iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Derek Flood

GET UPDATES FROM Derek Flood
 

The End of Compassionate Conservatism? Why Jesus and Today's GOP Don't Mix

Posted: 08/29/2012 9:00 am

The official poverty figures for 2011 will be released by the U.S. Census Bureau this fall during the critical weeks before of the November elections, and, as the AP reports, a broad consensus of experts is expecting to see U.S. poverty levels reach their highest point since the 1960s when the war on poverty first began. At the same time, we are seeing story after story about the super-rich getting even richer, profiting from financial crises while the economy is plummeting, and stashing trillions away in off-shore tax havens.

This is an issue that can touch any of us. A recent national survey showed that one in three Americans are just one paycheck away from being homeless. Among those hit hardest by poverty in America are children. According to a report by the Children's Defense Fund, the United States ranks first in number of billionaires, first in defense expenditures, but was the worst among industrialized countries in relative child poverty.

With that background, the proposed GOP budget, spearheaded by Romney's VP running mate Paul Ryan, seems all the more shocking: As the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities reports, the Ryan/Romney budget would slash funding for low-income programs like Medicaid and food stamps (SNAP), while preserving tax cuts for the nation's most wealthy. Ever since Romney announced Ryan as his VP pick, his campaign has been desperately trying to spin this, and distance themselves from this shocking reality of what their campaign represents, but the facts are overwhelming.

They say you can judge a society by how it treats its most vulnerable members. Looking at the proposed Romney/Ryan budget, however, together with their campaign rhetoric where we see the poor being disparagingly characterized as lazy freeloaders while the ĂĽber-wealthy are lauded as "job creators," we see a perspective that completely flies in the face of the "Christian values" that Republicans want to claim to represent. As Paul Ryan said himself in a recent interview with CBN, "A person's faith is central to how they conduct themselves, in public and private." Yet the values expressed in his proposed budget are completely at odds with the values of Jesus who proclaimed "good news for the poor," and said that the true measure of a person's love for God is measured in how they care for (or fail to care for) "the least of these."

Of course one does not need to be a Christian in order to recognize the importance of showing empathy and compassion for those who are struggling to make ends meet, or to recognize the importance of caring for those who are the most vulnerable. Compassion is a value we all can share. However, one simply cannot claim to uphold Christian values (as Republican politicians and pundits are so fond of doing) when those values and priorities are the opposite of Christ's who spent the majority of his ministry caring for the sick, the poor, and the marginalized. Poverty was not a minor theme for Jesus, it was undeniably central -- both throughout the Hebrew prophets and for Jesus in the Gospels we see a continual emphasis on compassion for those in need. There are over 2000 verses in the Bible that call our attention to the plight of the poor.

Consequently, a number of Christian groups, including the Evangelical Sojourners, Catholic bishops, and even some nuns on a bus, have confronted Republicans on these policies which seek to build wealth on the backs of the poor. Still, these remain voices in the wilderness. For the most part, conservative Evangelicals still offer unquestioning support for the Republican party. But the fact is, a major change has gradually taken place in the GOP. Gone is the focus on "compassionate conservatism" with its legislation to help the poor, and in its place is an Ayn Rand philosophy that despises compassion as weakness, and idealizes the super-rich. So while Republicans may continue to use religious vocabulary in order to appeal to their conservative Christian base, they are nevertheless promoting values that are diametrically opposed to those of Jesus.

That's why I want to appeal here in particular to my fellow Christian brothers and sisters to recognize what is happening. This isn't anything new: Since Constantine, we have seen it replayed over and over. It's the age old story of the faithful being seduced by power, and it's time for us to wake up and take a stand, even if that means standing against the tide, even it means losing our seat at the table of power and joining the marginalized -- because that is where we will always find Jesus.

The plight of the poor in America is one that is often overlooked in political discourse. Lacking a powerful lobby, they are often not only the powerless and voiceless, but increasingly shortchanged and scapegoated. What we need to realize is that attention to the plight of the poor will only be on politician's radars if we put it there. We need to let them know that we care about those in need, and expect them to care as well. We the people, we the 99 percent, need to stick together. We need to make our voices heard before we end up with a government of the 1 percent, by the 1 percent, and for the 1 percent.

This post is part of the HuffPost Shadow Conventions 2012, a series spotlighting three issues that are not being discussed at the national GOP and Democratic conventions: The Drug War, Poverty in America, and Money in Politics. HuffPost Live will be taking a comprehensive look at the persistence of poverty in America August 29th and September 5th from 12-4 pm ET and 6-10 pm ET. Click here to check it out -- and join the conversation.
 
 
 

Follow Derek Flood on Twitter: www.twitter.com/therebelgod

FOLLOW RELIGION
The official poverty figures for 2011 will be released by the U.S. Census Bureau this fall during the critical weeks before of the November elections, and, as the AP reports, a broad consensus of expe...
The official poverty figures for 2011 will be released by the U.S. Census Bureau this fall during the critical weeks before of the November elections, and, as the AP reports, a broad consensus of expe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 407
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frjohnmorris
01:12 PM on 09/19/2012
There is nothing more dangerous than someone who confuses their personal political views with the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. That sort of mixture of politics and religion is why the Middle East is exploding today. Different people have different ideas on how to help the poor. I personally think that the best way to help the poor is to have a good economy so that the poor can get jobs. I also think that we need a little tough love to pressure the welfare class to work. Our welfare programs have not helped the poor. Instead of ending poverty, they have created a permanent underclass of people who live off of the labor of others through the welfare system.
11:19 AM on 09/07/2012
Mr. Ryan, I direct you to Mark 10:21
Jesus looked at him and loved him. "One thing you lack," he said. "Go, sell everything you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me."
01:07 PM on 09/04/2012
Re: "Yet the values expressed in his proposed budget are completely at odds with the values of Jesus who proclaimed "good news for the poor," and said that the true measure of a person's love for God is measured in how they care for (or fail to care for) "the least of these."
- The "good news for the poor" was not a prosperity gospel. Jesus was not a televangelist. It was a proclamation of God's love for all peoples. It was a revelation of promise, purpose and fulfillment of everlasting life; one which this world could never provide. Jesus is directly addressing to each one of us to rise up to the challenge in caring for "the least of these". It's our personal responsibilty to assist those in need. Remember the "Good Sumaritan" parable? I don't recall the "good sumaritan" after seeing the poor guy who was robbed and left for dead go to the local magistrate and complain about the robberies and tell them to take care of this mess because it is a result of failed policy.. He took matters into his own hands. He WAS God's love to this victim. What you say is true, that a true measure of a person's love for God is revealed through his love of neighbor.
12:46 PM on 09/04/2012
I know this is an opinion piece and you're trying to make a point. But as a Catholic I could agree to some degree on the application of certain policies that exploit the poor, but I disagree with the premise of your argument.

Re: "They say you can judge a society by how it treats its most vulnerable members. Looking at the proposed Romney/Ryan budget,..."
This is true, but...
Romney/Ryan are not "society" but elected officials of government. Government is NOT society. It was created by society so as to legislate and govern. They feel that society together with local government can better address poverty than the almighty federal government. The emphasis is on local community via Churches, families, community organizations, etc. The onus is on us to directly assist rather than the government.
I think it sounds less "christian" to abdicate responsibilty to our neighbors who are suffering and just push the problem on to government. Government of course has a role to play but mostly as a safety net.
10:44 AM on 09/06/2012
The problem with today's GOP is that they want to have their cake and eat it to. You can't claim our country to be a Christian nation and then resist the implication that it then opperste on christian principles. The true problem is that the practice of Christianity is more difficult then it's rhetoric. "no one can serve two masters. Either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to one and despise the other. You can not serve both God and money." Matthew 6:24

Which one is it going to be GOP?
04:58 PM on 09/06/2012
What you say could be true but it transcends both parties and it no less gives us the authority to be sole arbitors of justice. Actually it applies to society as a whole alas through the individual. We can not use Matthew 6:24 to lambast politicians or use it as justification for taking money from one class of people and handing it over to another. I agree that it is difficult to see any sort of compassion coming from ruling parties and that's because they are imperfect and flawed like everyone else. That's why democracy predicates the "common good" which is largely based upon truth. I think the greater problem today is our obsession with "truisms" and the lack of interest for "truth." Christian Life is of course a lot more difficult in reality than its rhetoric because it proclaims truth. Christianity in the mainstream is usually noticed only when it is under trial via scandal or when discussing hot-button political issues. It is only referenced for rhetoric and its passages are for platitudes. i.e Golden Rule. That's what happens when your beliefs are translated only through words and not through devotion.
03:24 AM on 09/03/2012
Jesus also said that "you will always have the poor." Jesus may have a heart, but he's also a realist.

So what would Jesus do if he were a U.S. citizen today? Would he really go for a 2nd try by Obama? Would he even vote? The last question is easiest: yes he'd vote. But for Obama? That depends...
For more detail: http://jesustheheresy.wordpress.com/
11:18 AM on 09/07/2012
We will always have the poor, especially when the rich keep the poor from advancing.
03:47 AM on 09/08/2012
At least Jesus had the good sense to offer salvation not merely to those who took the step of confessing their sins, but also to those wealthy would would step forward, sell all and give it to the poor. Not an ethic many evangelicals own up to today.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:36 PM on 10/17/2012
The rich do not force the poor to spend beyond their means, to spend all income and save none, to buy a house they cannot pay for, to buy a fancy car they cannot pay for, to have expensive mobile cell telephone service, to buy and buy all type of personal property using credit cards. The rich are not responsible for the poor. The poor are responsible for the poor. There is no virtue in being poor. None. J. P. Morgan said it best: I've been rich, and I've been poor. Rich is better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pandora1
03:22 PM on 09/01/2012
As a staunch Democrat, my thoughts about the GOP may be questioned, but I have NEVER felt disgusted and upset about the current crop than I am now. John McCain, George W., George H.W., Reagan, etc. are/were all good men and true, no matter what their political stances; Ryan, Romney, Priebus are scondrels and liars and will do anything to gain the Presidency. Christians? No way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
soma77
Author, Speaker, Retreat Facilitator
01:52 AM on 09/01/2012
It is sad that even Christians in a person’s own family will embrace persecution and hatred over love and will join with the other Christian wolves. The strongest bonds of a family’s love are broken through with ill feelings and prejudice against the Christ doctrine of love for a false one that hates and uses others in the name of compassion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ttsgw
Atheist and secular humanist
04:44 PM on 08/31/2012
They pair perfectly.
03:29 PM on 08/31/2012
LOVE this!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
graceaustin
01:49 PM on 08/31/2012
"Compassionate conservatism" was an urban myth.
12:18 PM on 08/31/2012
I went to the website you cited, and you should have sited the actual STATISTICS for child poverty, not the report that does the "every minute, one child blah blah blah."

Since the report has no bibliography, and the "facts" cited at the beginning of the report have almost nothing to do with the rest of the report.

The stats are here. http://www.childrensdefense.org/child-research-data-publications/data/state-data-repository/census/census-2007-child-poverty-data.pdf
09:58 AM on 08/31/2012
I took a look at that report you linked to. Thanks.

I wish it included more graphs and stats, cause the document itself doesn't have a bibliography.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dzadzey
Afflicting the comfortable
08:03 AM on 08/31/2012
The GOP seems to be of the mind that Jesus was as greedy, short-sighted and mean-spirited as they are.
photo
Kev Bat
Fiber is good for my micro-bio !
05:55 AM on 08/31/2012
The compassion we will get from the ultra-right is them saying " Thanks for giving us back the White House after we nearly sunk the USA under Bush , Suckers !:
Emereaux
Cerca trova
10:52 PM on 08/30/2012
Thank you, what a great blog!