iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Edison de Mello, M.D., Ph.D.

GET UPDATES FROM Edison de Mello, M.D., Ph.D.
 

WORLD WATER DAY: The Water Bottle Lie and Your Health (VIDEO)

Posted: 03/22/10 01:00 PM ET

March 22nd is World Water Day. On this day all eyes will be turned overseas to the 1.1 billion people that lack access to clean drinking water. What few Americans realize is that the world water crisis has hit America with little fanfare and if we do not act soon, the devastating effects will be irreversible. But luckily this year something significant is being done about it. Beginning on world water day, an amazing new award-winning documentary, called Tapped, will embark on a 30-day cross-country trip across America in an effort to raise awareness of the water crisis in America and wean the public off their reliance on bottled water.

And yet, this is just a "drop" of what needs to be done.

While 90 percent of the US has access to clean drinking water, the remaining 10 percent live in conditions that resemble a third-world country. In a bonus clip for Tapped offered on their website, Tapped takes us to a town just three hours from Los Angeles where the water has been so polluted by the local farming community that residents must make daily trips to buy bottled water to cook, clean, and bathe in. They spend their paychecks buying bottled water thinking they will limit their exposure to the toxins in their tap water, not realizing that only a few of us really know what's in our bottled water because less than one full-time staff person at the FDA is responsible for making sure that bottled water is safe for us.

Take for example the water coolers that so many of us have in our homes and offices. Those five-gallon water jugs are made from a chemical called Bisphenol A (BPA), which was originally developed as a synthetic estrogen. Exposure to BPA has been linked to breast and prostate cancer, reproductive failures, heart disease, cognitive and behavioral problems, diabetes, obesity and asthma. A study commissioned by the Centers for Disease Control in 2007 showed that 93 percent of Americans have BPA in their urine. More recent studies are even scarier suggesting that BPA stays in the body longer than previously believed and that babies and young children may be particularly vulnerable because they may metabolize BPA more slowly than adults. Furthermore, in a study commissioned by the Environmental Working Group this past December, scientists found the chemical in nine of 10 randomly selected samples of umbilical cord blood.

The BPA compound is so harmful that several states have taken the matter on their own and are now banning it:

• Minnesota and Connecticut have lead the way and already have laws on their books banning BPA.
• Just this March, Wisconsin signed a law limiting BPA use.

• Governor Gregoire of Washington State has a bill on her desk limiting the use of BPA awaiting her signature.

• Both Houses in Maryland have approved a bill banning BPA. Governor O'Malley is expected to sign it into law

• Massachusetts has gone further and is considering banning BPA, including its use in baby bottles and sippy cups

Yet a powerful lobbying compounded by an aggressive advertising campaign by the bottled water industry have persuaded Americans that bottled water is safer, more pure and healthier than their tap water. And so bottled sales continue to rise astronomically even as scientific evidence proving the devastating effects of the industry is stronger than ever. Hello FDA, anybody home?

But what about the single-serve plastic water bottles that so many of us tote to the gym or keep in the trunks of our cars? Those are made with a different type of plastic called PET or polyethylene terephthalate, which is also not free of its harmful effect. Scientists at Goeth University in Frankfurt found in a laboratory experiment in 2009 that estrogenic compounds leach from the plastic into the water. The lead researcher of the study, Martin Wagener, and a colleague used genetically engineered yeast, which changes color in the presence of estrogen-like compounds to analyze 20 samples of mineral water. Nine samples came out of glass bottles, nine were bottled in PET plastic and two were in cardboard, juice-like boxes.

The experiment revealed estrogenic activity in seven of the nine plastic bottles and in both cardboard samples, compared with just three of the nine glass ones: "What we found was really surprising to us. If you drink water from plastic bottles, you have a high probability of drinking estrogenic compounds," Wagner reported.

Epidemiologist Shanna Swan of the University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry in New York summarizes the issue very effectively: "This is coming at a good time because the use of bottles for consuming water is getting very bad press now because of its carbon footprint," she says. "It's just another nail in the coffin of bottled water, the way I see it."

What she was referring to was the fact that It takes 1.5 million barrels a year of oil just to make the plastic water bottles Americans use. Add to that the energy needed to extract the water, refrigerate the bottles, transport them around the country (and the world), and you are looking at 50 million barrels of oil a year, according to the Pacific Institute. To add yet another nail to the coffin, a study by the environmental working group found that their samples of bottled water contained disinfection byproducts, fertilizer residue, and, not surprising, pain medication. Where do we think all the medication we take -- or worse yet, dispose of in our toilets -- ends up? Back in our water system. And most public water sanitation systems do not filter out medication or drug metabolites.

In a telephone interview with Tapped director Stephanie Soechtig, she was passionate about many of the facts uncovered in her documentary including the shocking reality that Americans in general fail to realize that 40 percent of their bottled water is drawn from municipal supplies and suffers the same problems as their tap water or worse. When water is packaged in plastic containers, it faces the potential of an array of other chemicals leaching into it. "The truth is we don't really know what is in our bottled water because it goes virtually unregulated by the FDA," Soechtig said.

According to the UN, by the year 2020, two-thirds of the world will lack access to clean drinking water. Due to economic disparities, women and Children will likely continue to be exposed to thousands of chemicals in water that are virtually unregulated by governments across the globe, including ours. And even in the US, the world's largest economy, the water and sewer pipes are so old and in such need of repair that Nestle has recently stated that America's failing infrastructure would boost bottled water sales. Yet with 40 percent of bottled water being drawn from municipal supplies, as stated previously, there is no guarantee that bottled water is any safer for us.

In addition, as previously indicated, plasticizers in our water and sewer stream are creating devastating effects to local ecosystems. The documentary uncovered that In Colorado, for instance, scientists discovered transgender fish that possessed both male and female reproductive systems because they had been exposed to the estrogen-mimicking effects of plastic. What can we do as citizens to promote change? Get educated, demand more specific water regulation and medication safety disposal from representatives in our local, state and federal governments and watch educational documentaries such as Tapped. At Akasha we found Multipure -- an affordable bottle-less water cooler than connects to the tap and runs the water through a filtration process that dispenses water more pure than bottled water. We are relentlessly educating our patients on their options and their power as consumers. We urge all of you to take a stand and not only demand more strict regulation by the FDA but also find safer and environmentally conscious alternatives to bottled water.

Dr. Edison de Mello is the founder, executive Director and co-director of the Men's Clinic of the Akasha Center for integrative Medicine in Santa Monica California. For further information visit www.akashacenter.com.



References and further Reading

Mass. to consider a limited BPA ban. Boston Globe, 03/03/10.

Doyle signs bill limiting BPA use. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 03/03/10.

Wisconsin protects kids from toxic BPA. Wisconsin Public Interest Research Group, 03/03/10.

Retailers object to ban on sports bottles with BPA. Puget Sound Business Journal, 03/04/10.

Senate votes ban on BPA in kids' containers. The Seattle Times, 01/29/10.

Plastic chemical linked to heart disease, Science Online, 17 Sep 2008.

Common plastic ingredient linked to birth defects, Science Online, 01 Apr 2003.

Plastic additive in urine and blood, Science Online, 05 Apr 2001.

Web sites:

http://motherjones.com/blue-marble/2009/02/your-water-bottle-one-quarter-full-oil
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/12/fashion/12water.html
http://www.jsonline.com/watchdog/watchdogreports/78384027.html
http://www.ewg.org/reports/bottledwater

 
March 22nd is World Water Day. On this day all eyes will be turned overseas to the 1.1 billion people that lack access to clean drinking water. What few Americans realize is that the world water cris...
March 22nd is World Water Day. On this day all eyes will be turned overseas to the 1.1 billion people that lack access to clean drinking water. What few Americans realize is that the world water cris...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 95
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
12:40 AM on 03/24/2010
I live in Fort Lauderdale where we are supposed to have clean water, but I wouldn't drink the water that comes out of my faucet. Nor would I give it to anyone else to drink. The water crisis is a lot closer than anyone thinks.
12:43 PM on 03/23/2010
Thank you Dr. deMello for your informative blog and including the video. Your care and compassion are sincerely appreciated and respected.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tom Lauria
10:52 AM on 03/23/2010
BPA is a plastic additive to polycarbonate plastic to make plastic harder. Nothing is made of "BPA" per-se. BPA effectively prevents botulism and millions of lives have been saved over the past 50 years while there is not a single reported illness or death from BPA. Let's name the countries whose health agencies have given the all-clear to BPA use: Germany, Japan, New Zealand, United States and Canada. Yes Canada, which banned baby bottles ("Out of an abundance of caution") because those bottled are heated to the boiling point in a microwave or on a stove in water. Most people don't cook in their soup in the can it comes in. As for the BPA in 5-gallon water cooler bottles, its cold-in and cold-out with incredibly minimal opportunity for migration. Your article does not the serve the public interest because its only intention is to alarm readers while ignoring any of the nuance that makes science so fascinating.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LooseCaboose
01:48 PM on 03/23/2010
Yes, science is fascinating. Take for instance, the pollution aspects of bottled water carcasses in the Pacific Ocean, one of the main plastic ingredients in the "island of plastic" that floats between Japan and the West Coast, to say nothing of those shells that have populated the ocean's bottom.
When the marketing efforts that made bottled water popular because it was distilled, or drawn from "sooooo organic" sources populated that myth of service, the Merican people bought it like a carp on a dough ball. They even think that the water is better because of the eco-friendly names it has been given, when in fact, it is the beverage industry gearing up for the eventual shortage that the population bomb and global warming together are scientifically dropping on us.
Water is the new oil, for we can get along without petroleum if we have to, but water is an essential element of survival. That's ---science.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tom Lauria
02:59 PM on 03/23/2010
There are a million different forms of floating garbage that make up the gyres in the Pacific, the Atlantic and the Indian oceans. In the movie "Tapped," and in your post, the entire, massive swirl -- the fishing lines, the Clorox bottles, the wood, all of it is falsely -- ruthlessly -- blamed on empty bottled water bottles, which according to the EPA, is responsible for only 1/3 of 1% of the waste stream. The nature of the water cycle is such that literally every drop of water that ever was on Earth is STILL on Earth. Where is going to go, Loose Caboose? Water can't leave the atmosphere of the planet. So this so-called global conspiracy of the beverage industry loses steam (pun indeed intended) when one realizes every single drop of water is still here, in one form or another. That, my friend, is also science.
photo
Halsey
"There is a price to pay for speaking the truth. T
05:01 PM on 03/23/2010
ahh...Tom (with....zounds....2 fans)...did you know that an unknowing segment (aka...tom lauria)....have partaken of the BPA is safe kool-aid?....I'm serious... enjoy today....a LOT...(please tell me you don't microwave food that comes in...plastic....Damn...I'm too late...(do you have a DNR notarized yet.....)..bye bye..
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:28 AM on 03/23/2010
Drink beer.
01:02 PM on 03/23/2010
Cheers
photo
yannb
Noblesse oblige
02:07 AM on 03/23/2010
In September 2004, I bought and brought home six 1 liter bottles of Evian. I've been refilling them with tap water ever since. I drink about 5 liters of water per day and it was out of question that I'd pay for so much bottled water when tap water in my area (Switzerland) is perfectly fine. I'm not at all sick. And I wash my towels only once a month. And I don't give a ratsass what people think.
photo
lightist
light as a photon, heavy as tungsten.
01:52 AM on 03/23/2010
If there's one thing the water companies can expect from the people of the good 'ol USA it's a good 'ol fight that they will definitely lose. That water belongs to the people who pay taxes.
01:14 AM on 03/23/2010
I'm involved up to my neck everyday. I'm paying taxes to produce water I'll never drink.
http://www.articlesbase.com/health-articles/muscle-boost-review-does-muscle-boost-really-work-1972189.html
01:10 AM on 03/23/2010
Water is precious. According to a 2006 United Nations report, the biggest source of water pollution is livestock production. How? 1) Manure 2) hormones and antibiotics given to the animals 3) pesticides and fertilizers for cattle feed and pesticides applied directly to the animals 4) chemicals from the tanning process 5) sediment from erosion caused by animal production.

It's serious folks: The U.N. also said that by 2025, 64 percent of the people on earth will live in "water compromised" areas.

The moral: Cut back on meat or even give it up. Becoming vegan saves an estimated 1 million gallons of water a year.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rougebaisers
01:09 AM on 03/23/2010
When I think that I personally have spared this planet a bottle a day for the past few year I smile.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William1950
everything I say could be wrong.
12:57 AM on 03/23/2010
whatever happened to Dean Kamen and his water purification systems.. small point of use systems that run on cow dung, wood.. whatever burns. He has a system that could be distributed to villages and farms all across africa... wherever they are needed. they are not giant plants that would need centralized power grids and governments to oversee them... maybe that is why they are forgotten.
look him up, "Dean Kamen".
02:23 AM on 03/24/2010
There are thousands of water filter projects going on all over the world. Check out your local Rotary clubs--they probably are sponsoring one or more somewhere in some third-world country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jgarma
12:08 AM on 03/23/2010
The argument Dr. Mello cites and that video says it all!

Plastic water bottles gotta go for our health and the planet's. It's just a habit. Easy to change... just get filter for the home and a good quality non-plastic water bottle for travel.

If you need more convincing, this slide show will surely do it:
http://www.garmaonhealth.com/2009/12/water-in-plastic-has-gotta-go-for-your-sake/

Yep.
12:55 AM on 03/23/2010
I think this was a good article that brings up some good points. However, what is not mentioned is the fact that most municiple water supplies in the US are fluoridated. (Fluoridated water has been banned in 98% of European countries). The fluoride used around the country is an industrial toxic waste byproduct. For example, hydrofluorosilisic acid used in many parts of the country. It is a toxic waste byproduct from Mosaic's and Cargill's phosphate fertilizer manufacturing industry. This is put in our drinking water because someone thinks it is good for our children's teeth! Cavities are not life threatening nor contagious. Yet we are being mass medicated via our drinking water with a toxic waste byproduct for this reason. If people want to take fluoride they have the right to do so. But those who do not think it is safe should not be forced to use it. Drinking fluoridated water has been linked with thyroid disease, autism, Alzheimer's, hip fractures and other bone problems, fluorosis, and more. Finally, the whole premise that fluoride prevents cavities is based on a faulty understanding of how tooth decay actually occurs. So the first step in reducing our insane use of plastic water bottles is to stop the insane practice of fluoridating our water. The only way to get fluoride of water is a reverse osmosis filter which is expensive and wastes a lot of water. But it is better than drinking fluoridated water.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
johnny g locker
12:07 AM on 03/23/2010
Well, if they would get rid of the fluoride in the municipal water, I might consider changing.

Fluoride is a menace to health and spiritual evolution.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
TaurusRose
just gimme some truth
05:48 PM on 03/23/2010
A water filter utilizing reverse osmosis removes fluoride from your water; It is cheap, much cheaper than unspecified, unknown water in bottles. The expensive home filters do not remove fluoride, only a reverse osmosis filter does. Get one. They are great.
Previously we spent 500 bucks in less than a year on bottled water from sparklets. When our town went fluoride, we went to filters. To filter our kitchen water for drinking cost only 200 bucks and it tastes great. For around another 200 bucks we could bathe in fluoride free H20
02:25 AM on 03/24/2010
If most of the bottled water is tap water, what exactly have you gained?
11:34 PM on 03/22/2010
While I fully agree with all the concerns and stupid behaviors (bottled water, etc.) discussed here, it seems to me that an overarching problem is the sheer waste of water, and the failure to do what is so easy to do in our individual homes...I call it "Cascade to Save", where water moves from the tap to non-fecal contaminant uses (showers, hand washing, dish washing, etc.), emerging as "gray water", then goes to the toilet for flushing, becoming "black water". We do it with a batch of plastic jugs that match the capacity of the toilet tank, and we (two people) have cut our water and sewer bills in half for three years now. Part of the problem is convincing people that the propaganda by the cleanser manufacturers about "household germs" is largely a bunch of bunk. Most of the germs in our houses are harmless to us, and there is no reason why the toilet bowl should be Fido's water dish or Junior's rubber ducky pond! Just put the lid down! Imagine the residential areas of Las Vegas or Los angeles cutting their household water use in half! It would have a colossal positive effect on the water problem.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
keenhumor
12:56 AM on 03/23/2010
this is already done in countries like Japan. We are just glutten, free idiots...
11:13 PM on 03/22/2010
"Governor O'Malley is expected to sigh it into law" I'm not familiar with that parliamentary procedure, how long do you have to sigh before its considered law? Most things seem to taste better from glass, but its hard to find glass containers these days.
10:41 PM on 03/22/2010
Here in Wyoming much of the well water has been dangerously polluted by "fracking" a process used by gas drilling operations. One of the known chemicals is benzine but many of the the poisons are listed as classified corporate secrets by firms like Haliburton so hospital personnel don't even know what their looking at when these terribly sick people come in. For over thirty years I've predicted a freshwater shortage here in the US and now it appears to be here thanks in part to the polluting allowed by these companies during the Bush years.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
WYHKTai-Tai
Wyoming, Hong Kong, Tai-Tai
05:32 AM on 03/23/2010
YES! What part of Wyoming are you in? Our US Based home is in Dubois, between Jackson & Riverton. They are proposing 2-3 new drills there, on Shoshone Natl. Parkland, although the other wells have produced next to nothing. We are trying to fight this now. Very worried about our water supply.
06:08 PM on 03/23/2010
Jackson, I was born in Cody.