More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Deepak Bhargava

Deepak Bhargava

Posted: July 1, 2010 12:04 PM

Immigration Reform Today: President Leads, Republicans Obstruct

What's Your Reaction:

Today, at a speech at American University, President Obama reiterated his support for comprehensive immigration reform. He said:

The question now is whether we will have the courage and the political will to pass a [comprehensive immigration ] bill through Congress, to finally get it done.

The Democratic Leadership in Congress has stated its support as well, as has a vast majority of Americans. According to a recent poll sponsored by America's Voice Education Fund, and conducted by Lake Research Partners and Public Opinion Strategies, 78 percent of all voters support comprehensive immigration reform. The controversy over Arizona's decision to usurp federal power and implement racial profiling as a solution to our immigration crisis would seem to have put this issue and America's frustration with lack of action from Washington on the front burner.

Problem? There is a huge stumbling block and it's called the Republican Party. Instead of even attempting to find common ground or proposing a solution, they've resorted to vilifying immigrants and fabricating stories to incite Americans' insecurities. Former advocates of comprehensive immigration reform have turned their back on what they once hailed as a practical solution. Sen. Lindsey Graham, gone. Sen. John McCain, gone. Sen. Jon Kyl, gone. Why? To even novice political observers, the answers are apparent. Threatened by a wave of racist tea party pressure, they've chosen to side with the racists over immigrants despite polling that shows the vast majority of Americans want Congress to fix this broken system. Specifically, it would seem Kyl and Graham are protecting McCain, who is facing a rabid anti-immigration nut, disgraced former Rep. J.D. Hayworth, in the Arizona Republican primary.

To be clear, Republican obstructionism isn't limited to the issue of immigration. Across the board, the GOP has chosen to put politics before the interests of their nation. Quite simply, they would rather do political damage to President Obama than work on solving America's problems. They've denied the unemployed access to jobs and assistance, they've tried to block Americans from access to quality affordable health insurance, they've sided with the millionaires of Wall Street over working Americans in the financial reform fight, and they are standing with BP rather than helping address our critical energy security and environment crisis. It's little wonder then that they are willing to demagogue and sacrifice immigrants for the sake of perceived political expediency.

If you think my words are too strong, than consider some of vile comments and completely off-base hysterical statements from Republicans:

Arizona Republican Gov. Jan Brewer, apparently buoyed by enacting SB1070, a law that begs for racial profiling, made a whopper of a statement saying that most undocumented immigrants are drug mules, a claim even the conservative National Border Patrol Council called unfounded. Days later, in an attempt to give credence to her claim that Arizona is suffering from out-of-control border violence, Brewer claimed local law enforcement officers had found several beheaded bodies in the dessert, but medical examiners who investigate all suspicious deaths said they hadn't seen not even one such case.

The author of Arizona's SB 1070 law is state Sen. Russell Pearce. Pearce is a well known white supremacist and has other racist ties that have been profiled by Southern Poverty Law Center.

Sen. McCain, in a quest to appear hawkish on border security and immigration, has set aside his integrity and honesty in a misguided attempt to appeal to extremists. He's not only is engaging in purely fictional fear mongering (FBI statistics show crime at an all-time low in Arizona and undocumented immigration at historic lows as well), but by identifying himself as "one of us," his advertisement is clearly engaging in despicable race baiting.

The President's speech makes clear where his administration stands. Now it is a time for Republicans to either stand with Americans who want a practical solution to our broken immigration system or continue down the road of un-American obstructionism and open flirtation with racist extremism.

If you'd like to join the call for Republicans to work with the President on immigration please call (866) 563-5608.

 

Follow Deepak Bhargava on Twitter: www.twitter.com/communitychange

 
 
  • Comments
  • 114
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Marie Russell-Barker
Grandmother
06:41 PM on 07/05/2010
I can understand not voting for something because something maybe in the bill that you may want to ask your district about before voting on it, what is confusing is that a Representative or Senator would not vote for something because they belongs to the same party. I can not believe that those who are truely Republicans, would want their Law Makers to just not vote to make a point. Their voices have been drown out by the Tea Party, who are for hate, and injustice, big oil and businesses and not for the common man of today, I think that the true Republicans are just as unhappy as we are but thanks to those who carries the biggies mouth and sign their voices have been drowned out! I believe that as a people regardless of which party they vote for they want a fair and effective solution to immigration we all do we are tired of fighting against ourselves, we all so want a strong jobs bill, so what if we are in debt. Once we have jobs and get the country back to running we will repay those we owe, but first and far-most get these thing together so that we can all move on!
02:07 PM on 07/02/2010
Obama did a fine job of forcing the Party of NO to make a choice on this issue. Cant wait to find out what side they choose.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ALRIGHTALREADY
02:32 PM on 07/02/2010
No , Gitmo isn't closed
No, unemployment didn't stay below 8%
No , porkulus hasn't worked
No , after 75 days the Gulf is still not contained
No , ObamaScare Healthcare isn't worth a damn, and is costing all of us

So actually the President of No and Pelosi and Reid are the No crowd
06:15 PM on 07/02/2010
No,Gitmo isn' t closed- SO?
No,Unemployment hasnt stayed below 8% - Ressision hasnt affected where I live
No, Bush's porkulus didnt work either
No, The Gulf spill hasn't been contained-But would it have been if you were President?
No, Obamacare is worth it cause Health care is a right!
07:30 PM on 07/02/2010
I doubt you would give credit for anything Obama has done. I do feel the stimulus has helped...there are many people teachers, and other workers who would not be employed today if it were not for the stimulus. On the oil, are you suggesting we nationalize the oil companies since that is about the only way the federal govt would contain the oil???? The oil leak is not a natural disaster...Healthcare reform is a first step - as we know the party of "no" did their best to water it down. Shows me the repub are more concerned with party preferences and not concerned with the country and citizens...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cdouglas
ignorance is nothing to be proud of
02:00 PM on 07/02/2010
First let me state I am what you would call a Liberal. However, I have very mixed feelings when It comes to immigration reform. On one hand, people who break our laws and come here illegally, are breaking the law, no if ands or buts about it. I live in L.A. where I see that illegals and legal immigrants communities live together enjoying the many benefits of America. But our system can not support every person who wants to come here. It would be great if we could, but we can not. We must be realistic, so what can we do that is not an extremist position? It certainly doesn't seem beneficial to grant everyone Amnesty, nor round everyone up and send them back. That being said, I truly think this COULD have be a bipartisan effort with real results, yet the Repubs are refusing to cooperate. It is very unfortunate.
photo
CelticMajic
The answer lies in each of us individually
11:52 AM on 07/02/2010
1. Secure the boarder
2. Sevier penalties for those that employ illegal aliens
3. Deport any illegal alien that breaks our laws
4. Citizenship for those here illegally, sure, go back and get in line like everyone else
photo
Alwayspissedoffatsomeone
Fighting for Common Sense
11:14 AM on 07/02/2010
You don't need reform if you simply enforce the laws already on the books.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
quillerm
10:36 AM on 07/02/2010
The fact is that over 70% of US citizens (voters) are in favor of the Arizona Immigration Law and Immigration is one of the top 5 issues voters care about. That translates to strong support of politicians who support the Arizona Law and similar laws that are being considered in 23 States.
The liberal media will continue to downplay the massive support for secure borders and screening of persons entering the US. But it all comes down to the fact that Americans will welcome immigrants to our country as long as they do so legally. This is necessary to protect the security of our Nation and more importantly protect our famlies from harm. Over 90% of Illegals are Hispanic who believe that they have special rights over all other Immigrants. They push to the head of the line demanding instant citizenship while other Immigrants that obey our laws must go to the end of the line. That is true racism.
01:38 PM on 07/02/2010
Please source the "fact" that 70% of Americans support this law.

And further " Over 90% of Illegals are Hispanic who believe that they have special rights over all other Immigrants"...where do you come up with this stuff? You seriously believe that 90% of illegal immigrants believe that they have special rights over other immigrants??

Fail.
Gasparilla
bottled water = environmental disaster
10:36 AM on 07/02/2010
Whether Brewer was correct about beheaded bodies, the fact is that Phoenix police have found bodies in the desert that they suspect are connected to the wave of kidnappings in that city that have been going on for years. The federal Bureau of Land Management has put up signs in natural areas warning of danger from smuggling gangs and has closed areas of a wildlife refuge near the border completely. So trying to pretend that all is calm and peaceful is not quite the truth.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/22614102/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
quillerm
10:32 AM on 07/02/2010
Obama is not serious about his offer to Republicans as he stated that he refuses to secure the border until Comprehensive Immigration Legislation is passed. Why is he against Arizona's Immigration Law? It's because he wants Open Border for one reason VOTER FRAUD to empower Democrats in future elections. But what is the cost to America for Obama's propaganda? One reason why Obama needs to secure our border with Mexico. It is estimated 275 metric tons of cocaine crossed into the United States from Mexico each year. Law enforcement seized 36 metric tons a year on average Export quality heroin and marijuana produced in Mexico averaged 19 and 9,400 metric tons annually. Heroin and marijuana seizures averaged one metric ton and 2,900 metric tons a year annually. The export of methamphetamine into the United States exploded as indicated by the more than fivefold increase in seizures according to U.S. officials
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RickCadena
Born & raised in the Anglo neighborhoods (Mid-City
12:41 PM on 07/02/2010
For God's sake, who consumes all those drugs you talk about? Everyone in Latin America knows that Latin American nations such as Mexico, Colombia, Peru, Bolicia, etc. are merely the diving boards, but the swimming pool is the USA. Is that supposed to mean United States of Addicts? How about trying some internal reflection. Why isn't the USA doing anything to curb addiction? Why aren't top level US drug kingpins arrested? Everyone knows that a lot of the internal distribution of drugs in the US is run by the different gangs from US jails, regardless of whether they are white, black or latino gangs. The US has to clean its own house first!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cdouglas
ignorance is nothing to be proud of
01:41 PM on 07/02/2010
Judging by your paranoia and readiness to believe in conspiracy theories, I know exactly where the drugs are going.
DUSAA-1775
never moon a werewolf
09:30 AM on 07/02/2010
immigration reform: Arizona leads and Obama follows.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
enigma2
Enigmas are enigmatic..
10:16 AM on 07/02/2010
Gee, what a statement, is it based on any facts, or is what your gut is telling you.
Grunty1
Micro-bio this
10:32 AM on 07/02/2010
Arizona fumbles, and Obama recovers.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
enigma2
Enigmas are enigmatic..
12:19 PM on 07/02/2010
I believe Obama is trying to be a good prez. I wish others would give him the benefit of the doubt.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
AZreb
equal-opportunity Independent heathen
09:12 AM on 07/02/2010
Another "reform"? Since 1986, the last so-called "reform" of immigration, the federal government has not enforced the laws. BOTH PARTIES have ignored the problems of illegal immigration and now we are supposed to believe that another reform will have different laws that will be enforced?

There is nothing wrong with our immigrations laws, other than the fact that they are not enforced!
Grunty1
Micro-bio this
10:35 AM on 07/02/2010
[the last so-called "reform" of immigration]

That's why we need a REAL reform now.
08:53 AM on 07/02/2010
"President leads, Republicans obstruct"

What else is new?

Don't forget what comes next:

"President caves, ineffective legislation passed, no problem solved"
12:51 PM on 07/02/2010
Obama please enforce the laws as you swore you would.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Matthew Kolken
Immigration Lawyer
08:51 AM on 07/02/2010
The only thing Obama is leading on the immigration front is the race to deport as many immigrants as humanly possible in his first term in office with his 1,000 deportation per day mandate.

Since being elected he ramped up immigration enforcement to levels that are unprecedented, and are even beyond what we saw under Bush. The vast majority of his speech was dedicated to his commitment to vigorous immigration enforcement, and he scapegoats the GOP for his administration's own policies.

Obama continues to fail immigrants, and it is time that immigration reform activists start calling his bluff.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
enigma2
Enigmas are enigmatic..
09:07 AM on 07/02/2010
What's your solution to the immigration problem. What are the immigration activists solutions. People keep saying something needs to be, I have not heard not one solution offered as to what could be done.
09:20 AM on 07/02/2010
Listen to the President's speech at American University on the White House web site and you'll see the outline and rationale.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:38 AM on 07/02/2010
Comprehensive immigration reform in the Democratic view is. Illegal immigrants come out from the shadows, are documented with an ID, pay a fine for being here without required documentation, pay their back taxes, and learn to speak English. In so doing they are earning a path to citizenship.
Grunty1
Micro-bio this
10:40 AM on 07/02/2010
[Since being elected he ramped up immigration enforcement to levels that are unprecedented]

And why in the world wouldn't you want that??
08:50 AM on 07/02/2010
This was commentary is a concise summary of the choice we have as Americans. Do we support a fair, practical immigration reform package or do we allow ourselves to be influenced by cynical appeals to black and white thinking and scape goating. Jan Brewer has demonstrated all too clearly the caliber of leader she is by claiming beheaded bodies are popping up in the Arizona desert. This is sounding more and more like the Salem witch trials, hysterical claims, demonization, cruelty and group think. Everything the President presented was clear and practical, upholding the law without forgetting that we are a country of immigrants and that's what makes us great.
photo
CelticMajic
The answer lies in each of us individually
12:09 PM on 07/02/2010
We are a country of "legal immigrants" but then I guess you would rather it be a country of "illegal immigrants"
photo
CelticMajic
The answer lies in each of us individually
12:13 PM on 07/02/2010
Another way to ask it is, do we wish to be a nation of laws or do we think our laws are just suggestions to be ignored?
02:31 AM on 07/02/2010
Twice Bhargava pretty much states that AZ1070 is a racial profiling law. He either has not read the bill, or he is incapable of understanding what the bill says.

What he calls obstructionism is driven by no mood to compromise on anything immigration before the border is secure so that the flood of illegals can be stopped, and no mood to reward law breakers with an amnesty and citizenship. If Obama and his gang can start with these two points, then we can talk about the other details of immigration reform.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:38 AM on 07/02/2010
"He either has not read the bill, or he is incapable of understanding what the bill says."

Or he has read the legislation, he understands what the legislation says, and he is lying.
09:00 AM on 07/02/2010
Or he is right. That's my vote.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
enigma2
Enigmas are enigmatic..
09:14 AM on 07/02/2010
Obama and his gang? What gang? Cripes ..Bloods, are these the gangs you are talking about, or are you disparagingly referring to the people who work for our government. I talk Obama or his 'gang' are interested in anything you have to say.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
enigma2
Enigmas are enigmatic..
09:18 AM on 07/02/2010
...correction...I doubt Obama...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:27 PM on 07/02/2010
Crips? Bloods?

No. They are pikers.

Try the Goldman Sachs gang.
12:43 AM on 07/02/2010
I wonder if Bhargava supported scrapping Obamacare because most Americans opposed it?
Wait, I'm looking at his past articles. Just as I figured, no opposition to the bill.
09:01 AM on 07/02/2010
Another narcissistic claim. Millions of people supported it and worked hard for its passage. What are we just chopped liver in your book?
Grunty1
Micro-bio this
10:43 AM on 07/02/2010
Of course. The same way smillis is viewed by his masters.
11:10 AM on 07/03/2010
How is that narcissistic? I was simply pointing out his blatant hypocrisy. We should pass comprehensive immigration reform because most people support it, but we should pass obama-care even though most people opposed it.

Sure millions supported it, but millions more opposed it.