More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Deepak Chopra

GET UPDATES FROM Deepak Chopra
 

Medicine's Great Divide: The View From the Alternative Side

Posted: 06/07/11 01:17 PM ET

I might as well begin by being blunt. There is no love lost between the medicine I was taught in medical school and the kind I practice now, which used to travel under the name of mind-body medicine. It acquired ayurveda (the traditional medicine of India) along the way and now incorporates influences from many other strains of healing.
Continue reading at ama-assn.org

 
 
 

Follow Deepak Chopra on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DeepakChopra

I might as well begin by being blunt. There is no love lost between the medicine I was taught in medical school and the kind I practice now, which used to travel under the name of mind-body medicine. ...
I might as well begin by being blunt. There is no love lost between the medicine I was taught in medical school and the kind I practice now, which used to travel under the name of mind-body medicine. ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:05 AM on 06/26/2011
There is no such thing as "classic rock" or "traditional" rock. There is just Rock. In the same way there is not such thing a "traditional" or "conventional" medicine as chopra writes. There is just medicine and the treatment of patients. Sometimes tis is prevention. Sometimes this is stress management. Sometimes this is surgery and other times chemotherapy. Chopra perpetuates the division through s buzz words like conventional medicine. There is nothing conventional about life saving bone marrow transplant techniques. They just save lives. There is also nothing " alternative" about herbal medicine and mind-body stress reduction techniques. These are as mainstream as anything else. These artificial distinction perpetuate the multibillion dollar industries that prey on patients fears on all sides.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mehida-Loco
12:01 PM on 06/16/2011
marked
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jj
Pediatric psychiatrist and SoCal beach bum
10:12 PM on 06/07/2011
What a waste of energy to have a conflict; both types of medicine have much to offer to each other and our patients!

JJ Shaughnessy, M.D., M.P.H.
Star2000dancer
Pay it forward, the movie..
09:51 PM on 06/07/2011
I did not have to read further. I am stunned to see people being convinced it's better to put synthetic herbs in their bodies than natural herbs

Big Pharma has convinced the American people that surgery (mutilation) is better than say, massage therapy. It sickens me to see people begging for expensive, lethal drugs with deadly side effects. I fight to stop it everyday since I found out what was going on.

My family grew old and healthy with castor oil and baby aspirin. We rarely needed a doctor. When we did, there were always side effects or misdiagnosis. I can remember being awake having a tonsilectomy at 6yrs.

I could see all the doctors talking to each other, and not about me. You'd have thought they were out having a drink. I could feel the doctor pulling on my tonsils and I kept trying to ask him to look at me. He was'nt even looking at my face! His head was turned while he was down my throat, chatting with a nurse..

They lied to me when I did'nt want to take a shot. The nurse said OK, we'll take your temperature instead. I said OK. As soon as I rolled over, she lifted the blanket and shot me in my rear end. I screamed.

We paid cash for our healthcare, and got treated like that. Imagine what the "system" is like that everyone is fighting gor. WE need ":cures", not smoke and mirrors you've been getting.
07:13 PM on 06/07/2011
One love.0
This is a great article by Deepak Chopra. I love the way that he refers to the alliance between allopathic and alternative medicine as a marriage. I would like to know more details about how the marriage would look and feel like. For instance, would alternative health be available in hospitals and would medicaid and medicare pay for these services too? So far only 2 states accept medicaid for naturopathy,Connecticut and Arizona. How do we get the movement started to make it a 50 state reality.
I am also very concerned with the way in which the alternative health movement has focused almost exclusively on Eastern influences from China, India, Tibet to name a few. I would like to see more incorporation of African and Caribbean as well as Latin American influences.
Finally, I feel strongly that so long as the United States continues to be a de facto Christian nation we won't see the kind of "polyamorous" union and/or marriage that Dr. Chopra writes so well about between allopathic and alternative medicines.
Blessings.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ncyim
09:32 PM on 06/07/2011
I've had Native American medical treatments for trauma and whiplash = fantastic!
05:00 AM on 06/10/2011
Where did you find it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ncyim
10:26 PM on 06/12/2011
Hey MP146 - the system won't allow me to reply to you directly. That healer is in Boston - if that location is ok for you, email me: ncyim at hot mail. Japanese acupuncture and crainosacral treatment are also excellent therapies for whiplash.
photo
Kristin Talbott
One should always be a little improbable.
09:21 PM on 06/08/2011
A big part of what is stopping alternative health care from being embraced more is the profit motive (I know, duh!), but why this is so only partially makes sense. Obviously, Big Pharma and the medical/surgical device manufacturers and suppliers want to keep (and keep expanding) their market share. But from the point of view of insurance (be it Medicare/Medicaid) or private coverage, many of these alternative treatments should be vastly less expensive than the mainstream option. Why more insurance companies haven't embraced and encouraged the use of alternative drugs/therapies is beyond me.

I think your observation about the effect of our "de facto Christian nation" on healthcare is quite astute. Many (not all, but many) don't want anything to do with practices that stemmed from other types of spiritual practices. And they routinely get defensive at any suggestion that people's thoughts can have real, tangible, effects on the conditions of their bodies.

I think that ultimately, if the answer is "marriage," it needs to be an open one, with as many options as possible for as many kinds of treatments as possible. Medical decisions are amongst the most personal we will ever make, and the less ANYONE - be it doctors, government, corporate profiteers or religious groups of any stripe, infringe on our ability to make well-informed decisions regarding what is right for us, the better off we will all be.
08:13 PM on 06/09/2011
One love.

Thanks for this very insightful commentary about Dr. Chopra's article and my comment. I hope that we see some changes in the practice of medicine in the U.S. soon. I believe that with the advocacy and scholarship of scholars, healers, practitioners and patients we will win this. And we'll live to see the marriage flourish and open to become very loving. Blessings
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
macrocosm
We are sorry your micro-bio did not meet our guide
05:41 PM on 06/07/2011
Well said Deepak...

Like many things they change with the times, how much asbestos wall paper do you see for sale today? The same will go for "anti-depressants" & "anti-biotics" et al before too long.

I believe these two modalities must get back together! Do it for the children! lol Seriously though, western med has fantastic surgical and analytical capabilities and natural medicine is the proven balanced way to heal & strengthen.
01:23 AM on 06/10/2011
Antibiotics have saved roughly 200 million lives since the 1930s. Don't really see the abestos comparison here.
02:56 PM on 06/07/2011
I enjoyed the article, as always. There's one element missing though, and that's the political one. Medical practitioners nowadays are to a great extent puppets. It is Big Pharma that pulls the strings. And it is there, in the highly lucrative pharmaceutical industry, that the real fear of CAM lurks because it threatens profits.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ncyim
09:51 PM on 06/07/2011
So true! I think there is also some shenanigans between the big pharma and medical insurance cartels in preventing holistic practices from becoming more available.
photo
Bob Ellal
Diogenes man; qigong guy, cancer survivor
02:42 PM on 06/07/2011
Nice article. But part of the problem is that many alternative practitioners make extraordinary, unsubstantiated claims for their approaches that seem almost magical in nature. Certainly there is a mind/body connection. Disciplined qigong practice helped me beat four bouts of Stage four lymphoma in the nineties--it kept me calm strong despite the onslaught of two bone marrow transplants. But the chemo killed the lymphoma--my efforts just gave it a clear playing field to do its job. I'd never advise someone to approach a situation similar to mine by only employing the mind/body connection. I've been clear of cancer for 15 years and practice standing post meditation an hour a day. My oncologist told me years ago: "Don't stop doing what you're doing--we have no idea why the cancer didn't continue to metastisize, or why the high-dose chemo didn't destroy your immune system." But if I didn't have both--Western and Eastern approaches--I would've croaked 20 years ago and left a good-looking corpse. Well, actually, a very good-looking corpse!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David4FreePress
I am a volunteer, Tong Ren distant energy healer.
01:23 PM on 06/07/2011
Excellent article.