iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Duane Elgin

GET UPDATES FROM Duane Elgin

4 Misconceptions About the Simple Life

Posted: 08/27/11 12:38 PM ET

It is important to recognize inaccurate stereotypes about the simple life because they make it seem impractical and ill suited for responding to increasingly critical breakdowns in world systems. Four misconceptions about the simple life are so common they deserve special attention. These are equating simplicity with: poverty, moving back to the land, living without beauty and economic stagnation.

  1. Simplicity Means Poverty Although some spiritual traditions have advocated a life of extreme renunciation, it is very misleading to equate simplicity with poverty. Poverty is involuntary and debilitating, whereas simplicity is voluntary and enabling. A life of conscious simplicity can have both a beauty and a functional integrity that elevates the human spirit.

    Poverty fosters a sense of helplessness, passivity and despair, whereas purposeful simplicity fosters a sense of personal empowerment, creative engagement and opportunity. Historically, those choosing a simpler life have sought the golden mean -- a creative and aesthetic balance between poverty and excess. Instead of placing primary emphasis on material riches, they have sought to develop, with balance, the invisible wealth of experiential riches.

  2. Simplicity Means Rural Living
    In the popular imagination there is a tendency to equate the simple life with Thoreau's cabin in the woods by Walden Pond and to assume that people must live an isolated and rural existence. Interestingly, Thoreau was not a hermit during his stay at Walden Pond. His famous cabin was roughly a mile from the town of Concord, and every day or two he would walk into town. His cabin was so close to a nearby highway that he could smell the pipe smoke of passing travelers.

    Thoreau wrote that he had "more visitors while I lived in the woods than any other period of my life." The romanticized image of rural living does not fit the modern reality, as a majority of persons choosing a life of conscious simplicity do not live in the backwoods or rural settings; they live in cities and suburbs. While green living brings with it a reverence for nature, it does not require moving to a rural setting. Instead of a "back to the land" movement, it is much more accurate to describe this as a "make the most of wherever you are" movement. Increasingly that means adapting ourselves creatively to a rapidly changing world in the context of big cities and suburbs.

  3. Simplicity Means Living Without Beauty
    The simple life is sometimes viewed as an approach to living that advocates a barren plainness and denies the value of beauty and aesthetics. While the Puritans, for example, were suspicious of the arts, most advocates of simplicity have seen it as essential for revealing the natural beauty of things.

    Many who adopt a simpler life would surely agree with Pablo Picasso, who said, "Art is the elimination of the unnecessary." Leonardo da Vinci wrote that, "Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication." Frederic Chopin wrote that, "Simplicity is the final achievement ... the crowning reward of art."

    The influential architect Frank Lloyd Wright was an advocate of an "organic simplicity" that integrates function with beauty and eliminates the superfluous. In his architecture a building's interior and exterior blend into an organic whole, and the building, in turn, blends harmoniously with the natural environment. Rather than involving a denial of beauty, simplicity liberates the aesthetic sense by freeing things from artificial encumbrances. From a spiritual perspective, simplicity removes the obscuring clutter and discloses the life-energy that infuses all things.

  4. Simplicity Means Economic Stagnation
    Some worry that if a significant number of people simplify their lives it will reduce demand for consumer goods and, in turn, produce unemployment and economic stagnation. While it is true that the level and patterns of personal consumption would shift in a society that values green living, a robust economy can flourish that embraces sustainability.

    Although the consumer sector and material goods would contract, the service and public sectors would expand dramatically. When we look at the world, we see a huge number of unmet needs: caring for elderly, restoring the environment, educating illiterate and unskilled youth, repairing decaying roads and infrastructure, providing health care, creating community markets and local enterprises, retrofitting the urban landscape for sustainability and many more. Because there are an enormous number of unmet needs, there are an equally large number of purposeful and satisfying jobs waiting to get done. There will be no shortage of employment opportunities in an Earth-friendly economy.

A central and exciting task for our times is consciously designing ourselves into a sustainable and meaningful future, from the personal level outwards. In envisioning what this future could look like, it is important to not be bound by old stereotypes and to instead see the realism and the beauty of simpler ways of living.

 
 
 

Follow Duane Elgin on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DuaneElgin

It is important to recognize inaccurate stereotypes about the simple life because they make it seem impractical and ill suited for responding to increasingly critical breakdowns in world systems. Four...
It is important to recognize inaccurate stereotypes about the simple life because they make it seem impractical and ill suited for responding to increasingly critical breakdowns in world systems. Four...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 68
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrMiaRose
Psychologist and Author
08:49 PM on 10/15/2011
To me, simplicity equals clarity. The more I let go of excess, the more I feel a sense of calm and inner peace. Eliminating clutter, whether in my mind or my environment, is an essential way of breaking through confusion. Besides, the simplest things are often the most beautiful.

Great article, thanks so much!

Mia Rose
http://www.healinglovenotes.com
09:26 PM on 10/15/2011
I'm posting this on my blog. Hope you don't mind. Your comment, in of itself, is clear, concise, simple, yet profound. Love it!
06:18 PM on 08/30/2011
Fight Club for the win "The things you own end up owning you." -Tyler Durden
I have seen this cycle break down person after person, relationships, marital or social, time and time again. I'm not saying less is more, but maybe more isn't more either. Learn when enough is enough, you'll stress less.
12:17 PM on 08/30/2011
For me the best simple life is one that balances time, space and money, My ultimate goal is to feel useful, creative, and in control of my own life. (I'm not there yet on time and space, but I'm working on it.) Obviously, the balance will be different for different people depending on what they most want and what they most lack. I agree that the simple life can be achieved in different locales--it's probably found 95% in our heads anyway.
10:59 AM on 08/30/2011
Simply stated...wanting what you have, and being content, are the foundations of "the simple life". We have been"programmed' by the media to desire more and more, and having say, a new car, as opposed to just a reliable o.k. car. I feel sad for the people who surround themselves with the trappings and forget who they are.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
einhverfr
Heathen Distributist
12:37 PM on 08/30/2011
BTW, I suggest the problem isn't consumption right now, but rather prestige in employment and an attachment to a corporate lifestyle. For what I say this go look up Elizabeth Warren's lecture entitled "The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class." People are actually spending less on the whole in consumer spending areas than they were a generation ago. The second car is because that's what you NEED if you need two corporate incomes......
11:03 PM on 08/30/2011
Agreed, and will look for that lecture. As far as "the corporate life", I couldn't comment on that, having never joined the rat race myself. Been pretty satisfied with who I am, never needed outside affirmation.
photo
MimiK
living in dramatic times
10:33 AM on 08/30/2011
The quotations from the artists are illuminating, pointing us to the creative essence of Voluntary Simplicity. At heart, we are talking about approaching our lives as a creative project. The art of life. Life as the one work of art we all create.

"Voluntary Simplicity" as the title of a life-art project that pares away all that is in unnecessary to a beautiful life.

I would add this: that beauty is not only in things and stuff; beauty is also in experiences and our emotional life. Part of the art of Voluntary Simplicity is creating a life that is, on balance, filled with life-affirming, beautiful human emotions -- caring, connecting, 'communing' with our human, natural, and built communities, and so on.

It is about the very challenging discipline and practice of making choices in your life that (as we put it in my family and tribe of friends) make your life story worth experiencing yourself and passing on to the generations that will come after.

What is the story you individually, and we, collectively, at this time in the evolution of humanity want future generations to tell about us? That we consumed the world to death, or that we created lives that allowed future generations to live?

Thank you, Duane, for never giving up on your beautiful vision.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Duane Elgin
Speaker, author, trans-partisan media activist
01:52 PM on 08/30/2011
I really like how you describe a life of voluntary simplicity: Our lives are the one work of art that we all get to create, and simplicity pares away to unnecessary to reveal the beauty of the life we consciously choose.
09:25 AM on 08/30/2011
The simple life means personal responsibility - responsibility for your own actions as well as responsibility for yourself. It means preparation and not giving in to the moment simply because something sounds good at the time, be someone actually living the simple life, knows well that you never know what tomorrow may bring. Unfortunately, in this day and age where Hollywood dictates morals and what you "need" to buy, hardly anyone lives anything close to the simple life anywhere. Radical consumerism as well this cultural construct of "It's all bout ME! Who cares about you?" have created far too many into brainwashed idiots unable to dictate between need and want. In the simple life, you know the difference well.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MUDPUPPY
07:10 AM on 08/30/2011
The simple life ain't simple. Those living the "simple" life have to be able to be very independent, able to take care of most of their own basic needs with enough excesses to sell and barter for the goods and needed skills of others. Yep, basic capitalism.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
einhverfr
Heathen Distributist
11:32 AM on 08/30/2011
Sure it's still basic capitalism.... At it's best!

But think about it this way.... Even if you were in the city, and you and your spouse became self-employed, working from your home..... That provides a myriad of opportunities to reduce expenses-- being a one car instead of a two car familiy, raising your own kids rather than hiring that job out to a day care center, living as a family unit economically. It's a good life. I know because that's what I do.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EcoHustler
www.ecohustler.co.uk
07:02 AM on 08/30/2011
Great stuff!

And of course if we all live simply we can have a beautiful, diverse and bountiful biosphere to play in.
06:40 AM on 08/30/2011
Well said, Duane, and simply. Especially the comments about art and the possible shift in the economy. More focus on what caring and concerned people can do out of love and awareness - that is knowing what to do, when, where, with who and how much - and less on our victimization by big banks, business and government.
05:15 AM on 08/30/2011
I like this article, thanks very much.
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
10:52 PM on 08/29/2011
Simplicity is not allowing advertisements to make your choices for you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
walsenberg
10:44 PM on 08/29/2011
This guy is saying what I have been thinking. We try to seek nourishment from an ever mounting pile of material goods. It gives us enough to keep going but it can never satisfy our hunger for more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
10:12 PM on 08/29/2011
I'm trying to gradually simplify my life as my budget allows. Part of this is buying for quality, which to me means durability and utility. I have some cheap stuff, but I'm always on the lookout for an "upgrade" that will last me a lifetime.
10:06 PM on 08/29/2011
No doubt id a significant number of people embraced your utopia there would be no pharmaceutical companies making your prescriptions, and no one importing your beloved Starbucks. How can you have healthcare without the $1,000,000 machine that goes Bing!!
MRI's cat scans, radiopharmaceuticals, don't come cheap or easy, or as you put it simple.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
10:20 PM on 08/29/2011
Aaaaand another one misses the point!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
einhverfr
Heathen Distributist
11:37 AM on 08/30/2011
Certainly if everyone started living consciously and in a more distributive way (smaller businesses, more people owning their own means of production, etc) corporations would be smaller and less powerful and those which don't deliver value in that world would have to change or die. That's the way of life. Maybe Starbucks and Walmart would go away. However those which are indispensable would survive, though perhaps as a somewhat smaller entity.
09:11 PM on 08/29/2011
And moving out to the country for "the simple life" means your triple platinum credit card won't dig you out of two feet of snow... You can read and dream about "the simple life in the country, but "city smarts" won't work when it's just you and an unforgiving mother nature.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
10:08 PM on 08/29/2011
...

Do you read articles, or do you just look at the title, hop down to the comments, and fire away?
01:32 AM on 08/30/2011
nope. I'm unlike you, speaking from personal experience, of being a person who can live a "simple life" away from the support of civilization. And who saw way too many "city folk" who read something like this about living the simple life, and discovered the hard way, that "simplicity" is way more than a concept of a way of life. "simple" can also be dangerous. A 5the degree Black belt is simple. simple often means you're not prepared to deal with what life and Mother Nature can throw at you. IOW, when concept meets reality.. All of the author's points about misconceptions refer to what I post. But you missed that, because you "Assume". and you are definitely not a candidate for the simple life.