iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Denene Millner

GET UPDATES FROM Denene Millner
 

Birthing While Black: An Experience I'll Never Forget

Posted: 01/30/2012 1:41 pm

There are a ton of things I'll never forget about the first time I gave birth -- showing up with a Donny Hathaway CD in one hand, a beautiful "going home" dress and blanket handpicked special for my daughter in the other, being scared to death of the epidural needle but grateful that it smoothed me out almost immediately, waiting for what seemed like an eternity to see my baby's beautiful face, how I seriously believe I saw a white light over my OB-GYN's head when she entered the room to help me deliver the love of my life. My daughter's baby soft skin against my breast -- her breath as sweet as Heaven. I imagine Beyonce, who gave birth just a few weeks ago to Blue Ivy Carter, her baby with husband Jay-Z, will have good memories, too, when the R&B superstar thinks back to the day she gave her most incredible performance, yet: giving birth.

But that is probably where our memories of that special day part. What I most remember? That the hospital and workers where I had my first daughter sullied what should have been one of the most amazing days of my life.

I gave birth at a hospital in upper Manhattan -- a renowned teaching hospital that, because of where it's situated, caters to a poor, uninsured community, but, because of its leading specialists, modern facilities and state-of-the-art technology, also is frequented by well-to-do patients who consider it one of the best hospitals in New York. They made it very clear in the brochures and birthing plans that a regular ol' birth there was neither more nor less than what a pregnant women could get elsewhere, but if you were willing to fork over an additional $800 or so, you could get the Cadillac birthing experience: a private room, extra personal time with your significant other, a special waiting room for family members replete with free refreshments, and a complimentary congratulatory meal -- two steak and lobster (!) dinners and champagne for two -- for the new parents. I promise you this: the words were so pretty I was convinced I was about to give birth in a posh hotel.

I did not.

Despite an incredible birthing experience facilitated by my personal angel/OB-GYN, from almost the moment my baby took her first breath, her mother was treated like a 14-year-old drug-addicted welfare queen, there to push out yet another daddy-less baby. Seriously.

  • They tested my newborn for drugs (though I've never taken an illicit substance in my entire life) without my consent -- something I later found out hospitals do at disproportionately higher rates with black babies than white ones.
  • Despite the fact that I paid for the private room and meals, I was immediately put in a massive post-birth room with three other women and their newborns. I was moved only after I asked why I wasn't in a private room -- a question that elicited scowls and foot-dragging from the nurse until she bothered to check my paperwork to see that, indeed, I'd paid for a private room. It took three hours for my room to be changed.
  • Once in the private room, the nurses disappeared for nine hours! Seriously. Nine. I had no diapers. No idea how to breastfeed properly (and no bottle or milk to feed my baby if I chose to formula feed). No instructions on what to do to care for my post-birth body (was it okay to walk? Pee? Wash?). Nothing. I seriously thought I was being punished for asking (nicely) for what I'd paid for. When a nurse finally did show up, she came with a "gift bag" full of formula and coupons for... formula.
  • The private "suite" was disgusting. The bathroom smelled like cheap, potent cleaning chemicals. The shower tiles were grimy and the shower curtain was full of mold. There wasn't so much as a picture on the bland walls. (I begged my back-up OB-GYN to let me go home after one night; thank God, she signed off on it).
  • The nursing staff was genuinely surprised (!) that the guy by my side, Nick, was my husband -- and actually said that stupid ish out loud.
  • Our special meal arrived only after we pointed out to the nurses that the fees we paid included it, and by the time it got to us, our dinner was cold and our champagne (a tiny hand-held bottle we could have finished with one big sip from the straw) was warm.
  • I couldn't get out of that place fast enough. And when it came time for me to have my second child, I stayed far, far away from that hospital -- even changed my ob-gyn, which really broke my heart to do -- to avoid it like the damn plague.

I wondered then what I know to be true now: It didn't matter how much money I had in my bank account or how good my insurance was, or that I had a ring on my finger, or that I was smart and accomplished, or that I tried to pay my way out of substandard service. At the end of the day, to almost everyone in that hospital, I was just another black girl pushing out another black baby and neither of us deserved to be treated with dignity or respect, much less special. That human beings charged with caring for new life and the people who ushered in that miracle could traffic in this kind of reprehensible treatment of anyone, much less a new mother -- no matter her race, financial or marital status, or background -- is beyond my level of comprehension.

But it happens. A lot. And there are studies that show that my birthing experience is a lot like that of other African-American women who've had babies in hospitals.

I bring up these things because earlier this week, the New York Times ran its story, "Chefs, Butlers, Marble Baths: Hospitals Vie for the Affluent," about how hospitals are creating special wings and services to attract and cater to the wealthy. The story, no doubt dreamed up in an editor's meeting after the whole debacle created after folks got wind of the opulent birthing suite and special treatment Beyonce got when she gave birth to Blue Ivy Carter at Lenox Hill Hospital, kind of makes it seem like this is some kind of new phenomenon. I know better, though. V.I.P. treatment, for those willing to pay for it, is not new. Neither is disrespecting and giving sub-par care to people, those extending care think are not worthy of VIP treatment.

And if you look like I did when I gave birth to my baby girl -- like an African-American woman giving birth to a black baby -- you are decidedly not V.I.P. Unless, of course, you are Beyonce. Then maybe you and your baby have a chance. This is, perhaps, the saddest of all.

This post appeared originally on MyBrownBaby.com.
 
There are a ton of things I'll never forget about the first time I gave birth -- showing up with a Donny Hathaway CD in one hand, a beautiful "going home" dress and blanket handpicked special for my d...
There are a ton of things I'll never forget about the first time I gave birth -- showing up with a Donny Hathaway CD in one hand, a beautiful "going home" dress and blanket handpicked special for my d...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 720
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (20 total)
10:40 PM on 02/25/2012
I'm sorry that your first experience giving birth to your little miracle was so miserable. Every woman, I believe, should remember their childbirth experiences as sweet nirvana. I hope your second birth was just what you wanted.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robjh1
We Have Met the Enemy and he is Us: Pogo
01:15 PM on 02/19/2012
Excellent story! It is sad that people whose job it is to administer to the sick and caring for new life have such disregard for human life and the human condition.
07:04 PM on 02/08/2012
As a nurse, I want to apologize to you for the horrible experience you had giving birth to your first baby. When I worked Labor and Delivery, I tried so very hard to make sure every new mom had a positive experience and it didn't matter to me the color of their skin, religion or whether they were drug addicts or the pillar of the community. I wanted the mom and baby to have the best care and a positive experience. I am white but truly feel we are all God's children. I am so sorry for your experience and I hope you will know that all nurses are not like those you encountered. Bless you and your family.
05:42 PM on 02/08/2012
Yet another reason to have home birth. Getting a good hospital and doctors etc are luck of the draw, imho. For me, I think there will be just as much risk having a home birth as one at the hospital. Hospitals are great modern marvels... with many pittfalls and I will NOT enable their poor behvior.
02:34 PM on 02/08/2012
this overwhelmed me with sadness. I hope despite the disrespect and downright lack of care, you were able to have a beautiful moment.
It's very sad that we are in the year 2012 and are still faced with racial issues. isn't it time everyone opened their eyes and realize we are all flesh and blood and bones after all. the same thing!
much love from South Carolina, Kim
11:47 AM on 02/08/2012
That is a sad story. I encourage low risk women to have home births. You are in control of your environment & birth experience. As a past birth doula & present postpartum doula I have attended many hospital births. They stress me out because they always want to take control away from the birthing mother. It is one of the most memorable experience in a womans life. We are strong & capable, yet they want to make us feel weak & dependent on them. Have a home birth & it will be a memorable moment!
03:33 AM on 02/08/2012
I am so sorry that there are so many people who did not say you experiences racism here. They can't see past their privileged lives and I'm so sorry you have to deal with that. Thank you for sharing your story.
06:28 PM on 02/07/2012
Thanks for posting this! I appreciate your perspective. As a postpartum doula, I have had African-American clients who were treated so disrespectfully by the hospital staff. One woman was refused drugs when she asked for it. Another one was asked 3 times if she wanted her tubes tied after giving birth to her 2nd child!
04:29 PM on 02/07/2012
It is sad that non-Black women lack the ability to insert a racial analysis into issues like these because their own experiences don't allow them to imagine race having any place in the conversation. In addition they often feel like adding race dilutes or deprioritizes their story (which it doesn't) and makes them feel less important. All PEOPLE who give birth experience birthing differently [queer women, trans folks, low-income people, people with disabilities and yes even Black women] We must not minimize the experiences of other people in an effort to focus the conversation on ourselves or because we are afraid we will be forgotten. This isn't a contest to see who is more oppressed but race does matter. Black infant/fetal mortality is significantly higher than that of White women and the value on Black life significantly lesser. Please, don't ignore the clear racism within pregnancy, labor and postpartum care. Acknowledge your privilege and support eveyone to have a empowering birth experience devoid of unnecessary medical intervention.
05:00 PM on 02/07/2012
I completely agree with you. But here's the thing: I'm not Black. In fact, I'm a white woman. So I feel that your statement that "non-Black women lack the ability to insert a racial analysis into issues like these..." is unfair because it IS a blanket statement that presumes that no white people know of white privilege and what that means. While I know damn well to never pretend that I know what the experience is, I can feel empathy and see very clearly that race had everything to do with this issue. And many others. I was lucky that in my education (in and out of the classroom) I was able to learn a bit about how systematic and deeply entrenched racism against Blacks is in our society and almost everyday I get to see it in action. I can never be Black. However, I do not believe that this fact means that I cannot empathize or even understand issues such as these. Most white people are not like this. I see it all the time. I argue all the time with people who want to turn a blind eye to racism because it doesn't fit with their "I'm a liberal therefore not racist" mentality. I think that the important thing is that people of ALL races be able to recognize the problems that white privilege has caused us all (including whites) and do whatever we, as individuals, can to work towards a better future.
03:04 PM on 02/13/2012
I'm pretty certain the author was not directing this article at folks who are able to recognise and own their privilege, but rather the people who aren't.
12:37 PM on 02/06/2012
I'm afraid that your experience probably had nothing to do with race. The way you were treated is Standard Operating Procedure in modern obstetrics. I (a 40 year old, married, professional, white woman) gave birth four months ago, and was treated like a petulant, moronic teenager at my local (AZ) hospital. Take a look at websites like www.myobsaidwhat.com and so may other birth-related personal blogs to reassure yourself: the medical birthing establishment doesn't hate blacks, they hate *all* women.
08:11 PM on 02/05/2012
I'd say if you're not living in nyc but in a smaller city your experience of giving birth would be totally different. It's not your race but the location that makes the difference. I totally enjoyed what happened to me in a hospital in north Carolina. Over there everybody got private birth room and good care regardless. Don't choose a hospital oriented towards large population with well fare if you want decent treatment.
03:35 PM on 02/05/2012
I AM PRAYING FOR YOU. I WISH YOU DID NOT HAVE TO READ ALL THESE NEGATIVE COMMENTS. ITS SAD THAT ANYONE CAN BE CRUEL ENOUGH TO TELL YOU THAT YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU ARE GOING THROUGH. ITS EASY TO KNOW IF YOURE BEING DISCRIMINATED AGAINST, AS A WHITE OR BLACK! RACE DOESN'T MATTER, AND THE PEOPLE WHO ARE DISAGREEING WITH YOU ARE PROVING THAT THEY ARE JUST AS BAD AS ANY RACIST FOR TRYING TO TELL YOU HOW YOU FEEL WHEN THEY COULDNT POSSIBLY KNOW! THANK YOU FOR SHARING YOUR STORY, ITS EXACTLY WHY I CHOSE HOMEBIRTH. GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bluespagan
Love is the Law, Love under Will
12:37 PM on 02/05/2012
I am sorry but you were not treated that way because you are black. I am white and I can say that my hospital stay after my glorious birth was really no different. The hospital I stayed at sound slightly better than yours but I was treated like a stupid white teenage girl who just pushed out a kid. They looked at my husband like some long haired (yes he had long hair at the time) hippie kid and one nursed even pushed him to the corner so she could get to me, like he didn't even matter. I decided to breastfeed as well and they did the same, pushed formula. It took them I don't know how many hours to get me to my room (paid for by my personally paid insurance) and it too was dumpy and old. The meals were supposed to be these wonderful healthy, organic and tasty meals, yet my meals turned out to be the opposite, more like small pieces of jerkey and vegetables. But you know, even with all that, my birthing experience was wonderful and I brought home a beautiful and healthy baby girl and thankfully only stayed at that hospital for a day as well.
12:24 PM on 02/05/2012
Assumptions based on color are always wrong. Racism still rears it ugly head from time to time. However, the nurses may have been inept, or indifferent. What is a magical moment for the birth mother, is routine day to day work for the hospital staff. Hopefully you filed a complaint about the conditions of the bathroom along with your OB-GYN, and also on the slowness of obtaining your private room. As for the stupid remarks about your husband actually being your husband..maybe they were jealous because they have none. It was ignorant on their part to even say anything about it. Married or Single Mother, all deserve great treatment as they push out the next generation of Human Beings of all colors and cultures.
10:47 AM on 02/03/2012
You could have used your writing abilities to bring this truly out in the open and maybe prevent it from happening to someone else.

Just sayin..