There is no period in the Gregorian calendar more demanding and transformative for diaspora Hindus than the weeks leading up to and culminating with Christmas. In daycares and schools, in workplaces and civic spaces, on television and in the digital media in North America, Hindus are constantly reminded about the holy days of Christians. Self-reflection is inevitable and inescapable when one is frequently enjoined to "Have a Merry Christmas" or even to "Enjoy the Holidays" when one sees no reason to celebrate the birth of Christ or when the days ahead are not considered holy.
With all of the marketing of merriment and conspicuous consumption, it is hard for diaspora Hindus not to feel left out, lacking, or deprived. This is especially true for the children of immigrants who are painfully aware of gift exchanges in schools and classrooms before Christmas and the plethora of presents that Christian classmates have received (made aware either after Christmas vacation is over or by observing the curbside evidence the day after Christmas). Christian classmates are stupefied that their "poor" and "downtrodden" Hindu friends have not received any gifts (confirming unfortunate stereotypes about poverty in India), and (seemingly delinquent) Hindu parents are forced to answer accusations of injustice and child abuse from their confused children.
Hindus have responded to the challenges of living in a Christian-centric society in many ways, though I will examine only two here.
Ho Ho Ho!: hota hai (you have to do it)
Many Hindus celebrate Christmas. Inundated by Christmas cheer and pressured by their children, Christmas has become part of the lives of diaspora Hindus.
Some have decided to celebrate Christmas superficially, as a mere commercial holiday. They purchase Christmas trees, gifts for one another, and encourage their children to enjoy the Santa Claus myth, in the same way that they may encourage their children to enjoy (and benefit from) the tooth-fairy myth. They classify Christmas as a secular, commercial, festival for children, in the same way that Father's Day, for example, is a festival for fathers.
Others utilize Hindu, specifically Vaishnava, theology to reconfigure Christmas to be a Hindu tradition. Vaishnavas believe that Vishnu has avataras (incarnations). These avataras of Vishnu appear and act in the world in order to defend dharma and his devotees. They characterize Christ to be an avatara of Vishnu. By including Christ as just another avatara of Vishnu, they indirectly make Christianity just another sect of Hinduism.
It is not surprising that the retail world has reacted to these markets in North America by making available Hindu ornaments that can be used on Christmas trees. Though the intended market is likely non-Indian, new age, yoga practitioners, it overlaps with diaspora Hindu families. The Christmas tree, a popular symbol of Christmas in North America is re-appropriated by Hindus and spiced with Hindu flavors.
No matter what narrative is given about the relevance of Christmas, secular, Vaishnava etc., many Hindu parents believe that they have to accept and celebrate it given the pressures of their immediate surroundings and shame that they will likely feel if they do not permit their children to have fun in these prescribed ways. Christmas celebration has become another dharmic obligation.
Yuletide Yatras (Pilgrimages)
Many diaspora Hindus make it a point to visit the local Hindu temple on Christmas Day. For those who see Christ as an avatara of Vishnu, a trip to the temple is no different than a visit to celebrate Krishna-janmashtami (the birth of Krishna). For those who do not envision Christ as a part of the Hindu pantheon their trip to the temple may be a chance to take advantage of the vacation day and to teach their children about Hinduism. Some temples even include Christmas Day in their "Schedule of Events" even though no special event is planned. The inclusion of a Christian holiday in their calendar signifies its importance in diaspora Hinduism.
This adaptation (or acceptance) of the Gregorian, rather than Hindu, calendar is further exemplified by the importance that is placed in many temples on New Year's Day (according to the Gregorian calendar). Many Hindu temples in North America include celebrations of the god Gaṇesh on New Year's Day. Gaṇesh is especially appropriate as he is worshipped as the god of beginnings and remover of obstacles.
In both of these cases, Hindus make pilgrimages to the local temples on days that are holy in the Gregorian/ Christian calendar, and certainly not in the Hindu calendar. Gregorian New Year's Day has been accepted, to some extent, as the beginning of the New Year and as a moment when the Hindu god Gaṇesh should be revered.
Hinduism has become part of the North American landscape as has the reverse. This is especially true if one examines the reactions of Hinduism to the Christian holy days that lead up to, and culminated with, Christmas and New Year's. There are aspects of Hinduism that make it amenable to change and to accommodation. The variety of Hinduism that is found in North America has adapted to these new contexts and cultural environments. In the process diaspora Hindus offer a desi (Indian) response to the December Dilemma.
Follow Deepak Sarma on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dsarma
The Hindu December Dilemma - Beliefnet.com
A Hindu Answer to the December Dilemma - Beliefnet.com
For many, December's a dilemma - CNN
Observing the Holidays as a Hindu - Christian Interfaith Couple
The December Dilemma: Acknowledging Religious Holidays in the ...
Rajiv rightly points out that x-tianity with its nicene creed and concept of abrahamic god will never mutually co-exist with hinduisms way of life.
it is totally impossible to combine the two - they are like apples and oranges.
hinduism & Krishna speak of divinity in all.
while jesus says he is the only way and all others are eternally damned. The two are totally incomprehenisble.
comparing Krishna to Jesus is like comparing Ganges to gutter water.
As Bengalis we don't have time like this during Durga Puja in October. For us, its basically its a big excuse to bake (and make mishti), be all the more mindful about charitable giving (food pantries and homeless shelters), and get time with family. To the extent that I have any traditions, ever since the third generation started rolling out I have been buying stuffed cloth ornaments with embroidery that were made in India (and sold here) that are grippy, they are strung together on the mantle at the grandparents' house. I'll give the lot of them to the nieces and nephews when they are older.
Hindus are a very accomidating people. I saw my grandmother going to churches, Masjids, Gurudwaras etc. This is almost 40 years back. The tolerant nature of Hindus made Hindu religion survive attacks from Islam and Christianity. Since we consider and respect gods of all religions, there was no nescessity of conversion.
So I think Christianity will be equally enjoyed by Hindus in USA. Who hates cakes anyway.
As a child I always preferred the 4th of July and Thanksgiving holidays because my Judaism in no way prevented me from their celebration. The more I wanted to be included the more I intensely I experience the pain of being the “other.”
Happily, these feelings eventually disappeared somewhere between adolescence and early adulthood, during that time of self-definition when the acceptance of my “otherness” became less of a lack and more of an attribute. And I suspect that this true of most non-Christians living in this culture. Hindu or Jewish, Muslim or Shinto – it’s part of our shared experience coming of age living in the Diaspora.
drawn by the hand of a humanbeing! out of the imagination of a humanbeing!
someone actually DREW a picture, of who s/he thinks "looks" like jesus.
and as if that is not enough, they added a picture of a woman with "jesus".
truly, you people makeup lies as you go along.
drawings out of their own imagination.
where did they get this "woman" from?
jesus never said anything about this woman.
so why draw him, holding hands with this woman?
other than forging history.
and they are floating up in the sky!
does anyone actually read God's book?!
so far fetched from the revelations about jesus.
pictures like this have caused people to disbelieve in jesus altogether,
because they wrap the truth of "jesus" with lies.
i feel bad for the innocent children who see this!
expecting people to believe that this is God?
two humans? holding hands?
come on people!
when i look around me, to the sky, that is real.
humans that i see, that is real.
the book that I read, that is real.
these pictures are someone's imagination.
i don't see the Creator, but i know He made it all, and the Creator, cannot be anything like the creation.
do yourselves, and your children some good. stop drawing and looking at these pictures.
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_3I6eIowAe7I/TH8IfL8BHNI/AAAAAAAAAz0/ueyBcoDyU_0/s1600/krishna-christ.jpg
What the picture is showing is they both walk on water. Look at the reflections of their feet. They are friends. I love this picture. It is one of my favorites. I love the peace on earth that it symbolizes.