. The people we profiled -- from Evangelical leaders to rank-and-file believers -- are for the most part formidable, intelligent, well-educated. And all are fixated upon Israel (the land of Christ's return).

Waiting for Armageddon opens with James and Laura Bagg, an attractive pair of 30-something jet-propulsion engineers living in Connecticut. Yes, Evangelical rocket scientists from the Northeast.

"We could be raptured out of this world during this interview," Laura says, referring to a miracle where all good Christians disappear from earth and rematerialize in the clouds as chaos seizes the world. "There will be car crashes and plane crashes. And the people left behind will be asking, 'Are they coming back for me?'"

Then James Bagg explains that, "You see God has a plan for the world and it all centers around Israel."

The Baggs are, in a way, typical. Millions of Evangelicals share one political belief even more sacred perhaps than opposition to abortion or same-sex marriage: The belief that Israel must remain a Jewish state forever.

If that sounds unfamiliar or contradictory, then you've never spent much time listening to Evangelicals. End Times theology declares that the Jewish people must maintain control of Israel and Jerusalem, and retake the Al-Aqsa Mosque (a/k/a the Dome of the Rock), or Jesus won't return. Period. Understand, they are talking about mankind's ultimate salvation. And if that means embracing foretold disasters and wars including the Battle of Armageddon, so be it.

Professor Gary Dickerson from the all-Christian Corban College puts it this way: "I don't look at the wars in the Middle East with the hope that things will work out. We've been told, Israel will experience this distress all the way to the end."

Thus comes the central political reality explored in Waiting for Armageddon: that Evangelicals risk creating what the Rev. Barbara Rossing calls "a self-fulfilling prophesy of death and destruction."

This is no small sect. Evangelicals control some 60,000 US radio stations. They meet in 25,000-member megachurches and sit on school boards and legislatures across the country. As the Rev. Mel White, former ghostwriter for Jerry Falwell and Billy Graham and Pat Robertson puts it, "They are everywhere and they are not going away."

Embedded in its dramatic illustration of the End Times, including a Christian tour of Israel, Waiting for Armageddon offers an object lesson: That if people believe their God has revealed the ultimate course of history, then nothing, not even war, with all its bloodshed and horror, is to be feared. It's a reality that, whether dealing with the Taliban or the Jews or the Evangelicals or even Sarah Palin, every leader -- religious or political -- needs to understand if true dialogue can take place. Because for a great many true believers, the end of the world is just the beginning.
 
It's been just nine years since dooms-dayers expected the new millennium to bring the end of the world, yet the cry of "Armageddon" still rings out. Last month alone, NASA had to allay fears of a 2012...
It's been just nine years since dooms-dayers expected the new millennium to bring the end of the world, yet the cry of "Armageddon" still rings out. Last month alone, NASA had to allay fears of a 2012...
 
Comments
444
Pending Comments
0
View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7  Next ›  Last »   (7 pages total)
Show: 
photo
NANANACHMAN   04:26 PM on 12/26/2009
I was driving down the freeway yesterday and was overtaken by four horsemen................. NBFD.......... I just down shifted, hit the accelerator and left them in the dust.................this happens to me at least once a month.
Louey   12:56 AM on 12/21/2009
All anyone has to do to form an intelligent opinion of the glorious "rapture" promoted and merchandised by Lindsey, LaHaye and other rapture barons is to read "Pretrib Rapture Dishonesty"on Google! Louey
telogaman   12:30 AM on 12/19/2009
It is incorrect to say the end of the world. According to the bible the world never ends. Only it will be the end of this age. After Armageddon Christ reigns on earth for 1000 years. After that the final judgement occurs and heaven will be on earth. A remodeled and improved earth I think.
Mark Cline   03:36 PM on 12/18/2009
There are three secular scenarios that can transpire. The dollar has collapsed, there is so much M3 money being printed that it has stopped reporting that economic benchmark. The fed. reserve chief said the depression was extenuated by printing more money to pay the debt, exactly what has and is transpiring. The world bank will be centered in New York, founded by the Rockfellars, (again). So, when Pres. Obama authorized the EPA to regulate carbon emissions, he will set the ground for a new tax for you. He knows cap and trade won't pass. So, your energy bill goes up 2 times, on top of your groceries up 2x, then of course gasoline at $9 a gal. Then, if that is not enough, rampant inflation of your worthless dollar, when the fed raises the interest rates. Then again there can be hyperinflation, you know, where you take a wheelbarrow of hundred dollar bills to get a loaf of bread. Then again, A eletrical magnetic pulse bomb by Russia, China, Chavez, Iran, or China, here we have no electricity, everything you depend on now, won't work. So, you're in the concrete jungle, You already lost your health care, job, pension, your stock portfolio, Poof gone in an instant. So, what are you going to do, besides hating Jesus and blaming the Christians? You don't realize yet that you are without a hope.
Signed: mark cline, Oklahoma
Gods Green Earth   01:51 PM on 12/18/2009
To comment on why Jesus did not "take over" Rome when he was on Earth the first time-if he had subjected the Fallen World to embracing his teachings by force, that would entirely miss the point of his birth, teachings, death, and resurrection.
Besides, Jesus tells us that Satan is the "Prince of the Earth" as evidenced when Satan tried to tempt Jesus to flip sides before he was crucified for our sins. Jesus rebuked him, and allowed the death sentence to be carried out.
Also, if you don't think that there are any Doomsday Scenarios for some in the New Age, Occultists, and some Agnostic communities; just travel down to the Buckle of the Bible Belt and visit the "Georgia Guidestones" in Elberton, GA.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgia_Guidestones

Lastly, to pigeon hole Evangelicals in to a universal position of IF & WHEN a rapture will occur shows ignorance of the debate that is on-going in the body of Christ. There are pre-tribulation positions, along with mid-trib, post-trib, etc. Many of these positions have Believers partaking in the Tribulation that will come to pass until the Day of the Lord comes, when Jesus will come down to rid the world of wickedness once and for all.
photo
Puller58   09:49 AM on 12/16/2009
Our education system cannot compete with the Creationist pinheads.
photo
GenosseJoe   08:42 PM on 12/17/2009
let's see what do we learn in that school:

1. How many elements make up an average DNA?
2. What is the mathematical possibility of two-three-four random mutations of these elements making up something useful for the next level of evolution instead of sick creature ?
3. What natural selection does with the creature, who is simply less adopted than average DNA standard of the species?

Simpler task would be to randomly change letters in the computer program and expect it to evolve into more useful program.

Don't you see, that Darwinian own law of natural selection makes his evolution virtually impossible, after we learned about the real size of the genom.
fdavis99   04:56 PM on 12/29/2009
Actually, computer scientists DO use random mutations to computer programs to evolve a more effective solution to a problem, in a technique called "Genetic Algorithms."

The success of crossover / mutation / selection in improving computer programs is a good analogy for biological evolution -- and because it runs in a short time, we can "see" evolution working, which supports the fact that evolution is what has created all the life forms on earth.

You can see one here: http://math.hws.edu/xJava/GA/ -- This program randomly mutates and cross-breeds the most successful "plant-eaters", and over many generations their eating "scores" go up and up.

Or, you can be the force of natural selection in this demo: http://www.rennard.org/alife/english/gavgb.html

http://geneticalgorithms.ai-depot.com/Tutorial/Overview.html -- A fairly simple, understandable explanation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_algorithm -- A detailed explanation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Guitanguran   06:54 AM on 12/16/2009
"...Waiting for Armageddon offers an object lesson: That if people believe their God has revealed the ultimate course of history, then nothing, not even war, with all its bloodshed and horror, is to be feared. It's a reality that, whether dealing with the Taliban or the Jews or the Evangelicals or even Sarah Palin, every leader -- religious or political -- needs to understand if true dialogue can take place. Because for a great many true believers, the end of the world is just the beginning."

It's here that Mr. Helbroner reveals his true intentions:

"It's a reality that, whether dealing with the Taliban or the Jews or the Evangelicals..."

Mr. Heilbroner wants to create stew of moral equivalency comprised of these three groups where none exists. It's also telling that the president of Persia has made clear to us and the UN that its his goal to hurry up the apocolypse he believes in, and yet Mr. Heilbroner makes no mention of him at all.

and of course:

"...even Sarah Palin..."

This is the most telling aspect of Mr. Heilbroner's slant on his documentary.
photo
belly dancer   08:07 AM on 12/16/2009
Are you saying he has a leftist slant? this is a left leaning web site everyone knows that. You act put off that the doc might be slanted that way. it would be like me frequenting redstate.com (you know just so i can comment there and be an obnoxious a.s.s) and then complain in a thread about Glenn Becks new book that it is slanted to the right-wing and act putt off by it. how much of a d.i.c.k would that make me?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Guitanguran   10:44 AM on 12/16/2009
According the American Heritage Dictionary, the adjective is defined as:

"Presenting facts objectively without editorializing or inserting fictional matter, as in a book or film."

Based on Mr. Heilbroner's remarks, I'd say he hasn't adhered to the objective facts and non-editorializing criteria indicated above.

Perhaps a new category or genre may be required for films like this. 'Mockumentary' comes to mind, but it appears Mr. Heilbroner is more serious about Evangelicals and Sarah Palin than that. Maybe 'opinionentary' would suffice.
photo
SpoonieLuv   01:20 PM on 12/16/2009
I think what Mr. Heilbroner is trying to demonstrate is not a moral equivalency between the groups that he (and you) mentioned, but is trying to say that Evangelicals view all of these groups through the same worldview, and that this skewers their analysis of reality, thus replacing objectivity with superstition.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Guitanguran   02:01 PM on 12/16/2009
I think Mr. Heilbroner was pretty definitive by HIS grouping all three with the same perspective as to eschatology, which they do not have.
universal me   03:46 PM on 12/17/2009
This is my first visit to this site...all I can say is "Dear Lord!

I knew that society was on a downward spiral, but the foolishness of the comments on here really took me by surprise...

With rare exception, it seems that at least the people who comment on here are as intolerant as any group of people I've ever met...you mock Christianity, morals, even God Himself...

I pray your eyes will be opened before its to late...there "will" be a rapture, and sooner than later...God is merciful, but if you reject Him, you have no one to blame for your eternal abode but yourselves...

The fact that so many of you (almost ALL of you) are so arrogant about your beliefs, or I should say, lack thereof, is evidence of the Bible's accuracy....it says that in the last days there will be scoffers, and I'd say that about sums it up concerning you guys....wouldn't you?

Open your eyes people....hell may be a dry heat, but it's still "HELL"!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fireslayer   01:55 AM on 12/16/2009
This article is a prime reason to never, ever vote for a Republican for anything.

Do we really want people who pray for Armageddon anywhere near our nuclear weapons or control of same?
Chicagofan1   10:25 AM on 12/16/2009
Ignorance is at it's pick.
Justtellthetruth   12:13 AM on 12/16/2009
The thing that is most perplexing about these people is that after all of their biblical machinations and torture of the scriptures, all of which is necessary to make Christs message of love into one that instead focuses on a war like return to earth over what appears to be the worlds biggest real estate tiff, it seems utterly lost on them that Christ, when he was here the first time, had ABSOLUTELY zero interest in taking the land of Israel back from the Romans who occupied it at the time. NONE.

Instead, he lamely spent his time preaching that we should love each other in the way that we ourselves would want to be loved, and that treating the least of our brothers poorly was tantamount to treating Him (Christ) in that fashion.

The "promised land" is the salvation of mankind, and not some nice seaside real estate. The temple is in your heart. The world is going to end for you and I when we each pass away.

These people have so much narcissistic self involvement that they want to believe that THEIR lives will end in some much more special (and privileged) manner. much like the crusaders in the middle ages who murdered the Jews in Jerusalem (in Christian vogue at the time) believing that THEIR violent and detestable narcissism was the true interpretation of Christs relatively simple message.
photo
Cambridge9   10:13 AM on 12/16/2009
Bingo!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kaviraj   12:23 PM on 12/16/2009
Faved and fanned.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Guitanguran   12:41 PM on 12/16/2009
The problem with your premise is that there is only one message.

There are two:

Love, Mercy, and Grace

and

Judgement
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kaviraj   12:50 PM on 12/16/2009
Don't appeal to the department of justice then. We are all guilty. Appeal to mercy & grace, for justice without mercy & grace is revenge.
Mark Cline   05:28 PM on 12/17/2009
Secularly speaking in 1754 a bible scholar named Bishop wrote many essays on the endtimes, he was read and known by our first president G. Wash. Wash. helped design our dollar bill. If you look on the back of it you will find the star of david, made of stars. One of the reasons he did this was a debt that all Americans owe. It is a debt of honor that cannot be repaid. The Salomon brothers made approximately one million in bonds to support the Revolution and the Continental Congress. Washington's men were at the time, in the winter, boiling their boots and eating them. So, the cannons, gunpowder, food, and monetary support was provided by the worldwide Jewry.
I am a direct descendant to Henry Clay Cline, a officer with G.Wash's. Calvary. so I am very aware of what transpired at that time. I know that only 4% of the citizens would support the Revolution, much less fight for it. The Founding Fathers were Christians, they were very literate and well studied. In support of this statement, please go to WallBuilders a web page by David Barton, who can document these statements, because he has a great store of historial information.

Signed: Mark Cline
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shane Hatch   05:31 PM on 12/15/2009
It's no wonder the world is such a mess--there's 50 million americans doing all they can to destroy it to prove that their doomsday prophecies are true. Oddly, these same people usually claim to be "pro-life'. [How can one be pro-life and be working for the destruction of life as we know it?] Fundamentalists of all religions prove how dangerous religion can be, and I personally think we need to give up on freedom of religion and ban these destructive groups and arrest their leaders.
DeniseA   07:06 PM on 12/15/2009
Exactly what are the Evangelicals doing to destroy the world?!
photo
JohnFromCensornati   07:15 PM on 12/15/2009
Exactly what are gay people are doing to destroy the "sanctity" of the English word "marriage"?!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shane Hatch   08:02 AM on 12/17/2009
they generally oppose environmental regulations, birth control/abortion, and general support war and continued arms build-ups. in other words, they want us choking on dirty air, drinking dirty water, being run into extinction from over-population, and killing one another through war. BTW, I think a more accurate term would be fundamentalists, not evangelicals, which is who the film discussed in this article is about.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
cordyc   05:29 PM on 12/15/2009
Glad awareness of this cult is raising. They are especially active in local elections and school boards. Why do you thing so many schools banned Obama's back to school talk?

If you do not want to be run by these people then get active at the local level, state level and nationally. Our survival as a secular society depends upon shining the light on this system of belief.
GsusFreek   04:39 PM on 12/15/2009
Correction. Scripture does not say Israel will have to retake the Al-Aqsa Mosque. It simply says they will build the temple. Many scholars agree it appears the temple can be rebuilt without disrupting the Mosque. But ten points to the author for slyly referring to educated believers as educated/but still dangerous extremists. Someone is wrong. We'll know soon enough. Wink wink.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
guitargeorge1964   09:17 PM on 12/15/2009
Man, I hope the rapture comes soon. wink,wink. Can I have your car when you're gone?
photo
CarmenCameron   03:19 PM on 12/15/2009
Love of conflict is inevitable for people who believe in a schizophrenic "god" who loves and hates with an arbitrary abandon virtually identical to us mere mortals. And while that is clearly not the God of Jesus Christ, "he" is the absolutely perfect projection of the pathological portion of our human population (of every creed).
bobwalters   11:32 AM on 12/16/2009
Well said. They love the conficts because THEY will be sucked up into the clouds while everyone else endures it...so they have no problem fomenting such conflicts. They are truly pathological, as is most religion, which promotes ignorance and animosity toward anyone who disagrees. On one level, these people are truly pathetic, in that they are so bereft of healthy self-regard as to require this sort of "membership in an exclusive club" to feel worthwhile. "End-times" predictions are little more than elaborate fantasies by weak, down-trodden people, essentially shaking their fists at their oppressors, and saying, "Boy, you are gonna get YOURS some day!"

It is also testament to the human capacity to compartmentalize reality to come up with such bizarre beliefs. Cro-magnons and Neanderthals I can understand embracing some mythic power to explain phenomena they had no ability to fully grasp. Modern man, not so much. If the 50 million figure is correct -- and I don't doubt that their numbers are large -- then we're basically screwed as a species.

Heilbroner didn't bother to include, BTW, all the other rabid religionists in the world: Zionists (which is more political than religious, although not above using religion to "justify" whatever they want), radical Islamists, nativist "religions", etc. They're all of a piece, and clearly dangerous to children and other living things.
northstar11   03:18 PM on 12/15/2009
nurturing of cults is the ultimate folly of humanity.
bobwalters   11:33 AM on 12/16/2009
Co-sign.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
PWM   01:36 PM on 12/15/2009
In the New Testament Jesus said he would return to judge eveyrone according to their deeds (not faith) while those then and there were still alive. St. Paul believed it would happen in his lifetime, and whoever wrote II Peter wrote it in response to the early Christian community wondering when the world would end.

Too bad Evangilogicals - humans may die off but the world will last until the sun vaporizes it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Guitanguran   02:32 PM on 12/15/2009
"In the New Testament Jesus said he would return to judge eveyrone according to their deeds (not faith) while those then and there were still alive."

Among other places, it refers to this in Matthew 16:28, the end of that chapter. One needs to carry on to the next chapter to get what Jesus was referring to.

Original text wasn't divided by chapters. We tend to forget that.

Likewise, Mr. Heilbroner needs to remember not to have a pre-conceived idea about his subject matter before filming.

Twitter Edition