More

Derrick Crowe

Derrick Crowe

Posted: August 6, 2009 10:15 AM

Three Dead Afghan Children


BBC reports that U.S. forces piloting helicopters killed three children last night in the Arghandab district of Afghanistan. Enraged locals took the bodies to Kandahar to display them to local officials. (Warning: graphic video.)

"What was the fault of my innocent children? They were not Taliban," Mr Rahim said. "Did they come here to build our country or kill our innocent children?"
But keep in mind, this is all making you safer, America.
... The villagers shouted "Death to America! Death to infidels!" as they displayed the corpses in the back of a pickup truck.

AFP reports the boys killed in the strike were ages 10-13, along with a 25-year-old man.

There's discontinuity between the descriptions of the strike: locals say the helicopters attacked a house, while the U.S. military claims they attacked "militants" in an open field. Stay tuned.

The New York Times is also on the story. One addendum to Dexter Filkins' piece: while his closing paragraph is true,

As the Afghan war has intensified in recent months, more civilians have died. A United Nations report released last week said that 1013 civilians were killed in the first six months of 2009, compared with 818 in the same period last year. Insurgents were to blame for 59 percent of those deaths, the report said.

...it fails to point out that it's not just the total number of civilians killed that increased during the months in question. Civilian casualties in general and casualties specifically caused by U.S. forces and their allies have steadily increased in each year for which we have systematically collected data, despite repeated escalations intended in part to reduce non-combatant deaths.

For more on the topic of non-combatant deaths, see Rethink Afghanistan's section on civilian casualties.

Follow Derrick Crowe on Twitter: www.twitter.com/derrickcrowe

 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:18 PM on 08/08/2009
Pay off the locals then investigate. But the fight must go on. The same Afghans will be ten times more furious if NATO troops leave and Al Qaida takes over again.
01:20 PM on 08/08/2009
past time for some one to get out the history book. . .
12:32 PM on 08/08/2009
The inconsistency of BBC reporting is legendary. Often times they headline hearsay or rumors of "innocent" civilians being killed by Western troops fighting terror and they often times minimize or fail to report anything on the killings by terrorists or as they would say, "militants." The BBC rarely gives perspective-----if a bystander is killed by the Israelis or American when going after barbaric terrorists, they emphasize it without mentioning the hundreds or perhaps thousands of innocents killed by the actual terrorist. If the Taliban or Hamas issue a press release accusing others of committing murder, the BBC usually reports it without investigation. Their skewed reporting in the Middle East does a grave disservice to journalism and the truth.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paula Ann
04:10 AM on 08/08/2009
Making friends and influencing people as we go
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:19 PM on 08/07/2009
Get out of Afghanistan - we are not winning and do not have the tools to do so.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:15 PM on 08/07/2009
Not every case in which afghans have claimed the death of innocents in coalition air attacks has been substantiated, but some have, and every single case was immediately and strenuously denied, as this one is, by military sources.

The military's denials would be more plausible if they came off as something more than automatic.
10:37 AM on 08/06/2009
Get us out of Obama's illegal war in Afghanistan now!