iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dr. Boyce Watkins

Dr. Boyce Watkins

Posted: March 22, 2011 12:54 PM

Al Sharpton, Ben Jealous, Tom Joyner Plan to "Measure the Movement" in Black Leadership


A year ago, we thought this date was never going to arrive. It's the one year anniversary of last year's "Measuring the Movement" forum, where Rev. Al Sharpton brought together a list of black public figures to produce constructive solutions for problems being faced by the African American community. The list of invitees was a virtual "who's who" of black leadership that only Sharpton could put together: NAACP President Ben Jealous, Urban League President Marc Morial, radio show host Tom Joyner, CNN's Roland Martin, Georgetown University Professor Michael Eric Dyson, Harvard Professor Charles Ogletree and even men like Judge Greg Mathis got together to talk about the direction of black America.

I was personally invited to speak at the forum, given my role as founder of the Your Black World Coalition and the Athlete Liberation Academic Reform Movement (ALARM). The forum was unique in that it demanded both action and accountability on the parts of everyone involved, and everyone agreed to be measured against a list of promises the following year. The day of reckoning has arrived, as the forum is set to take place in Harlem next month.

With regard to the direction of black America, the debate seems both perpetually engaging and consistently volatile. It is further complicated by the famous black guy in the Oval Office, President Barack Obama. Some seem to feel that having a black president eliminates the need for progressive black leadership. But after having two years of a black president who won't even say the words "black man" or "black woman" in public (at least not since the Henry Louis Gates debacle in 2009), we are learning that black leadership is needed more than ever before. The millions of African Americans who loyally support Obama are standing knee-deep in double-digit unemployment rates, massive home foreclosures, a persistent wealth gap, bankruptcy, mass incarceration, unaddressed racial discrimination in the workplace and failed inner city schools. All the while, the black community is determined not to disturb the president as he does favors for other constituencies who've threatened to abandon his administration.

An obvious outsider to the Measuring the Movement forum is Tavis Smiley, who's been at odds with Sharpton and President Obama for the last three years. Cornel West (a close friend of Smiley's) likely won't attend either, and I am not even sure about Rev. Jesse Jackson. This is unfortunate, given that it makes no sense that black American leadership has been divided by a president who has made it abundantly clear that he has little interest in targeting the black community for any form of specific advocacy or support. In their nearly unanimous conclusion that Obama is the best that Washington has to offer, black America must also understand that Washington never has offered us very much. Keeping in sync with their loyalties toward President Obama, it seems that Sharpton, Jealous and Morial can still find a way to reconcile with Smiley, Jackson and West.

By pulling together the most progressive and respected minds in the African American community, it might be possible to produce an agenda that truly reflects the best that black leadership has to offer. But in order for the healing to occur, Smiley and company would have to express a greater degree of empathy toward those in the black community who hold President Obama in high regard. In my weekly on-air conversations with Sharpton, we've often debated the merits of the Obama Administration, and by agreeing to disagree on key points, Sharpton seems open-minded toward those who disagree with the president. In a fundamental sense, we cannot allow the Obama Administration's massive political power to divide and conquer black America by rewarding one group over another as a function of their individual loyalties.

In politics, they say that in order to be effective, you must govern from the center. Well, the same thing might be true for black leadership. As a community, we must ask ourselves just how much of our future we are leveraging in exchange for a few years of Obama power in the White House. The long-term sustainability of genuine black advocacy is far more important than nearly any other mechanism for our community's advancement. Thus far, Obama's tangible impact on the state of black America has been minimal, so the millions of African Americans who are suffering must find alternative paths for personal peace, security and social liberation. The leaders at the Measuring the Movement forum are among our greatest hopes as it stands, so it is important that they find a way to work together.

 

Follow Dr. Boyce Watkins on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DrBoyceWatkins1

A year ago, we thought this date was never going to arrive. It's the one year anniversary of last year's "Measuring the Movement" forum, where Rev. Al Sharpton brought together a list of black public...
A year ago, we thought this date was never going to arrive. It's the one year anniversary of last year's "Measuring the Movement" forum, where Rev. Al Sharpton brought together a list of black public...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:03 PM on 04/07/2011
Boyce, I have one simple question, were there any women at the table here? Are there any African-American women who's voices count in such a weighty discussion about the good of ALL African-Americans? I'm curious.
10:14 AM on 04/01/2011
While I respect all parties involved in the discussion and know they are all trying to make a difference in their own way, nothing has changed? People can meet all day and have great ideas but we are in the same position. I've wondered what is accomplished besides putting out what someone else is doing or not doing. A lot of people have great ideas but ideas aren't actions. If all the political figures at these meetings could hire people instantly or find jobs for people then that's movement. Coming on t.v. or constantly talking about the same issues month after month, year after year means something isn't getting done and not much progress is being made. Imagine the money and power at these meetings. Something more surely seems like it can be done. I'm just an observer and I don't have all the answers either but I also don't have the resources these people have. How do you measure success in this instance? Is it by a number? I guess people will be "called out" and held accountable when this meeting takes place again. Perhaps then progress can be measured. But I doubt it.....
07:15 AM on 04/01/2011
I wonder if both sides of the leadership dilemma realized that neither side is in touch with the reality of the African American Community. Many of the issues debated by the intellectuals are not relevant to the community and not well understood by them. Both groups are leading their perception of issues and not leading the people. We cannot lead by doing social justice for the people but it has to be done with the people. What does Pookie want for his life not what we think Pookie needs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeanrenoir
05:08 PM on 03/22/2011
The real problem for the Civil Rights Movement, as for Democratic liberals in general, is that it so far has no answer whatsoever to Fox, Rush, and the rest of the far-right media gurus who've created such a huge voting block of white voters who are now utterly open and unashamed in their all-out war on government programs aimed at supporting the poor, and especially the black poor, in any way, shape, or form. So the Civil Rights Movement seems dead in the water politically, with much less clout than at any time in the past fifty years. The bottom line is that the right now has the votes, and until blacks find a way to build a voting majority in the electorate through appeals to moderate whites and independents, it's very hard to see the Movement ever having any decisive impact on American politics again, especially since Hispanics are becoming the larger and larger most important minority in America every year, thus further marginalizing black political power at the ballot box.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
flacon
02:25 PM on 03/22/2011
These men are all diminished by their association with Al Sharpton. Did I miss something or is today's black leadership made up entirely of men?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeanrenoir
05:10 PM on 03/22/2011
This has been a dirty little secret of the top leaders of the Civil Rights organizations all along, hasn't it? There have been well-known black female elected officials at all levels, and famous women in the Movement, like Rosa Parks and the rest, but the leadership of the organizations has been utterly, and anachronistically, male.
01:49 PM on 03/22/2011
Ugh.