Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dorian de Wind

Dorian de Wind

Posted: July 26, 2010 01:27 PM

Ramblings of a 'Fake American'

What's Your Reaction:

My radio dial found a conservative station a few weeks ago and I listened for a while to one of the most stirring, hauntingly beautiful, patriotic songs I have ever heard: "Let Freedom Ring." I left my dial there for a bit and listened to the talk-radio host, a Great American, taking a number of calls from several other Great Americans.

It brought back memories of the 2008 presidential campaign, when righteous Republican candidates, True Americans, standing tall and proud in front of rows of giant American flags delivered rousing "This is our land" speeches to crowds of cheering True Americans.

More recently, at Tea Party rallies, there has been the soaring oratory by Constitution-loving, "take-our-country-back" Real Americans. Oratory that warns about those "Other Americans" who want to take away the guns, Bibles, and freedoms of Real Americans.

There have been other warnings and accusations against those Americans who presumably aren't Great, or True, or Real.

For example, the contemptible accusations that I, along with my fellow Democrats, are weak on national security and do not support our brave troops.

I have served my country honorably, "meritoriously," for 20 years. During those years, I would have laid down my life in defense of my country...and still would. I revere the men and women who have served us so heroically in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere, regardless of my views on any particular war. I know, without a doubt, that my fellow Democrats, fellow Americans, are at least as patriotic.

It saddens me--"infuriates" is perhaps a better word--when Republicans take sole ownership of the U.S. Constitution and of the American flag, take sole ownership of patriotism, and take sole ownership of "our land," this America that, last time I checked, still belonged to you and me, regardless of what political affiliation you or I may have.

It upsets me when I hear Republicans act as if they have a monopoly on loving our country. I know, for a fact, that I love America at least as much as they do. I loved it even before I set foot in America, while still dreaming of one day coming to America. And ever since that day arrived, that cold April day when an overjoyed, 17-year-old immigrant from the Netherlands landed in New York, I have loved America more and more, an America that has blessed me and my family with freedoms, opportunities and successes that people elsewhere only dream about.

When I hear Republicans accuse me, and my fellow Democrats, of "tearing up the Constitution," I get really upset because, you see, in order to become a U.S. citizen, I studied the U. S. Constitution, cherished its immortal words, and committed its preamble to memory...and the rest, to my heart. At my naturalization ceremony, I solemnly swore that I would support and defend the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic and that I would bear true faith and allegiance to that Constitution, so help me God.

I swore so again upon my enlistment into the U.S. military and, for a third time, when I received my U.S. Air Force commission.

"Take our country back?" From whom? From the nearly 100 million Americans who were born and raised in this country, who love America even more, if that's possible, than this 70-year-old naturalized geezer? From Americans, whose fatal flaw is that they happen to be Democrats?

Real Americans live throughout these United States, not just in the "heartland," not just in Sarah Palin's fictional and fanciful "Real America." Real Americans are not just Republicans, conservatives, libertarians, Tea Party supporters, or whatever. We are all Real Americans. There are no "Fake Americans."

I respectfully ask our Republican friends to challenge us, Democrats, on policy and politics, on party line and philosophy, even on principles, but, please, do not question our patriotism, our "Americanism," our love for God and Country, because when you do so you are not only dishonoring half of all Americans, you are doing a disservice to your causes, legitimate and righteous as they may be. You are also discrediting yourselves and, more important, you are demeaning and dangerously dividing the Real America you profess to honor and love.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:31 PM on 07/27/2010
"I respectfully ask our Republican friends to challenge us, Democrats, on policy and politics, on party line and philosophy, even on principles, but, please, do not question our patriotism"

Therein lies the difference in the parties. While Democrats are invested in policy and the business of governing, the Republicans are invested in playing politics. Unfortunately in many conservative bastions, when the Democrats talk governing, it's like they brought a knife to a gunfight. Dems want to get close and look for detailed points of attack, while Repubs just shoot all over the place making lots of noise, hoping to take down a target or two. See? That's an analogy a Republican can relate to - guns, knives, shooting, noise, excitement. I should be a consultant.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fisher65
07:43 AM on 07/27/2010
repubs want to sucede and they think they are patriots? no
02:42 AM on 07/27/2010
You listened to some Hannity? Yeah, that'll infuriate you every time.
02:31 AM on 07/27/2010
When they say real American they are saying there had to be laws made for some to be citizens.It's code for white rule.it attract the kkk types,it make them feel needed since there was a time when their philosophy ruled and they want it back.when they say the original intent they mean some was not meant to be citizens or they would have been made citizens then.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
I'm actually a radical leftist
12:06 AM on 07/27/2010
"Patriotism is the last refuge of many a scoundrel"--Samuel Johnson
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FogBelter
Illegitimis non carborundum
10:58 PM on 07/26/2010
I seem to recall when the United States last unambiguously won a war, against an Industrialized Japan and an Industrialized Germany, the President that led a unified American Public to victory was a Liberal Democrat named Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

When I hear these nonsensical "True American" versus "Fake American" claims I think of the ten generations of my family. I think of my forefather that fought under General Washington at Long Island, during the Revolutionary War, and his son that defended Washington during the War of 1812. Of members of my Family Tree that fought in the French Indian Wars, and Mexican War, of my great-great-Grandfather, whose father signed him up at age fifteen to fight in the Union Army during the Civil War. or my great-uncle who landed on Leyte with MacArthur during WWII, or a distant cousin who was KIA in Karbala Iraq in 2003 , and was lauded as "a good guy for a liberal" by one of his peers on his memorial war .... and I ask myself:

"By what right does any American believe he or she can pass judgment on a fellow countryman and declare them a "Fake American" for having political beliefs they disagree with?"

Answer: They have no right.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:31 AM on 07/27/2010
Awesome post! Faved, from a long-time fan.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JazzyJim
Nuzis stay to the Right
09:36 PM on 07/26/2010
True story: Two soldier during fleet week come into a bar in Manhattan, I buy them both drinks, thank them for their service. They're about to go back to Iraq at the time (2 years ago+) for their 2nd and 3rd tour respectively. As I thanked them I asked their views and they were very proud and very strong in doing what was being asked. I stated that it was our job here at home to make sure they get home safely and did they think that "Democrats" weren't supporting them. The soldier going back for his second tour said, "Are you a democrat or a republican?" - Cautiously, I said, "Oh, I'm educated and went to school, I'm a democrat." The one soldier laughed out loud, the other just grinned. I said, "What's so funny?" "I'm a school teacher...and a democrat!" We all laughed and then I asked the other soldier, "...and you?" With a straight face and seriousness, he said, "I love my country and I know I'm going to die over there. I love George Bush. I love America, but I'm going to die over there." Well, there's not a lot you can say. I bought the guys more drinks and we agreed we're all Americans despite the politics. I also said it is our job as citizens to demand of our government to not put our children in harms way unnecessarily.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JazzyJim
Nuzis stay to the Right
09:28 PM on 07/26/2010
Thanks for you blog. 2 quick comments and I wish I didn't have to be sarcastic, but the propaganda machine also "hires" people to "work from home" to propagate their ideas via mass marketing techniques, so a) Republican constituents in concert with the TV Evangelicals are fearful of enlightened and educated Americans and b) don't like to read. They want to be told. Sans, Fox and the TeaBaggin Republicans that have tried to co-op America for the 1776 Patriots whom are spinning in their graves at how "lack of knowledge, history and education" has been supplanted with "blind faith". The are not equal on the playing field of life, but they each count as a vote. Look what the Dugger's are doing. Home schooled limits one's "social studies" and skills that are important to a society. I fear the Republican Party is starting to "resemble the Religious group following their leader into the dark caverns of the mountains in fear of the end of the world (Poltergeist 2)" praying for the end of days - when, if they had actually been educated, would see they were following a cult, not a journey of faith, but of crazy.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
BeasleysMom
Liberal Elitist
08:25 PM on 07/26/2010
Let me add my voice to those who thank you and hardily agree with ever word. We couldn't have envisioned that so many noisy Americans could voice so much hatred against their fellow countrymen and women based soley on l ies told to them by conservative TV and radio personalities.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kittyarmy
08:03 PM on 07/26/2010
Thank you for this piece and your service. I too immigrated to the US as a teen with my family and we all have come to love this country and call it ours. In my opinion we as immigrants are in a unique position to appreciate many aspects of American society that our native friends tend to take for granted. And so, although we have not served in the military, we have expressed our appreciation by volunteering in various public and community services. Our love and sense of duty to this country are just as strong and genuine as any "real" Americans out there.
photo
ChiBloger
And the truth shall set us ALL free
05:52 PM on 07/26/2010
What mother would ask, “Which one of you are my real children?†You would think the mother would know. It’s only the right wingers who would ask such a thing about American’s. Progressives tend to by far be more about building collisions’ than finding ways to divide us. None of us progressives have anything to prove to these people. They always come with false and notions and preconceived impressions. And they must constantly be scared because there is seemingly no activities that they can conceive of doing that would not be better without a gun. I meet far too many non Americans that would be a better example of a good American than these people. I would say though that they cannot be ignored because their paranoia is dangerous when coupled with power.
IMOPINIONH8D
because I want it empty...
04:48 PM on 07/26/2010
It seems that most of the rightwingers I discuss/ argue politics with have never served in the military. I usually get to the quick and ask them If they are pro war, if they answer yes I then ask if they were in the military if they answer no, I call them a coward.That being said no one made me join, yet I don't want American soliders dying during a lied into war. I don't care if you have served or not but not one American is any more American than the rest. I really dislike repubs and teabaggers but they are Americans, they're just wrong for America.
photo
Debbie Shoemaker
bleeding heart and proud of it
04:44 PM on 07/26/2010
My ancestors were Blackfoot and Cherokee Indians. Other ancestors migrated here from Germany and the Netherlands. But a large part of my genetic make up is Native American. I live in mid-Missouri on a farm that has been in the family for generations, my children being the 6th generation. However, I am not a "real" American because I will thump my Bible while making "goo-goo" eyes at my neighbor. I have no fondness for guns and do not have any and my husband doesn't hunt. I feel that every woman knows what is the best decision regarding her reproductive rights and the gays do not threaten my marriage or frighten my children. I believe in education for myself and my children. So as you can see, I am a "fake" American living in "real" America.
photo
e-cat
limit the litters, neuter your critters
05:21 PM on 07/26/2010
Hmmmm.... you are more like a *real* American living in a *fake* America as of late. I applaud and stand with your sentiments. I, too, am a *fake* American according to the Palin fictionary.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
outsidethemainstream
05:33 PM on 07/26/2010
faved
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Robert Mackey
04:42 PM on 07/26/2010
Amen. Three combat tours, but because I'm a Democrat, I'm not "a real American."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Stewart Nusbaumer
05:28 PM on 07/26/2010
Had leg amputated in Nam, so I'm not "a real American"?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dorian de Wind
08:53 AM on 08/07/2010
Robert and Stewart:

Thank you both for your service. You are the Real Americans
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dorian de Wind
08:56 AM on 08/07/2010
Stewart:

I must add: and thank you so much for your sacrifice.
photo
Debbie Shoemaker
bleeding heart and proud of it
05:54 PM on 07/26/2010
Thank you for serving our country and thanks for putting your country first(being a Democrat) :)
03:51 PM on 07/26/2010
Thank you. It is amazing how so many Republicans who have never served in the Armed Forces can wrap themselves in the flag. Most of our wealthiest citizens (the core of the Republican Party) were too busy making money to serve the country that protects them and allows them to flourish. Let's remember that our red, white and blue colors are the same as the French Revolution's tri-color. We are a far better people when we embrace Liberty, Fraternity and Equality than when we permit the establishment of a permanent, hereditary American nobility through the avenue of acquired wealth.

Historical Aside about the tri-color: Following the French disavowal of the Iraq War (they were right), I've often heard rude remarks about the French and their Foreign Policy. Most have forgotten that it was French Naval support at Yorktown that prevented the escape of the British army. This was a very courageous confrontation on their part to stare down the most feared and respected navy in the world for the sake of American colonists who were mostly English, not French. It was Napoleon who allowed us to expand to the west by selling us the Louisiana Purchase territories. The French nation has suffered much devastation by their neighbors since the 1870's, but have not surrended their belief in liberty and their republic. They have held their nobility at bay. We should likewise hold our nobility at bay for the sake of our liberty.