More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Earl Ofari Hutchinson

Earl Ofari Hutchinson

GET UPDATES FROM Earl Ofari Hutchinson

America's Most Segregated Cities Likely to Stay That Way

Posted: 04/ 1/11 10:15 AM ET

The recent report that America's most segregated cities are just as -- if not more -- segregated than they were a couple of decades ago is hardly a revelation. The report focused on the top 10 most segregated cities. But this could easily be expanded to find vast and unbroken pockets of racial segregation in many of the nation's smaller and mid-size cities as well. A casual drive through any of the major urban neighborhoods in America, a walk through the neighborhood schools, hospitals, and clinics reveals the stark pattern of the two Americas. In fact, even three or four urban Americas: an America that is poor, black and Latino; an America that is black and middle class; an America that is white, working class and middle class; and one that's white and wealthy.

But whichever urban America one travels through, the line dividing the neighborhoods is as deep as the Grand Canyon. There are the usual suspects to blame for the rigid segregation. Poverty, crime, lender redlining, a decaying industrial and manufacturing inner city, white and middle-class black and Hispanic flight, crumbling inner-city schools, the refusal of major business and financial institutions to locate in minority neighborhoods, and cash-strapped city governments that have thrown in the towel on providing street repairs and basic services.

This tells a big part of the story of the chronic segregation, but it's only part of the story. The painful truth three years after the election of America's first black president is that there are far too many policy makers, political leaders, and many whites that still think that segregation is too much a longstanding, even immutable, way of life in America to ever change. The entire history of Northern urban segregation is damning proof of that.

In the decades before the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, the great migration of blacks from the South before and after both World Wars, and the flight of whites from urban neighborhoods to the suburbs locked in place the economic, social, and political mindset that racial segregation was a fact of life in the North and would stay that way. Redlining, zoning laws, and the federal government's deliberate policy of bolstering residential segregation insured that. Even as the Jim Crow barriers tumbled in the South and blacks and whites mingled in schools, public facilities, and more and more neighborhoods, residential segregation in the North remained America's idée fixe.

Every census report in the post-Civil Rights era and the countless Urban League's State of Black America reports showed that the inner cities continued to get blacker and browner and poorer, while the suburbs got whiter and more well to do. That trend isn't likely to change.

With President Obama and Congressional leaders trying to figure out where to cut every penny they can from education, health care and employment programs, there is absolutely no chance of any new spending or initiatives to be put on the legislative table to deal with the continuing decay of urban neighborhoods. Some experts have pointed to the increasing gentrification by young whites and non-blacks of some urban neighborhoods as a hopeful sign that residential segregation could in time pass away. That's not likely. In fact, studies have shown that gentrification has not altered the neighborhood racial segregation patterns as much as is popularly presented. Many of the old homes that have been renovated as chic, pricey, apartments and townhouses, have been gobbled up, not by whites and non-blacks, but by upwardly-mobile black professionals. They are upscale, but they are still black, and so are the freshly gentrified neighborhoods they live in.

Urban racial segregation, then, may not be the permanent lot of American society, but if past decades and current policies are any sign, America's most segregated cities will stay that way for more census counts to come.


Earl Ofari Hutchinson is an author and political analyst. He hosts a national Capitol Hill broadcast radio talk show on KTYM Radio Los Angeles and WFAX Radio Washington, D.C. streamed on The Hutchinson Report Newsmaker Hour on blogtalkradio.com and wfax.com and Internet TV broadcast on thehutchinsonreportnews.com

 

Follow Earl Ofari Hutchinson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/earlhutchinson

 
 
  • Comments
  • 180
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
Epilef2000
Cafe Con Leche Party
07:53 PM on 04/03/2011
Only a white president will be able to address the issue of desegregation in America--not Obama. but, there is considerable amount of voluntary desegregation is not only white flight, its also black and Latino voluntarily associating with their groups--the problem exists when certain racial or ethnic groups are primarily associated with the lower social classes, and other are associated with higher classes or more opportunities.

Even in college, I had a relationship with black girll..and someone starting singing "jungle fever" which I looked at them..and thought..are these people in the 21st century? ignorance is not bliss
08:59 AM on 04/04/2011
It's not just lower social classes. And it also applies to all cultures and races. Chinatown, Little Italy are other examples of how culture and race have maintained separation. I also understand that in my two examples, those areas likely came about due to force and prejudiced early on.
05:30 AM on 04/03/2011
Gee, where do the white poor live. They do exist. They must live somewhere.
photo
papapj
..light as a feather..
02:54 PM on 04/03/2011
They are everywhere..and there are more of them (poor Whites) than of any other ethnicity, numerically....check a trailer park near you....
garystartswithg
el sueno de la razon produce republicans
04:06 PM on 04/03/2011
the most accurate map of poor whites I have seen is a map made by the Christian Science Monitor that mapped where the tea party was most active. When you look at the map of LA/Orange county you have to remember to the east of the cities is a band of trailer park ex-urbs -- and the tea party thrives in that area like no other.
09:03 AM on 04/04/2011
So by your statements, you don't like the tea party? You're reviewing 1 city. While it's probably true that rural, poor white people are likely to identify with the tea party and limited government, it is not a majority of the demographics. Rural living people tend to be and want to be self sufficient and be left to live without much interference from government bodies. At least the ones I know. There are always exceptions.
11:14 PM on 04/02/2011
i don't care who lives next to me as long as they're quiet most days of the year and take care of their kids.
11:10 PM on 04/02/2011
my suburban neighborhood in austin is white and hispanic only.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
missingwmd
Not afraid of the Elephant in the room.
10:13 PM on 04/02/2011
i don't know if moving next door to people of another race is the answer. Sure people have the right to if they want but if you think the key to a better life is living next to white people then you are in for a rude awakening. Nothing wrong with moving to the burbs or anywhere else but conversely there is nothing wrong with staying in the urban areas and working to make them better.
09:05 AM on 04/04/2011
Agreed, everyone has their quirks and peeves.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeanrenoir
04:56 PM on 04/02/2011
There never has been any way to legislate de-segregation in America. Whites do their best to stay as far away as they can afford from the crime and blight of urban black America. What a shock! Of course, as blacks themselves improve their status through education and better pay, they abandon the black inner city in droves, too. American politics is now utterly dominated by conservative white middle-class and working-class voters. The Supreme Court is right wing, too. Under these circumstances, there is less hope for de-segregating the lives of urban poor blacks today than there has been in the past fifty years. It's hard to see how this picture will change any time soon. Obviously, Obama wouldn't touch this issue with a thousand-foot pole. He's barely hanging onto power by his fingernails anyway, in which a huge chunk of the white electorate, which controls almost all national and state outcomes, still wants to believe he's not even an American. So in the area of civil rights, as in that of climate change or any other "progressive" issue, "progressives" are now left to talk only to each other, within their helpless minority of voters. The majority is opposed to everything "progressives" believe in which is the least bit controversial. Until "progressives" figure out a magic trick allowing them to win over a solid chunk of white right-wing voters, "progressivism" will be dead in America, and so will de-segregation beyond black suburban flight.
Tommi2
Ignorance is a self-inflicted disease.
07:21 PM on 04/02/2011
Obama was elected by a huge majority who were endlessly told that he was a liberal, progressive, socialist, communist, Muslim, etc, etc.
If he is "hanging on to power by his fingertips" as you say, it's because he has revealed basically none of those tendencies.
He's barely a moderate.
He will be our President for another 4 years.
Until the "fright wing" figure out a magic trick to win over all the people, we will vote Obama back in because the Palin, Bachman, Gingrich, Barbour, etc. etc loonies are out of their respective minds. "Tea-party" Republicanism, conservatism, etc is a laughing stock that will survive only in it's ignorance.
The majority of this country is progressive. Yes. It is. Sadly they just are not progressive enough to all vote.
They are passive observers of politics who are too busy trying to survive, get a paycheck, raise their kids, and pay their bills with chump wages, unemployment checks, or worse.
The zealousness of tea partiers get's them to vote. They are duped. Most all of them vote with glaring ignorance.
I commend them though.
But they are overreaching and hopefully will wake up all the true progressives they dump on.
11:32 AM on 04/02/2011
Patches of Urban Atlanta are "revitalizing" with a blend of whites and blacks. There is a 97% black neighborhood next door (across the tracks) and I'm in a 70% Black Neighborhood that was nearly 100% black in past. Of course there's still white isolationism to the north -- so much so that major highways are being added at tremendous cost...money that could build infrastructure of the city they like to "use" and then drive away from. In this vein I hope gas goes to $10 a gallon...then they'll rethink their ridiculous 2-3 hour commutes! Nobody is talking about how the taxpayer is "enabling" this white flight and segregation!

This Neighborhood is coming round to Balance and diversity because of the very affordable, awesome 20's & 30's homes that are being renovated; it's proximity to the city and public transit, park space, and location on the beltline (The nation's largest urban renewal project). Some blacks want to keep the area a "hood" and fear property tax increases....but most blacks and whites want to live in a revitalized neighborhood where their homes are eventually worth more. As another said, it really is about behaviors --- I trust some of my black neighbors (keys to my house) but a very few others (black, hispanic or white) I don't bother with cuz they're angry, cracked out/drunk, and/or thieves.
photo
papapj
..light as a feather..
01:30 PM on 04/02/2011
Parts of urban Atlanta are being GENTRIFIED, let's not get it twisted...Those same people you mentioned subjecting themselves to 2hr one-way commutes are now feeling the results of their panicked, ill thought out White flight. Now the consequences of spending 5hrs and more a day commuting are being felt with estranged couples with mall-rat kids seeking comfort in electronic gadgetry.

They want back into the city..there's some handsome property in urban Atlanta that's being furiously snapped up by returning suburbanites.
garystartswithg
el sueno de la razon produce republicans
09:42 PM on 04/02/2011
I live in midtown between Ponce and the park, and a friend was just visiting, and he said "its not as gentrified as I thought it would be". My rent is cheaper than anything I could get in Roswell. Is that gentrified?
There is what I think is more of a by product of suburban divorce -- its not whole families moving intown to gentrify, I agree there are people sick of the commute, but they are taking up new high rises, not old neighborhoods.
Currently East Point is trying hard to turn itself around -- and that includes selling for dirt cheap, but the housing stock isn't going to attract anyone that isn't ready to do a whole lot of work. .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeanrenoir
05:03 PM on 04/02/2011
Atlanta is the best place on earth for black people. Certainly better than anywhere in South Africa, for example, it's only competition in this area. It has long since surpassed the DC area in regard to the prosperity of its vibrant and growing black middle class. I'm a white guy who grew up in Atlanta during the King era, and was very much on his side. So I love to see how well Atlanta is doing. In Brokaw's book on the Sixties called Boom, Andy Young says flat out that Atlanta has "arrived," and has achieved King's "dream" of fair opportunity for all. Young goes on to say that, of course, there are hundreds of thousands of poor blacks left in Atlanta, but Young explicitly says there is nothing government can do to solve their plight. He in effect endorses Cosby's idea that it's up to each family to work hard to improve the lots of its kids in an Atlanta which offers equal opportunity to all those prepared by hard work and character to take advantage of it. Atlanta's not paradise. Nowhere is. But it has made miraculous strides in race relations, and especially opportunities for middle-class blacks to make plenty of money, in the last fifty years. Just watch The Real Housewives of Atlanta. Most of these nouveaux-riches obsessive shoppers are black.
garystartswithg
el sueno de la razon produce republicans
09:29 PM on 04/02/2011
I haven't watched "real housewives" but I would assume they were in Alpharetta, not Atlanta.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
LisaLisa1234
10:50 AM on 04/02/2011
I expected that Memphis would not end up on this list, because there was an article in the city's newspaper recently showing the results of the census report, and how there are quite a few diverse areas in metro Memphis.

However, all one has to do is read a few comments at The Commercial Appeal to see how very strident and loud the racists can be. Most of them have moved out of the city & get their daily jollies commenting how bad Memphis is; but many folks in the city & metro area are looking forward and quietly making progress.

So if you ever happen to read The Commercial Appeal online, keep in mind that many Memphians aren't thinking the same way as the commenters (you'll see very quickly who they are) on that website.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bobclapp1936
09:54 AM on 04/02/2011
Urban, and all other forms of segragation, will be gone NOT one day sooner than RACISM is gone. True here, South Africa, and anywhere slavery's remains persist.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:05 AM on 04/02/2011
Hey Earl, how about the list of the top ten cities, you referenced?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
LisaLisa1234
10:41 AM on 04/02/2011
Click on the words "recent report" in the first sentence. :)
06:59 AM on 04/02/2011
Along with all the reasons you mentioned for segregation, you forgot one - choice. It is human nature and surely a social paradigm for groups to congregate and draw comfort from a sense of sameness. Mr. Hutchinson, on your day off, when you're not being scholarly or journalistic...who do you CHOOSE to spend time with? People have clustered together as long as there have been people and not always do to external or negative forces.
photo
FirstGame72
The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters
09:48 AM on 04/02/2011
In other words: This just in! Humans do not get along with each other nearly as well as we claim we do. Imagine that?
photo
LoneTree
Don't shelter me from criticism.
02:23 AM on 04/02/2011
I speak only for myself, but I'll tell you this. It's behaviors, not race or ethnicity. I really don't give a rat's donut what race or ethnicity or religion or sexual orientation someone adheres to. What I do care about is a common ethic of respecting the privacy and property of others. I do care about not people, my neighbors, keeping their behaviors inside the boundaries of their own property. I'm interested in not having to lock my front door, or even know where the key is. Anyone, or any race, or any ethnicity, or any religion, or any sexual orientation, or anything else, is welcome as a neighbor in this neighborhood, if they extend the same respect back to me.

The burden to respect community standards is on anyone who would want to move into that community. The burden is not on the community to accept and condone destructive behaviors. This is the true divide that keeps socio-cultural-economic groups separate. You can't escape something by moving somewhere else, if you drag what you're trying to escape along with you.
photo
FirstGame72
The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters
09:53 AM on 04/02/2011
Wonderfully stated Tree. I would only add that on a daily basis it can take real self dicipline to truly behave completely decently to others around you at all times and to treat others as you yourself would like to be treated (golden rule). This is a dicipline that most people fall short of, leading to many of society's problems.
photo
LoneTree
Don't shelter me from criticism.
01:38 PM on 04/02/2011
You are absolutely correct. Good relationships with neighbors can help bridge some of these incidents. If our neighbors have a party that goes late and gets loud, but it only happens occasionally, and they don't spill over into our yard, eh, you know? Forgive and forget. The next day, they probably feel worse about it than anyone else.
10:28 AM on 04/02/2011
Perfect ! It always comes back to personal responsibility.
01:36 AM on 04/02/2011
I am quite stunned to learn that I live in the 10th (Los Angeles) most segregated city in America. I feel immersed and surrounded by many other cultures. However, one stroll through my neighborhood quickly brings reality into perspective. It wasn't until long ago that I remember out first "black" neighbors moving in, a mixed family at that; I'm only 19 which further illustrates the circumstance.
01:30 AM on 04/02/2011
I grew up in a very segragated town and when I was old enough, I decided that I would always live in the most diverse areas that I could. I have been extremely happy with the result.
photo
Alwayspissedoffatsomeone
Fighting for Common Sense
01:13 AM on 04/02/2011
Why? Drill down until you find the true answer. Why have areas like say, LA, once a thriving metropolis and highly sought after relocation city of the early 20th century, turned into the $***hole it is today? This goes for Atlanta, Detroit, New Orleans, Buffalo, and on and on? Why?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
SitandStay
Lorenzo&BushH8ter
04:10 AM on 04/02/2011
I live in Atlanta, you must not get out very much.