Oct. 2 marked the fourth anniversary of the tragic schoolhouse shooting in Nickel Mines, Penn., when a non-Amish neighbor unleashed his anger toward God for allowing his firstborn daughter to die nine years earlier. He shot 10 young Amish girls execution style, killing five and seriously injuring the rest before turning the gun on himself.
Within hours of the shooting, several Amish people, at their own initiative, visited the gunman's widow and his parents and offered words of grace and forgiveness. Other expressions of forgiveness by Amish people for the gunman and his family soon followed. More than half of those at his burial were Amish neighbors, some of whom had buried their own children the day before. The story of forgiveness startled the world. Why did Amish people offer almost instantaneous forgiveness in the wake of such a tragedy?
As I interviewed them after the shooting, I discovered that old-fashioned obedience explained their forgiveness. They said that they were simply obeying Jesus' instructions to love enemies and forgive transgressors. Moreover, obeying God lies at the heart of their faith.
As I talked with parents I found that obedience is also the key to Amish child rearing. While modern child rearing emphasizes individualism, independence, choice and self-actualization, the Amish accent obedience, respect for authority and cooperation with others.
When asked, "What are the most important things to teach children?" one Amish grandmother replied, "To work and to obey." These words would hardly top the list of child-rearing goals in modern households. For many of us, obedience training applies mostly to dogs. In Amish life it pertains to people, beginning with children. Amish child-rearing literature abounds with references to obedience because it's a core value of their faith. In Amish eyes, disobedience is a sin, a signpost on the road to eternal damnation.
Most Christians would agree that children should obey their parents. But Amish understandings of obedience go deeper: Church members follow church regulations such as not owning cars because compliance signals their obedience to God. By teaching their children the habits of obedience, parents point them toward heaven and safeguard them from hell.
I told Hannah, an Amish mother of seven, that many non-Amish people are astonished that Amish offspring are so quiet, well mannered and well behaved. "Why might that be?" I asked. Without hesitation or a trace of humor, she responded, "Oh, it's the spanking that makes them so nice."
Hannah explained that, when children are about two years old, their wills need to be broken. If it's not done at that stage, she said, they will likely become disobedient, rebellious adults. The spanking helps correct them and "make them nice." Another mother explained that when children learn to fold their hands at prayer time, they are old enough to be reprimanded with light spanks when disobedient.
Amish parents turn to the words of King Solomon to support corporal discipline: "He that spareth his rod hateth his son; but he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes" (Proverbs 13:24). They also note that the book of Hebrews suggests that God disciplines Christians as a father disciplines a son and that such discipline yields "the peaceable fruit of righteousness" (Hebrews 12:11).
Parents are quick to say, however, that spanking and other forms of physical discipline should never be done in anger or frustration. The child should understand the reason for discipline so that "punishment ends on a happy note, sweet and forgiving," says Naomi, a mother. She adds that because correction ultimately "leads to happiness ... [discipline] must be the result of our love for the child's happiness, both now and in the hereafter."
These links -- between spanking, happiness and heaven -- provide the framework for Amish child discipline, an approach that nurtures obedience instead of individuality. It's a framework that disturbs modern sensitivities. Naomi disagrees. In fact, she believes that letting children go without discipline is "the cruelest kind of child abuse." She poses the question rhetorically: "Now wouldn't it be abusive above all abuses to withhold from our children the training they need for a life of discipline and self-control, of service to God?"
This countercultural view of child rearing lies at the heart of Amish society. We can praise the Amish for their forgiving response at Nickel Mines and we may yearn for a simpler and less frazzled Amish-style life. We may even seek to sew some patches of Amish faith onto our own spirituality and instill some old-fashioned virtues into the lives of our own children. Such fine intentions will fail, the Amish contend, without a generous dose of obedience training.
Donald B. Kraybill is co-author of The Amish Way: Patient Faith in a Perilous World.
If the Amish are successful in breaking their children’s will, it means the children become compliant because they are afraid to be otherwise, which makes them vulnerable to abuses.
The most important aspect of Amish children’s compliance is that they will not question the Amish ways. When they become members of the church, they will be asked to give up their individuality to become part of the community twice a year in communion services. And those who have been “made nice†are happy to accommodate.
For more about the subject, please visit "About Amish" http://aboutamish.blogspot.com/2010/11/amish-and-spanking.html
Saloma Miller Furlong
No longer Amish by choice
That act was beyond inspirational. But I don't believe it was due to being spanked as children. I suspect there is much more behind this obedience to the ideals of their faith than corporal punishment.
I remember seeing an interview with the Amish grandfather of one of the murdered children. He was asked if he forgave the killer. He said, "In my heart, yes," which left open the possibility that in his head he wanted revenge, as any victim of such a horrible thing would naturally and rightly want.
Explain to me how that is good child-rearing.
Good for them , Less cannon fodder.
My father, who was an Episcopal minister, taught me that free will was something that was given to us from God. Acting Christian-like, caring, forgiving, etc. should not come from fear, it should come from the heart. One should be obedient to God's values, not out of fear, but out of the belief that it is good--therein lies true obedience.
Amish don't have any worse issues than the English have -- we all have our faults because we are human. I caution those who throw stones at a "group" which may have similar qualities to many other portions of our society. The difference between the 'un-stoned group' is that there isn't a different name to set them apart. Check out how abuse and incest exist in other parts of the U.S. and you would be unfortunately surprised to see how rampant it is. But those groups don't have a specific name.
Instead of spending energy blaming or chastising how someone, or a group, does something so wrong, we would all be better if we tried to just go out and do something good and help someone.
Just check with the Roman Catholics on that.
Is their forgiveness special because they decided to selectively freeze their technological development at year 1850?
They forgave a man of a similar faith for doing something awful. An admirable thing, yes, but hardly rare and not really the kind of story we need to marvel at. In fact, if I'm not mistaken, I believe that forgiving people who do you wrong is the kind of thing ALL Christians are supposed to. (And again, here we are marveling at some people who actually did it).
To "hit" to a child, is to striked that child unjustly, without a cause and with aggressive intent.
To "spank" a child, is to adminster a mild form of corporal punishment, for correction, rebuke,and to focus attention on the dangers or injury caused by a thoughtless action.
So, perhaps the unacceptable feelings you seem to experience, might be what was often expressed by my mother, who whenever she was going to spank me, would start off by saying, "now, this is going to hurt ME more than its going to hurt YOU!"
Of course, I didn't believe that for one second....not until I grew up, and had my own children to discipline, then I knew just how right she was.
So, I believe most modern day parents refuse to spank their children, not because a little spanking will actually injure the child, but because it hurts them as parents to give that child the proper training to be an healthy respectful adult, so as a result of course today's children are absolute tyrants.
They live apart by choice...and they take nothing from the "English", save modern medicine...but within their community, there is no tolerance of self. As impressed as I am by their ability to live so completely by their beliefs, I have seen interviews with those who left...and understand the crushing burden of choosing a life without everyone they ever knew or loved, to maintain their own personalities.
I know three people who have actually hit a lottery---despite the odds of that.
I know NO ONE in my family, or circle of friends and contacts who had cosmetic surgery of any kind...so obviously that is not as common a practice as you perceive.
I don't stress individuality above all else...I simply know that I would not be healthy if I was forced to suppress mine to such a stringent degree.