Crossposted from Grist.org
On Thursday the University of Charleston in West Virginia hosted a debate between Don Blankenship, CEO of mountaintop-removal mining firm Massey Energy Co., and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., environmental lawyer and founder of the Waterkeeper Alliance. I kept up a running play-by-play that can be accessed by scrolling back through my Twitter feed, but I didn't take notes, so this is from memory and I won't be using direct quotes.
The mystery to me going in was why Blankenship agreed to it. What possible incentive is there for a corporate CEO to put himself in a risky situation, publicly defending a widely reviled product? What's the upside? Why not just buy some ads or hire more lobbyists?
Having watched the debate, I'm more mystified than ever. If that was supposed to be damage control, I'd hate to see damage. Blankenship had every advantage, with a friendly hometown crowd eager to applaud him and a moderator who helpfully read off pro-coal facts during commercial breaks, but he was painfully and obviously outmatched by Kennedy. I guess it's easy to get over-confident when you've effectively purchased a state government and broken the law with impunity for years.
He didn't seem even cursorily prepared. Kennedy reeled off fact after fact about declining mining employment in WV, the age of Appalachian ecosystems and the impossibility of recovering them after MTR mining damage, the enormous health and economic impacts of coal on Appalachia, the size of Chinese investments in clean energy, the number of Clean Water Act violations from Massey, and on and on and on. Every fact was geared toward a plea to West Virginians: look, this man is making himself rich by making you poor. He's sapping your state of jobs, income, health, and a future.
In response Blankenship had nothing but ressentiment and nativism. Over and over he dismissed Kennedy's facts as "rhetoric" and "just false" claims that "you can find on the internet," but not once did he refute or even convincingly contest a particular claim. He asked the audience to dismiss them based purely on crude stereotypes about out-of-state environmentalists.
His very first rebuttal drew on a familiar conservative trope: environmentalists are are overly emotional and rely on extremist rhetoric rather than facts and cool reason. But no sooner had the words left his mouth than he was talking about how the coal industry is really "your neighbors" and "Sunday school teachers," working to create down-home energy so terrorists don't come over and kill us. He warned that pesky regulatory constraints from do-gooders mean "we all better learn to speak Chinese." This is what reasoned, non-emotional rhetoric looks like, I guess: if you criticize my company you hate Sunday school teachers, love terrorists, and want to surrender national sovereignty to Red China.
When Kennedy accused him of leaving behind ghost towns across WV, Blankenship responded that he'd bought up all those homes at fair market value ("those people left voluntarily"). In response to Kennedy's points on water pollution, Blankenship effectively dismissed the threat of mercury as a bunch of hype on the internet. (If mercury is dangerous, he asked, how is it people in India live to be 79? Really, that was his argument. Apparently he's never heard of Minimata disease.) When Kennedy listed the social and health damages done by coal--"externalities" the industry charges to taxpayers--Blankenship mumbled, "do we have some of those externalities? I don't know. Maybe." When Kennedy pointed out that China is dumping trillions into renewable energy, Massey responded that they were only building windmills to appease the UN. When Kennedy pointed out that Massey's own disclosure revealed some 12,000 violations of the Clean Water Act last year, Blankenship responded that they're reducing their violations year to year, now that they've been reminded by the EPA that it would be a good idea.
In short, Kennedy was the encyclopedic superego of environmentalism and Blankenship was the raw id of crony capitalism.
I'll admit I've always been perversely fascinated by Blankenship. Most big corporate CEOs have mastered the art of calorie-free management speak. They've learned how to stay on message and skirt controversy. Not Blankenship. Not only does he openly flaunt the law and buy political access, he remains defiantly unpleasant in person, speaking in an affectless, heavily accented mumble. Watch toward the end of this video, the archival footage:
He still talks like that. He simply dismissed Kennedy's facts and stuck to his narrative: global warming's a hoax, hippie environmentalists are strangling free enterprise, out-of-staters have no right to question what happens in WV, and China is going to take over if we don't mine and burn all the coal we can as fast as we can. We're crazy to be worried about "parts per million" of pollutants when coal is the only thing keeping our life expectancy above Angola's. We're in a ruthless global competition for dominance and the most productive and efficient win, mountains and poor people be damned.
In sharp contrast to, say, Duke Energy's congenial, folksy CEO Jim Rogers, Blankenship fashions himself a hillbilly John Galt and doesn't give a f*ck what you think about it.
Why he'd want to take that act to a national audience is a true puzzlement.
Follow David Roberts on Twitter: www.twitter.com/drgrist
Kevin Grandia: Big Coal Running Attack Ads Against "Tree Hugging Extremists"
Massey Energy, a large coal producer in the country is running political-style attacks in West Virginia claiming that "tree hugging extremists and self-serving politicians" are killing jobs.
Jeff Biggers: Colbert Report Takes Down Big Coal: Save the Endangered Hillbilly (VIDEO)
Goodbye purple mountain's majesty--here comes Patriot Coal! Last night on the Colbert Report, Stephen Colbert hosted scientist Margaret Palmer in a brilliant takedown of the...
Could it be that Kennedy is for "green energy" as long as those nasty windmills do not spoil the ocean view from the Kennedy compound?
He has enough money to buy any politician and legislation he wants to continue to strip mine the tops off of mountains. The Supreme Court says so. It's just a matter of time.
On my way back to the Chicago area from a trip to New York city a couple of summers ago, I took a side trip to Falling Water and drove through Greene County to get to I-79. It's a beautiful part of a beautiful state, and its sad to learn about the destruction that comes about when people aren't able to protect their communities and their natural heritage from rapacious corporations. I feel like I am consoling you for a death in the family when I say that I am sorry for your loss.
Personally, it does not matter to me how strange a person's point of view is, how far to the right or to the left, so long as they are willing to try to discuss their views respectfully and honestly. From honest dialogue we can hope for progress and improvement.
These are the capitalist {teeny tiny 'c'} criminal terrorist of this country, terror comes in many forms and many ways and done by the few on the many!!
While I certainly would not say that I side with Mr. Blankenship economically or intellectually, I applaud his willingness to meet face to face with environmental lawyer Mr. Kennedy.
Here in Orange County, CA, I find myself surrounded by people with radically different views from my own. Most of those I talk with do not even accept the theory of Evolution as a working model, but I find that I have been able to make friends with most of my neighbors. We need to want to get along with people, even when we cannot agree on religion and politics. By wanting to get along, we do not needlessly insult one another, and interpersonal friction is reduced.
It is when cordiality is rejected out of hand that we are on the verge of real trouble.
If you are interested in alternative energies and environmentally-friendly technology, check out http://www.greencollareconomy.com. It has hundreds of case studies on green tech and the largest b2b green directory on the web.
Natural gas phasing into wind, solar and tidal energy.
I am disgusted with the destruction of W.VA, and parts of western VA by these mining companies that come in, rape the land, and walk away. They are a blight.
However I know Don well, have been to his home many times, coached his son in soccer, and his kids and mine were friends. He is one of the nicest, gentlest, most generous men around. If the school or youth group need something, they get it. If a friend or neighbor needs something, they get it. His wife is also wonderful, the stereotypical Appalachian country girl.
This has always put me in an awkward position, as I respect and admire the man in his personal life, and am disgusted by how he earns his millions.
I wonder if you are real, by the way? He is divorced. Maybe he is remarried. But he should not be allowed around children. He should be in prison, locked away forever.
Here is a map of current MTR areas. City sprawl of major US cities is destroying more area then MTR is. People like their suburbs though.
I don't know why you think he shouldn't be allowed around children. He actually likes kids better than adults and is a easy mark when any civic group raises funds for kids' projects.
BUT, I never saw him call Blankenship on any of the lies/innuendo he was posing that
this article accurately mentioned e.g. you just want to ship jobs overseas; out-of-staters
got no bidness even being here.
It was disappointing that RFK did not push back on some of those things because
I would not be surprised if the local audience thought Blankenship won the debate.
Plus, all too coincidentally, Blankenship is a prime example of why yesterday's Supreme Court decision on campaign finance is a disaster.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ian-millhiser/supreme-courts-judge-for_b_171498.html
I wish I could have been there to see it for myself. I've seen RFK speak and he is an amazing man; both patriotic and wise.
President Obama needs to subsidize alternate energy companies. It will create energy independence, create jobs for Americans, and fund our next industrial revolution.
Wow. Appears you are the one that needs educated.