EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Don McNay

Don McNay

Posted: December 29, 2008 01:57 PM

Making the Best of the Economic Mess


?>


Love the one you're with

-Stephen Stills

2008 hasn't been a fun year. A recession was coming, but greedy and self-interested leaders brought us to the brink of a depression.

I'm angry about the shape we are in. I want to make sure it never happens again.

It wouldn't bother me to see a bunch of Wall Street CEOs lose their jobs, and take some of the Wall Street-enabling Congressmen with them.

On the other hand, I need to get past the anger. My family has to eat. Your family has to eat. It is time to focus on feeding them.

I have my eye on the clowns on Wall Street, but my feet are on Main Street, trying to make a buck.

We need to learn from the mistakes. Somewhere along the way, everyone lost touch with reality.

People bought houses, cars and clothes with the primary goal of impressing their neighbors. They took trips they couldn't afford and ran up credit card balances larger than their annual incomes.

Will Rogers once said that "America is the first nation to go to the poorhouse in an automobile."

Will didn't know about credit cards, designer clothes and subprime mortgages. Somewhere along the way, things got completely crazy.

It's easy to see how Wall Street and Washington got crazy, too.

The American economy was built around the idea that people would keep spending more than they made. It worked for a long time and then it all collapsed.

No great nation has ever been built on debt. No one has ever gotten rich by spending money foolishly.

We didn't break the trend.

Now is like the hangover after a three day drunk. We have to pay the piper.

I hated the Wall Street bailout from day one.

One of my biggest concerns was that we didn't teach the fat cats a lesson. We propped them up and kept them in business. We gave them over $700 billion with little accountability.

Instead of learning from the experience, Wall Street keeps screwing up. They fly on private jets to fancy conferences and give themselves million dollar bonuses.

Once the dust settles, it will be clear that we've done nothing to stop them from doing the same thing a couple of years from now.

There is only one way to stop them: Reduce the impact of Wall Street in our lives. We need to quit borrowing money from them and depending on them for employment.

Credit cards are only issued by a very few banks. For the most part, the issuer banks are the banks getting bailout money.

I don't know how a Citigroup collector is going to convince an unemployed worker that he has a moral obligation to pay up.

Thus, I am expecting huge credit card defaults in 2009.

There's a good side to the defaults, too. People won't be able to get new cards for a few years. They might learn to live within their means.

I don't have an all purpose credit card. (I have two gasoline cards.) I don't want one, and don't need one. Not having a card has not stopped me from doing what I want to do.

Our parents and grandparents lived without credit cards. We can, too.

Many of our grandparents didn't work for large corporations. They were self-employed farmers or laborers. We are headed back that way. We've been moving toward a nation of self-employed people since corporate employment peaked almost 40 years ago.

2009 will be the year of the accidental entrepreneur.

I have some experience in that. I came out of graduate school at Vanderbilt during the recession of 1982. The only employment I could find was working on the clean-up crew at the Kentucky Horse Park. (Which, now that I think of it, might have been good training for shoveling what Wall Street and Congress have been shoveling at us recently.)

Cleaning up after horses will cause you to look at other possibilities.

I didn't want to start my own business. But I just didn't have another choice.

26 years later, I'm glad it happened. Just like a lot of the accidental entrepreneurs of 2009 will eventually be happy, too.

For every laid-off auto worker, there is a potential car mechanic. And for every laid-off journalist, there is a potential blogger, teacher, or public relations guru.

I didn't want the economic crisis, but now it is time to make the best of it. If we wind up with a nation full of self-employed people who live within their means, it might work out for the best.

And if we can give Wall Street the finger, it's really going to be a bonus.

It will feel like a million bucks. Or a ride on a private jet.


Don McNay is the founder of McNay Settlement Group in Richmond, Kentucky. You can read his award winning, syndicated financial columns at www.donmcnay.com or write to him at don@donmcnay.com McNay is the author of Son of a Son of a Gambler and The Unbridled World of Ernie Fletcher. McNay is Treasurer of the National Society of Newspaper Columnists.

Follow Don McNay on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Donmcnay

Love the one you're with -Stephen Stills 2008 hasn't been a fun year. A recession was coming, but greedy and self-interested leaders brought us to the brink of a depression. I'm angry about the s...
Love the one you're with -Stephen Stills 2008 hasn't been a fun year. A recession was coming, but greedy and self-interested leaders brought us to the brink of a depression. I'm angry about the s...
 
  • Comments
  • 42
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:32 PM on 01/04/2009
Every sentence of Don's is worth pasting in your hat band, as we used to say in the hold-the-p­resses days.
02:04 PM on 12/31/2008
I like what Don has said in this essay. In fact, I thought he was talking about me! I've become self employed, converting an old hobby into a side biz that pays the bills, (small mortgage and utils). There is a brotherhoo­d amongst those of us who ply related trades and live by our wits as we watch the world burn. If the economy grinds to a complete halt, we'll know we gave it our best shot. Then we'll be looking to the gov't to pop to with some relief or you can bet we'll be replacing this system with one that will. If that happens, you can bet there won't be Wall Street or a stock market next go round!

Speaking of that stock market, if the banks won't lend with the borrowed Chinese dollars we lent them, then it's time for the Treasury to vacuum that 346 billion dollars back out of the vaults where it's being hoarded. There's far better uses for that cash than bailing out millionare­s. What about you and me? The banksters and their bonuses can flame. We'll still have our credit unions and with a timely repeal of interstate banking we could have local banks again, where the money, (and accountabi­lity) stays in the community.

Would YOU be terribly upset if Morgan Chase, AIG or B of A went belly up? Me neither! :>)
10:32 PM on 12/30/2008
Let's hope that automobile is American, or were all in a lot of trouble.
04:45 PM on 12/30/2008
Lol, reading some of these posts, I almost WISH I had bought a fancy car, a mansion, taken trips to Hawaii and Mexico, you name it! I didn't do those things and we're still struggling financiall­y. At least it sounds like those who were really irresponsi­ble had a good time while it lasted. Ok, I'm being sarcastic here. Mostly... but still, that trip to Hawaii would have been nice!
04:40 PM on 12/30/2008
We live and work outside of Chicago, so median housing prices are higher than in other parts of the country. however, we bought a modest house in the burbs- certainly not a McMansion- and moved in, planning to refinance our mortgage as rates went down. We were told that although our credit scores were excellent, we didn't have ENOUGH credit history ( we were making one regular car payment, utility bills, etc) and that to qualify we should get at least two credit cards and start paying bills with them or something, just to build up a larger history. So your idea that we can all 'live without credit cards' no longer holds water today. I am not advocating overspendi­ng, but unless you have years of financial history, it is almost impossible to get a house or car or any major life purchase without a credit card. I don't agree with the system, but that is how it is. Now, lol, our house is worth LESS than what we paid for it and we cannot refinance anything. We just need to keep working, make our payments and watch all the people who defaulted on their loans get help and lower rates which we apparently don't deserve.
01:13 PM on 12/30/2008
Congress should eliminate the Federal Reserve or veto many of its decisions.

Congress should consider backing our currency with gold, silver, and other commoditie­s.

People may want to support an Amendment to the United States Constituti­on that allows State government­s to "coin Money" -- make gold coins and silver coins. This may reduce the amount of harm the federal government causes.

If the federal government is serious about growing the economy and creating jobs, it should stop taxing interest from savings accounts, dividends, capital gains, and estates. People will be better able to pay credit card bills and make mortgage payments. Businesses will have an easier time obtaining loans and investment­s.

The United States of America should end the trade embargo with Cuba. We trade with China. We should be willing to trade with Cuba. We should let in sugar, cigars, and many other products. Trading with Cuba may improve the lives of the Cuban people and improve the economic conditions in many southern states.

State government­s may obtain more money from taxes on restaurant­s and taxes on cigarettes if they allow people to smoke in restaurant­s. Many state government­s should consider reducing cigarette taxes so that smokers will have more money for other things.

I graduated from the University of New Hampshire in 1992 with a BA Degree in Political Science and a minor in Economics.

I ran for United States Senate from New Hampshire in 2002.

My website is http://www­.myspace.c­om/kenneth­stremsky


Sincerely,

Ken Stremsky
06:00 PM on 12/30/2008
The current amount of dollars in the US system is about 45 trillion; there isn't enough gold or silver to back it up. The country is stuck with debt as the main factor.

check out money is debt on google videos, it is an eye opener.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tcagle
Solar and wind energy consultant
07:22 AM on 12/31/2008
When you get to the "legalize and tax pot" thing, you may actually get elected.
10:49 AM on 12/30/2008
I remember hearing a story of a cost cutting expert going over a credit card company's books. He pointed out that if they got rid of 5% of their customers, their default rate would go down 90%. The response: "But that 5% are 95% of our revenues!"
The point of this is that credit card companies are no longer in the business of short term convienenc­e credit (and try to get rid of those customers)­. They prefer long term debtors who are given more money than they can pay back.
If we revoked the bankruptcy laws the credit card issuers pushed through congress a few years ago, the debt would become dangerous again, and they would have to go back into the business of convienenc­e credit. Credit card companies wouldn't loan to bad credit risks, and wouldn't loan more than people are able to pay back, there would be fewer defaults, and folks would learn to live within their means.
Another option would be to require credit card payments to be based on a 5 year repayment term instead of a 30 year term, this would make credit card payments much higher, and encourage people to get rid of them.
sonoffestus
Got smart & got out!
02:15 PM on 01/01/2009
Yeah, the one credit card company my wife and I have absolutely hate us. We pay off our monthly bill in full every month. The CC industry has a special name for folks like us. Seriously, I'm not sure what it is, but probably a$$ holes or something like that.
10:47 AM on 12/30/2008
Unfortunat­ely, in this country, if you attempt to rent a car or hotel room without a credit card then you are automatica­lly assumed to be too poor to afford either.
09:45 AM on 12/30/2008
I get at least four robo-calls a day, offering to help with my credit card debt of over $10,000. I get treated like there's something wrong with me when I do get disgusted and get someone on the phone to say I don't have any! I can't get them stopped. I think the incredulit­y of the person who called, from India, to offer cheaper pharmaceut­icals for my chronic diseases, when I said I didn't have any, is a really good example of what others think of Americans. I have to have something wrong with me, I'm an American over sixty! I have to be fat, have high blood pressure or diabetes, or... I must overconsum­e, live beyond my means, etc. I finally converted my weight to kilos and my height to centimeter­s for him. He then asked me where I was from.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
joebhed
Greenback Revolutionist
09:35 AM on 12/30/2008
Any bank with a credit-car­d operation ( that is probably most of them) that receives any bailout money - NOT just from the $700B Treasury, but also any FED subsidized bank loans - must FIRST use the bailout money to pay off the credit card debt of its customers, and roll the entire amount into an unsecured personal loan, with an interest rate at the bailout money cost PLUS two percent.
Or else, they do NOT get the money.
Wake up, America.
The taxpayers are the only game in town.
The taxpayers are ultimately responsibl­e for every dollar that is loaned by the FED to the banks.
It's OUR money.
Restore economic democracy.
Put the banks to work for us, not vice-versa­.
This will restore hundreds of billions of dollars to Mainstreet over the next twenty years.
THIS is the mainstreet bailout.
We don't avoid the money we borrowed, we just pay it back as a lower-inte­rest loan.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skyshoes
06:47 AM on 12/30/2008
Having been through the first "daddy Bush's" recession in 91.. Customers couldn't pay because they "hadn't made a sale in a week". I was horrified when I had to take calls from high school dropout credit "calls". The degrading.­. "Can you explain why you can't pay your bills on time?" was a particular gut wrencher.

Now when the phone bankster in Mumbai, or the high school dropout in Nebraska asks, "Can you tell me why you are behind on this bill?" I take a long pause..

Then I calmly state "You are kidding of course..." and I pause. The cockier newbie kids from Colorado or Nebraska or the forty five dollar a week phone banker in New Dehli might say "No I am not" but most fall into their own stunned pause.

My response; " I am having the same problems YOUR company is experienci­ng, people aren't paying, can't pay, are refusing to pay, are going out of business. YOUR company is virtually out of business and is now being propped up by taxpayer monies, it is now subsidised from the taxes I have paid in over forty years of being in business. "

I do not raise my voice, I know it is to no real avail. But I can assure you that by the time I get to "refusing to pay" most of the working stiffs emboldened by the telephonic shield of righteousn­ess are begging me to "stop.. stop ...OK!".
06:10 AM on 12/30/2008
Yep. Wall Street and their political beneficiar­ies -- Bush, Republican­s almost unanimousl­y, and many Dems -- sold the poor and middle class this idea: debt is wealth.

Buy a big house -- four bedrooms when you only needed two -- borrow against the rising equity (this concept needs to be exposed for what it is, an illusion) to buy furniture you could not afford if you held two full time jobs, park a Lexus in the driveway and vacation in Mexico, or the Pacific islands, on the frequent flier miles earned by cranking the card to its limit.

Meanwhile, some of us did not fall for the basic lie -- that debt is wealth. Oh sure, I'm still paying off a boat loan (17 footer, the monthly payment is proportion­ately low), and two cars, one of which will be paid for this spring, the other next year.

But we lived BELOW our means during the big bubbles, paid off the mortgage two years early, paid off the college loans and the many credit card debts incurred while in school, and now only buy stuff when we have the actual cash to pay for it. If we don't have the money, we do without.

The old mantra: Pay to play.
The new one: Pay as you go.
10:16 AM on 12/30/2008
Absolutely right -some of us did live below our means. IF YOU ARE NOW MAKING LESS THAN YOU DID A YEAR AGO, SPEND LESS THAN YOU DID A YEAR AGO. It's a simple idea, and it's what our parents and grandparen­ts did. That is how they accumulate­d whatever assets / wealth they had. All the financial problems we are having now are caused by our financial over-consu­mption.
06:08 PM on 12/30/2008
I come from Ireland which experience­d a boom until it experience­d a crash this year. People were telling my that I was crazy for not buying a house in order to rent it. I knew the boom wouldn't last (i didn't know when it would crash though) and I stayed out. i choose to live by my means, and I plan to build a house which is small, enough for my wife and I and perhaps a child in the future. We don't give a damn about designer clothes, furniture, cars on credit. We buy what we can and watch our pennies.

I found it shocking that the taxpayer has now to pay out the same banks who propped up the stupid credit driven lifestyle of people who had no common sense.
photo
Lotus19
Power Concedes Nothing Without a Demand..FD
12:01 AM on 12/30/2008
"For every laid-off auto worker, there is a potential car mechanic. And for every laid-off journalist­, there is a potential blogger, teacher, or public relations guru"

I have been thinking about this very thing since layoffs are always looming in the horizon in my workplace. This option may seem more doable for those who have built a career around a particular skill and trade, however anyone can improvise. Still, the point is well taken that we are going to have to explore our options for making a living, and using the skills that we have built over time is a good place to start. One local woman who lost her wall street job used her savings and severance money to start a cupcake baking class. She used her marketing and sales skills to build the business.

The important thing is to not despair, be flexible, and keep the creative juices flowing.
photo
ImmanuelGoldstein
Founder of the "Brotherhood"
03:56 PM on 01/01/2009
Yeah right 'accidenta­l entreprene­urs'. This is the mythical Irish village where me make our livings taking in each others laundry. Small business owners all around are going belly up because PEOPLE HAVE RUN OUT OF DISPOSABLE INCOME AND CREDIT. If they don't have money to spend in the mall where are they going to get it to spend in your storefront­?
Want to see plenty of AE's? Just take a look at any picture from the thirties showing people selling apples. That's the reality of the idea that we'll simply replace jobs with small business.
11:36 PM on 12/29/2008
Political correctnes­s and our culture (helped by the media) urged everyone to live like they were rich. Unfortunat­ely (or fortunatel­y) that just doesn't work, can't work,and shouldn't work. What needs to happen is a return to respectabi­lity of the average worker. Not everyone can be rich. We need jobs, average jobs that will allow average people to build a future, not be a slave to the banks
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TJCole
10:50 PM on 12/29/2008
Boy Don have you got that right...we have yet to see the worst of this, and we will be paying for this unbridled greed and the corruption of this administra­tion for many many years perhaps decades..!
09:44 AM on 12/30/2008
You apparently didn't read the article. We're suffering from our own greed, not the administra­tions.