iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dawn Teo

Dawn Teo

GET UPDATES FROM Dawn Teo

SB1070 Goes to U.S. Supreme Court, SB1070 Author to Be Recalled

Posted: 05/10/11 08:44 PM ET

After drafting Arizona's controversial new immigration law SB1070 last year, Arizona state Senate President Russell Pearce held the spotlight and became the anti-immigration poster boy in Arizona and across the nation. One year later, Pearce is on the verge of being recalled, and his pet legislation, SB1070, has been neutered by a federal court and is on its way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

In April, a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court's injunction against the most controversial parts of SB1070. Monday, Arizona Governor Jan Brewer announced the state of Arizona is appealing directly to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Meanwhile, nonpartisan group Citizens for a Better Arizona, co-chaired by a Republican and a Democrat, say they are on track to meet the May 31st deadline to submit the 7,756 signatures required for a recall election.

A Republican group, Arizonans for a Better Government had also been collecting recall petition signatures separately but shifted their focus to recruiting and grooming potential Republican candidates to challenge Pearce in the recall after it became clear that the nonpartisan group would meet the signature requirements.

Voters in Arizona's 18th legislative district say it's not just SB1070 that has motivated them to sign the recall petitions. In fact, some of the recall supporters I've spoken with also support immigration crackdowns. Most either feel SB1070 goes too far, or they are angry about other legislation Pearce has sponsored.

Although most of the enthusiasm comes from the Democratic side, many recall supporters are Independents and Republicans. Among them, "Russell Pearce is too extreme," is a common refrain.

I thought [Pearce] would be the answer to [immigration] problems, but now he wants to let people bring guns into our schools, and they gave money to businesses to build more houses. I'm stuck in mine. I can't get out from under it, and this guy wants to build more. I know I sound bitter, but this house is my life," said a longtime Mesa Republican who asked not to be named. He shook his head, adding, "I don't know the answer. It's not Russell, but I never voted for any Democrat either.

Business groups have stayed out of the recall fray but have worked hard to neuter Pearce at the capitol. According to the Yellow Sheet, a publication that monitors insider information at the Arizona capitol,

The passage of strict illegal immigration enforcement measures like employer sanctions and S1070 has led some to question the extent of the Arizona business community's clout at the Capitol. But the results of this year's session should put any doubts to rest: Big business remains powerful. Exhibit A is the death of five controversial immigration bills, which included legislation that backers hoped would prompt the U.S. Supreme Court to revisit the issue of citizenship. In addition to intense lobbying from chambers of commerce, CEOs of some of the biggest companies in Arizona put their foot down....

Brewer recently issued surprise vetoes on some of Pearce's pet legislation, including a birther bill, a bill that would have allowed guns on college campuses, and a bill challenging federal healthcare law. Brewer didn't hold back in her veto responses, saying the birthed bill failed "to do anything constructive for Arizona" and calling the gun bill too "poorly written" to become law.

Pearce has also come under fire recently for taking illegal trips paid for by the Fiesta Bowl. He and his wife traveled to Chicago and Boston courtesy of the Fiesta Bowl, even staying at the upscale Ritz-Carlton.

In past years, Pearce was criticized for his associations with self-proclaimed neo-Nazi J.T. Ready and for forwarding white supremest clippings via email.

Citizens for a Better Arizona also announced on Facebook that they have registered more than 1,000 new voters within the district. Most, they say, registered to vote in order to support the recall effort.

 

Follow Dawn Teo on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dawnteo

After drafting Arizona's controversial new immigration law SB1070 last year, Arizona state Senate President Russell Pearce held the spotlight and became the anti-immigration poster boy in Arizona and ...
After drafting Arizona's controversial new immigration law SB1070 last year, Arizona state Senate President Russell Pearce held the spotlight and became the anti-immigration poster boy in Arizona and ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Wischkaemper
12:53 PM on 05/26/2011
Ooops... Democratic Party Government.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Wischkaemper
12:53 PM on 05/26/2011
I think anyone who reads this will understand that SB 1070 may well do well with the Supreme Court.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2011/02/02/hint-supreme-court-rejects-rulings-row-west-coast-bench/

The Ninth Circuit Court has become a political arm of the Democratic Government. We shall see soon, and it should be a dilly.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
JessCostello
02:50 AM on 05/14/2011
It's interesting to see how this anonymous republican voting for the recall didn't even mention SB 1070. Why was it even included in this hit piece?
photo
Ice9
If money is speech, then speech is never free
03:25 PM on 05/12/2011
Russell Pearce is busy chasing his own ideological agenda, not the things Arizonans need. We need jobs and his efforts help to reduce tourism because of boycotts.

At least we have a State Firearm: The Colt, invented by a guy from Connecticut.
05:08 AM on 05/11/2011
This commentary is mostly overheated hyperbole to attract comments and generate controversy. OK, it worked because here I am. LOL!

First let's have a reality check: Given enough financial support to professional signature gatherers there is a good chance that enough signatures can be gathered to get a recall petition in place, but who cares? Russell Pearce has very broad support for a wide variety of reasons, tough immigration enforcement being just one of many. Pearce is very popular in his district and that isn't going to change because a small minority of lefties manages to stage a brain dead attempt to subvert popular will.

So, let's say somebody was foolish enough to run in the recall election to oppose Pearce. Do Democrats actually believe that they can get a fellow leftie to beat Russell? A more likely result would be that somebody to the right of Pearce would be elected.

Dawn Teo is a political analyst so she must have had a tough time holding back the laughter when she wrote this. In fact, I think it's legitimate to ask her if this is her attempt at political satire?

Anyhow, naive readers shouldn't be mislead by Teo's bombast because they will get unrealistic expectations that us Arizonans are going to dump Russell Pearce.

Personally I wish Russell Pearce would stop fooling around with lowly state level offices. He would be a great Representative or Senator and could probably win considering how weak the competition is from Democrats.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
joelwisch
01:38 AM on 05/11/2011
What a cute little piece this is. If you actually go to the Arizona Newspapers, the stories she cites don't exist. The Tucson Newspaper hates Pierce and they should have it all over the front page. Instead, another home boy from the Buckeye, AZ police department was murdered by a doper the California System let go a number of years ago, and didn't deport. Illegal aliens may be booted out by the citizens if this keeps up. The Democrats... nay friends.. the socialists who call Pierce too extreme are few and far between right now.
But.. it is a cute little piece.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:03 AM on 05/11/2011
That's funny, I went right to the Republic and found the story she cites up there, so that one sure exists. But you've got a point, sort of : I don't think the Star has it in for anybody named Pierce. If you'd start looking under "Russell Pearce" instead of "Russell Pierce", though, you might be surprised at all the news you'd find. Maybe that's why you've missed it; but then again, people only see the things they think they want to see.
photo
Ice9
If money is speech, then speech is never free
03:26 PM on 05/12/2011
Yes, I read them too. Wasn't difficult if you try.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Wischkaemper
12:57 PM on 05/26/2011
And that is why you linked them. Thanks.
11:04 PM on 05/10/2011
Maybe there's hope for Arizona yet.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rockyrococoAZ
ArizonaEagletarian (dot) com
10:32 PM on 05/10/2011
Excellent report. There will be dancing in the streets when the recall petitions are filed this month!
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
JessCostello
02:53 AM on 05/14/2011
Doesn't look like he'll be in any danger of being defeated.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rockyrococoAZ
ArizonaEagletarian (dot) com
12:49 PM on 05/14/2011
Don't be so sure...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Marla Turner
10:11 PM on 05/10/2011
I was having a crappy afternoon and then I read this. See, we're not a hopelessly stupid society.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
JessCostello
02:54 AM on 05/14/2011
Maybe, maybe not. It's quite ridiculous that a wealthy nation with 200k+ troops scattered around the world can't be bothered to secure it's southern border. Mind you it's the same nation that put a men on the moon.