Eat The Press

barney calame nyt.jpg


Scoop from the New York Observer: Apparently the New York Times is deciding whether to eliminate the public editor position, first installed following the Jayson Blair plagiarism-and-making-front-page-news-up-out-of-his-head scandal. Executive editor Bill Keller told the Observer's Michael Calderone that the position might be eliminated after the current public editor, Byron Calame (aka "Barney") completes his term in May 2007.

Keller, who created the position as first order of business when he took over from Howell Raines in 2003, raised the idea of axing it at an in-house Q&A in December. Keller told Calderone that "some of my colleagues believe the greater accessibility afforded by features like 'Talk to the Newsroom' has diminished the need for an autonomous ombudsman, or at least has opened the way for a somewhat different definition of the job."

Oh, really? As Calderone points out, "Talk To The Newsroom" is done by NYT editors, about their section. Some, like Keller's entry (to his credit) are pages and pages long. Others, like TV editor Steven Redicliffe, are much shorter. How are the questions selected? Does every question get answered? Who decides? I know the answer to number two, because I submitted a question to Redicliffe during his stint, asking if Redicliffe was aware of Alessandra Stanley's reputation in the blogosphere for making obvious errors and what measures, if any, had been implemented to address those errors. The question was not selected for response, and this was the most detailed analysis Redicliffe offered about Stanley: "Alessandra Stanley, our senior television critic, has written about everything from Web episodes of "The Office" to the instant availability of campaign commercials on the Internet." Did Redicliffe have to answer my question? Of course not. I don't even know if it reached him. But this example highlights the built-in dangers of consigning Ombudsman-like duties to editors with a vested interest in making their sections look good.

But here's a even better reason to keep the Public Editor position safe: "When Mr. Calame wrote a piece on The Times' National Security Administration wiretapping story, he did not receive responses to questions from either Mr. Keller or Mr. Sulzberger." And another: "A source with knowledge of the relationship between Mr. Keller and Mr. Calame characterized it as 'a really bad relationship.'" These two statements suggest that section editors aren't the only ones with a vested interest here.

Keller is the top editor at what is arguably the nation's top paper, the self-styled Paper of Record. With huge, lightning-rod stories like NSA spying and SWIFT bank records making major waves across the country and at the highest levels and criticism coming in from all sides, the NYT can't afford to lose it's Public Editor; the office is meant to keep the NYT honest, a constant reminder of who it is supposed to be serving and to whom it is accountable. Even more important during, in Keller's words, "a period when the credibility of the media generally has been under assault," the NYT must appear to be accountable. Getting rid of the Public Editor position ain't that.

Media Blogroll


Romenesko Gawker TVNewser Wonkette Crooks & Liars CJR Daily Drudge Dealbreaker Dealbook Defamer Deadline Hollywood Daily Mickey Kaus Jeff Jarvis Radosh James Wolcott IWantMedia The Slot Bloggermann Jake Tapper Blogging Baghdad Russert Watch Jossip Mediabistro The Media Mob at the NY Observer The Transom FishbowlNY FishbowlDC FishbowlLA GalleyCat Reference Tone Panopticist The Minor Fall, The Major Lift Penguins On the Equator Gelf Magazine- Gelflog Animal (New York) White House Press Briefings Altercation
Page Six Liz & Cindy NYDN Gossip Intelligencer Reliable Source Patrick McMullan


Jack Shafer Howard Kurtz WWD Memo Pad NYO Off The Record Broadsheet Gail Shister Keith Kelly NYT Business/Media Jay Rosen’s PressThink Fine on Media Simon Dumenco’s Media Guy Jon Friedman Media Matters The Guardian (Media) NRO Media Blog Columbia Journalism Review On The Media The Public Eye The Daily Nightly Today’s Papers Regret the Error Dan Froomkin David Folkenflik


Slate Salon New York Magazine The New Yorker The New York Review of Books The New Republic The Nation Harper’s The Atlantic Monthly The Virginia Quarterly Review Vanity Fair Esquire n+1 The Believer


The New York Times The Washington Post The New York Observer The LA Times Time Newsweek US News & World Report Wall Street Journal Editor & Publisher NY Daily News NY Post USA Today NY Sun Times of London Financial Times The Smoking Gun McClatchy
NBC ABC CBS CNN Fox News MSNBC NPR Air America BBC C-SPAN Al Jazeera
AdAge Broadcasting & Cable MediaPost MediaWeek Variety Entertainment Weekly Folio:
HuffPo Home